Mutual Funds
Top Bets of Best Funds
17 stocks selected with the same methodology that beat 88% of equity schemes last...
Premium Content
Monthly Digital Access


Already A Subscriber?
Yearly Digital+Print Access


Moneylife Magazine Subscriber or MSSN member?

Yearly Subscriber Login

Enter the mail id that you want to use & click on Go. We will send you a link to your email for verficiation
How to resolve iron ore mining issues

Due to uncertainty, the Indian steel industry has resorted to import iron ore. Although the SC has allowed category A mines to start production, miners are facing several issues like renewal of licence and compliance


A three day Mining Exploration Convention and trade show, organised by the Federation of Indian Mineral Industries (FIMI), was inaugurated by the Union Minister for Mines, Steel and Labour, Narendra Singh Tomar, in Bangalore. More than 300 delegates are expected to participate in the Convention, where, there is no doubt that the steel industry's spokesmen are going to explain the state of affairs in the mining sector.


Indian production of iron ore has now come down to 140 million tonnes (mt), as against 220 mt before the ban on illegal mining. Supreme Court, while permitting the mining operations to start, classified the categories of mines as A, B and C, and permitted those under "A" to commence their mining operations. In the meantime, in order to continue and/or revive production, import of iron ore in 2013-14 amounted to 360,000 tonnes, and, so far, during the current fiscal, it has reached 2.37 million tonnes.


Iron ore production in Karnataka, for instance, is now only 17 million tonnes against the rising demand of over 30 million tonnes annually. Karnataka has 160 iron ore mines of which, currently, only 27 are operational. After the Supreme Court permitted those mines, categorised as "A" to commence operations, most of them have been attempting to renew leases (many of which expired during the interim period), acquire fresh licences, and, of course, comply with the usual formalities relating to environmental clearances.


Although the Environment Minister, Prakash Javadekar, had assured one and all that his Ministry would not be a speed breaker, it now appears that mine owners wishing to start their operations are confronted with potholes! Because of the recent amendments to the Mines & Mineral (Development and Regulation) Act 1957, the process of lease renewals have become "particularly difficult" according to Basant Poddar, Managing Director of Mineral Enterprises. The steel industry has been left with little choice and due to uncertainty in obtaining the indigenous ore, to tide over the production needs, they have resorted to import.


Details of the pathetic conditions of the steel industry, arising out of the non-supply and inadequate supply of iron ore are expected to be highlighted in the Convention. Union Minister Tomar, it is hoped, would carry the details and ensure necessary steps are taken with the Environment Ministry and the State Government authorities, so that Karnataka iron ore mines can start brimming with activity. It will also help to bring down employment to the mines, who have been suffering for long.


(AK Ramdas has worked with the Engineering Export Promotion Council of the ministry of commerce. He was also associated with various committees of the Council. His international career took him to places like Beirut, Kuwait and Dubai at a time when these were small trading outposts; and later to the US.)


VIP culture is built on no rules and dubious practices

According to a reply procured under RTI, traffic can be stopped only for the President, the Vice President, the PM and visiting foreign dignitaries who are given President and PM level security cover


Most cases of traffic being stopped or diverted for VIPs to pass, making our life difficult, are illegal. Jammu-based RTI activist, Deepak Sharma was surprised to find out that the police have no right to stop traffic for most VIPs that pass by. Fed up of being inconvenienced due to all grades of ministers enjoying VIP treatment on roads, he filed an RTI application, seeking information on who is eligible for special privileges on roads.


The Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) replied that, traffic on roads can be stopped only in the case of movement by the President of India, the Vice President, the Prime Minister and visiting foreign dignitaries, who are given President and PM level security cover.

This is what the reply stated, “…it may be stated that as per guidelines issued by MHA in consultation with Central Security Agencies, traffic is to be stopped only in the case of President of India, the Vice President of India, the Prime Minister of India and visiting foreign dignitaries who are given President and PM level security cover so as to give them safe passage during movement by road.”

Stopping the normal flow of traffic is just one way VIPs misuse their illegal privileges.


Here are many other examples of, how VIPs flout rules unabashedly to pamper their cronies. An RTI application filed with the MHA regarding nominations for the 2013 Padma awards shockingly revealed that several VIPs nominated their family members and friends for the prestigious awards.

As per the RTI reply, there were 25 nominees, recommended by VIPs. Lata Mangeshkar had nominated her sister Usha; Ustad Amjad Ali Khan had recommended both his sons, Amaan and Ayaan; Congress MPs Motilal Vora and T Subbarami had recommended over 10 names and Amar Singh had nominated Jaya Prada. This was in gross violation of the rules for application for Padma awards.

Another example is of former aviation minister, Praful Patel, who is fighting hard to defend himself regarding the purchase of the aircraft fleet. He would have no voice when it comes to his daughters’ misdeeds during his tenure as minister. Noted RTI activist, Subhash Chandra Agrawal, had filed an RTI application in this regard.

The replies were shocking. In April 2010, Patel’s daughter Avni Deshpande decided to have a bigger Air India aircraft from Bangalore to Male in Maldives, as seven of her family members from her in-laws side, could not be accommodated in the business class, as it was full.

The RTI documents show that directions were given by email from Mumbai office of Air India to change the 'equipment' of Bangalore-Male flight on 25th April and Male-Bangalore on 28 April 2010 from a smaller Airbus A319 to the larger A320.

Accordingly, Air India provided a bigger plane so that the following members could travel in business class: R V Deshpande, Radha Deshpande, Prasad Deshpande, Meghna Deshpande and Master Dhruv, in addition to Avni and her husband Prashant Deshpande. What is worse is that the reply states that the return flight went half-empty, thus frittering away public money.

Similarly, his other daughter, Poorna Patel: a Delhi-Coimbatore Air India flight was cancelled 12 hours before departure as she turned it into a chartered flight so that she could fly from Chandigarh to Chennai with some cricket players for an Indian Premier League (IPL) match!

Pune-based RTI activist, Vihar Durve, after the horrific incident of sexual assault on a lady journalist in Mumbai, filed an RTI application, to procure information on police security for VIPs in Maharashtra. His reply revealed that 64 VIPs have 812 policemen around them. Out of these, Sushilkumar Shinde, his wife and daughter were surrounded by 66 security personnel. His wife alone had 14 policemen to guard her. Maharashtra chief minister Prithviraj Chavan enjoys the cover of 46 security guards while 31 security personnel protect Ajit Pawar, the deputy CM. The reply shockingly revealed that out of 48,969 policemen on duty in Mumbai, more than 55% or 27,740 are deployed for security of VIPs, while the remaining over 21,000 cops attend to around two crore odd population of the metro city.

Several RTI applications have been filed regarding former President of India Pratibha Patil, who spent Rs225 crore on foreign tours wherein she visited 45 countries during her tenure as President. RTI applications filed by Subhash Chandra Agrawal and others reveal that in most cases she took along with her, a large contingent of her family members and friends. Several RTI applications had also revealed how she tried to usurp a 2.60 lakh sq ft of prime Defence land in Pune to build her home but a tenacious campaign through a series of articles in Moneylife thwarted her dreams. She had to surrender the land and is now residing in a smaller residence.

As for the railways, the VIP quota is an accepted norm. Veeresh Malik, Delhi-based RTI activist and Moneylife's Consulting Editor, has filed a series of applications with the Rashtrapati Bhavan, Prime Minister's Office (PMO), the MHA, Ministry of External Affairs, Ministry of Civil Aviation, Ministry of Surface Transport and Ministry of Railways, and a few other government bodies, which use or used the term ‘VIPs’.


However, he says he has “never got anything close to a cogent definition of the term (VIP).” The Railways, he says, has been more than helpful with the information provided.  Picking up from the reply, Malik summarized that, “There is no definition for the term VIP, and apart from the usual lot, pretty much anybody who holds a requisition from a 'High Official' (yet another undefined term) qualifies to be one as far as out-of-turn allotment of reservations is concerned. That letterheads of these VIPs are regularly misused for reservations under emergency quota is a known practice, and is also reported on in the media from time to time.”

Refreshingly, the Balaji Temple in Tirupati - wherein the VIP culture had reached insufferable proportions – has clamped down on VIP privileges. Earlier, with 5,000 VIPs visiting the temple every day, thousands of common people had to wait for long hours. Now, only 800-1000 VIPs are permitted per day, resulting in 10,000 more common people being able to take the darshan.

VIP culture simply mocks at democracy. It is up to us to become more assertive and put our foot down against it. Like the Pak passengers who prevented XXX from boarding the flight because he was two hours late, let us do it in our own way; click photographs and take videos with your mobiles and post them on YouTube!

Some links of stories pertaining to VIP culture:

(Vinita Deshmukh is consulting editor of Moneylife, an RTI activist and convener of the Pune Metro Jagruti Abhiyaan. She is the recipient of prestigious awards like the Statesman Award for Rural Reporting which she won twice in 1998 and 2005 and the Chameli Devi Jain award for outstanding media person for her investigation series on Dow Chemicals. She co-authored the book “To The Last Bullet - The Inspiring Story of A Braveheart - Ashok Kamte” with Vinita Kamte and is the author of “The Mighty Fall”.)



Ronnie Burjor Mistry

3 years ago

Do the numerous RTIs result in anything? I have my doubts. Nobody cares. We are, by and large, a soul-less nation. Let all join the fray!

Veeresh Malik

3 years ago

At a modest estimate made by a friend of mine who has been in the government for a few decades now and is soon reaching super-annuation, approximately one third of people and budget in governance would become redundant and surplus if this whole thing about VIPs was suddenly removed overnight.

Think about it. The person was very serious.


3 years ago

India has always been about "who" rather than "what". Pygmies like Nehru who have ruled India after the fashion of Aurangzeb and Ashoka rather than the royalty of Mysore and Travancore or Lord Curzon, Sir Mark Cubbon and Lord Chetwode have wrought it so. So, the Indian view is, "The Dalai Lama is safe, we have given him sanctuary, so what is he cribbing about?", Just like, "We have given ourselves "Z" Class security, what are all these raped women, Ladakhis, Kashmiri Pundits, Tamil Brahmins, Manipuris, Arunachal citizens and families of beheaded soldiers complaining

Madhur Aggarwal

3 years ago

I was waiting for this article to be published.
I have written an email regarding this to various forms to create awareness.

We need to make the Executive
and the PM of India- Chief Executive
24 x 7 accountable for their actions and performance on the job.
bcoz Actions speak louder than words.

This shows that many PEOPLE working in govt . r there for different reasons .
This can be clearly evident in their performances.
Praful Patel- Descent of Air India
Maharashtra -is going through social political and economic turmoil.
Railways- in Disarray management .
Pratibha Patil - shocked everybody with this maneuvering for land .
Fall from Grace.

Compare these politicians from statesmen of 1947 India .
S Radhakrishnan - First Vice- President of India donated 7,500 rupees per month out of total salary of rs 10,000 for Prime minister relief Fund in those days.
He was nominated for Nobel prize for 5 consecutive years.
Other names
C. rajagopalchari
Sarojini Naidu
Maulana Azad
Vallabhbhai Patel
and J. Nehru .

These VVIP culture politicians are are Good time Charlies .


Kailash Kanugo

In Reply to Madhur Aggarwal 3 years ago

Right thought.

Ramesh B Mhadlekar

3 years ago

VIP culture is built on no rules and dubious practices is very much true today. Everyone in India wants to take advantage of having the tag of VIP. The government officials want to be VIP through the vehicles affixing the sticker of Bhart Sarkar or Government of India because of the advantages viz park your car in slots easily, receive a salute by the poor constable on road ,no checking of vehicle during naka bandi, etc. Such vehicles are mostly used by the family members of such officials which is advantageous and prestigious. Hence, Reserve Bank of India officials have got the Government of India or Bharath Sarkar stickers affixed on the official vehicle, though they are strictly autonomous body and raise a cry and hue when the Finance Ministry wants encroach on their functioning or want the RBI to be under the CAG.
But for dishonest benefits they easily convert their vehicles into Bharth Sarkar Vehicles.
An RTI, in the matter reveals that the CPIO is not aware of such information if available even though the vehicles having such stickers are being captured by CCTV in the premises daily for years now, even a partial blind person would be able to view the same but the CPIO is unable to see or provide information in the matter. The Appellate authority has decided to remain mum and not to respond to the first appeal. How can they do away with such dishonest benefits easily so just simply do not respond.
I do not think the law enforcing agencies are interested in verifying such facts and some day taking advantage of such stickers the vehicles may be used for unlawful purposes and then the law enforcing agencies would wake up and do a Post Mortem, till then let all enjoy such dishonest officials and their family members enjoy such a culture.

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)