Bonds, Currencies & Commodities
United Stock Exchange’s ‘big-bang’ entry into currency futures is faltering

The newly-established USE boasted of a world record for capturing the highest market share and daily turnover. Turnover has crashed now. With trading being literally free, will the USE survive?

The country's newest stock exchange, the United Stock Exchange (USE), was launched amid much fanfare a couple of months ago. With eyes firmly set on the skies, the USE went on a vigorous membership drive, even with established rivals like National Stock Exchange and Multi-Commodity Exchange - Stock Exchange (MCX-SX) patrolling the waters in this keenly-contested segment. It made headlines on its debut on 20 September 2010, for capturing a whopping 52% of the market share on its very first day coupled with a world record for the most contracts traded in a single trading day. This has turned out to be a flash in the pan.

The USE clocked a turnover of Rs45,486 crore on its debut, outshining rivals NSE and MCX-SX who recorded a turnover of around Rs21,000 crore each. Volumes continued to hold steady for a few days as the USE maintained a leadership position in the segment with a market share of 38% by 6th October.

However, this superlative performance soon started losing steam. USE witnessed a steady dip in volumes and turnover since this 'big-bang' opening. With a turnover of just Rs4,142 crore on 11 November 2010, USE has seen its market share plunge to 18%. Indeed, since 1 November 2010, its market share has averaged just 15% while NSE and MCX-SX enjoy a much bigger slice of the pie at 37% and 48% respectively. Volumes and turnover on the much-hyped new currency derivatives exchange have almost halved from mid-October 2010.

Another important indicator of the failure of the USE is its low average open-interest position relative to volumes. Since its launch, daily open interest has averaged a measly 5% of the total daily volumes at the USE. Comparatively, the figure is much healthier at the NSE (38%) and the MCX-SX (30%). Open interest is the total number of futures contracts that have not yet been offset or fulfilled by delivery. It is an indicator of the depth or liquidity of a futures market and commitment of the participants. Low volumes and low open interest point to a shallow market, one that is dominated by day traders. In this case, a large part of such volumes are possibly created by Jaypee Capital, a stock broker that SEBI quite happily, allowed to be a promoter of an exchange.

After making a splash initially, the USE now faces an uphill task trying to keep pace with its bigger competitors. Unless it makes some changes to its revenue model and introduces some innovations soon, it could end up the same way as the Bombay Stock Exchange's (BSE) failed currency derivatives segment. The BSE, which has a 15% stake in USE, had set up and shut down its own currency-derivatives market within a matter of months. Unfortunately, there is no revenue model possible for this segment.

The USE is forced to impose zero transaction fees in line with the predatory move made by NSE earlier, and followed by MCX-SX. In doing so, the nascent exchange is already burning a lot of cash with each passing day. This works out for the NSE as it can use its highly profitable equity segment to subsidise the currency segment. But even for an established player like the MCX-SX, it hurts business badly. The MCX-SX, which had dragged the NSE to the Competition Commission for its anti-competitive strategies, has already incurred a loss of around Rs120 crore, reveal sources. In one of its lawsuits, it has said that it is losing Rs5 crore a month. For a relative newbie like the USE, the situation is dire. If it incurs the same costs as the NSE and the MCX-SX, its net-worth would get eroded rapidly.

Surprisingly, the USE continues to maintain a stoic silence when asked about its revenue model, despite repeated attempts on our part. 

Click here to view the data for currency turnover of MCX-SX, NSE and USE




7 years ago

Dear Sucheta,
From day 1 - it was apparent that - truth is getting manufactured and people are coaxed to believe through news paper ad that - here is a guy who stood first in the class before he understood the alphabets properly. I wonder why such things are not under scrutiny.

The more important thing - How do you get USE turnover data? I have tried several times - those guys have made it impossible to download historical data. I do not think it is technical error. I am afraid it is a tactical decision to hide the long time series data. If you happen to have it, could you post it in your site in a time series manner.

with regards,



In Reply to Rishi 7 years ago

As per your suggestion, pls find the link for the turnover data below the article.

Crude oil prices to remain range-bound, but below $90 a barrel: Analysts

Despite the financial measures that the US is trying to push through, American demand is expected to stay suppressed due to the faltering economy, and prices are expected to remain in check

Global crude oil prices, which hit a new two-year high of $88 a barrel on Thursday, will not rise much and will remain range-bound below $90 per barrel, say analysts.

In a report, BRICS Securities said, "We expect oil prices to average between $70-$80 per barrel at least till FY12, even as global demand crosses 2007 levels in 2010. The likelihood of demand flagging appears limited as global governments are determined to stimulate their economies at (the) slightest hint of a slowdown. With no large incremental supply expected, we have assumed the long-term oil price at $75 a barrel."

Global oil prices dropped below $87 a barrel in Asian trade today due to a decline in regional stocks amid a strong dollar. According to the US Department of Energy, oil prices surged after a decline of 3.3 million barrels in US crude oil stockpiles in the first week on this month.

"This is a seasonal phenomenon, as in the US, this is the hurricane period which leads to supply disruption. In this season, demand for heating oil and diesel is always high and the drop in inventories is just a weekend activity. Until the trend continues for eight to ten weeks, we can not jump on this demand trend," an analyst from Emkay Global Financial Services Ltd told Moneylife.

The depreciation of the US dollar is pushing up oil prices. However, high prices will not sustain until the world's largest oil-consuming country recovers completely.
On the subject of recovery, according to Nobel Laureate economist Joseph Stiglitz, the US Federal Reserve's policy of quantitative easing will do little to boost the US economy. The recent bout of quantitative easing by the Fed has boosted commodity markets. However, crude prices may remain in check due to the long road that the USA has to limp along for economic recovery.

"The falling dollar and the quantitative easing measures by the US Federal Reserve are supporting commodity prices; but oil has remained at the downside compared to other commodities because there are still concerns over the US and European economies. So until there is concrete growth in the US economy, oil prices will not reach $100 a barrel," the analyst from Emkay added.

Mayur Matani, research analyst, ICICI Securities, said, "The Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) has predicted that crude oil prices will remain around $74-$75 a barrel for this fiscal year. Over a period of time, crude oil prices will be about $80 a barrel, where (both) oil-consuming companies and OPEC are comfortable."

"Many stimulus packages are being poured into markets by the US and a few European countries. This has already fuelled oil prices - they touched $88 a barrel recently. And to touch higher levels of crude oil prices, more stimulus packages are required, which seems difficult at this time" added Mr Matani.

However, some market pundits are also predicting that oil prices would be seen at $100 a barrel. According a report which quoted Dallas-based energy investor T Boone Pickens, oil prices will rise to $90-$95 a barrel next year, and may touch $100.

However, Mr Matani told Moneylife, "It's difficult to touch the level of $100 a barrel. The economic situation in the US and European countries is not encouraging. Prices may touch $95 a barrel on speculation, but it would be difficult to sustain prices at this level. I don't think crude oil prices would go beyond $90 a barrel."



V Malik

7 years ago

Good article, thanks.

However, it is not just the price of benchmark crude at loadport which is relevant, but also the rapidly increasing cost of transporting and converting this crude oil into usable products.

That the increasingly stringent requirements for cleaner low sulphur fuels as well as the rapidly increasing cost of ensuring safe passage of crude has gone up by almost 100% or even more in dollar terms, and even more when calculated in SDRs or some other currencies, needs to be factored in too.


Sharad Matade

In Reply to V Malik 7 years ago

Thanks sir for your suggestion. Next time I will definitely take that factor into account.

Anant concerned about declining industrial growth

New Delhi: Chief statistician TCA Anant today expressed concern over slow industrial growth for two consecutive months of August and September, reports PTI.

"I am disappointed by these Index of Industrial Production (IIP) numbers. We have got poor numbers for two consecutive months - August and September.

As the finance minister has said, I think we need to take careful look", he said.

The chief statistician, however, said that the country would end the fiscal with double-digit factory output expansion and 8.5% gross domestic product (GDP) growth.

"I expect overall IIP growth this fiscal to close at 10% because of the onset of festive season and agriculture produce hitting market in November, December and January," Mr Anant told reporters here.

He elaborated there was a tendency for industrial activity to pick up with the start of the festive season and rise in purchasing power with farmers selling their produce in these three months.

Industrial growth slowed down to 4.4% in September, about half of 8.2% in same month last year. Similarly, the IIP growth for August was 6.91% against 10.50% in the year-ago period.

However, industrial growth for the first six months of this fiscal stood at 10.2% against 6.3% a year ago.

Perplexed by this phenomenon, finance minister Pranab Mukherjee said, "We will have to analyse why that is happening. And after that considered comments can be made. But it's a matter of concern."

On the GDP growth this fiscal, Mr Anant said, "It seems agriculture growth would be much better than last year. I will still be comfortable with projection of 8.5% (GDP growth) which is our original estimate."

About high inflation numbers, which had rocked the last two Parliament sessions, he said, "It is coming down and it would be closer to 7% by December."


We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)