Rs2.5 lakh crore of demonetised notes may not come back to the system
Moneylife Digital Team 02 December 2016
Since the Prime Minister announced demonetisation on November 8, there has been a lot of calculation and research being done, on how much money will come back to the system and how much will not. Dr Soumya Kanti Ghosh of State Bank of India calculates that that around Rs2.5 lakh crore will not be returned to the system. Here is his logic.
 
As of November 9, 2016, the amount of high currency denomination notes was Rs15,441 billion, excluding the cash with banks. Till date the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has published data regarding the deposited/exchange notes, twice, with a gap of 9 days, 10-18 November and 19-27 November. 
 
The total money deposited/exchanged during the period 10-18 November was Rs5,446 billion, with an average of Rs605 billion per working day and during the period 19-27 November was Rs3,004 billion, with an average of Rs501 billion per working day. This shows a 17% decline in average working day deposit/exchange money. 
 
As is evident from the data, the daily deposit average is on a declining trend. The remaining three days of November can be conservatively assumed to have an average of Rs375 billion per day (25% less than what came during 19-27 November) i.e. a total of Rs1,125 billion. 
 
Breaking December into three different periods, a total of Rs3,360 billion can be assumed to be returned to the system (Rs1,500 billion between 1-7 December, Rs900 between 8-15 December and Rs960 between 16-30 December). As per the assumptions, Rs10 billion will be deposited during 1 January to 31 March 2017. 
 
Adding these numbers up, Rs12,945 billion will be returned to the system against Rs15,441 billion as of November 9, 2016 and Rs2,496 billion will not be returned, as per SBI research. 
 
Comments
Veeresh Malik
5 years ago
Anecdotal but dipstick - one of the busiest and most efficient SBI CDMs is in front of my house, located at a major bus/metro interchange called Moolchand, serving not just people from the area but also transients of all sorts. This SBI CDM has been working continuously since 8th November, day and night, weekends and holidays included, swallowing old currency notes relentlessly. The lines were there 24x7, including middle of the night and pre-dawn, and so was the clearance. Over the last 5-6 days, there are no lines at all most of the time, and the inference one draws is that a bulk of the old currency notes that had to be deposited have been deposited.

It is the same at the 11 other PSU branches opposite my home.

Lines here are now only for withdrawal of cash as the ATMs have been dry for some time now - it appears that ATMs at non-bank locations are functioning at the cost of ATMs attached to bank branches.
MUKESH AGARWAL
5 years ago
As in news more than 11 lac crore out of 15 lac crore deposited so far and in view of even in decline pace remaining portion will also be deposited. I am fearful what will happen if deposit is more than money in circulation as per RBI. Is there proper system to recognize forged notes or they also have been deposited as normal.
MUKESH AGARWAL
5 years ago
As in news more than 11 lac crore out of 15 lac crore deposited so far and in view of even in decline pace remaining portion will also be deposited. I am fearful what will happen if deposit is more than money in circulation as per RBI. Is there proper system to recognize forged notes or they also have been deposited as normal.
MUKESH AGARWAL
5 years ago
As in news more than 11 lac crore out of 15 lac crore deposited so far and in view of even in decline pace remaining portion will also be deposited. I am fearful what will happen if deposit is more than money in circulation as per RBI. Is there proper system to recognize forged notes or they also have been deposited as normal.
MUKESH AGARWAL
5 years ago
As in news more than 11 lac crore out of 15 lac crore deposited so far and in view of even in decline pace remaining portion will also be deposited. I am fearful what will happen if deposit is more than money in circulation as per RBI. Is there proper system to recognize forged notes or they also have been deposited as normal.
MUKESH AGARWAL
5 years ago
As in news more than 11 lac crore out of 15 lac crore deposited so far and in view of even in decline pace remaining portion will also be deposited. I am fearful what will happen if deposit is more than money in circulation as per RBI. Is there proper system to recognize forged notes or they also have been deposited as normal.
MUKESH AGARWAL
5 years ago
As in news more than 11 lac crore out of 15 lac crore deposited so far and in view of even in decline pace remaining portion will also be deposited. I am fearful what will happen if deposit is more than money in circulation as per RBI. Is there proper system to recognize forged notes or they also have been deposited as normal.
MUKESH AGARWAL
5 years ago
As in news more than 11 lac crore out of 15 lac crore deposited so far and in view of even in decline pace remaining portion will also be deposited. I am fearful what will happen if deposit is more than money in circulation as per RBI. Is there proper system to recognize forged notes or they also have been deposited as normal.
MUKESH AGARWAL
5 years ago
As in news more than 11 lac crore out of 15 lac crore deposited so far and in view of even in decline pace remaining portion will also be deposited. I am fearful what will happen if deposit is more than money in circulation as per RBI. Is there proper system to recognize forged notes or they also have been deposited as normal.
MUKESH AGARWAL
5 years ago
As in news more than 11 lac crore out of 15 lac crore deposited so far and in view of even in decline pace remaining portion will also be deposited. I am fearful what will happen if deposit is more than money in circulation as per RBI. Is there proper system to recognize forged notes or they also have been deposited as normal.
MUKESH AGARWAL
5 years ago
As in news more than 11 lac crore out of 15 lac crore deposited so far and in view of even in decline pace remaining portion will also be deposited. I am fearful what will happen if deposit is more than money in circulation as per RBI. Is there proper system to recognize forged notes or they also have been deposited as normal.
MUKESH AGARWAL
5 years ago
As in news more than 11 lac crore out of 15 lac crore deposited so far and in view of even in decline pace remaining portion will also be deposited. I am fearful what will happen if deposit is more than money in circulation as per RBI. Is there proper system to recognize forged notes or they also have been deposited as normal.
MUKESH AGARWAL
5 years ago
As in news more than 11 lac crore out of 15 lac crore deposited so far and in view of even in decline pace remaining portion will also be deposited. I am fearful what will happen if deposit is more than money in circulation as per RBI. Is there proper system to recognize forged notes or they also have been deposited as normal.
Amol Kokate
5 years ago
I don't see any strong logic in this article, not worth of publishing
Ramesh Mehta
5 years ago
Due to the new scheme of allowing deposit w/50% tax, all the money should get deposited.
Free Helpline
Legal Credit
Feedback