DHFL Forensic Audit Reveals a Rs20,000-Crore Hole: Why Is The Report a Secret?
A forensic audit of DHFL (Dewan Housing Finance Ltd) by KPMG, commissioned by top lenders to the non-banking finance company (NBFC), is understood to have confirmed diversion of Rs20,000 crore to private entities of the promoters through the use of ‘box companies’. I have this information from a top banker who wishes to remain unnamed. Here is how box companies operate:
 
 
I have further learnt that the report has not been submitted to the board of directors. The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) is aware of the forensic audit report.
 
The question then is: Why hasn’t the DHFL board been sacked? Why do SEBI and Reserve Bank of India (RBI) allow the Wadhwan family to remain in management, even when actions of the Enforcement Directorate (ED) suggest underworld links and lending to companies belonging to Iqbal Mirchi, an associate of gangster Dawood Ibrahim?
 
What is behind this extraordinary reluctance to initiate decisive action against them even after such a huge crisis? Is there a political deal with DHFL’s promoters in exchange of information on politicians who were in cahoots with the group and the underworld? Even if that is the case, can a financial crisis causing systemic damage be ignored for so long? DHFL owed a massive Rs83,873 crore to a spectrum of lenders and investors as of 6 July 2019.
 
And, yet, as recently as on 14th October, the company signed a term sheet with Oaktree Capital to sell its entire Rs35,000-crore wholesale book, reports The Economic Times. Over time, it has allowed buyers to cherry-pick chunks of its loan book, leaving a virtual shell behind. Media reports talk about lenders working on a resolution proposal, including conversion of debt to equity which will allow DHFL to get fresh credit with the Wadhwan family sacrificing only half their promoter holding in the process. 
 
Who Is Afraid of SEBI’s Corporate Governance Rules?
In DHFL’s case, SEBI seems unwilling to enforce the corporate governance rules it had tightened just recently. SEBI has not asked lenders to present the forensic report to the board of directors for discussion. The report is material disclosure under the listing obligations and disclosure requirements regulations of SEBI.
 
Deepali Pant-Joshi, former executive director of RBI, who is an independent director of DHFL since May this year, says she is unaware of the forensic report and has refused to say if she has raised this with the management.
 
Ironically enough, none of this is a surprise. Many people in the realty industry are at pains to distance themselves not only from the DHFL but the Wadhwans of HDIL (Housing Development and Infrastructure Ltd). 
 
The Wadhwan family separated in 2008 and, after a formal separation agreement in 2010, DHFL was with one part of the family and HDIL with another. Both sides stand accused of large-scale misuse of funds. This raises serious questions about the role, responsibility, due-diligence and accountability of lenders, who are now running helter-skelter to salvage what they can of their massive loans, while retail investors and depositors are left to fend for themselves.
 
Private Investigations, Silent Regulators
DHFL has been tottering and has faced allegations of large-scale loot for over 10 months now. In December 2018, Debashis Basu wrote in Moneylife about how loans to promoters and poor disclosure were used to boost net worth and valuation. 
 
Two weeks earlier, Moneylife wrote about how two mutual funds (MFs), viz., Templeton and Aditya Birla Mutual Fund, had subscribed to non-convertible debentures (NCDs) of the group without showing promoters’ shares as a pledge against them. The regulator did nothing.
 
At the end of January 2019, an explosive sting by Cobrapost alleged that the Wadhwans had siphoned off a massive Rs31,000 crore to create personal wealth, through a network of shell companies. The KPMG forensic audit appears to have confirmed at least Rs20,000 crore of that amount.
 
Lenders and regulators should have gone into an overdrive right then, but they failed to respond even in June 2019, when Risk Event-Driven and Distressed Intelligence’s (REDD) report exposed the modus operandi of how DHFL and other large NBFCs avoided disclosure using the ‘box system’. 
 
Citizen’s Action
Finally, when DHFL actually began to default, it is bondholders and shareholders, not the lenders, who may have prodded regulators and watchdog intermediaries to act. Ashok Khemka, a whistle-blower and IAS officer from Haryana, whose wife, Jyoti Khemka, has invested in bonds of DHFL, is at the forefront of this fight. 
 
Ms Khemka has written to the heads of RBI, SEBI and the finance minister; filed queries under the Right to Information (RTI) Act and moved the consumer court in Haryana against Catalyst Trusteeship Ltd, CARE Rating, Brickworks Rating, DHFL and SEBI. She also filed a writ petition in the Chandigarh High Court. 
 
Mr Khemka points out that DHFL’s NCDs were given ‘AAA’ rating (highest possible) by CARE and Brickworks from July 2016 to January 2019 and then, suddenly, downgraded them to default rating (D), within a span of just three months. He alleges that rating agencies and the trustee company failed in their responsibility to do their job and protect investors. 
 
He makes the point that options, such as approaching the Debt Recovery Tribunal and the National Company Law Tribunal, are not open to retail investors; so they have to depend on RBI and SEBI, as regulators, to act on their behalf to recover their dues. 
 
Mr Khemka has demanded an investigation by SEBI under Section 11C and action to suspend activities, forfeit security and impose costs u/s 11 (4) and 11D of the SEBI Act. He also wants the promoters of DHFL to be declared personally bankrupt, their shares frozen and assets seized so that depositors’ dues are recovered.
 
On 15th October, the Chandigarh High Court admitted the plea of Jyoti Khemka, issued notices and posted a hearing on 18th November against the notice of motion. 
 
Earlier, an interim order of the Bombay High Court on 10 October 2019 (Suit No. 1034 of 2019) by two MFs (Reliance Nippon and Edelweiss) had brought out how DHFL and Catalyst Trustees failed to protect debenture-holders’ interest and has restrained them from making payments to unsecured lenders. 
 
The order brings out how DHFL and the debenture trustees allowed a sale of securities to avail securitisation advances and also paid Rs150 crore to an unsecured creditor, DSP Mutual Fund, ignoring the rights and interests of secured creditors. 
 
It also highlights other shenanigans of DHFL, such as deliberately issuing a cheque of Rs200 crore from an account which did not have sufficient funds. The order notes that DHFL had 132 bank accounts with resources to cover the payment.
 
Big Lenders & Enforcement Agencies Wake Up
Interestingly, big lenders seem to be showing some urgency, but still no unity, even after things have reached a point of hopelessness. State Bank of India (SBI) wants the finance ministry’s intervention to force united action, since the government has no financial resolution law. 
 
The effort is to get MFs, which have an exposure of over Rs5,000 crore to DHFL, to agree to a joint resolution plan. Funds with exposure to DHFL include: UTI, Kotak, Reliance Nippon, Axis, Tata, DSP and Primerica. Kotak and Axis have also filed litigation to recover their dues. The custodian of DHFL bondholders has finally moved court on 17th October.
 
So, the united action that SBI wants is easier said than done. How will they recover the Rs20,000 crore siphoned off by the promoters? The ED has raided over a dozen DHFL properties (and unearthed a loan of Rs2,186 crore to a company called Sunblink Real Estate, reportedly connected to gangster Iqbal Mirchi), but whatever is recovered or attached by ED will land up before the PMLA (Prevention of Money Laundering Act) court. 
 
This indicates that we would see a morass of litigation by lenders and depositors against DHFL, as well as credit rating agencies, trustees and MFs, without any positive outcome in the foreseeable future. 
 
Those affected include: DHFL’s debenture-holders and equity investors; the Life Insurance Corporation, International Finance Corporation and the Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation have invested in this dubious enterprise which will affect their investors indirectly.
 
DHFL is yet another example of what columnist Andy Mukherjee calls the ’jungle raj’ in finance, where failed supervision and timely action hurts all lenders, but retail investors face the hardest blow.
  • Like this story? Get our top stories by email.

    User

    COMMENTS

    sundararaman gopalakrishnan

    2 months ago

    I see no hope for India..All are corrupt..politicians, auditors, rating agencies,bureaucrats etc..The common man is left to fend for himself..Case in point is PMC bank depositors..

    Suketu Shah

    2 months ago

    People voted for Modi May 2014 as he claimed he/his party was anti-corrupt.Just another one of untrue promises by him else such disaster would not be happening last 5.5 yrs.How long can you blame Congress.Youi govt rules India for last 5.5 yrs and counting.

    REPLY

    K V RAO

    In Reply to Suketu Shah 2 months ago

    One is not able to tolerate 5.5 years when he/she has forgotten more than 50 years of misrule by a party whose claimed achievement is independence. This government has inherited an economy that is beyond repair. During present times, any good leader simply wants to give up and doesn't wish to carry the legacy. If someone like Modi has come forward Indians should thank their stars. It's easy for anyone (including me) to write that anything coming to the mind but getting into the worfield calls for grit, hardwork etc.

    Gayaprasad Lal

    2 months ago

    It's matter of great concern that nowadays such things are happening where common man is suffering, concerned authority to please take stern action against guilty be punished.

    S K Nataraj

    2 months ago

    DHFLs troubled status became public when they started defaulting on their commitments. The forensic audit reveals something very serious and can have a cascading effect on other companies and the Banking sector/economy.
    SEBI/RBI should act immediately in the matter. Crooks should be swiftly and severely punished, for wrongs.

    Mita Choudhury

    2 months ago

    what happens to fixed deposit holders?

    Mita Choudhury

    2 months ago

    I am a fixed deposit holder in Dhfl which matures in December. Where do I stand....please advise.

    REPLY

    Nagaraju Bommanahalli

    In Reply to Mita Choudhury 2 months ago

    You can not get money because NCD not secured

    kd.paranjpe

    2 months ago

    Sir, There is greater need for stricter law enforcement. We are uncertain whether the Police and the Central Investigation Departments can be involved at the beginning itself. A fraud whether by individuals or by a group or a corporate organization is a crime and those responsible, for committing errors of omission or commission, have to be punished swiftly. In India, we have a very strange form of natural justice at play. Unlike in other countries, where criminals are convicted swiftly, we have a system in which the process punishes. It is mostly the victims who are at receiving end.
    One way to turn the system on the culprits is to book them under police processes. Perhaps, there is a need to change the IPC to include such crimes as being committed under the very nose of the regulators.

    Ranbir Lamba

    2 months ago

    SEBI knew but no action. RBI Regulator must be aware but no action. Ministry informed? Public money going to Promoter+ politicians + Mirchi ( dawood) May be used for terror funding .

    Cobrapost alleged that the Wadhwans had siphoned off a massive Rs31,000 crore to create personal wealth, through a network of shell companies. The KPMG forensic audit appears to have confirmed at least Rs20,000 crore of that amount.

    K V RAO

    2 months ago

    Lengthier the feature lengthier the confusion. My head started rounding and rounding though I don't stand invested. I am imagining how actual investors feel about the whole episode. Even the investigating agencies reports would be lengthy and decision makers just don't read them. All reports should have action plan of punishments and solutions not exceeding 3 pages. A usual joke that if you don't want your employees or public know about some unpleasant news, put it in the notice board.

    Sreenath

    2 months ago

    Thanks Sucheta Dalal and Moneylife for being at the forefront of investigative financial news. Have been following you for several years now..
    Iam one of those personally affected by the DHFL imbroglio having invested in their so called AAA rates secured NCDs. I have not recd a single update till date either from the company or the trustees of the security.
    Is there is a common forum for the affected to come together ?
    Can u help with a connect to the Khemkas so that I could join them in their fight.

    Thks, sreenath

    M Ramachandiran

    2 months ago

    Home loan account bank details

    Manjunath Swamy

    2 months ago

    So it's very clear, that all these years the companies running were the biggest joke of the century. So if you have right contact you get loan no matter you will return it or not. But to an ordinary citizen, the banks burden them with processing fees, documents, proofs, notary proof etc.
    I personally stand for the stance for freezing any defaulted who want to vanish the money deposited by hard working common man.

    Nagaraju Bommanahalli

    2 months ago

    I am telling from past one year how most of the companies running fraud business by taking huge fraud loans from all banks and made banks to bankruptcy
    I will ask both both parties please reply ,how much money recovered till today by selling assets of fraud persons who taken huge fraud loans,how much money returned to the bankrupted bank account holders , don't do drama,my friend lost several lakhs from Alpic finance a NBFC in twenty five years back, but till today he have not received single paise , this Alpic finance company is a subsidiary of Cipla group, this NBFC done huge fraud,but till today no action taken, these companies go to court and take stay order for the sale of theirs assets, Court will drag the case to twenty to thirty years at that time all investers will die, these fraudessters enjoy our loot money with political leaders, these are all drama nothing will happen only poor will die
    In India nobody knows how Indian companies are doing fraud from the beginning to last ,for example a big business men will start the company in India as below .His companies actual value is Rs2000crores but with the help of the auditors,Banks,and chartered accountants he made his company s values to RS 6000 crores by book adjustment with bribe and he call IPO that is in share market and collect Rs10000 crores in share market, first he pumped 60%of money to foreign country in the name of business and will deposit most of the money in his name next he will file bankruptcy due to losses and will write off all the loans this is the business doing in India ED is doing drama ICICI Bank chandakochar is well known to all she done huge fraud in ICICI Bank, this drama of enquire is doing from past one year, but still she is not arrested, reasons In this icici bank scam all SEBI auditors ED RBI central government rating agencies big leaders of all parties involved.central government making all efforts to avoid arrest these fellows,if arrested all all foreign country become knows most of the Indian companies running on bogus and take away all foreign investment,then India become bankruptcy.This is well known by central government hence avoiding all efforts to arrest directors of icici bank chandakochar DHFL jetairways Videocon kingfisher airline PNB bank head [email protected] etc .even Vijaymalya kingfisher airline companies don't have single plane in his companies name but all banks gave Rs10000 crores money, same type loans gave to jet airways,DLF, Devan housing finance company,[email protected],fs,etc wait in few months most of the common people investment in icici bank NBFC PSU banks equity NCD mutul funds become Zero,All parties RBI officers, SEBI, etc are corrupt they are taking India towards bankruptcy.

    REPLY

    PRASAD

    In Reply to Nagaraju Bommanahalli 2 months ago

    Well said.

    SuchindranathAiyerS

    2 months ago

    This no longer has any shock value in an India where conversion of tuum to meum is now standard operating procedure in all financial institutions and government departments.

    Harish

    2 months ago

    Or is it Neverland of DHFL?

    BHEL jumps 22% on government stake sale plans
    Heavy electrical equipment maker Bharat Heavy Electricals Ltd(BHEL) on Friday gained over 22 per cent on the BSE over reports that the government may soon divest its stake in the company.
     
    BHEL scrips on the BSE had surged as much as 29.29 per cent to hit an intra-day high of Rs 57.60 apiece before closing at Rs 54.45 a share.
     
    "Shares of state-run BHEL jumped the most in a decade and NMDC rose nearly 6.5 per cent after reports that a group of secretaries would meet on Friday to consider lowering the government's holdings in public sector companies below 51 per cent," said Deepak Jasani of HDFC Securities.
     
    IANS had earlier reported that the state-owned BHEL may sell four to five units of its non-core manufacturing business under the government's asset monetisation programme during the ongoing financial year.
     
    The government also plans to dilute its equity in the power equipment manufacturing entity to 26 per cent in phases under the plan unveiled in this year's budget.
     
    According to official sources, out of the total 16 manufacturing units of the company, a few units which do not have material synergies with its core business, such as transportation and water would be put to sale.
     
    Asset monetisation of public sector enterprises has been on the government's agenda for some time now given the fiscal pressure the Centre is under, while the companies too are going through a rough financial phase. 
     
    Disclaimer: Information, facts or opinions expressed in this news article are presented as sourced from IANS and do not reflect views of Moneylife and hence Moneylife is not responsible or liable for the same. As a source and news provider, IANS is responsible for accuracy, completeness, suitability and validity of any information in this article.
  • Like this story? Get our top stories by email.

    User

    Auto Policy: Scrap, Rattle or Shake? - I
    Several newspaper headlines in recent times have been proclaiming, “Scrappage policy soon to give impetus to the automobile industry.” Apparently, the government will shortly announce a policy that encourages the scrapping of older automobiles, thereby boost new purchases, which, the policymakers expect, will help the automobile industry come out of the depression that it has sunk into. 
     
    The policy, one hears, is to adopt a two-pronged strategy of dis-incentivising the older polluting vehicles, and promoting the scrapping of older vehicles in authorised scrapping centres in an “environmentally friendly” way.  
      
    The onus apparently is on the original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) to play a critical role in this: to facilitate the collection of scrapped vehicles, ensure supply of new vehicles (but of course), as well as provide incentives in the form of discounts or additional benefits to the buyers of new vehicles in lieu of the older scrapped vehicles. 
     
    The government also believes that to drive away older polluting vehicles, we need deterrents. One of them is raising registration fees by significant sums (25 times, is what one hears!), after the completion of 15 years of life. The other is to exempt registration fees for new electric vehicles altogether. 
     
    Will these measures work in rejuvenating the automobile industry? Will they mitigate the issues of vehicular pollution? I really doubt it. 
     
    The setting up of regulated scrapping centres is a good move, and is long overdue. Though it has been proposed and discussed for the last four years, it’s only now that the government seems to be taking the necessary steps to set standards and issue guidelines (all off which are available in Europe and North America, and should be emulated, with minor exceptions). 
     
    Old vehicles, in poor condition, ought to be scrapped, both from pollution and safety points of view. This calls for execution in a proper, systematic way by which important parts can be salvaged for reuse, and the rest destroyed and/or recycled correctly.   
     
    Europe, North America, Japan and other developed markets have been following this voluntary vehicle scrappage system for years now. Yet it has not had any impact in improving the “lot of the automobile industry” in any of these countries. 
     
    In United Kingdom, which has pushed for voluntary scrappage schemes over the last few years, four-wheeler vehicle sales fell from 1.82 million to 1.6 million between 2016 and 2018, a drop of over 12% in two years. 
     
    Of course, several other reasons, including the uncertainty of Brexit, amongst others, must have caused this recession, but the voluntary vehicle scrappage scheme does not seem to have helped matters. 
     
    Cash for Clunkers 
     
    During the financial crisis of 2008-2010, when the Western economies were in serious trouble, incentivising the British automobile industry with the scrappage scheme, really helped. The scheme was known as “cash for clunkers,” a phrase to describe a system of scrappage of older vehicles, replacing them with newer, “cleaner” cars, with cash incentives doled out by the government. 
     
    Introduced by the British government on 22 April 2009, British citizens who had a car, which was at least 10 years old or more, when scrapped, could apply for £2,000 (Rs1.8 lakhs) funding at the time of purchase of a new automobile. 
     
    Similar schemes were also launched by France, Spain, Italy and Germany, and for the latter, car sales surged by 11.5% during January and May 2009 (Germany had introduced the scheme on 13th January 2009). During 2009, car sales recovered significantly in France and the UK too, after a disastrous 2008.
     
    The recovery of the industry came at a price though: it cost the British exchequer $500 million (Rs3,500 crore), the French $554 million (Rs3,870 crore), $3 billion (Rs21,000 crore) for the Spanish a whopping $7.1 billion (Rs50,000 crore) for the Germans!  
     
    Yet there was a Keynesian economic reasoning in boosting demand, which these cash rebates could do, by stimulating the economy, and escaping from what John Maynard Keynes called a “liquidity trap.” Even if the government had needed to plough in money in the shorter term, most governments expected to earn back most of it through the rise in car sales and economic activity, which, in turn must have generated more taxes, and so on. 
     
    The current Indian government’s thinking though may not be along those lines. So, what could be the alternative? We will discuss that in the next part. 
     
    (Gautam Sen is acknowledged globally as a leading automotive journalist, writer, automotive design consultant and expert from India. He founded the country’s first newsstand car magazine Indian Auto in 1986, followed by Auto India, Auto Motor & Sports and BBC’s TopGear. Mr Sen has also been directly involved with the automobile industry in India and Europe, and has worked with eminent designers such as Gerard Godfroy, Tom Tjaarda and Marcello Gandini.)
  • Like this story? Get our top stories by email.

    User

    COMMENTS

    Deepak Narain

    2 months ago

    Some price should be fixed for scrapped vehicles also which the owner will take to (or offer to be taken by ) scrapping centres. Ideally speaking, there should paid health test for old vehicles and those in good health should be allowed to be re-registered and re-insured and allowed to ply. I have one Maruti 800 of 1996. Since I use it for local short travel only, it is still in good health and I wish it is allowed to be used.

    Suketu Shah

    2 months ago

    This govt thinking is flawed in the sense that they want to just do what they want and they want the public to stay quiet and praise them(!) for whatever nonsense they do.This is the standard mode of operations of present govt.We never had a stage under Congress where the banking system was suspect.Some government banks are not paying FD interest openly which can only mean one thing-they have the support of present Indian govt to do whatever they want against the citizens.

    Aditya G

    2 months ago

    Comparing India and Europe is like comparing apples and oranges. Completely different mindsets & population, not to mention the quantum of vehicles on our roads. Europe has a super efficient public transport system, so there aren't many cars plying on their roads, at least when compared to India on an absolute basis. Plus, where will the scrapped vehicles end up? We don't even have space for parking! We already have issues with land acquisition for infrastructure projects on the countryside.

    Seriously, a scrappage policy is a welcome idea, but it has to be practical and well thought out. What is the purpose of it? Why have one? Does it solve a particular problem with long-term benefits? I don't buy the environment nonsense of replacing old with new.

    The problem is this: our roads are effed up and there's no space even for cars, nevermind buffaloes. Just try driving in Bangalore. The irony is -- no one uses the metro. We have a mindset problem.

    REPLY

    Surendra Babu Matavalam

    In Reply to Aditya G 2 months ago

    I disagree when you say No one uses the metro. I'm a frequent commuter by metro and the metro is getting heavy crowds most of the times, green line in particular. The problem may be the existing route which does not cater to the IT crowd well.

    Ranbir Lamba

    2 months ago

    India is not a rich country like US & Europe. Indians dream to buy even as second hand car is not met. The countries pollution has not come Down.
    Effects of scrapping policy
    A) Those who could live for 30 years with 2 cars will have to live with 3 cars.
    B) An extra burden to buy one car. Big hole in customer Pocket
    C) Corporate can increase easily production by 30% & earn big profit margin
    D) Insurance can command bug premium
    E) Government revenue will increase by 30%
    F) Public will go broke by 33% & all other's will command extra wealth by 33%>

    We are listening!

    Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.
      Loading...
    Close

    To continue


    Please
    Sign Up or Sign In
    with

    Email
    Close

    To continue


    Please
    Sign Up or Sign In
    with

    Email

    BUY NOW

    online financial advisory
    Pathbreakers
    Pathbreakers 1 & Pathbreakers 2 contain deep insights, unknown facts and captivating events in the life of 51 top achievers, in their own words.
    online financia advisory
    The Scam
    24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
    Moneylife Online Magazine
    Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
    financial magazines online
    Stockletters in 3 Flavours
    Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
    financial magazines in india
    MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
    (Includes Moneylife Online Magazine)
    FREE: Your Complete Family Record Book
    Keep all the Personal and Financial Details of You & Your Family. In One Place So That`s Its Easy for Anyone to Find Anytime
    We promise not to share your email id with anyone