When management gurus failed to bell the CAT

After two disastrous days of technical problems and pathetic coordination between the country's prestigious management schools, the Common Admission Test (CAT) 2009 finally had a smooth run on Monday, which is the third day of the staggered model that has been adopted. CAT, which determines admission to top business schools, mainly the Indian Institutes of Management (IIMs) usually sees applications from millions of students.

 This is the first time that the exams were being conducted online, but the process was marred with technical glitches and systems crashing, leading to cancellations at 49 labs in 24 centres across thirteen cities. The launch of the computerised CAT involved the delivery of exams by a unit of US-based technology-enabled testing and assessment services provider Prometric Inc into more than 360 testing labs at 104 individual locations.
Prometric Testing Pvt Ltd (Prometric India), a subsidiary of Prometric, was awarded a multi-year, multi-million dollar contract by the IIMs to conduct the CAT for entry into top management schools in India.
According to a PTI report, Ramesh Nava, Prometric’s vice president and general manager for Asia Pacific, Japan and Africa, had said, “Exhaustive plans were developed and put in place well in advance of the start of the testing window. Unfortunately viruses and malware that attacked the test delivery system were not detected by the anti-virus software at the testing centres."
Echoing the same views, IIM Bangalore's director Pankaj Chandra had said, "In each centre there are five-six rooms where the CAT exam is being conducted. In a few rooms of some centres, there was a virus attack on computers. However, students in such centres will be given an alternative for the test—either today or on some other day, and they will be intimated."
However, there is no independent confirmation of a virus either by any student, who took the test or by any media reports. Many experts are questioning the preparedness of Prometric and IIMs to conduct an exam of this scale, the technical infrastructure at the labs as well as the basic technical knowledge of the support staff.
Vijay Mukhi, cyber expert and head of IT for the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FICCI), says, “Had the CAT exams been conducted using cloud technologies, none of the servers would have crashed and students would not have had to go through such hardships. I cannot understand why the IIMs shy away from using the latest state-of-the-art technologies used by the likes of Facebook, Yahoo, Google and Amazon.”
This time, there are around 2.4 lakh aspirants taking the CAT 2009 exam online, spread over 10 days, for admission into India's top management schools. Many IT experts are also questioning the logic behind conducting the exam over 10 days, when the same can be done in a day. "Any computer professional will say that it is not difficult to build a system taking the load of some question papers for 2.4 lakh people, and the test should have been held on a single day," said an expert.
According to media reports, students in centres across the country, particularly Chennai and Bengaluru and a number of Tier II cities, had reported that they could not log in using the given username. They also reported that computers were ‘crashing’ or ‘shutting down’ during the course of the exam, execution errors were being thrown up on the screen in the middle of the test and some questions were refusing to respond to a click and hence not being answered and so on.
IIMs have put a disclaimer on their site warning that anybody who attempts to leak the question will face three years of jail or a fine of Rs2 lakh. However, given the high stakes on IIM admissions and the long period of 10 days to conduct the CAT, there are chances that a lot of business and tech-savvy players may be making a killing by revealing question papers stealthily, another expert said.
Following the chaos during the first two days, many IIM aspirants—especially those who could not take the test—are feeling depressed. Prometric claimed that all affected students have been notified and the exam would be rescheduled within this year's testing period. However, there was some confusion among students for whom the test had been rescheduled.
“We were not informed immediately. When there is a change in the schedule, we must be informed immediately. The change in the schedule adds to the pressure on us,” one student told PTI.
One IT expert said that he was thinking about filing a class action suit against the IIMs. "Those who spent a lot of money to come to the centre and could not take the test should at least be compensated for the money spent. Not to mention the mental agony. It doesn’t matter a hoot if thousands are able to take the test. What about the uncertainty in the mind of a student who has a test scheduled for tomorrow? He doesn’t know whether it will be held or not," the expert said.
Earlier, Indira Gandhi National Open University (IGNOU) tried an online entrance exam where the entire online infrastructure collapsed within a few minutes. IGNOU has asked Yahoo, the infrastructure provider for the exams, for a detailed report on the collapse.
Why were the staff at NIIT, a partner of Prometric, not trained properly? Why did Prometric's personnel not reach the faulty testing centres on time? Why were there delays in registration?
And when there were so many problems, why are the IIMs and Prometric blaming it on a virus? Or is it just a gimmick they are using to bluff the nation? Did both of them conduct the process and software testing so as to avoid glitches?
The CAT fiasco has not only put a question mark over the inadequate preparedness by both IIMs and Prometric, but also on the country's IT prowess.

 -Yogesh Sapkale [email protected]
  • Like this story? Get our top stories by email.


    Driving a Hard Bargain

    how you can get the best deal on your new car and pump up fuel efficiency. Also, a test drive report on the new Cruze

    After the big boom around Diwali, sales of personal vehicles as well as two-wheelers may have declined again. There is no conclusive data available at the time of writing, but anecdotal evidence indicates a slowdown. The message from friends who are automobile dealers and...

    Premium Content
    Monthly Digital Access


    Already A Subscriber?
    Yearly Digital Access


    Moneylife Magazine Subscriber or MAS member?

    Yearly Subscriber Login

    Enter the mail id that you want to use & click on Go. We will send you a link to your email for verficiation
  • India's Q2 GDP grows 7.9%

    Belying predictions, the Indian economy grew by a significant 7.9% in the second quarter of this fiscal, up from 6.1% in the previous quarter, essentially due to a good showing by the industry and the services sector. The growth compares favourably to the figure of 7.7% recorded in the July-September quarter in the previous year.

     Consequently, the economy rose by 7% in the first half ending 30th September of the current fiscal on the back of stimulus packages and revival of domestic demand, giving hopes that final figures for the year could be much higher.
    "While loan growth remains anaemic, strong GDP numbers and rising WPI will likely result in a tightening of policy rates in January. However, as mentioned in our earlier notes, with liquidity remaining in surplus, liquidity tightening measures will likely precede rate hikes. We maintain our call of 125bps tightening in 2010 as inflation is primarily supply side drive and excess tightening would have implications for the Indian rupee," said Rohini Malkani, Economist, Citi India.
    The government, including finance minister Pranab Mukherjee, the RBI and the Planning Commission had predicted a growth of about 6%-7%, while global agencies and analysts forecast it to be even lower. The prime minister's economic advisory panel had pegged the economy to grow by around 6.1% in the second quarter due to the impact of a weak monsoon on agriculture.
    Tushar Poddar, Vice President & Chief Economist, Goldman Sachs India said, “Although the growth momentum is strong, we believe the impact of the drought on agricultural growth would be seen in the next quarter. Looking ahead to 2010, we would expect the role of the private sector to start increasing more rapidly while that of the government to ease gradually. There are upside risks to our FY10 GDP growth forecast of 5.8%. For FY11, we expect GDP to grow near-trend at 7.8%. We believe the recovery in activity will drive the INR stronger and expect the Reserve Bank of India to start hiking rates in January. We also continue to recommend short US dollar and Indian rupee positions".
    During the quarter to end-September, financing, agriculture and real-estate growth stood at 7.7%. The surge in GDP numbers was helped by the manufacturing sector, which grew 9.2% in the second quarter vis-a-vis 5.1% a year earlier.
    Analysts were expecting a growth rate of 6.1%-6.6% in the second quarter. The economic growth of close to 8% in the second quarter is also remarkable in the context of just 0.9% expansion in farm production due to a weak monsoon and continued contraction in exports due to slackening demand overseas.
    However, the manufacturing sector grew by 9.2% in the July-September period compared to 5.1% in the corresponding period of the last fiscal and mining and quarrying grew by 9.5% versus 3.7% recorded in FY09.
    Community, social and personal services expanded by double digits at 12.7% against 9%. Despite being affected by the international slowdown, trade, hotels, transport and the communications sector grew by 8.5%, which is lower than 12.1% a year ago.
    Financing, insurance, real-estate, and business services rose by 7.7% against 6.4%. Electricity, gas and water supply were up 7.4% compared to 3.8%. Construction rose by 6.5%, down over 9.6% a year ago.
    It was after September, that growth declined to 5.8% in the subsequent two quarters last year. So, if the trend continues, the growth rate is expected to be much higher in the second half of this fiscal.
    The size of the domestic economy stood at Rs17.90 lakh crore in the first half of FY10.
    -Yogesh Sapkale [email protected]
  • Like this story? Get our top stories by email.


    We are listening!

    Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

    To continue

    Sign Up or Sign In


    To continue

    Sign Up or Sign In



    online financial advisory
    Pathbreakers 1 & Pathbreakers 2 contain deep insights, unknown facts and captivating events in the life of 51 top achievers, in their own words.
    online financia advisory
    The Scam
    24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
    Moneylife Online Magazine
    Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
    financial magazines online
    Stockletters in 3 Flavours
    Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
    financial magazines in india
    MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
    (Includes Moneylife Online Magazine)
    FREE: Your Complete Family Record Book
    Keep all the Personal and Financial Details of You & Your Family. In One Place So That`s Its Easy for Anyone to Find Anytime
    We promise not to share your email id with anyone