Here’s another company that’s openly flouting IRDA norms on prohibition of chain marketing of insurance products
Ravi Samalad 18 May 2010

You have to hand it to this company. The name itself—Rose Valley Chain Marketing System Ltd—makes it clear that the outfit is neck-deep in multi-level marketing schemes. And insurance is part of its arsenal.

The company, certified by the Insurance Regulatory & Development Authority (IRDA) is a corporate agent of the Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC) since 2002 and has six lakh foot soldiers pushing various insurance policies across India.

Moneylife had reported earlier (http://www.moneylife.in/article/8/5371.html) on how according to Section (42) of the Insurance Act, 1938, appointing sub-agents and passing on commission or kickbacks is prohibited. When we had approached the insurance regulator on the proliferation of various MLM insurance schemes, along with the details, IRDA's executive director A Giridhar had told Moneylife, “Selling insurance through unlicensed persons is illegal and we will act on the information provided by you.” In addition, IRDA certification is mandatory for selling insurance products.

But here is an example of a company that does not even find it necessary to cloak its insurance MLM business—its name itself is a dead giveaway.
The model operates as follows—a sales executive has to achieve a target of Rs40,000 within 12 months. This is the joining stage. At the 18th rank, a sales executive ‘graduates’ to become a ‘Development Advisor Group 3’.
The products being peddled include LIC policies, along with fixed deposits and recurring deposits of Rose Valley.

A sales executive does not have to pass an IRDA examination, says an official from the company, which is in express violation of the rules.

The official from Rose Valley said, “Once you reach a certain level, you don’t have to work any more; you can earn commission bought by your chain.”
The brochure also says that a ‘marketing executive’ can also recruit a maximum of 15 sales executives.

At the first stage, the annual target is Rs40,000 and at the final stage (the 18th rank) the target is Rs20 crore. This target also includes the business achieved from the lower chain(s).

The group is a huge conglomerate with its finger in many pies. It has interests in real estate, hospitality, retail, broadcasting and IT education & training.
According to the company official, the group is also looking at entering the housing finance loan segment.
 

Comments
Prof. Bajaj
2 decades ago
IRDA ?? Does something of that name exists ??

IRDA Norms ?? Are they supposed to be followed. Come on, someone must be kidding with you.

The way IRDA has been working, I dont even believe in its existence, forget about its functioning. IRDA reminds me of "Dhritarashtra" who is blind and helpless to stop the Duryodhans (Insurance Companies) and Dushasans (So called Corporate agents) from exploiting investors.

Hope this article of Moneylife acts as Lord Krishna.
MAYUR KULKARNI
2 decades ago
Just like this Amway is also selling Life Insurance Products thru its MLM/Direct Selling Distributors, under brand name of Amsure (visit:http://www.amsure.in). Notably the products giving highest Points are being sold by distributors regardless of customer needs. I met one such advisor recently but he was totally ignorant about basics of investing, insurance & ULIPs
How about this ??
Will irda take action against this ?
DEBRAJ SENGUPTA
2 decades ago
Not only Rose Valley but many other such Coporate Chanells of Reliance Life Insurance, Birla SunLife, Bajaj Allianz are running similar schemes in metros and in rural India without any intimidation. Reliance Life Insurance has created a new hierarchy to look after this thriving business. Even Global players like AMWAY has entered this MLM insurance business. All IRDA and Life Insurance companies are lending a deaf ear to such complaints as every body wants to mintain status quo.
Dillip kumar swain
2 decades ago
Dear ML,
You are writing/scouting aginst illigal things for indian citizen.GOOD.I request u pl. go another step.i.e. PLI.
Nikhil Ghosh
2 decades ago
I wish Moneylife could have brought to the IRDA notice few month back, as all the Insurance as well as MLM companies collected huge amount by silling ULIPs.. I do hope the IRDA the regulators will take some action atleast..
I wish to CONGRATULATE Monelife
Pintu Das
2 decades ago
Hats off to Moneylife, do provide more details to IRDA as they may not be aware off, whats going on and how the policy holder get fooled.
J SATISH
2 decades ago
This is not the new one nowadays many company as been selling the insurance policies by way of MLM only for example TLC who selling BAJAJ ALLIANZE POLICIES , AMWAY who selling MAX NEW YORK POLICY and ROYAL SUNDARAM MEDICLAIM POLICY and there are many more companys which have not come out.
Tapas Chakraborty
2 decades ago
Great Work and kudos to Moneylife for unearthing this group which has its roots in Kolkata and has many of its business interests in West Bengal. This organisation has revolutionised the art of Insurance selling. It claims in many of its Advertisements that it is the largest "Corporate Agent" of LIC and uses the LIC logo in all its branch Signage. In fact the fixed Deposits are also Shams and they have raised crores of Rupees. Their success has inspired many a dubious business entities to take up similar business models in Bengal. Please take up the issue and highlight the ineffectiveness of the regulators
Free Helpline
Legal Credit
Feedback