Citizens' Issues
White paper on irrigation scam in Maharashtra within three weeks, HC told

The state government informed the HC that a white paper on the alleged multi-crore irrigation scam would be ready within next three weeks

Mumbai: Maharashtra government on Thursday informed the Bombay High Court that a white paper on the alleged multi-crore irrigation scam, involving bureaucrats of Water Resources Department and Konkan Irrigation Development Corporation (KIDC), would be ready within three weeks, reports PTI.


This statement was made by Advocate General Darius Khambata before a division bench of Justices AM Khanwilkar and Mridula Bhatkar which was hearing a public interest litigation filed by social activist Pravin Wategaonkar seeking an inquiry by the Central Bureau of Investigation (RBI) into the scam.


"A White paper will be ready in this case within three weeks. Based on this we will file an affidavit before the court in reply to the allegations levelled in the petition," Khambata said.


The bench directed the government to file its affidavit by 20th December.


Wategaonkar in his petition has alleged criminal conspiracy and misconduct on the part of public servants and sought CBI probe in all projects where cost escalations of Rs20,000 crore were approved across three months in 2009 by the Water Resources Department (WRD).


"It is not mismanagement or ignorance of the WRD but deliberate and well managed act of massive corruption by WRD and KIDC and contractors paid to carry out works associated with these projects," the petition claims.


Relying on a speech made by Chief Minister Prithviraj Chavan in May this year, Wategaonkar has said, "In the decade beginning with year 2000-01 till 2009-10, the government of Maharashtra has spent about Rs70,000 crores on irrigation projects. In the next decade the projected cost is Rs75,000 crores. Probe should be conducted to rein in the unwarranted cost escalations and arbitrariness."


The activist further said many acts of omission and commission by the government departments against public interest would amount to criminal misconduct and abuse of power by public servants and thus an offence under the Prevention of Corruption Act.


According to the petition, even after incurring an expenditure of Rs4,363 crore up to 2009-10 on 90 projects of KIDC, only 13 projects could be completed.


"Due to slow progress of the projects the very objective of forming KIDC which is for expediting the entire process of completing ongoing projects has failed. The projects which otherwise would have been completed by the irrigation department in ten years, could not be completed by KIDC even after 12 years of its formation," the PIL states.


The corporate earnings picture is not so bad

A Moneylife analysis of 1,099 companies shows a lot of them have increased profits, helped by lower commodity prices even though sales growth has slowed down

The 1,099 companies in the Moneylife database clocked aggregate sales of Rs11,77,846 crore when compared to Rs10,39,595 crore recorded in the same quarter last year, or 13% higher on a y-o-y basis. Both operating profit and net profit grew 32% y-o-y and 68% y-o-y, on an absolute basis, to Rs1,76,911.5 crore and Rs1,07,255.4 crore respectively. Out of the 1,099 companies, nearly half of the companies reported net profit higher than last year despite even as roughly two-thirds of the companies saw their net sales increase on a year-on-year (y-o-y) basis. This shows that companies have been able to keep cost under control even as inflation continues to worry the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and companies.

Furthermore, a more important measure is margins. On an overall basis, operating profit margins have expanded by more than two percentage points, y-o-y, to 15.02% while net profit margins have expanded by nearly three percentage points, y-o-y, to 9.11%. This is impressive and shows that topline is not all. This also shows that companies have exuded far more cost control than before in the face of slackening demand, mainly helped my lower commodity prices. Last year, operating profits declined by 10% (when compared to September 2010). This year, however, companies have managed to grow operating profit by 32%, a significant number. Considering that global situation is far more difficult today than last year, companies have managed to do well.

If you look at the aggregate net sales and profit figures, net sales have hardly increased (only by 13% y-o-y) while profit increased by 68% y-o-y. Sales have been subdued because of lack of demand. Higher interest rates, lack of liquidity due to a hawkish stance by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) have forced consumers to cut down on spending. Net sales slowed down even on a y-o-y basis, by seven percentage points. As demand slows down, companies are forced to cut down on capital expenditure and spend only once demand picks up. This has kept operating profit up. This is one of the cornerstones of cost management. Some companies are waiting for the opportune moment to invest, especially that raw materials are now cheaper to produce items. During difficult times, it is the only controllable variable companies can do to keep profits stable keeping in mind shareholder interests. And in this realm, they have done well, considering that RBI has taken a hawkish stance and not resorted to monetary easing nor have their done any open market operations (OMO).

Whether the third quarter results will be good is in doubt as America prepares to tackle the fiscal cliff while there seems no end in sight to the Eurozone crisis. Several Bills are due to be passed in the parliament in the winter session of the parliament, including the landmark Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in retail and FDI in aviation, which could be game changers and possibly stimulate the market, at least in the short-term. But all this is uncertain as political wrangling continues and this could affect companies’ decision making on investment matters. Companies are on wait and watch mode and striving for consistency in cost management.

You can check out our similar analysis we’d done on previous quarters below:


Q4FY12 -

Q3FY12 -



Anil Agashe

4 years ago

Nice to know this. But I have following observations:
1. The analysis means high interest rates are not hurting companies right?
2. Cost control is done only when things are bad?
3.Sales growth of 13% is good considering the situation.
4 How much sales growth has come from volume and how much from price increases?
5. This explains the increase in indirect tax collections.

EC notice to Gujarat Congress chief for comments on Modi

The Election Commission said that Modhwadia's remarks prima facie violated Model Code of Conduct which prohibits personal attacks on the leaders of rival political parties

Ahmedabad: The Election Commission (EC) has issued a show cause notice to Gujarat Congress president Arjun Modhwadia for his reported remarks on the personal life of Chief Minister Narendra Modi and also for comparing him with animals, reports PTI. The Commission also asked him to file his reply by 24th November.
Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) MP and state unit General Secretary Balkrishna Shukla had filed a complaint with the Commission about Modhvadia's speech in Vadodara on 2nd November when he made the controversial comments.
The Commission sent the notice to Modhwadia after listening to the CD containing his speech.
The notice said that Modhwadia's remarks prima facie violated Model Code of Conduct which prohibits personal attacks on the leaders of rival political parties.
"The Commission hereby gives notice to you to show cause as to why action should not be taken against you, for the violation of the Model Code of Conduct," said the EC notice issued yesterday and signed by its secretary Harbans Singh.
The EC has also directed Modhwadia to submit his response by 24th November and added that, "failing which it would be assumed that you have nothing to say in the matter and appropriate action will be taken against you without any further reference to you."
Modhwadia, in a public meeting on 2nd November in Vadodara, had criticised Modi for repeatedly targeting Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and also took a dig at Modi for his remarks on Sunanda Pushkar, wife of Union Minister Shashi Tharoor.
He had also compared Modi with animals in the same meeting.


We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)