SC Asks for Files about Appointment of Arun Goel as Election Commissioner
IANS 23 November 2022
The Supreme Court on Wednesday told the Centre that it wants to see the files relating to the recent appointment of Arun Goel as election commissioner (EC) and emphasised that it wants to see by what mechanism, 'he was picked up', and 'there is no danger to produce it (files)'.
Advocate Prashant Bhushan, representing a petitioner, raised the issue in connection with the appointment of Mr Goel. He said Mr Goel was a sitting secretary, was given voluntary retirement on Friday, the appointment was issued on Saturday, and on Monday, he started working as EC.
Mr Bhushan said he had filed an application in connection with the appointment and the Court was hearing the matter; yet, the government made the appointment. Pointing out that the Centre appointed someone in a single day, he asked what process they have followed and what are the safeguards?
A five-judge Constitution bench, headed by justice KM Joseph, said the court heard the matter on Thursday and Mr Bhushan said that there is an intervention application in connection with the vacancy and the Centre appointed a person as an EC.
Justice Joseph told attorney general (AG) R Venkataramani: "Produce the files of appointment of this officer... you say there is no hanky-panky in this. Was he appointed on the basis of voluntary retirement... how was he appointed, what is the mechanism by which he was picked up... the matter is being heard."
He told the AG, if there is no illegality, "then you shouldn't be afraid" and "if everything is going on smoothly, then show us the file."
As the AG said "I don't think we have to travel that far", justice Joseph said the court will not sit in judgement on the appointment and "we want to see that file, unless you claim some privilege... we want to see how things work."
The top court orally observed that the order of appointment was made, after it started hearing the case on Thursday and Mr Bhushan had filed an application relating to the vacancy. The AG said he has an objection which is that this solitary instance cannot be used and the matter is regarding a larger question. To this, Justice Joseph said that "it is curiosity intertwined with our duty..."
The bench—also comprising justices Ajay Rastogi, Aniruddha Bose, Hrishikesh Roy, and CT Ravikumar—said the AG can bring the files with him on Thursday and if he feels he should not disclose it, then he should let the bench know.
Concluding the hearing in the matter, justice Joseph said there is no danger in getting the files related to Mr Goel's appointment and told the AG that "it is not a matter to withhold the information".
Earlier in the day, the bench queried the Centre's counsel to show it the mechanism adopted in the appointment of the EC, while citing the appointment of Mr Goel.
Former bureaucrat Arun Goel assumed the office of EC on Monday, after being appointed to the post on 19th November. Since May, this year, the post of one Election Commissioner in the three-member commission was lying vacant after Sushil Chandra retired as the CEC.
The AG contended that the convention is that all senior bureaucrats and officers at the state and the Central government are taken into consideration while appointment and this is scrupulously followed. He submitted that the appointment is done on the basis of convention and there is no separate appointment procedure of a chief election commissioner (CEC).
He added that he has already shown how a convention is followed, the process involved in the appointment, and appointments are made on the basis of seniority, and on the aspect of recent appointment, he added that the office was vacant since May.
The top court is hearing a batch of pleas seeking a collegium-like system for the appointment of the CEC and ECs, and it will continue to hear the matter on Thursday.
On Tuesday, the Supreme Court said the CEC heads an institution, though with his truncated tenure, he cannot do anything substantial and added that 'silences of the Constitution' is being exploited by all and expressed concern at the absence of a law governing the appointments of ECs and CEC.
Last week, the Central opposed petitions seeking a collegium-like system for the selection of CECs and ECs.
The apex court in October 2018, referred to a PIL (public interest litigation) seeking a collegium-like system for the selection of CECs and ECs to a five-judge Constitution bench.
Disclaimer: Information, facts or opinions expressed in this news article are presented as sourced from IANS and do not reflect views of Moneylife and hence Moneylife is not responsible or liable for the same. As a source and news provider, IANS is responsible for accuracy, completeness, suitability and validity of any information in this article.
Meenal Mamdani
1 week ago
Wonderful! I have not read such pertinent and persistent questions asked of the Executive by the Supreme Court judges.
What a contrast this is to the illogical and damaging judgement given by the Supreme Court in the matter of the EWS reservation. That was a split decision and we are grateful to the 2 judges including the Chief Justice, who made their opposition clear. We must monitor the careers of the 3 who delivered this judgement, one of them is from Gujarat and there may be pressure to appoint her as Chief Justice when she rises in seniority. Heaven help us if that happens.
In Light of SC Judgement on EWS, Petition Seeks Tax Exemption on All Families Earning below Rs8 lakh; Madras HC Issues Notices to Union Govt
Moneylife Digital Team 25 November 2022
The Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court (HC) has sought the response of the Centre on a plea (Case No: WP(MD) 26168 of 2022) challenging the fixation of Rs2,50,000 as the base income for the purpose of collecting income-tax...
Need a CEC Who Can Even Take Action against PM, Says SC
IANS 23 November 2022
The Supreme Court on Wednesday orally observed that the need is for a chief election commissioner (CEC) who can even take action against the prime minister and also asked the Centre to show the mechanism adopted in the appointment...
I-T dept detects unaccounted transactions exceeding Rs 100 cr across country
IANS 22 November 2022
The Income Tax Department on Tuesday said that it has unearthed unaccounted transactions exceeding Rs 100 crore during searches on a few groups engaged in jewellery and real estate business across the country in connection with...
Self-declaration Submission on Air Suvidha Portal No Longer Required for Int'l Passengers
IANS 22 November 2022
After the sustained decline in the COVID-19 trajectory across the globe and in the country, the guidelines of health ministry on submission of self-declaration form on the Air Suvidha portal has been discontinued. The decision will...
Free Helpline
Legal Credit