“After the first day of shooting, Boman wanted to walk out of the film”

In the second part of this three-part interview series, Rajkumar Hirani speaks on how he convinced Boman Irani to play the part of the dean of a medical college in the cult classic Munnabhai MBBS

Moneylife: Was it your decision to get Boman Irani into films? Tell us about it.
Rajkumar Hirani:
When Shah Rukh was to do the film, we had gone to Amrish Puriji for the role. It didn’t work out. Then we went to Paresh Rawal, but that also didn't happen. I had a very tight budget. Vinod was doing a film for the first time with someone else, so he had put some money in a bank, given me a cheque-book and said that I had to complete it in that budget. So, I had to be very careful. But, thinking back, it is a good way to make a film because it makes you think. You should not have the luxury to splurge. I am very cost-conscious even today. I must tell you about Munnabhai MBBS. At the end of that movie, we have these snapshots about what happened to the main characters. So there was a still of Munna at his wedding with his friends. We had to get a backdrop for the still and they said it would cost Rs10,000. Then they said, you need a costume and that was to be another Rs10,000. So I said, just hire the costume. Sanjay threw a fit about wearing a hired costume, but I convinced him that we would dry-clean it and it was only for an hour.

We were shooting at Pune near the agricultural college and there was a wedding hall on the way, where I used to see wedding receptions happening everyday. So I sent one of my assistants to go there and find out if we could take a shot after all the guests had left. They agreed, and were very excited that Sanjay Dutt was coming. The only problem was that Sanjay had packed up at 8pm, gone back to his van and was drinking. He was also getting restless and wanted to go back to the hotel and we couldn't tell him that we were waiting for the guests to leave.

Finally, at 11.15pm, we were told that you can come; the guests are leaving. So it was literally when the bride and the groom were leaving that Sanjay Dutt dressed as a bridegroom walks in. Before they could think or react, we clicked five or six stills of a drunk Sanju standing there and joking away, put them in a car and drove away. 

ML: You were telling us about Boman Irani.
Ram Madhvani, who worked with Vinod in Mission Kashmir, had done a film called Let’s Talk with Boman which we had seen. He was extraordinary in that film. Then, I went and saw his play, "I Am Not Bajirao"; it was an amazing performance. We asked him if he would do our film and, surprisingly, he didn't want to. He had some bad experiences with Hindi films and was clear that he didn’t want to do Hindi cinema. It took a lot of convincing to get him to agree.

Finally, Ram told him to at least listen to the script and then make up his mind. He came to the office and I narrated the script to him. I love to do that. Even today, when the script is done, I do 40 or 50 narrations, because that is the best way to communicate. Boman heard the script and, being a very emotional guy, he was laughing, crying… he sobs at the drop of a hat. He liked it and agreed to do it, but he said, ‘My biggest problem is that I don't know Hindi’. So we said, we will modify it, we will make it Hinglish and make him a little Western. Then he got involved and there were some things he didn’t like. For instance, this laughter trait that he had—when he got angry in the film, he had to laugh. He found that very unconvincing. While rehearsing he made a little expression of pain when he laughed. So we said, if you use this, it will be convincing, because it will show that you do not feel like laughing but are making an effort because you think your blood pressure goes down by doing it. So, suddenly it became very convincing.

Then again, after the first day, he wanted to walk out. On day one, he had a shot with Dutt-sa’ab. It was the first day for Sunil Dutt after 16 years, and it was the first day for Boman in Hindi cinema. And, I guess, our attention went to Dutt-sa’ab, because he was so senior and I was trying to make him comfortable. By then, Boman had become a good friend. After the shoot ended, we were standing in the parking lot and he asked me, “How did it go?” I said it was okay, but you could have done better. I didn't see the magic that I see in the plays. He heard me.
The next day, he comes to office, closes the door and says, “You take somebody else, I don’t think I can work in this film.” He kept telling us all the reasons why he can’t do the film and even as he was talking, he started crying; then he became aggressive and then he accused me. ”A director is like a mother, you have to make me comfortable; you have to encourage me. If you say I haven't done well, when you know I have a problem with Hindi, how will it work?” Finally, I realised that this is a baby. So I got up and said, ”Come on Boman, let me give you a jaadu ki jhhapi.” I then convinced him that he had to do the film and we would work on his Hindi.

I went to each location where he was to shoot and described the scene to him. I gave him the gist and told him to say it in his own words, instead of giving him the lines. And then I would record it and rewrite his lines to make him comfortable. He added a lot too. For instance, he added the bit about how doctors should not be compassionate towards patients because, if they are, they won't be objective. ”If I have to operate on my daughter, my hand will shake and I won't be able to do it,” he said. I had a big debate with him on it and said you have a valid point, but if you have such a valid point, my hero will look stupid. He said, ”That is your problem. I should have my point of view.”

That has stayed with me. Now, whenever I make a film, I say that the antagonist must have a point of view that is believable. If he does not have a point of view, it does not work. So even in 3 Idiots, Boman has a point that life is about competition and nature has made you like that. And after the rewriting, his confidence came back. Now, we have become great friends. In fact, I have some close friends in the industry and I consider Boman one of them. I can talk to him about anything; I can share things with him. He is a great guy.

(For the complete the interview, please pick up the next issue of Moneylife to hit the stands on Friday)

  • Like this story? Get our top stories by email.


    Thums Up: Cat & Mouse games

    Thums Up’s new TVC dabbles in the extreme sport called ‘Parkour’ with a dash of sexual innuendo. Cool mix! 

    Although Thums Up’s adverts don’t appeal to me… I neither like Akshay Kumar nor his babes nor his drink nor his stunts… I admire the communication for its single-mindedness of purpose. The positioning of the brand and the target audience is crystal clear. Thums Up, unlike Pepsi and Coke, is focussed on grabbing the eye balls of macho studs (read: wannabe macho studs), and the TVCs starring Akshay, babes and the thrills are targeted at only that particular segment. To state it rudely, the all-cash, all-brawn sods with no culture or class. Fair enough.
    So, over the past few years, Akshay Kumar has been indulging in dangerous stunts for the brand. He sometimes competes with other studs, on other occasions with his babes, or at times even with himself. The template and the ‘raw’ ingredients are in place. And the only fresh variable each new season offers is the sort of stunt the actor will pull to get the adrenaline going.
    Thums Up’s new television commercial has Akshay Kumar dabbling in the extreme sport called ‘Parkour’. Wiki defines the sport as such: ‘Parkour or l'art du déplacement is the physical discipline of training to overcome any obstacle within one's path by adapting one's movements to the environment. It is a non-competitive, physical discipline of French origin in which participants run along a route, attempting to negotiate obstacles in the most efficient way possible, as if moving in an emergency situation.’ Frankly, I have no idea what that means! 
    What the TVC features is a typical cat-and-mouse chase. Man chases babe. Babe has the Thums Up bottle. Man wants Thums Up. Babe wants man. Man gets babe and Thums Up. Cool! The TVC opens with Akshay Kumar strolling by, sipping his Thums Up. A babe bungee jumps onto him, grabs the bottle, and flies away. The macho man chases her into the air, on his own two feet, and retrieves the ‘treasure’. The madness continues. This time the star is seen riding a bike. The babe grabs the bottle from him and another chase gets underway. The stud grabs a vase from the streets, chucks it at the babe. The babe prefers the vase, and drops the bottle. Akshay skids on his bike to catch the falling bottle. Finally, he grabs the girl from behind and demands to know why the babe follows him everywhere. The girl coos, "So that you can follow me."
    Basically, a nonsense, irrational ad, a replica of the nonsense action movies the star often does. But I am pretty sure such advertising works for the targeted audience. The spirit of action, adventure and attitude comes through as always. And it also helps the brand differentiate itself in the crowded cola market.
    One more thing: The background track keeps buzzing with the words, ‘Pakkad pakkad’ (catch, catch). And in the last shot, as he clasps the babe from behind, the stud orders her, ‘Kholo!’ (open). The advertiser may officially deny this, but I think there is clear sexual innuendo playing out here. Good idea. What’s the point of all the hard work if it doesn’t lead to a reward? 

  • Like this story? Get our top stories by email.


    Commerce ministry may shuffle stimulus among sectors

    While tobacco, spices, man-made yarn, gems, chemicals and jewellery have shown satisfactory export growth in the past few months, textiles, handicrafts, carpet, engineering goods are still reeling under the impact of global crisis.

    The commerce and industry ministry may withdraw incentives offered to certain export-oriented industries and reallocate them to those that are struggling for survival after a review in April, reports PTI.

    "...Decision for any kind of change in the stimulus measures for the sectors coming out from the impact of global financial meltdown will be taken after 31st March," minister of state for commerce and industry Jyotiraditya Scindia told reporters at an Assocham function in New Delhi.

    While tobacco, spices, man-made yarn, gems, chemicals and jewellery have shown satisfactory export growth in the past few months, textiles, handicrafts, carpet, engineering goods are still reeling under the impact of global crisis.

    The ministry had given enhanced assistance for exploring new markets to exporters and extension of duty refund scheme till December 2010, besides other sops.

    On the Budget expectations, Mr Scindia said that he has requested finance minister Pranab Mukherjee to at least retain the previous year’s allocation of Rs3,652 crore for the ministry.

    Sources said that as exports have started showing signs of recovery and industrial production too has picked up significantly, the finance ministry may start withdrawing stimulus measures, resulting in lower budgetary allocation for the commerce and industry ministry.

    The government had provided over Rs1.80 lash crore as part of three stimulus packages to prop up the economy against the recent global downturn.

    The index of industrial production (IIP), an indicator of industrial activity in the country, zoomed 16.8% in December compared to a contraction of 0.2% during the corresponding month a year ago.

    After falling for 13 straight months, exports grew by 18.2% in November 2009. Exports growth was 9.3% in December 2009 and 11.5% in January.

    The Prime Minister's Economic Advisory Council (PMEAC) has forecast a 12% growth, to $88 billion, in India's exports in the second half of the current fiscal.
    Exports were valued at $81 billion in the first six months of 2009-10; exports during October-March 2008-09 were estimated at $78.5 billion.

  • Like this story? Get our top stories by email.


    We are listening!

    Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

    To continue

    Sign Up or Sign In


    To continue

    Sign Up or Sign In



    online financial advisory
    Pathbreakers 1 & Pathbreakers 2 contain deep insights, unknown facts and captivating events in the life of 51 top achievers, in their own words.
    online financia advisory
    The Scam
    24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
    Moneylife Online Magazine
    Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
    financial magazines online
    Stockletters in 3 Flavours
    Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
    financial magazines in india
    MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
    (Includes Moneylife Online Magazine)
    FREE: Your Complete Family Record Book
    Keep all the Personal and Financial Details of You & Your Family. In One Place So That`s Its Easy for Anyone to Find Anytime
    We promise not to share your email id with anyone