Pantaloon Retail buys 99 lakh shares of Future Ventures for Rs8 crore, despite its weak financials

Another Future Group company, Pantaloon Industries, also bought 98 lakh shares for another Rs8 crore to prevent a further fall of the stock price on debut. But the Future Ventures share is still struggling well below its issue price

Future Ventures India Ltd, the investment company promoted by Future Group's Kishore Biyani, made its debut on the stock exchanges yesterday. On the first day of trading itself, the scrip underperformed and closed 17% below its issue price.

On the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE), the share made its debut at Rs9.50, and after touching an intra-day low of Rs7.95, it closed at Rs8.30. Around 76 million shares were traded on the stock exchange.

There was panic among retail investors as the scrip underperformed on the opening day itself and this led to heavy selling of the company's shares. In the middle of this chaos, Pantaloon Retail, another company of the Future Group, purchased about 99.55 lakh shares of Future Ventures at Rs8.20.

Interestingly, Pantaloon itself hasn't shown any robust growth in the last quarter. So, given its own weak financials, this move by the company, to buy shares of Future Ventures, raises several doubts. Pantaloon Retail's net profit for the quarter ended 31 December 2010 stood at Rs19.91 crore, up just Rs2.33 crore from Rs17.58 crore in the preceding September 2010 quarter.

Further, Pantaloon Industries, yet another group company, also bought 98.25 lakh shares of Future Ventures yesterday at the price of Rs8.20. The promoters of the group company were prompted to buy Future Ventures shares after witnessing the heavy sell-off on the counter, and this helped the stock recover some upward momentum.

The Future Ventures stock followed the same trend on the National Stock Exchange (NSE) as well. On the NSE the share made its debut at Rs9. It touched an intra-day high of Rs9.65, but closed the day at Rs8.20. Around 174.75 million shares were traded during market hours.

A simple calculation would reveal that Pantaloon's decision to buy the Future Ventures shares cost it around Rs8.16 crore. This appears strange, for the company's net profit in the December 2010 quarter was just Rs19.91 crore. Analysts expect that the stock will slide further. This could see the company suffer losses.

Future Ventures raised Rs750 crore through the initial public offer of shares priced at Rs10 each. The issue was subscribed 1.5 times. The company's shares were mainly subscribed by high net worth individuals, while the quota for institutional and retail investors was under-subscribed.

Moneylife has reported earlier how the Future Ventures prospectus stated that it cannot compare the promise and performance of Galaxy Entertainment, the company it acquired, because it did not have the IPO records of Galaxy which are legal documents. Still, SEBI cleared the Future Ventures prospectus, unaware of this irony.  (Read, 'Future Ventures says it does not have IPO documents of a listed company it acquired three years ago'.)

Meanwhile, in trading today, the Future Ventures stock rose to Rs8.60 from yesterday's close of Rs8.30 on the BSE. On the NSE, the stock closed at Rs8.60, up from its previous close of Rs8.20.

  • Like this story? Get our top stories by email.

    User

    COMMENTS

    K A PRASANNA

    9 years ago

    No body sells cheaper than Future group. They have kept their word! It really sells cheaper.For them, financials does not matter. They have, invested either the public money or from the loan availed from banks.

    Vikas

    9 years ago

    I bought Pantaloon Retail at 390 in nov 2010 and today it is trading at 240/- in 6 months.

    Vikas

    9 years ago

    It looks like Mr Kishore Biyani the next Ramalinga Raju and Pantaloons the next Satyam because Pantaloon's share had already crashed close to 50% a few months back and now this insane buy is a scam of its own. Are these people hand-in-glove with SEBI? What about investors stuck with them?

    shom

    9 years ago

    Worth looking at who are the HNIs who subscribed and sold the shares?

    Question mark over timing of JP Morgan advisory, moneycontrol report on SKS Microfinance

    The stock price of the country’s only listed microfinance firm crashed 35% in two trading sessions, leading the market regulator to initiate an inquiry into possible insider trading

    The SKS Microfinance stock price crashed by 20% on the bourses on Friday, after brokerage house JP Morgan slashed the target price of the country's only listed microfinance firm by more than half, to Rs200, from the earlier Rs550.

    Even as speculation is rife over the hammering of the scrip, market experts are questioning the timing of the advisory released by JP Morgan, as it was released shortly before the announcement of the company's fourth-quarter results.

    One market expert pointed out that only two days before the results, the financial portal moneycontrol.com published a report, titled "Bear of the day: Stock that plunged 58% in 6 months", in which it described how SKS has "lost 58.30% in the last six months."

    "Two things happened before the results-the story on moneycontrol.com and the JP Morgan sell advisory. The timing looks suspicious. In my opinion it is both bear hammering and an insider trading violation," he explained.

    The JP Morgan report cited challenges ahead for SKS and slashed its target price. Then on May 6, the shares price of SKS Microfinance plunged by 20% to Rs331.30, its lowest ever.

    The 20% fall on Friday was coupled with a 10-fold surge in the stock's trading volumes, prompting the bourses and market regulator Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) to consider a probe into the possible breach of insider trading norms, or hammering by a bear cartel.

    Strangely, the SKS stock price crash coincided with a strong upward trend in the market, as the BSE Sensex rose by over 300 points, and came only a few days after the Reserve Bank of India said that bank loans to microfinance lenders would be categorised as priority sector lending.

    On Friday, the company announced that net profit fell 36% to Rs111.63 crore in the quarter to 31 March 2011, compared to Rs174 crore in the corresponding previous period.

    The surge in trading volumes and a heavy fall in the share price when the company announced a loss only after market hours is being seen as an unusual event by market surveillance authorities who have therefore initiated a preliminary probe.

    On Monday, the SKS stock continued to fall, losing over 18% to a new low of Rs268 as analysts forecast a dull outlook for the microfinance lending sector. Volumes continued to surge. Over 27 lakh shares were traded on Monday, which was double the volume that was traded on Friday.

    The company has said that it would welcome an inquiry by the regulator, to investigate the circumstances leading to the fall in the share price.

    Moneylife sent e-mail messages to JP Morgan and moneycontrol, as well as SEBI, seeking their comments on the questionable timing of the advisory and the publication of the story. The messages have not been answered.

    The SKS Microfinance stock price climbed steadily through the morning trade on the Bombay Stock Exchange today, and closed at Rs297, a gain of 10% over its previous close of Rs270.

  • Like this story? Get our top stories by email.

    User

    COMMENTS

    S Amin

    9 years ago

    It is ridiculous to believe on what ground did JP Morgan and money.control issue such irresponsible comments. The stock price tumbled and investors had to suffer. May I request ML to go deep into this matter and ensure confidence is regained to the investors.

    Anonymous

    9 years ago

    http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes...

    Link to Narayan Murthy's allotment to SKS shares

    Anonymous

    9 years ago

    http://microfinanceafrica.net/microfinan...

    http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes...

    The second link explains how overvalued the shares were when the IPO came out. Even the current market price doesn't seem to match the price at which employess / CEO got the shares. Other investors like Narayan Murthy (his Trust actually) were also sold the shares, at a premium though (but cheaper than the IPO price)

    Anonymous

    9 years ago

    There was another coincidence which escaped the eye of investors. The case between the sacked CEO and SKS microfinance was settled by compensating the CEO for some shares priced at 300 Rs

    K A PRASANNA

    9 years ago

    Manipulators are busy again in SKS Micro. There were no takers for Rs 270 on 09-05-11 and toady the stock is locked at the upper end (10%). Some thing fishy. The stock is not worth Rs 100. Like water, this stock will find its level in due course.

    Share prices struggling to rally; fall to resume soon: Monday Closing Report

    Expect selling pressure at the Nifty level of 5,600

    The market opened with gains following last week’s sell-off in commodities, especially crude, easing the government’s worries about higher prices. Sensex and Nifty opened in positive at 18,629 and 5,575. Immediately the market hit their respective intra day high, which was higher than Friday’s high, at 18,644 and 5,586. A firming trend in the Asian markets also boosted investor sentiment here. Stocks of metals, realty, oil & gas, banking and capital goods propped up the indices higher in early trade.
     
    The market, however, soon started falling trend amid choppy trade. In the morning session itself the market hit its intra day low at 18,367 and 5,502.  Immediately thereafter the indices hot up, but lack of direction ensured that the benchmarks stayed near at the same level as yesterday. However, the market doesn’t have the strength to rally much. The Sensex rose 10 points to close at 18,529 while the Nifty fell 0.35 points at 5,551. For whatever it is worth, for the second day in a row, the market has made a higher high and a higher low. The advance-decline ratio on the National Stock Exchange was 540:801.
     
    In line with the Sensex, the broader markets also ended unchanged. The BSE Mid-cap index gained 0.12% while the BSE Small-cap index added 0.22 points.
     
    In the sectoral space, BSE Fast Moving Consumer Goods (up 1.24%), BSE Metal (up 0.74%) and BSE TECk (up 0.49%) were the top gainers. On the other hand, BSE Auto (down 1.29%), BSE Bankex (down 0.37%) and BSE Consumer Durables (down 0.32%) were the major losers.
     
    The top performers on the Sensex were Bharti Airtel (up 3.93%), Hindustan Unilever (up 3.55%), Tata Power (up 2.49%), Jindal Steel (up 1.02%) and Sterlite Industries (up 0.95%). The laggards were led by Maruti Suzuki (down 2.24%), Jaiprakash Associates (down 1.91%), Tata Motors (down 1.90%), Bajaj Auto (down 1.84%) and Reliance Infrastructure (down 1.43%).
     
    New Delhi-based research firm PE Analytics has drawn up plans to launch its real estate price Index in partnership with a leading commodity exchange. These indices will be based on the actual transaction and registration values prevailing in various micro-markets for the residential and commercial asset classes.
     
    The indices will be the barometer for measurement of the real estate sector performance and will also enable trade on the exchange. The company is looking at September 2011 to go live with this product offering.
     
    Markets in Asia settled mostly higher on Monday, bouncing back after a sharp fall last week. However, the gains were capped by concerns about the euro zone’s sovereign debt troubles. On the other hand, the Japanese market was down on fears of potential power outages and the Seoul market was weighed down on speculations that the Bank of Korea might hike interest rates this week.
     
    The Shanghai Composite gained 0.32%, the Hang Seng surged 0.76%, the KLSE Composite rose 0.26%, the Straits Times jumped 1.21% and the Taiwan Weighted climbed 0.65%. On the other hand, the Jakarta Composite fell 0.34%, the Nikkei 225 declined 0.66% and the Seoul Composite lost 0.39%.
     
    Back home, domestic institutional investors were net buyers of stocks worth Rs1,018.04 crore on Friday. On the other hand, foreign institutional investors were net sellers of equities worth Rs655.34 crore.
  • Like this story? Get our top stories by email.

    User

    We are listening!

    Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.
      Loading...
    Close

    To continue


    Please
    Sign Up or Sign In
    with

    Email
    Close

    To continue


    Please
    Sign Up or Sign In
    with

    Email

    BUY NOW

    online financial advisory
    Pathbreakers
    Pathbreakers 1 & Pathbreakers 2 contain deep insights, unknown facts and captivating events in the life of 51 top achievers, in their own words.
    online financia advisory
    The Scam
    24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
    Moneylife Online Magazine
    Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
    financial magazines online
    Stockletters in 3 Flavours
    Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
    financial magazines in india
    MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
    (Includes Moneylife Online Magazine)
    FREE: Your Complete Family Record Book
    Keep all the Personal and Financial Details of You & Your Family. In One Place So That`s Its Easy for Anyone to Find Anytime
    We promise not to share your email id with anyone