Economy & Nation   Exclusive
Reliance serves legal notice to Moneylife

Mukesh Ambani-led RIL has served legal notice to Moneylife for allegedly lowering the prestige of Reliance Industries among the conglomerate's friends and well-wishers

Mukesh Ambani-led Reliance Industries Ltd (RIL) has served a legal notice on Debashis Basu, editor and publisher of Moneylife, Moneywise Media Pvt Ltd and Sucheta Dalal, managing editor of Moneylife, for publishing articles "Congress gift to Reliance: RIL sole beneficiary of anti-dumping duty on PTA" () and "Ambani ki dukaan?"

 

The notice, sent by legal services firm Khaitan & Co also accuse Moneylife of "lowering the prestige of RIL among the conglomerate's friends and well-wishers".

 

The notice, while referring Ms Dalal, the managing editor of Moneylife as 'reporter', accuses her of "validating highly objectionable parts from the book "Gas Wars - Crony Capitalism and the Ambanis" in her article 'Ambani ki dukaan?'. Interestingly, the notice referes to the book as 'Pamphlet' at all places, including notices sent to the writers and publishers of the book.

 

"...you have entered into a deliberate attempt to slander our client's name and reputation by publicizing a highly-objectionable Pamphlet titled "Gas Wars - Crony Capitalism and the Ambani's dukan" by one Paranjoy Guha Thakurta alongwith Subir Ghosh and Jyotirmoy Chaudhuri written, published and distributed with the explicit purpose of making slanderous and baseless allegations against our client (Pamphlet) by validating its highly-objectionable parts in your piece 'Ambani ki dukaan?' on 14 April 2014 at 4.01pm and repeated the injury to our client in the 1 May 2014 edition of Moneylife on pages 16 and 17. In this article you have mixed the wholly unrelated issue of PTA described in para 1-15 of this legal notice with the machinations and the slander inherent in the said Pamphlet. Our clients reserve the right to include for colluding with the said authors of the Pamphlet for the same as the distributor of their canards," the notice from Khaitan & Co says.

 

Last week, the same lawyer firm issued notices to the authors and distributors of the book "Gas Wars - Crony Capitalism and the Ambanis". The notices also accuse e-distributors of the book, Authors Upfront and Feel Books Pvt Ltd as well as Flipkart and Amazon of being party to a "common conspiracy" to "ensure the defamation of our clients for personal gains". Also included among those served notice is Deepshikha Shankar, event manager for the Foundation of Media Professionals, who had in her personal capacity forwarded the e-invite for the book release function to several people, says a report from Times of India.

 

Over the past two years, Reliance has been the target of attacks by Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) leaders Arvind Kejriwal and Prashant Bhushan, but they have never been served any legal notice.

 

In fact, TV news channels, owned by the RIL group itself broadcast the press conferences of Kejriwal and Bhushan LIVE several times, in which the latter have made serious allegations about Reliance. “I find it quite perplexing. If you felt that you have been defamed by what Prashant Bhushan and I said, then we are the real culprits and, if you had to send a defamation notice, it should have been to us. The TV channels merely broadcast what we said,” Kejriwal was quoted as saying in a English translation of the letter posted on the AAP website. Its not clear whether large media groups like TV18, in which RIL has substantial interest, have also received any such notice, since their TV channels had also carried the press conferences of Kejriwal.

 

Earlier in February this year, Kejriwal, while speaking at a rally, repeatedly cited two bank account numbers claiming that they belonged to Ambani brothers, Mukesh and Anil. This was done as part of challenging Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)'s prime ministerial candidate Narendra Modi to get black money back from Swiss banks.

 

However, all the Mukesh Ambani-led conglomerate did was issue a press release refuting the allegations made by Kejriwal, blaming it on mythical ‘vested interests’. "It is being reiterated that neither Reliance Industries nor Mr Mukesh Ambani have or had any illegitimate accounts anywhere in the world. The continued tirade of baseless allegations being made by AAP against us appears to be instigated by vested interests," the company had said. (Reliance refutes Kejriwal's allegations terming it as 'baseless')

 

Seperately, EAS Sarma, former secretary of the Government of India (GoI), had demanded an independent investigation into the whole gamut of showering one largesse after another on RIL that would unravel the hidden links in this web of improprieties. (Set up SIT to investigate showering of one largesse after another on RIL, says Sarma )

 

The former secretary had written several letters to the PM and petroleum ministry on the improprieties committed by the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) government in dealing with RIL’s gas project in Krishna Godavari (KG) Basin in Andhra Pradesh.

 

Last week, Gopalkrishna Gandhi, former governor of West Bengal, called Reliance Industries as 'parallel state', which exercised power brazenly over natural and financial resources, says a report from Times of India. Quoting Mr Gandhi, the report says, "We used to talk of black money as a parallel economy and so it continues to be. But Reliance is a parallel State. I do not know of any country where one single firm exercises such power so brazenly, over the natural resources, financial resources, professional resources and, ultimately, over human resources as the company of the Ambanis". The former governor was speaking at the 15th DP Kohli Memorial Lecture that had over 3,000 officials from the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) in the audience.

 

From what we know, none of these parties have been served legal notice by Reliance Industries.

Like this story? Get our top stories by email.

User

COMMENTS

TrueView

4 years ago

Thank you for your existence, Thank you that you are still there. Please continue in the same vein and with the same fearless spirit!

Your predictions regarding Mukesh Ambani trying to control Indian media unfortunately came true. We Indians more than ever need Debashis Basu, editor, publisher of Moneylife, Moneywise Media Pvt Ltd and Sucheta Dalal and its dedicated and fearless employees.

An idea:
if you can please do video reporting over some special topics like "Indian media Freedom: The end is near?", "Indian pollution and heath: grave danger" , "Indian culture or Bad people: who is responsible for rapes" etc.

Dr Paresh Vaidya

5 years ago

Is there something in Law that permits a Book to criticize someone within some boundaries but a pamphlet can not? The use of word 'pamphlet' for a book needs to be understood before it begins to operate legally.
Does the notice to Authors also uses the word Pamphlet?

MG Warrier

5 years ago

Copied below is an excerpt from my article on corruption published here in July 2012:
"India has an array of politicians, statesmen, businessmen and bureaucrats who do not face corruption charges. These eminent individuals have a moral responsibility to help the country pull out of the present crisis. UPA Chairperson Sonia Gandhi had exhorted for ‘zero tolerance’ to corruption while addressing congressmen in Allahabad sometime back. Her vision did not find takers even among her followers inasmuch as the government guided by her failed to take steps to ensure that at least people facing huge corruption charges did not hold public offices. While convalescing in the United States last year, Sonia Gandhi once again remembered the need to tackle corruption and on return to India promptly requested her party to do something about it.
Going by dictionary meaning, the word corruption is associated with words like bribe, cheating, evil, badness, decayed, stinking, decayed, false, defilement, wickedness, violation, defective, spoilt, faulty, wrong, malignant, offensive, immoral, unchaste, vile and fallen (the list can go on). Suffice to say, anyone or any institution/organization having something attributable to any formations out of any of these words can be alleged to be corrupt. Luckily not so. It is generally accepted that what is legal is not corrupt. Then, like morality, the perception of corruption varies from individual to individual, society to society and country to country. Meaning, what is construed as legal in one context need not be so in another context.
For the rich and the powerful, there will always be legal remedies, as, historically, the laws are made and interpreted in their favor. No wonder, while really corrupt people take shelter under legal interpretations and the age-old protection available to those facing allegations to the effect that until proved guilty, the benefit of doubt would go in favor of the accused, eminent statesmen and innocent common man get dragged into controversies related to corruption, day in and day out, despite their efforts to maintain high moral and ethical standards in their own lives. In the deluge of corruption that the world is witnessing today, no Krishna will be able to float on a leaf unaffected by the deluge. The value system which is in disrepair globally needs a shock treatment. The initiative can come from India, if the nation decides to make every embarrassment an opportunity to correct and move forward. This can be done only by handling individual corruption cases on the basis of the facts of the case and not with reference to the impact such action will have on coalition government’s equilibrium or the immediate inconvenience or discomfort some individuals will face."

RUSHABH R SHAH

5 years ago

I think ML should not stop its relentless efforts against those who have been responsible for large scale political and bureaucratic corruption and we as ordinary and law abiding citizens should declare our unconditional support to ML. Truth should prevail under any circumstances.

JOSEPH KORAH

5 years ago

Money Life Foundation must give a fitting response to this kind of arrogance of the Industrialists. We as people can do our bit to boycott the products and services of such companies who are trying to muzzle down fair reporting. Our prayers and best wishes to Money Life Foundation and its founders to get over these problems and you will surely succeed.

Indur Chhugani

5 years ago

Sucheta - There is no need to worry - However corrupt may the Judges be - Reliance had also threatened me with defamation case in 1999 - On account of one of my Ads in which I had mentioned Reliance - Nothing happened. Had written back - Please go ahead and file case against me.

Harish Kohli

5 years ago

I have no comment to make at the present but wish to read what other people feel. But I cannot tick the "Alert me ...." box unless I make a comment. Why?

Indur Chhugani

5 years ago

- At the slightest dissent from any person writing against the Judges or courts - the Judges file Contempt case - BUT I have sent mails to the concerned Judges and High Court and Supreme Court - tempting them to initiate contempt proceedings against me - BUT they refuse - Perhaps apprehensive, this case of my eviction from flat at age 66 - Will reach all across the country -.
.
What use are 2 Judges together – IF both are having extremely low IQ level ? – Just one with human intelligence would be better

http://ikchhugani.wordpress.com/?p=8

Indur Chhugani

5 years ago

High Court Judges and Supreme Court Judges travel in pockets of criminals - Mukesh Ambani is definitely one of the topmost in India.

SuchindranathAiyerS

5 years ago

My personal experience with the High Court of Karnataka shows how the Courts bend or even completely ignore laid down laws and procedures to favour the wealthy and influential in a defamation case that I had filed against several VIPs and which was cognized. The High Court granted a stay before the Magistrate could receive and weigh evidence on both side, directly accepted averments and fabricated documents from the VIPs as evidence and proclaimed in open court that what cannot be considered to be more serious than "littering" to be "vandalism" and declared that the evidence of defamation produced by me to the Magistrate does not constitute a crime on the basis of inadmissible "evidence"! I wish Moneylife all the best, but in the prevalent state of the Indian judicial system, I would urge great care and caution.

REPLY

Indur Chhugani

In Reply to SuchindranathAiyerS 5 years ago

- At the slightest dissent from any person writing against the Judges or courts - the Judges file Contempt case - BUT I have sent mails to the concerned Judges and High Court and Supreme Court - tempting them to initiate contempt proceedings against me - BUT they refuse - Perhaps apprehensive, this case of my eviction from flat at age 66 - Will reach all across the country -.
.
What use are 2 Judges together – IF both are having extremely low IQ level ? – Just one with human intelligence would be better

http://ikchhugani.wordpress.com/?p=8

SuchindranathAiyerS

In Reply to SuchindranathAiyerS 5 years ago

The memory of the pillorying of the Kanchi Shankaracharya by the Kanchi Magistrate and the High Court of Madras on false (non) evidence is fresh in recent memory! As well as the Supreme Court refusing to give the Chief of Army Staff a fair hearing. I wish Moneylife all the best, but in the prevalent state of the Indian judicial system, I would urge great care and caution.

Dolphy Dsouza

5 years ago

Surely, Gopalkrishna Gandhi's comment on Reliance as a parallel state holds true. All is money power. It appears there is some truth in the allegations, otherwise Reliance with all its resources would have refuted the charges. Now they are baring their fangs to threaten and browbeat even if you ask the correct questions. Reliance does it all the times. It is truly democracy in which the Reliance control the government. Does it need another revolution?

Dolphy

Bidyut Chatterjee

5 years ago

I have serious doubts about the honesty and integrity of the Ambanis and in fact they are the most dishonest business house this country has ever seen. They squeeze the poor of the little money they have and thus enrich themselves. Build luxury mansions worth tens of thousands of crores. These are the guys who are responsible for the rise in NPA of the Banks. Real jokes who are sucking the people of this country dry. Someone must be helping them. I am sure the people of the country know.

krishna

5 years ago

We are 99 %, the notice has come from 1 % camp. It is an assault of money power on truth. Truth hurts 1 % class the most. Occupy Wall Street movement and its myriad incarnations have a long way to go.

krishna

5 years ago

We are 99 %, the notice has come from 1 % camp. It is an assault of money power on truth. Truth hurts 1 % class the most. Occupy Wall Street movement and its myriad incarnations have a long way to go.

krishna

5 years ago

We are 99 %, the notice has come from 1 % camp. It is an assault money power on truth. Truth hurts 1 % class the most. Occupy Wall Street movement and its myriad incarnations have a long way to go.

HUL Q4 net profit up 11% to Rs872.13 crore

Hindustan Unilever’s net profit during the March quarter grew to Rs872.13 crore on low input costs and growth in domestic business

Hindustan Unilever Ltd (HUL), the fast moving consumer goods (FMCG), company reported a 11% higher fourth quarter net profit on lower input costs and growth in its domestic consumer business.

For the quarter to end-March, the FMCG company, a unit of Unilever, said its standalone net profit rose 11% to Rs872.13 crore from Rs787.20 crore, while total revenues, including sales, increased 10% to Rs7,094.10 crore from Rs6,465.81 crore, same period last year.

“Against the backdrop of a challenging environment, we have delivered another year of competitive and profitable growth. We stepped up investment behind our brands and innovations, whilst driving cost savings and operational efficiencies with even greater rigor. Looking ahead, we are confident that our strategy is on track to deliver sustainable long term growth and margin improvement,” Harish Manwani, chairman of HUL said in a statement.

The company said during the quarter, its domestic consumer business grew at 9% with 3% underlying volume growth. “The operating context during the quarter remained challenging with slowing market growth and high competitive intensity. Firm input costs were managed through a mix of judicious pricing and cost savings. Brand investments were sustained at competitive levels with higher advertising spend being offset by lower promotional activities,” HUL added.

Soaps and detergents segment

Skin Cleansing delivered double digit growth, aided by a step up in price growth as judicious pricing actions were taken to manage input cost inflation. Growth was broad based across brands with the liquids portfolio seeing accelerated growth.

In Laundry, growth was led by the premium segment with Surf maintaining its double digit growth momentum and Rin delivering good growth on the bars portfolio. Wheel growth stepped up on the back of its re-launch in the last quarter. Comfort Fabric Conditioners continue to lead market development with sustained high growth. Vim led the performance in Household Care.

Personal products

Skin Care grew well in a soft market. The re-launch of Fair & Lovely, with the new ‘Best Ever Formula’ and supported by a focused activation plan, is yielding positive results. Ponds had a good quarter at the premium end while Lakme and Dove sustained their robust performance. The Facial Cleansing portfolio registered broad based growth driven by innovations launched in previous quarters.

Hair Care sustained volume led double digit growth with Dove delivering another strong performance and Clinic Plus doing well. TRESemmé, which saw the addition of a new Split Remedy variant, continued to make very good progress.

In Oral Care, significant investments were made to sustain our competitiveness in the category. While Close Up grew in the quarter, Pepsodent was impacted by the high promotional intensity in the market. Actions are underway to step up performance.
Colour Cosmetics maintained its strong innovation led growth momentum across both Lakme and Elle 18. Lakme continues to strengthen its position in premium make up driven by a range of exciting and contemporary offerings.

Beverages segment

Tea sustained double digit growth on the back of stepped up volumes. Taj Mahal, Red Label and 3 Roses grew in double digits, driven by a strengthened mix and focused in-market activities. The thrust on leading market development for tea bags saw flavoured and green tea bags more than double sales in the quarter. In Coffee, Bru Gold continued to perform well.

Packaged foods segment

Kissan registered another robust quarter with growth accelerating on both Ketchups and Jams, driven by impactful activation while Knorr growth continued to be led by Instant Soups which more than doubled volumes. Ice Creams saw strong growth arising from the selling in of Magnum which was extended to 4 other cities, and sharper in-market execution on Kwality Walls, ahead of the season.

For the 12 month to end-March, HUL said its net profit increased 1.87% to Rs3,867.49  crore from Rs3,796.67 crore, its total revenues grew 8.56% to Rs28,019.13 crore from Rs25,810.21 crore a year ago period.

HUL has declared a full year final dividend of Rs7.50 per share.

HUL closed Monday flat at Rs580.60 on the BSE, while the 30-share benchmark too ended the day flat at 22,631.

For more stock results, check out this page

User

It's Odisha's turn for iron ore mining ban!

There is the fear that a total ban on mining of iron ore in Odisha would practically cripple the iron and steel industry in the country

Odisha is India's largest iron ore producer, accounting for nearly 45% of production of 145 million tonnes. Besides iron ore, it is also the large producer of chrome and bauxite. There is the fear that a total ban on mining of iron ore in Odisha would practically cripple the iron and steel industry in the country.

It is generally believed that more than 100 illegal mining operations are being carried out in Odisha leading to environmental degradation. It may be recalled that the Supreme Court lifted the ban on iron ore mining in Karnataka a few months ago, and the industry is limping back, though normalcy will take a few months more to achieve. In the meantime, only a few weeks ago, iron ore mining operations in Goa was lifted, though with conditions, where the industry feels that it would be a good six months or so before some semblance of normalcy can be expected there. As reported in Moneylife earlier, there are chances that the cap of 20 million tonnes may be increased taking into consideration the overall impact in the country.

Today, Lawyer Prashant Bhushan, on behalf of NGO Common Cause will seek a temporary ban on Odisha mines that do not have clearances. It may be borne in mind that a total ban would hurt the domestic industry and lead to needless imports; and even if this should occur, it would be atleast 60/90 days before imported ore can reach India, during which time, the steel industry would suffer, and thousands would be unemployed, for no fault of theirs!

The state government is expected to meet the Central Empowered Committee that has been appointed by the Supreme Court to decide what interim orders could be issued.

MB Shah Commission recommendations, it may be recalled, seeks a closure of all illegal mining operations. Penalties imposed on defaulters be directed towards welfare of tribals and villagers. Petition also seeks for a CBI probe into mining and for restoration of revegetation and natural surroundings. Besides, it seeks all mined ores to be traced electronically and sold through e-auctions!

Based on the petition submitted by Prashant Bhushan, NGO Common Cause, the Supreme Court has given four weeks to both central and state governments to file their replies. It has also directed the Court appointed Central Empowered Committee to prepare and submit an interim report on mining in Odisha and also submit a list of miners who have been operating in the State without proper environmental and forest clearances. On all these matters, the Court will be hearing the case today for the interim order.

India's largest FDI of Rs52,000 crore covering the POSCO Steel plant, to be set up to produce 12 million tonnes of steel at Jagatsinghpur is stuck for the last eight years due to regulatory hurdles and delays in land acquisition. The Centre has asked the state government to resolve these issues without delay!

In the case of Jindal Steel & Power Ltd, the Odisha Directorate of Mines has ordered the closure of Sarda Mines Private Ltd's Thakurani mines, owing to expiration of environmental clearance, as on 1st April 2014, effectively cutting off supplies to JSPL, which sources all the iron ore produced in these mines!

It may be noted that JSPL was sourcing these iron ore fines for its 5 million tonnes pellet plant at Barbil in Odisha and lumpy ore for its 3 mt steel plant at Raigad in Chhatisgarh. Luckily for JSPL, it has adequate stocks on hand and the inventory is estimated at 15 million tonnes, which will be presumably transported to the pellet plant, until the formalities are completed.

One other issue that would also need government assistance is the clearance for companies working on "deemed leases". If the state government gives preference to original lease holders, the industry may be relieved but if new bidding process is to be held, this would be time consuming and may delay the starting of the mining operations, once they come to a stop.

India's export of iron ore fines has gone down to 16 million tonnes in 2013 against 108 mt in 2010. Compare to this poor performance, Australia exports 600 million tonnes, while Brazil runs second at 300 million tonnes.

Now the issue at stake is not how much India can export. What is of paramount importance is to keep the Indian steel industry going. We must remember that it took months when mining activity came to a stand still in both Karnataka and Goa. As we mentioned before, Karnataka has not yet realised its full potential, while Goa would take another six months or so before some activity can be seen, since a lot of formalities have to be completed for the existing mine owners, particularly those who have proper documentation and clearances. Of course, it is imperative that illegal mining activity must be stopped; but those with the least "lapses" in terms of compliance of formalities should be permitted to commence their operations.

A total ban would affect the industry and thousands employed, besides loss of revenue for the country.

(AK Ramdas has worked with the Engineering Export Promotion Council of the ministry of commerce. He was also associated with various committees of the Council. His international career took him to places like Beirut, Kuwait and Dubai at a time when these were small trading outposts; and later to the US.)

Like this story? Get our top stories by email.

User

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.
  Loading...
Close

To continue


Please
Sign Up or Sign In
with

Email
Close

To continue


Please
Sign Up or Sign In
with

Email

BUY NOW

online financial advisory
Pathbreakers
Pathbreakers 1 & Pathbreakers 2 contain deep insights, unknown facts and captivating events in the life of 51 top achievers, in their own words.
online financia advisory
The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Online Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
financial magazines online
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
financial magazines in india
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Online Magazine)