Governor Rules: Joint Secretary Overrules
This is a true story. It was told to me by one of the dramatis personae.
 
It happened sometime in the 1960s when Kerala was under governor’s rule. A politician from Uttar Pradesh was the governor of Kerala at that time.
 
A young officer from the state secretariat was entrusted with the task of carrying files from the secretariat to the governor’s house daily and getting his orders and signatures. 
 
The governor was so pleased with the meticulous and dedicated manner in which the young man did his job, that he issued a written order that the young man may be given two advance increments in his salary in appreciation of his good work.
 
When the order reached the finance section of the department concerned, an undersecretary, driven probably by envy, felt it his duty to save the state from the capricious whim of a politician. 
 
So, he wrote on the file: “If this order is implemented, it will become a precedent, which will create requests for similar incentives in future. Therefore, it is proposed that it may not be implemented and that the governor’s order may be lodged in our archives. For orders please.” 
 
And then he sent it up to his joint secretary.
 
The joint secretary, a very brilliant young man, who had fully imbibed during his training in a prestigious institution the conviction that, in a parliamentary democracy, it is the bureaucracy that constitutes permanent government,  that  elected politicians are birds of passage who have to pass a test every five years  and that bureaucrats can exercise their powers with impunity to safeguard what they consider the interests of the nation, thought for a while and, as a bold exercise of his decision making powers, wrote with a firm hand: “As proposed”, added his signature with a satisfied smile and sent the file down. 
 
The file was promptly sent to the archives where it must be resting in peace ever since, in the company of many similar trophies of an undemocratic bureaucracy.
 
When my friend told me this story, I was not at all surprised because I had spent nearly 35 years as part of Indian bureaucracy during which I was witness to such antics by non- accountable bureaucrats, in almost every file which came to me.
 
And that deadly combination of authority with lack of accountability in the higher levels of the bureaucracy has cost the country very dear. 
 
One example is the non-implantation of a Cabinet resolution made in 1957, which would have changed the very face of Indian bureaucracy and hastened the pace of national development. 
 
It was suppressed, just like the governor’s order cited above, to safeguard certain vested interests. 
 
Another example is the massive toll of lives in the Andhra Pradesh cyclone of 1977, which could have been minimised if the then chief secretary of the state had not sat on a warning sent by the meteorology department in Delhi, without taking any action. 
 
And recently, in a temple in Kerala, we had a ghastly explosion, which took more than a hundred lives. Would it have happened if the district collector, the superintendent of police, the inspector of explosives and the home secretary, who is supposed to receive daily intelligence reports, had taken prompt and timely action to prevent illegal accumulation and storage of explosives against all rules?
 
In the meantime, administrative reforms commissions come and go, one after another. They submit voluminous reports, the key recommendations of which remain unimplemented because they undermine vested interests. And files keep going round and round exactly as they did in the days of the East India Company.
 
When will our country get a modern, professionalised, people-friendly bureaucracy with efficient structures, systems and procedures so that the dreams of the founding fathers of our democratic republic could be fulfilled and the sufferings of the poor millions mitigated?
 
(SS Kaimal is former chief engineer of the government of India and former chief technical adviser to the United Nations (UN). He is also the founder joint secretary of the All-India Confederation of Central Government Officers' Associations, which worked in the 1960s and 1970s for reforms in the administrative apparatus and to convert it into a modern, people friendly organisation, liberated from the Macaulayan snail-paced redtape rituals.)
  • Like this story? Get our top stories by email.

    User 

    COMMENTS

    Meenal Mamdani

    1 month ago

    The only check on govt, whether politicians or bureaucracy, is vigilant citizens. Middle class is the only who can do that as the poor are too busy trying to just exist and the rich could not care less as they can buy/bribe to get what they want.
    Until now the Indian middle class has enjoyed the fruits of independence but has shrugged off its responsibility towards maintaining democracy.
    How many citizens are part of any organization that investigates wrongdoing? The usual response to wrongdoing is "let the govt solve the problem". But when the govt itself is the problem, then what?
    I have lived in the US for over 40 years now and witnessed the keen interest of ordinary citizens in keeping a watch on various govt activities. These organizations have members who pay annual dues, have elected officers and paid employees to collect information and follow up wrongdoing till it gets corrected.
    ML Foundation is doing a yeoman's job is investigating and making public the financial irregularities that occur but what about various other activities. We need similar organizations to monitor the irregularities in transport, education, health, you name it.
    When will it happen?

    Newme

    1 month ago

    Bureaucracy is fixed compensation, fixed tenure, time bound increment, seniority bound promotion.
    Any out of turn personnel action would affect independence of bureaucracy.
    However, better performance is rewarded with better roles ideally. Having said that, more money making opportunity in certain departments and roles has already affected the bureaucracy.

    raaajan03

    1 month ago

    We always keep blaming politicians for the ills of the country. But the biggest culprits are the bureaucracy. Many of them are more corrupt than politicians and their only aim during the service is to get choicest postings by pleasing the political masters and use their positions to amass wealth. I hope someone writes a detailed story on how the bureaucracy has crippled the country and slowed the country's progress.

    REPLY

    Newme

    In Reply to raaajan03 1 month ago

    Agree mate. 80% of IAS, Judges, Auditors, CA, RBI, Tax, Banking posts are with Jewish Brahmins and their main aim is control of Government and not welfare of country.
    Corrupt politicians like Lallu Prasad Yadav and Jayalalitha are atleast sent to prison but IL&FS Parthasarathi who caused 90000 crores loss is not even touched.
    Rich businessmen who swindled PSU Banks are being chased but none of the Bank top brass who sanctioned the loans in connivance with the corporates in 5 lakh crores NPA write offs are even questioned.

    FRANCISXAVIER

    In Reply to Newme 1 month ago

    fully agree.

    doctordhanbpathi

    In Reply to Newme 1 month ago

    If your idea is implemented, no space is available to accommodate in Indian jails. NO PRUDENT GOVT. OPENS THE PANDORA'S BOX & GETS ENGULFED IN CHAOS!!!

    doctordhanbpathi

    1 month ago

    https://www.moneylife.in/article/governor-rules-joint-secretary-overrules/63090.html
    1. No change in the aproach of IBA, a cartel of undeocratic bureaucracy.
    2. When the PM & UFM sanctioned OROP scheme to PSB retirees, the IBA with strategic support from UFM Duds of Adhocism had reached an agreemen on 06.01.2021 with UFBU DUMB-ASS-HOLES LED BY CHV TO REFER THE MATTER TO UNDISCLOSED ACTUARIES TO CALCULATE COST OF OROP SCHEME. The IBA has been, successfully, postphoning the issue from 2018 nwards.
    3. https://lnkd.in/f6eNdcv.
    4. SATYAMEVA JAYATHE!!!

    We are listening!

    Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.
      Loading...
    Close

    To continue


    Please
    Sign Up or Sign In
    with

    Email
    Close

    To continue


    Please
    Sign Up or Sign In
    with

    Email

    BUY NOW

    online financial advisory
    Pathbreakers
    Pathbreakers 1 & Pathbreakers 2 contain deep insights, unknown facts and captivating events in the life of 51 top achievers, in their own words.
    online financia advisory
    The Scam
    28 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
    Moneylife Online Magazine
    Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
    financial magazines online
    Stockletters in 4 Flavours
    Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
    financial magazines in india
    MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
    (Includes Moneylife Online Magazine)