Taxis are not easily available to travellers arriving at the airport and public buses are inconvenient, underlining the case for a proper bus shuttle service
Transport experts in Mumbai agree that there is a desperate need to initiate action to end the harassment of passengers at the domestic and international airport.
This is the result of the regular refusals by taxi and autorickshaw drivers to ferry passengers without a fuss, the inadequate public transport and expensive-but-usually-unavailable pre-paid taxis, due to which many people are stranded at the airport terminals for as much as two hours.
The solution to this is a special bus shuttle with adequate luggage space from the Mumbai airport and transport experts are pushing hard for it.
Mumbai's Chhatrapati Shivaji International Airport is one of the busiest air terminals in the world, but it doesn't have a dedicated bus shuttle service to various parts of the city, even today. While some major cities like Bangalore and Hyderabad have launched efficient, air-conditioned bus services, the country's commercial capital has none. Even Delhi airport now has a special train service-the Delhi Airport Express-that is a convenient facility for travellers. (Read, 'Delhi Airport Express is a brilliant train service which requires finishing touches'.)
With passengers at the mercy of errant taxi drivers who often refuse to ply and an inadequate number of public bus services to the airport, it is common to see many travellers cart their baggage to the main connecting highway a kilometre away. Most of them are professionals travelling on official work.
While many regular taxi drivers try to fleece passengers, the pre-paid taxi services (like Radio Taxi) are expensive and few. Even those who have cars, find parking charges and the long wait to get to their vehicles unaffordable.
Transport experts insist it is high time Mumbai had a special bus shuttle to and from the airport to eliminate this painful inconvenience.
Ashok Datar, an expert in transport, says, "This is absolutely correct. (This is) the least we can do in Mumbai, without fuss or investment and within a few months, without waiting for a bus lane, but by undertaking proper publicity at the bus stops on the frequency of service and appropriate signage (say aircraft) to identify these buses. At the bus stops, the service should get prime space at the airport terminals, with information easily available at various points, for the benefit of passengers as well as those who come to receive them or see them off. We must have at least three routes with a half an hour frequency throughout the night and day, and each should go to south Mumbai, the western suburbs and to Vashi /Thane."
Sudhir Badami, transport activist, estimates the frequency of buses at 3.5 minutes. "In fact, the whole concept of reducing carbon footprint has to come into arguments and we must provide for higher frequencies to attract almost every potential air passenger. These buses need not be restricted to air travellers, so long as other passengers are also willing to pay the fare might be higher on account of the fewer number of people using the service, as the luggage space will reduce seating. Also, these buses should not allow standees, from the point of view of safety of luggage."
Not very long ago, Indian Airlines provided a pick-up facility from certain points in the city to the airport. "In the Indian Airlines days, I used to board the airport bus from Shivaji Park. There was no need to discontinue it. Today, taxis don't come to Mahim, considering it is a short distance for a fare of Rs100. Taxi drivers are known to pay traffic police about Rs100 to get a slot in the queue. Since I always carry a handbag I prefer to come out of the airport and hop in to 'dropping cabs'. I entirely agree that this is urgently needed across Mumbai. I understand that with the phasing out of Fiats, Mumbai is short by 35,000 cabs," says Nagesh Kini, Mumbai-based social activist.
The monopoly by the taxi unions is the main reason for such inconvenience to travellers. Walter Vieira, marketing consultant, says, "Mumbai is like Goa airport, where the union of taxi drivers, in connivance with politicians, have successfully thwarted all attempts for a bus service. When Damania (Airlines) introduced a free bus service from the city office to/from the airport in Goa, the buses were attacked and the company was compelled to discontinue the service. The government did not intervene and just looked the other way as if nothing had happened. This is also one of the foremost reasons why foreign tourists dislike coming to Goa, for the first hurdle they are faced with on landing is the unreasonable demands of taxi drivers."
Inside story of the National Stock Exchange’s amazing success, leading to hubris, regulatory capture and algo scam
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance.
1-year online access to the magazine articles published during the subscription period.
Access is given for all articles published during the week (starting Monday) your subscription starts. For example, if you subscribe on Wednesday, you will have access to articles uploaded from Monday of that week.
This means access to other articles (outside the subscription period) are not included.
Articles outside the subscription period can be bought separately for a small price per article.
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance.
30-day online access to the magazine articles published during the subscription period.
Access is given for all articles published during the week (starting Monday) your subscription starts. For example, if you subscribe on Wednesday, you will have access to articles uploaded from Monday of that week.
This means access to other articles (outside the subscription period) are not included.
Articles outside the subscription period can be bought separately for a small price per article.
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance.
Complete access to Moneylife archives since inception ( till the date of your subscription )
What *would* go a long way is making the Mumbai local train line come up to the airport. This would vastly reduce the chaotic traffic in and around the airport.
The passes can be pre purchased after landing or on the bus. A similar project can be replicated at Mumbai and other Metros and Tier II cities to start with. For Mumbai the touch points can be, from Airport to Borivali, Bandra, Dadar via (Eastern express & Western express), CSMVS, (Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj Vastu Sangrahlaya), Chembur, Ghatkopar, Mulund, ThaneVashi with limited stops, connecting with taxi and rickshaw stands for convenience
BMC/AAI/state govt /central govt. will not take such initiative because such arrangements ( providing point to point bus service ) will stop their extra INCOME / BRIBES by taxidrivers/auto drivers AND ALSO MAY BE THEIR ASSOCIATIONS.
Who is bothered for a common man ( passangers ) in this country boiling with corruption.
Our Rail/Air passanger's associations and consumer organisations must act to solve this problem.
Such bus services are available at most of major cities' airports around the world.
=================
I have no idea how BEST can be made to live up to its mandate especially wrt public transport at intermodal exchanges. Maybe a start could be made with bus to railway station options, since there are more people and more regular/daily pax there, before going on to airports?
Agreed, the taxi dominance at Mumbai airport is a combination of existing power games which have no part in this day and age, and must be changed.
Good luck.
BTW, I was at Mumbai Airport domestic arrivals yesterday, at about noon, and there were ample taxiis, as usual fighting for our business - especially when they learnt that the destination is Vashi. But yes, the driver of the MERU cab did agree that matters are terrible during the rush hours and nights, especially at the International Airport.
Auto and Taxi drivers arrogancy is directly proportional to BRIBES they pay to cops on duty and OFF duty.
CORRUPTION IS ROOT CAUSE OF THESE PROBLEMS.There was an article 2/3 days back in Mumbai news papers - during surprise check by RTO -AUTO RIKSHA meters were found heavily tempered and this leds to 40% over chargeing to passangers.
Such temperaing of meters by AUTO drivers is not possible without connivance of some elements in RTO who are supposed to check tempering of meters.Even taxis with old mechanical types of meters are tempered -taxis operating from Borivali/Dadar/Mumbai central and VT..
AUTO drivers showing taxi tarrif card to an non-mumbai passanger is also very common.
About a week back-during 10 am in morning- taxi drivers were asking Rs.200 / Rs.250 for traveling to Sahar International Airport from Swami Nityanand Marg ( Andheri east ) / western express highway crossing ( not a distance of 2 to 3 Kilometers).
Till corruption is not checked-these problems will remain and passangers will be looted / harassed by AUTO/Taxi drivers.
===========================