PMS in troubled waters
Frequent churning of portfolio, high management fees followed by dismal returns and dwindling profitability is leading to several Asset Management Companies (AMCs) exiting the portfolio management service (PMS) business. Such exits would have not been normally noticed because PMS is a privately sold service. But one of them, from Franklin Templeton, has turned controversial after the fund house abruptly exited from the PMS business, leaving the investors and distributors high and dry. According to distributors, Franklin Templeton has failed to offer enough reasons to them and investors for impetuously pulling out two equity products—FT Select and FT Opportunities.

The distributors are now angry with the fund house for putting them in an awkward situation in front of the clients, to whom they were once encouraged to sell PMS. “During the bull run, AMCs tried to convert PMS from a large value item into a retail item. But as the market crashed, they realised that it was not the right place for them to be,” said T Srikanth Bhagavat, managing director, Hexagon Capital Advisors Pvt. Ltd. Zankhana Shah, co-founder, Moneycare Financial Planning Ltd, said, “I was surprised with Templeton’s move. I had to incur 50% loss because of this.”

In an attempt to underplay the crisis, Harshendu Bindal, president, Franklin Templeton Investments India said, “We haven't closed down our PMS business but pulled out only two equity products—FT Select and FT Opportunities.”

Before 2005, if an investor wanted to enter the PMS business, the entry level charge used to be anywhere between Rs50 lakh and Rs1 crore. During 2005- 2006 when the stock market was bullish, AMCs had slashed the PMS entry level charge between Rs5 to Rs10 lakh in a bid to attract more retail customers.

Besides Templeton, DSP BlackRock Investment Managers has also shut down its PMS business.

The profit-sharing fee charged by most PMS houses is also on the higher side. Most PMS houses charge 20% more than the hurdle rate profit-sharing ratio. Even if the scheme shows poor performance, the PMS house charges a fixed fee which is very high. Again there is no control on the cost in terms of churning and the brokerages paid to distributors. There is no transparency in the process.

Some distributors don’t even like PMS. “I do not like PMS schemes and I do not sell these schemes. It’s my personal choice as I am not convinced with what fund houses like Templeton have done,” said Kolkata-based Brijesh Dalmia, founder, Dalmia Advisory Services.
When asked whether PMS is a dubious product because of high costs and poor returns, Dalmia said,”PMS is a good product but the paradox is that customers do not understand it. PMS is sold as a customised product, but in reality, it is not. This is because the cost is very high compared to other investment options available in the market. The taxation is not suitable for customers. Besides, there is no control on the churning part by the fund house or the fund manager.”
“I find there is no logic to differentiate PMS from a mutual fund. The PMS schemes are operated in a manner where there is no fixed fee structure and capping on expenses on churning. This is obviously not in the interest of the client. In the last couple of years, I have not seen any PMS which has beaten the benchmark index of any diversified equity fund. Of course, PMS will be promoted by the distributors and financial advisors because of high commission offered by the fund houses which range anywhere between 2%-4%,” said Dalmia.
Vidyut Kumar Ta & Pallabika Ganguly [email protected]
  • Like this story? Get our top stories by email.


    The Cycle Turns
    The domestic tyre industry is in a revival mode, driven primarily by substantial demand improvement in the automobile industry, specifically in the commercial vehicles and replacement market. Phillips Carbon Black Limited (PCBL) is a major beneficiary of this revival. Carbon black is the key ingredient in making tyres.

    PCBL, a part of the RPG group, is the largest producer of carbon black...
    Premium Content
    Monthly Digital Access


    Already A Subscriber?
    Yearly Digital Access


    Moneylife Magazine Subscriber or MAS member?

    Yearly Subscriber Login

    Enter the mail id that you want to use & click on Go. We will send you a link to your email for verficiation
  • Explosive Potential?
    Secunderabad-based Premier Explosives Limited (PEL) is a small but growing company that will not appear on the radar of institutional investors. Its turnover for the year ended March 2009 was just Rs70 crore but it claims to be a manufacturer of the entire range of explosives and accessories in India. PEL claims to have the widest range of products and technologies in explosives and accessories. The company also undertakes complete drilling and blasting contracts in collaboration with associates having drilling and excavation resources. Its manufacturing units are based in Madhya Pradesh, Andhra Pradesh and Maharashtra.
    Founded in 1980 by AN Gupta, a gold medallist in mining engineering, PEL is a company with a difference. Look at its enviable track record in research & development (R&D) work. PEL’s R&D facility is recognised as an established research centre by the Centre for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) and for doctoral studies by Osmania University, Andhra Pradesh. In January 2007, the company had signed a long-term contract of Rs70 crore for 10 years (renewable for another 10 years) with Satish Dhawan Space Centre, Sriharikota (SHAR), belonging to Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) mainly for the operation and maintenance of the second propellant plant (SPP) project at SHAR. Recently, PEL has signed a memorandum of understanding (MoU) with the material science department of Gulbarga University for taking up R&D activities in the area of material sciences. The company has received a number of awards for R&D, environment conservation, industrial relations and technology. It won the prestigious Defence Technology Absorption Award 2007 from the Defence Research Development Organisation (DRDO), Ministry of Defence, Government of India.
    PEL also has two joint ventures abroad—Premier Synthas (Turkey) and Premier Georgia (Georgia), mainly for manufacturing explosives and accessories. In August 2008, the company formed a joint venture with M/s VXL Technologies Ltd, Faridabad, called ‘VTL Premier Pyrotechnics Ltd’ for manufacture of pyrotechnic devices, fuses, etc, used for defence. The company also received a licence from the Indian government to manufacture propellants, pyros, hexanitrostilbene (HNS), hydrazinium nitroformate (HNF), a cyclic nitramine explosive called CL-20 and site-mixed explosives. This licence will help the company expand its product portfolio and the quantity of output ensuring higher revenues. Over the next two years, the company proposes to invest Rs50 crore for capacity expansion and backward integration, i.e., manufacturing raw materials used in the company’s products. Alongside, the company expects to obtain new orders as the Indian government proposes to increase defence expenditure by 33% for 2009-2010 and the fall in raw material prices could reduce manufacturing costs, currently (2008-2009) at 54.53% of the total cost.
    The stock is trading at Rs66, which is not cheap. Its market-cap is 0.65 times its five-quarter sales (annualised) and five times its annualised operating profits. But its PE is 17—lower than 25 of Solar Industries. In FY08-09, PEL reported sales of Rs70.23 crore (a rise of 23% over the corresponding period the previous year); operating profit was down from Rs9.7 crore to Rs8.06 crore (-17%). For the June 2009 quarter, the company posted sales of Rs23.08 crore (up 51%) and operating profit went up 95% to Rs4.07 crore. Over the past five quarters, its sales have grown by an average 28%. Its operating margin averaged 13% over the past five quarters. It would be worth buying this stock at Rs45.
    Stepping Up
    Relaxo Footwear has an edge
    Relaxo Footwear is in the humdrum business of making footwear such as Hawaii slippers, casuals, joggers and school shoes. Headquartered in Delhi, the company was founded in 1976. While foreign footwear companies have introduced a brand culture in India and are focusing on the rich and upper-middle-class, Relaxo is catering to the lower-middle-class and the lower-income group. In this segment, it is competing with Bata India, Action Shoes and Liberty Shoes.
    Relaxo’s edge is based on low price, reasonable quality and large production capacity. Its manufacturing capacity, of 100 million pairs per annum, is second only to Bata’s. It also has the capacity to manufacture 300,000 pairs of Hawaii slippers per day which is the highest in India. Economies of scale enable the company to keep its product prices low. It also exports products to the US and the UK. Its financial performance for the past two quarters has been good. Sales have grown 30% and 31%, respectively, while operating profit has risen 80% and 102% in the March and June quarters over the same quarters of the previous year. The five-quarter average sales and operating profit growth are 33% and 42%, respectively. Its operating margin is low (11%) but the stock is really cheap. Its market-cap is 0.25 and 2.14 times its sales and operating profit. Following its robust quarterly performance, the stock has soared from Rs28 in March to Rs105 till date. Buy it at around Rs70.
    Lesha Energy Resources (Rs71)
    In the June 2008 quarter, the company posted sales of Rs67 lakh while in the following four quarters (September 2008, December 2008, March 2009 and June 2009), it posted zero sales. The company has been posting operating losses consistently, for the past four quarters beginning June 2008. Lesha posted operating losses of Rs1 lakh, Rs8 lakh, Rs4 lakh and Rs2 lakh, respectively and an operating loss of Rs9 lakh in the June 2009 quarter. In January 2008, the company is supposed to have terminated its steel business to deal in oil & gas after exploring various alternative business opportunities. As it happens, the stock price is another story. Lesha surged 673% between 20 February 2009 and
    11 September 2009.
    Natura Hue Chem (Rs19)
    Chhattisgarh-based Natura Hue Chem is supposed to be engaged in organic farming of turmeric, chilli and ginger. It also claims to have diversified into the power sector. Beginning June 2008, the company posted quarterly sales of Rs2.29 crore, Rs1.14 crore, Rs2.15 crore and Rs5.89 crore, respectively. In the June 2008 and September 2008 quarters, it recorded operating profit of Rs4 lakh each, whereas in the December 2008 and March 2009 quarters, the company posted an operating profit of Rs10 lakh and Rs41 lakh, respectively. As you would expect, the stock price movement has nothing to do with these fundamentals. Between 24 March 2009 and 11 September 2009, the stock was up a humungous 784%. Are the regulators watching?
    Street Beat stocks are selected stocks in the Moneylife database. Disclaimer: None of the stock information, data and company information presented herein constitutes a recommendation or a solicitation of any offer to buy or sell any securities. Information presented is general information that does not take into account your individual circumstances, financial situation or needs nor does it present a personalised recommendation to you. Individual stocks presented may not be suitable for you. Although information has been obtained from and is based upon sources, we believe to be reliable, we do not guarantee its accuracy and the information may be incomplete or condensed. All opinions and estimates constitute our judgement as of the date of the report and are subject to change without notice. This report is for informational purpose only and is not intended as an offer or solicitation for the purchase or sale of a security. Past performance is no indication of future results. Investors must do their own research before acting on them. Exit Strategy: Please exit if the stock closes 9% below the purchase price. This is called stop loss. However, if the market price is above the purchase price, exit if the stock falls by 20% below any day’s closing price. This is called stop profit. 
  • Like this story? Get our top stories by email.


    We are listening!

    Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

    To continue

    Sign Up or Sign In


    To continue

    Sign Up or Sign In



    online financial advisory
    Pathbreakers 1 & Pathbreakers 2 contain deep insights, unknown facts and captivating events in the life of 51 top achievers, in their own words.
    online financia advisory
    The Scam
    24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
    Moneylife Online Magazine
    Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
    financial magazines online
    Stockletters in 3 Flavours
    Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
    financial magazines in india
    MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
    (Includes Moneylife Online Magazine)
    FREE: Your Complete Family Record Book
    Keep all the Personal and Financial Details of You & Your Family. In One Place So That`s Its Easy for Anyone to Find Anytime
    We promise not to share your email id with anyone