Equity funds shunned, while gold ETFs are popular, even though both have risen by 20% this year
Debashis Basu  and  Sanket Dhanorkar 08 November 2010

Even as equity markets and gold have enjoyed a similar rally since March this year, investors have shown much more appetite for the allure of gold ETFs than equity mutual funds

It is a tale of two asset classes that have evinced contrasting interest from investors. Both equities and gold have enjoyed a remarkable run since March this year, recording around a 20% jump each till now. But while the rally in stock markets has failed to enthuse equity mutual fund investors, gold ETFs have enjoyed phenomenal patronage from the investor community.

Clearly, the equity market is no longer the preferred destination for investors here. Since March this year, the Sensex has surged almost 19% from 17,528 to 21,000 now and is now hovering around a new all-time high. Meanwhile, equity mutual funds have witnessed a torrid time. The number of equity folios has gone down an alarming 4% from 402 lakh to 386 lakh. Equity MFs have witnessed outflows to the tune of Rs21,200 crore over this period.

In sharp contrast, gold exchange traded funds (ETFs) have been attracting investor money by the buckets, on the back of a phenomenal surge in the price of the yellow metal. Since March this year, gold prices have risen by around 21% from Rs16,232 to Rs19,970 now. The popularity of gold ETFs has soared as a result, with retail folios in gold ETFs jumping by a massive 65% from 142,270 to 235,218 over this period. Inflows into gold ETFs have surged 80% over the same period.

Heads of various asset management companies (AMCs) have attributed the waning interest in equity mutual funds to the stretched valuations in equity markets. Investors are booking profits and getting out of the market, they argue. However, as Moneylife has been pointing out regularly, this is not entirely true as equity MFs have witnessed a steady leakage of cash for more than a year now - which has little to do with the stock markets. The ban on entry load in August 2009 has had far-reaching consequences on the industry, which has found it difficult to cope up with many of the whirlwind changes introduced by the regulator, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI).

At the same time, gold ETFs have emerged as the favoured investment avenue for the retail population, seduced by the relentless rise in gold prices. Many investors have accepted the continuing rally in gold as a foregone conclusion and put their savings in this asset, cheered on by AMCs and their distributors.  

Comments
shankar
2 decades ago
why the govt of India is not taking any strict action against this MLM companies...why? Are the govt waiting to see the scame?
shankar
2 decades ago
Will the editor in chief of Money life please put some light on the MLM company Unipay2u.What is going to happen to this company.I am asking because i am a IFA and many investors are now not interested in MF.they all want to put their money in Unipay2u winch is giving double in only 10 month period
MDT
Replied to shankar comment 2 decades ago
@Shakar.... If your investors are not interested in MF, then there are lot of legitimate avenues for investment. Don't fall prey for a MLM company, which is bound to dupe all its investors. Hope you would have read our earlier article on the company and its 'business model'. Anyway read it here..
Malaysian MLM company ‘offers’ 200% returns in 10 months via gold trading in India
http://www.moneylife.in/article/81/8343....
Take care
shankar
Replied to MDT comment 2 decades ago
Thank you very much Dear Sir for your reply.......
thanks a lot
Parag Mehta
2 decades ago
In continuance to my previous comment, America as well as Europe have been printing currency with the expectation that with more money in the hands of people, demand will be generated.
Instead, that money is flowing into Asia. This has also been one of the many reasons for rise in gold prices.
As Marc Faber mentioned today on CNBC-TV18, US Fed Reserve was established in 1913, when 1 ounce of gold was available for $25. Today 1 ounce of gold is available for around $1400.
So, today what is the worth of dollar vis-a-vis gold.
Parag Mehta
2 decades ago
Initially, when the global funds began investing in gold, the reason was to stem the erosion in the value of their holdings because of recession in America and Europe.
Subsequently, the rest of the pack followed, hence the rise in gold prices and not due to genuine demand of gold.
In my opinion, investment in gold is a hedge against currency and not a hedge against inflation.
Once, there is economic recovery in Europe or America, there would be correction in the price of gold.
liju phili
2 decades ago
and then the gold prices will correct a bit and the same fellows who sold their mutual funds to jump onto to the gold etf bandwagon will cry.

the retail investor will never learn.
jagadees
2 decades ago
I find difficult to understand u guys. if you are telling that banning entry load pushed small distributors out of the industry. so there is leakage of money from equity mutual funds as there is no one to market the product. But who is popularizing the gold ETF's???? i guess no one. people investing because they feel tat gold price wont go down and it will act as good hedge. whereas they are not investing in equities because the scar of 2008 meltdown is still intact and they dont want to take risk. generally indian people are always "once bitten twice shy".
Roopsingh
2 decades ago
Is there enough gold kept in lockers as has been invested in gold related securities?in equities atleast investor knows that tata steel or reliance exist at this place-but what about these gold papers(ETF).will they deliver if all investor run to ask for physical gold?
shankar
2 decades ago
Equity Market Khatam.Chapter closed.A New trend has come into force-Gold.All the AMC's will be now a Jewelery Shop.
malq
2 decades ago
And now the Americans are talking about a new gold standard, too . . . so what happens to all the debt in dollars, then?
Free Helpline
Legal Credit
Feedback