SC tells CBI not to take any instructions from its political masters
Moneylife Digital Team 30 April 2013

The Opposition is demanding Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's resignation after Additional Solicitor General Harin P Raval wrote a letter to Attorney General GE Vahanvati accusing him of interfering with the CBI's case in the coal scam

The Supreme Court said that the suppression by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) that it shared the coal scam status report with the law minister is not ordinary. The court came down heavily on the CBI and has told the agency not to take any instructions from its political masters.

 

The court questioned as to why it was kept in the dark about sharing of information with government officials in the coal scam. The Supreme Court has also said, “The CBI's independent position must be restored. Our first exercise will be to liberate CBI from political interference.”

 

The apex court has said that the details in the CBI affidavit on the coal scam are “very disturbing”. “There has been a massive breach of trust that has shaken our foundation,” the apex court said. The court said sharing information with the government has shaken the entire process.

 

Media reports indicate that changes were made in the status report on the coal scam after a meeting with law minister Ashwani Kumar. CBI sources said they will not hide anything from the Supreme Court, which was hearing the case and will decide whether the government tried to influence the CBI probe.

 

The political fall-out of the Supreme Court criticism of the law minister and CBI is severe. The Opposition is demanding prime minister Manmohan Singh's resignation after Additional Solicitor General Harin P Raval wrote a letter to Attorney General GE Vahanvati accusing him of interfering with the CBI's case in the scam.

Comments
NSriramamurty
1 decade ago
SC has not Told in Clear Terms that CBIs investing Scams by States Politicians not to Share their Investigation Details / reports to State Authorities. Even Union Law Minister tells that He Followed only Normal Existing Policy of Governing CBI. Thus it is Clear that States Ruling Politicians think and Act as though They are Controllers of CBI. Ofcourse, it is well Known Fact All States CID / Police,etc take Regularly Instructions from their Political Bosses, Eventhough They are all Paid by Indians Public Money and No Politician is Paying/ spending any Money.
Shadi Katyal
1 decade ago
What a shame that people had beewn fooled by telling everyoine that it is independent and yet has always been under the ruling party.
Anyone with self respect could have resinged and let the public know the truth.
How does the chairman or other officers feel when being directed by SC for being fair.
Why is that while we call ourselves a democracy yet we act like a fuedal JEE HAZOORI
vineeth kumar
1 decade ago
wow!!! finally, honorable supreme court of India has woken up, twice in this month,Apex Court has questioned the motive of CBI on this case; and EOW/SFIO, almost similar disturbing question in another case, where an ordinary man can see the political power play.
I am not at all optimistic of any speed in justice, as a top priority to fast track on TAT is lacking.
All right/left/center...are all together in licking the Honey (money) and act before public scoring points, evaluating to adopt a strategy, to prepare for 2014 Election.
People like me inculcated legal rules n regulations, for so long..even now, I am struggling to get a loan of 5 Lacs.
If I can compromise a little funds will flow, will be generous. But, my idea of a self sustaining start up is not to become Rich..but leave a legacy for future generations.

These examples set by corrupts, make me to think of tweaking my strategy and join them in looting without any sense of guilt.

God save Bharath...
Free Helpline
Legal Credit
Feedback