Callousness and high-handedness of Bengaluru cancer hospital HCG

At HealthCare Global Enterprises, Sudhansu Mohanty was subjected to nuclear scan by a technician when a specialist’s supervision is mandatory. Instead of threatening to sue Aamir Khan, the IMA will do the nation a great service if it gets cracking on such cases

The comments to Moneylife's article on the Indian Medical Association (IMA) just shows how deep rooted the anger is there in the country with regard to the medical fraternity. While all of the comments brought out various aspects related to medical malpractices and corruption, one of the most shocking stories was related by Sudhansu Mohanty (as a comment to the above article).

Read on… to visualize and experience what Sudhansu perhaps went through on 24 May 2012 at HealthCare Global Enterprises (HCG), a Bangalore-headquartered specialist in cancer care. According to its own website, HCG "is the only dedicated cancer care network with quality care across 25 centres. …Each centre is provided with a business system, management expertise and capital resources to bring patient-focused, state-of-the art cancer care to new regions." As the website further notes, HCG's approach to cancer care is supposedly unique:

"We do extensive research and develop innovative treatment methods to provide the finest cancer care. This is supported by the most advanced technology to make cancer a manageable health condition and improve the quality of life of patients. It is our goal and commitment that one day India will be free from the agony of cancer. …For over five years HealthCare Global Enterprises (HCG) has been defining the future of cancer care in India by designing, building and managing cancer centres with a steadfast vision: To transform cancer care environment by bringing core clinical services to one central place. The intent of this single place is to help patients achieve longer, better lives-and to improve cancer care one centre at a time. …At HealthCare Global Enterprises (HCG), we view each centre as a model of excellence, a place where physicians can achieve professional fulfilment and breakthroughs in patient care. …Patients are the beneficiaries of these achievements-every accomplishment brings us one step closer to our ultimate goal of longer, better lives for cancer patients and their families." (To read more about HCG click here).

To be honest, if you ask me, anyone reading the above descriptions (on the HCG website) would be convinced to go to them for "Cancer Care".
Given that context, let us see what Sudhansu has posted on the Moneylife website the same is also available at his blog:

Mr Sudhansu states as follows...

"I seek to put in public domain my recent experience (just about 12 days ago, to be exact on 24 May 2012) in the HCG cancer hospital (also known as Bangalore Institute of Oncology) in Bangalore. I am a patient of carcinoid cancer. A month ago, I experienced pain in the anastomotic site. The CT scan done shortly after showed up cysts in the liver, apart from inflammation and ulceration in my colon. The most effective treatment for carcinoid is the complete, surgical removal of the tumour(s), which in my case had been performed. But microscopic cells could even show up after years and it's the tumour diasporic proclivity that prompted my doctors advises me a nuclear scan called Gallium-68 PET CT DOTANOC to zero in on the problem.

After the scan got over, I requested the nurse if I could speak with the doctor and get a preliminary idea of the scan before the detailed results came a day later. She said, "No doctors around. The technician did it."

I couldn't believe what I heard. "You mean to say that this nuclear scan was done without the supervision of a doctor, a consultant of nuclear medicine?" She looked at me, speechless. I walked over to the edge of the console room and asked the technician if he could do the scan without the specialist in nuclear medicine being around. In my money receipt the specialist's name was mentioned. I demanded an answer.

The technician panicked and spoke to the specialist seated in Tower 1. My scan was in Tower 4, about 200 meters away from where the doctors-consultant, nuclear medicine and the radiologists-sat.

Within minutes the technician materialized. "You can speak to Dr Kallur", he said, handing me the cordless phone.

"Doctor," I asked, "how is it that no doctor was around when my scan was done?"

His reply was pat. "I can't be present in all the 60-70 scans done everyday. You can take your money back!"

For all my ailments and my sundry visits to doctors across hospitals/cities wherever I've lived, I had never heard anything remotely resembling this. "That's okay but what happens to the radioactive isotope injected that's gone into my body? And is this the medical protocol your hospital follows?"

Silence. Later, I heard a voice say, "If you want to meet Dr Kallur, you can."

"But am I not speaking to him?"

"No, this is Pravin speaking." I asked him to come meet me.

He came half hour later-after two reminders. I demanded to meet the chairman. "The chairman is in a meeting," Pravin promptly conveyed.

"That he must be," I said, my voiced dipped in sarcasm, "but know that that ploy won't work. Please set up my meeting with him. Quickly."

He shuffled from one foot to another. Then moved away.

I sought him out again, as my wife and I sat in the patient's room in the high radiation hazard zone. It was getting to six in the evening.

Finally, Pravin after his string of meetings and phone calls materialized to take us. But no, it wasn't the chairman of HCG, Dr Ajaikumar. It was Elizabeth, the chief administrative officer. I told him I had nothing to do with her. After confabulation with Pravin, Elizabeth came over, now seated in the reception of Tower 2. I told her I wanted to see the chairman and there was no point repeating things time and time again. She hadn't been purveyed the full story. When she heard it, her face mirrored her shock.

I was fasting since morning. More than two hours after my scan got over, we're being escorted to the chairman. I was asked for my visiting card. "I'm a patient. You know my name, below it write PATIENT.

Dr Ajaikumar quickly apologized on Dr Kallur's behalf. "I've already told him," he said, "and I'm going to tell him again". I asked if his hospital followed the medical protocol prescribed for nuclear scans. He was politeness personified but his disembodied answers waffled with US examples. I knew they were faux excuses.

"How can a doctor ever mutter such words you can take back your money to a patient?"

"Stress", he tried to reason. "He's a busy doctor!"

"Who isn't? Certainly you don't do 60-70 DOTANOC scans everyday! Your hospital says about 3-4!"

Little later, he said Kallur is "compassionate" and "an icon!"

"Compassion" to a cancer patient I'd freshly experienced. So I told him to disabuse culting his icon. "My personal ethics prompted me to meet tell you before I hammer out the next course of action for the criminal neglect in medical care in your hospital. This isn't the Hippocratic Oath that you doctors are sworn to, this is Hypocrites' Oath! I speak here not for me but for the voiceless-the illiterate, uneducated masses-who know nothing what doctors, whom they trust blindly, do!" In my throat I added, "As you go pursuing Mammon relentlessly throwing all medical ethics out the window!"

The next morning I saw a half-page advertisement on the front page of a national daily enticing cancer patients to the hospital. In the evening I got my report. I found the radiologist's signature; three names (without signature) of consultants in nuclear medicine printed alongside, including Kallur's-conveying unmistakably that the nuclear scan was examined only by the radiologist, not the nuclear medicine specialist! So today, as I ready for another surgery, I must seek out another nuclear medicine specialist for an expert opinion-this after paying Rs17,000 and with the radio-isotope in my system. And how right you are Aamir!"

Very interestingly, I came across another item on the HCG's blog which is incidentally dated 25 May 2012-exactly a day after Sudhansu's experience of 24 May 2012 (as stated above). Read on…

First cancer centre in India to be accredited by NABH, NABL and CAP

 25th May, 2012, Bangalore: HealthCare Global Enterprises, The Specialist in Cancer Care, Bangalore, is the first cancer centre in India, to have accreditation from National Accreditation Board for Hospitals & Healthcare Providers,(NABH) Government of India, College of American Pathologists ( CAP), State of Illinois, and National Accreditation Board for Testing and Calibration Laboratories (NABL), Government of India. The combined accreditation for quality from three distinguished accreditation bodies was possible because of HCG's focus on robust process for patient quality, efficient practice of diagnosis and improvements in medical outcome.

Dr. B S Ajaikumar, chairman, HCG, said, "We are proud of this achievement of a combined accreditation from three bodies which endorses our hat or clinicians and non clinicians' together have been working together ensuring highest quality standards in cancer care with a focus in delivering the best in medical outcome. I'm happy to note that our team was the first to get these three accreditations in India."

It seems unbelievable as well as ironical that an institution (like HCG) which has received accreditation from several bodies-including the National Accreditation Board for Hospitals & Healthcare Providers,(NABH) Government of India; College of American Pathologists (CAP), State of Illinois; and National Accreditation Board for Testing and Calibration Laboratories (NABL), Government of India - has allowed its process of treating its patients to degenerate to the levels suggested in Sudhansu's stated experience above. Specific questions that arise in this regard are:

a)    Was it alright for a specialist doctor not to be present when the procedure-nuclear scan-was being actually done on the patient? This is especially a critical question given that the disease in question is (specialized) cancer and also given the fact that in the money receipt, the name of the specialist had been mentioned. Further, I have heard that to provide proper diagnosis, it is imperative for a specialist doctor to be part of the process of scanning - as much is learned from the process of scanning as the scanned output. That being the case, how does one explain away the doctor's absence when the patient (Sudhansu) was being scanned?   

b)    Can a doctor-because of being stressed, busy and/or excess workload (taking about 60/70 nuclear scans a day)-absent himself from a critical nuclear scan being taken? Is this appropriate as per the medical protocol prescribed for nuclear scans as well as critical care illnesses like cancer?

c)    Was it fair and appropriate for the doctor to tell a patient-"You can take your money back"? Was not the doctor breaching the code of ethics and conduct by retorting to the patient in such a manner? And as Sudhansu argues, while money can be returned, what about the actual scan procedure experienced, the radioactive isotope injected into his body and the ramifications therein?

d)    And, can a doctor who has behaved as described above be referred to as either "compassionate" or "an icon!"?

Moneylife sent an email to Dr Ajaikumar and other authorities at HCG, which was acknowledged by one official over phone. He said HCG will respond to Moneylife's mail after speaking with top management and the doctor concerned.


Here is what Dr Kallur has said in a reply to our mails...

Without any doubt, several issues need to be critically examined in the light of Sudhansu's narration above as also other comments that have come in response to the Moneylife article. And I hope that instead of taking pot-shots at Aamir Khan and threatening to sue him, the IMA will do itself and the nation a great service if it gets cracking on such cases (which seem to be in plenty) and takes appropriate action against those who break its (very own) code of ethics and medical protocol…

(Ramesh Arunachalam has over two decades of strong grass-roots and institutional experience in rural finance, MSME development, agriculture and rural livelihood systems, rural and urban development and urban poverty alleviation across Asia, Africa, North America and Europe. He has worked with national and state governments and multilateral agencies. His book-Indian Microfinance, The Way Forward-is the first authentic compendium on the history of microfinance in India and its possible future.)

1 year ago
Thanks for sharing this informative post with us. You can also visit the
3 years ago
"India’s first integrative oncology cancer care center.
Let's create world FREE from CANCER"
7 years ago
HCG is a well oiled business. In HCG unnecessary radiotherapy is given just to extyract money.Doctors at thath HcG are only money minded mean arrogant.Doctors at HCG will realise only when they suffer from cancer.They are there not to treat cancer and curecancer but to aggravate make patients suffer more and extract money.
Dr H C Sharatchandra
9 years ago
I am happy some one like Monhanty is fighting. This evening I also walked out of the Hospital not from Medical care point of view but on the issue of inordinate delay in preparing discharge clearence after First Chemo cycle. From 4 Pm to 11.30 Pm, no response. No senior person is present in the hospital to resolve the issues. I am also taking up the issue to the chairman. They refused to divulge email ID of chairman. If Sudhamnshu can give it I would appreciate.
my email is [email protected]
1 decade ago
It is sad to know that KMC had to rule in favour of an erring doctor. But the missionary zeal with which Mr. Mohanty is fighting the battle--facing influential people in the medical industry-- not for selfish ends but to spread awareness and to infuse a sense of accountability in the medical profession on behalf of lakhs of voiceless people, I am sure justice will ultimately prevail and truth will surface.
To cover-up one lie, one has to invent hundred lies. This is what seems happeneing.

Let truth prevail in the end.
Dipika Mohanty
1 decade ago
I think the most important satisfaction in life is mental satisfaction and peace. I myself am from the medical profession, and in my entire professional career, I have been sated only when I have tried doing my best serving mankind as selflessly as possible.The peace comes from within. I am appalled at how a doctor of such high reputation could behave in the way he did, no matter how much frustrated he might be in his own life.
lipika patnaik
1 decade ago
Just now I went through Sudhansu Mohanty's prayer to the KMC and the Council's ORDER on 19th July.
I wonder how KMC has mentioned "Dr. Kallur has followed the Standard Protocol while performing the PET Scan".The case was dismissed by KMC even though the complainant mentioned everything pointwise after going through the Code of AERB.
Everyone going through the entire episode from the beginning can find the dual statement of the doctor's description of facts.One has to build an imaginary castle to prove one's single lie.Don't worry, Dr.Kallur's conscience will definitely alert him oneday.
Anyway,Mr.Mohanty,don't be disheartened because you are pleading selflessly for thousands of victims of medical apathy.
Plead for truth & justice, We are with you.
1 decade ago
Most of us are unaware and uneducated in even knowing the fact that a nuclear scan requires supervision and those of us who know, choose to remain silent. It is this silence that is allowing people of such repute to have the audacity for any form of negligence knowing that no action would probably be taken against them. Common man would never take such steps to fight for justice. Mr. Mohanty is the voice for many such people.
1 decade ago
Can't believe a doctor of repute can be so callous and irresponsible.Hats off to you,Sudhansu, your fight against the system is an eye-opener for common ones like us.
1 decade ago
Napoleon said: "The world suffers a lot, not because of the violence of bad people, but because of the silence of good people".

Most of the patients just accept their fate and suffer in silence. I am glad that
Shri Mohanty has decided to fight against injustice done to him in the hearing held on 12th July, 2012 in Karnataka Medical Council, and
I applaud his efforts in fight against truth.
It is surprising that in view of the Orders quoted by Shri Mohanty in the case of the criminal negligence on the part of Dr. Kallur, Karnataka Medical Council have deemed it proper to dismiss the complaint. Any right thinking person believing in rules & regulations cannot appreciate such an Order handed down.

We should all join Shri Mohanty in his fight for Justice, which also he is doing on behalf of all of us.
Dr H C Sharatchandra
Replied to Bharadwaj comment 9 years ago
Iyou can count on my support for the cause
anjali ellis
1 decade ago
Though I know, it cannot be easy, but I am happy that Mr. Mohanty has decided to remain undeterred in his struggle to get justice, not just for himself but for thousands of other nameless, silent victims of medical apathy. The current verdict handed down by the KMC must have been expected by him, as it was by a few others, primarily because of the fact that medical apathy has deeply permeated the Indian society and ethos. The indifferent attitude of doctors and medical professionals so wonderfully suits our “chalta hai” attitude, that we’ve forgotten our own rights! Nonetheless, it is people like Mr. Mohanty who show the rest of us to take a stand. I wish him all the best in his struggle, which is for a worthy cause.
laxminirmalya das
1 decade ago
Can't believe this type of irresponsible behaviour from a reputed Doctor or institution.Hats off to you,Sudhansu, for fighting against it while you yourself is not well and undergoing surgery.Common people want someone like you having grit of iron to get justice.God Bless.
1 decade ago
Little knowledge is a dangerous thing is what explicates based on the clarification letter as given by Dr. Kallur or HCG. It seems they are completely heedless of the fact that a nuclear scan needs to take place under the supervision of a nuclear medicine doctor who needs to be at least present in the near area if not inside the chamber of scanning. I am sure the amount being charged must have also the so called Doctors supervision fees included in it. To add to the agony of the patient he is being explained the volume of scans in a day being under taken by the hospital and the refund options. That best defines a salesman profession not of a Doctor…..
It is disheartening to see that even KMC is not looking at different facet of this episode which should have actually directed HCG to follow correct procedures during a nuclear scan process.

1 decade ago
Just went through the updates shared by Mr. Mohanty in the comments section, as well as some more from others. NABH informs Mr. Mohanty that post the communication from him to the hospital, the hospital has "initiated soft skill training program for the Front Office and Technical Team". I wonder what would be the contents of such a training program. Would it for example, have a 1 hour session on, "How to not let the patient know that standard operating procedures are being violated"?
Dr H C Sharatchandra
Replied to Jolly comment 9 years ago
soft skill my foort. My experience indicates they have no skills
1 decade ago
What is troubling is that there are so many people who are not even aware of how they are being taken for a ride by their doctors.

No matter what the conclusion of this case, I think it's important to ensure that this information goes out to as many people as possible.
Free Helpline
Legal Credit