Four out of 12 offices have no Ombudsmen since November 2013. Mumbai has no ombudsman for 4 months and Delhi has a part-time one visiting from Chandigarh
Did you get Income Tax (IT) refund? If not, you can file a complaint with IT Ombudsman. But do you know if the IT Ombudsman of your region is actually in office or the post is lying vacant? IT Ombudsman is an independent body set up by the government. They are appointed from the ranks of former IT officials or officials from the Indian Revenue Service (IRS). These officers have been empowered to settle grievances and they can take up matters to the highest authority. They act as an arbitrator and are independent of the jurisdiction of the IT Department.
But the IT Ombudsman office in Mumbai has backlog of pending cases because the Ombudsman is missing since 8 November 2013. There are 10-12 cases coming in daily to the office and hence it can be estimated that there can be over 1000 pending cases. The office has no idea when the new Ombudsman will be appointed and expects no one to take charge till June 2014 due to pending general elections. Does consumer redressal go for a toss till elections are over?
Pune Ombudsman is the link officer who had recently visited Mumbai Ombudsman office to give guidance, but there is no one present to make decisions unless there is some critical pending case. Pune Ombudsman office itself is vacant as per IT website. But, the position got filled by GG Shukla who was earlier deputed at Kochi Ombudsman office. This information is not updated on the IT website. In fact, most of the Ombudsman related data is obsolete on the webpage.
Please see - http://www.incometaxindiapr.gov.in/incometaxindiacr/home.jsp?p1=ombudsman_contacts and http://www.incometaxindia.gov.in/KnowYourOmbudsman.asp
Even major region like Delhi has no full-time Ombudsman. It has to satisfy itself with Chandigarh Ombudsman visiting part-time. But, the Chandigarh Ombudsman probably has his hands full by serving complaints from Chandigarh as well as Himachal Pradesh, Punjab, Haryana and J&K.
Surprisingly, there is no Ombudsman since November 2013 in the offices of Kanpur (covering UP and Uttarakhand), Hyderabad (covering Andhra Pradesh) and Ahmedabad (covering Rajasthan, Gujarat, Daman & Diu, Dadra & Nagar Haveli). Did the Ombudsmen serving these offices all retire at the same time? Will there possibly be no replacement till election is over (June 2014)?
The IT website has completely outdated information about serving Ombudsman in the offices. We got correct information (in table) after calling all the 12 IT Ombudsman offices in India. We are putting out the data we have collected which would be useful for the readers.
Region | Website data | Actual Ombudsman | Phone |
Delhi (NCR) | Prakash Chandra. Invalid phone number 011-23379925 | Ashok Manchanda (Not full time. Chandigarh Ombudsman visits Delhi) | 011-23233688 |
Kanpur (UP and Uttarakhand) | KP Singh | No Ombudsman since November 2013 | 0522-2204473 |
Kolkata (WB, Bihar, Odisha, NE States, Jharkhand, Andaman & Nicobar islands) | Manoj Misra | KK Mahapatra | 033-22136702 |
Mumbai | Mukesh Bhanti | No Ombudsman since November 2013 | 022-22829930 |
Kochi (Kerala and Lakshadweep) | GG Shukla | K Madhavan Nair | 0484-2378455 |
Hyderabad (Andhra Pradesh) | AK Basu | No Ombudsman since November 2013 | 040-23425612 |
Chennai (Tamil Nadu & Pondicherry) | Sunil Chopra | MD Kabra (appointed after vacancy of six months) | 044-28295486 |
Bengaluru (Karnataka and Goa) | ML Agarwal | ML Agarwal | 080-25538389 |
Ahmedabad (Rajasthan, Gujarat, Daman & Diu, Dadra & Nagar Haveli) | Dr Kalyan Chaudhuri | No Ombudsman since November 2013 | 079-26581459 |
Pune (Maharashtra excluding Mumbai) | Vacant | GG Shukla | 020-26056238 (invalid number) |
Chandigarh (HP, Punjab, Haryana, Chandigarh, J&K) | Ashok Manchanda | Ashok Manchanda (works part-time as Delhi Ombudsman) | 0172-2701903 |
Bhopal (MP and Chattisgarh) | Kalyan Chand | GS Randhawa | 0755-2467032 |
Income Tax Ombudsman data across all the 12 offices
The government of India has appointed Ombudsmen at various locations to look into the grievances of taxpayers if the normal system does not respond. They handle a host of grievances other than IT refunds. These include interest waiver petitions, giving effect to appellate orders, rectification of applications, release of seized books of accounts, allotment of PAN, and issue of PAN cards, credit of tax paid etc.
Under the current rules, before you approach the Ombudsman, you should have submitted a written complaint with your IT officer. If you feel that the complaint has not been addressed to your complete satisfaction, or if the officer rejects your complaint, or if no reply is received within 30 days of writing the complaint, only then should the issue be raised to Ombudsman. It is important to note that the complaint should be filed with the Ombudsman within one year, after the 30 day wait for a response from the IT officer.
Inside story of the National Stock Exchange’s amazing success, leading to hubris, regulatory capture and algo scam
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance.
1-year online access to the magazine articles published during the subscription period.
Access is given for all articles published during the week (starting Monday) your subscription starts. For example, if you subscribe on Wednesday, you will have access to articles uploaded from Monday of that week.
This means access to other articles (outside the subscription period) are not included.
Articles outside the subscription period can be bought separately for a small price per article.
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance.
30-day online access to the magazine articles published during the subscription period.
Access is given for all articles published during the week (starting Monday) your subscription starts. For example, if you subscribe on Wednesday, you will have access to articles uploaded from Monday of that week.
This means access to other articles (outside the subscription period) are not included.
Articles outside the subscription period can be bought separately for a small price per article.
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance.
Complete access to Moneylife archives since inception ( till the date of your subscription )
At the outset, thanks for highlighting this one area where the grievance redressal Government Nodal Authority is absent. But frankly this is not NEW or surprising. The entire Government machinery stinks and people suffer by this criminal negligence of Government . Wherever, the redressal or regulating Authority is there, it also suffers from lack of Government support in providing adequate Manpower or Infrastructure. Posts at all levels remain VACANT FOR YEARS. EXISTING AUTHORITIES EITHER have inadequate support staff or infrastructure. All Ombudsmen in almost all key areas ( Example- Banking ,Insurance, etc. ) are OVERLOADED. Complaints can be lodged easily, but to get those heard or get an AWARD, it takes years as there is huge backlog. Let some Doctorate student write a thesis.The bogey of Government's claim to have provided enough laws will come out fully ineffective for lack of DELIVERANCE for one reason or the other .
Even the Telecom and Insurance Regulators have failed in their duty to monitor the complaints against service providers. And the vital field of Telecom Services does not even have an OMBUDSMAN. Users are at the mercy of the resolutions offered by the Telecom Service Provider itself as per the Grievance Procedure framed by TRAI. And that is flouted with impunity almost at levels of service provider. Since there is no Authority like Ombudsman to mediate; consumers have no option but to only approach the Consumer Court for even a small relief. And for violations of laid down norms by either TRAI or IRDA, complaints for penal action are never taken up/ acknoledged bythe Regulators.
And that grim scenario is order of the day for which WE CRY ON THIS CONSUMERS DAY
( TODAY 15 TH MARCH)
thanks for your help we donot know that there exist an IT ombudsman and after this article only we came to know about it but can you help me in my case where India infoline stock broking firm had misused my POA and had cheated me the matter had been referred to sebi nse bse no response as an third party why cannot you champion for my cause otherwise we have only platform is our international media and channel in which case the whole indian capital would be collapsed and that to in the yeear of election this would back fire our economy and inflation and there by US would try to dominate our country which as citizen of india never wish to do so this article personal to vaibhav Dhoka