Delhi HC declines stay on CIC order allowing RTI plea on salaries of Hockey India officials
IANS 13 January 2022
The Delhi High Court on Thursday refused to stay an order of the Central Information Commission (CIC) which allowed a petitioner to get to know the financial records and salaries of members and staff of Hockey India through the Right to Information (RTI) Act.
Noting that Hockey India, a public authority cannot be shy away from disclosing such information, Justice Rekha Palli said even the salaries of judges are also known to everyone.
"Prima facie I really don't see what is wrong with the CIC order. You are a public authority, you can't shy away from disclosing the salaries of employees, no matter how high or low it is. When our salaries are known to everybody then what is the problem with the salaries of your employees. You are a public authority which is getting so much of aid, benefits, and funds," the court said.
Senior advocate Sachin Dutta and standing counsel Anil Soni, appearing on behalf of the Centre, backed the sports body stating it was in consonance with the National Sports Code and the guidelines of the Centre. On their prayer to grant more time to file an affidavit in the matter, the court allowed five days' time. The further hearing will continue on January 20.
Opposing the CIC order allowing an RTI plea seeking various information on the financial details of Hockey India, including records of fund transfer to bank accounts in foreign countries, the governing body of the game in the country on Wednesday challenged the December 13 CIC order before the Delhi High Court.
In the plea moved by the apex hockey body, it was stated that Subhash Aggarwal had sought information through RTI with regard to salary and address of employees of Hockey India, monthly rent details of its premises taken on lease, signatories of bank accounts, records relating to funding transfer by the Hockey India to bank accounts in foreign countries and information on its cash withdrawals.
The petition stated that CIC suffers from "complete non-application of mind', in as much as the same is wholly arbitrary, contrary to statute, and contrary to the law laid down by this court and its own judgments".
The plea further said: "There is no discernible public interest that could override the exemptions of the information as sought. It is also pertinent to mention herein that the annual accounts of the petitioner are already published on its website and the petitioner is duly audited by the Comptroller and Auditor General of India."
The overall accounts of the petitioner, including the heads of expenditure, income, cash flow etc., are all part of the petitioner's accounts which are already available to the public on the website of Hockey India at and may be available to the RTI activist."The information that is subject to disclosure under the RTI Act has already been disclosed by the CPIO of the respondent, it said.
"There is no overriding public interest, which warrants the disclosure of information, which is otherwise exempt from disclosure under the RTI Act under Sections 8( 1 )(d), 8( 1 )(e) and 8(1)(j) of the Act," stated the plea.
Disclaimer: Information, facts or opinions expressed in this news article are presented as sourced from IANS and do not reflect views of Moneylife and hence Moneylife is not responsible or liable for the same. As a source and news provider, IANS is responsible for accuracy, completeness, suitability and validity of any information in this article.
5 days ago
If Hockey India have nothing to hide, they should not hesitate in furnishing the requested information. On the contrary, it is clear from their appeal to Court that there is something fishy.
Sorry, There Is No Provision To Blacklist RTI Applicants!
Vinita Deshmukh, 12 January 2022
Those appointed as a ‘public authority’ by companies as well as government, often look for every trick in the book to avoid giving information under the Right to Information (RTI) Act, rather than facilitating the flow of...
Milk Is Indeed Adulterated, Reveals RTI!
Vinita Deshmukh, 30 December 2021
Repeatedly, research data and raids by the food safety authorities show that there is adulteration of milk with urea, starch, detergent, caustic soda, formalin, glucose and water. However, the lack of stringent action emboldens the...
8-year-old Son of RTI Activist Starts a Fast for Arrest of His Father’s Murderers
Vinita Deshmukh, 21 December 2021
Remember the Right to Information (RTI) activist Bipin Agarwal, a resident of Motihari town of the East Champaran district of Bihar, who was shot dead on 24th September in broad daylight on a busy road, by two assailants astride a...
PIO Knocks at the Court to Reverse Penalty Order by Information Commissioner; Gets Knocked out
Vinita Deshmukh, 15 December 2021
In a stern and no-nonsense order, the Dharwad bench of the Karnataka High Court has directed all the state’s public authorities and the chief secretary to ensure that every public information officer (PIO) regularly stores...
Free Helpline
Legal Credit