Citizens' Issues
The upwardly mobile rural poor must be represented in Anna Hazare’s movement too

The movement against corruption deserves a lot more support than it is getting so far. Because, the truth is that the target for other countries to "control" India will be the wealth of agricultural production and potential thereof which rests in the hands of the upwardly mobile rural poor. Who seem to be terribly unrepresented in the movement so far 

You don't have to go too far from the bright lights and shiny malls of South Delhi to find out what the rural poor and people from the agricultural heartlands are doing or thinking about the Anna Hazare and India Against Corruption movement. But you do have to take time out, let go the bonds of metal and glass, and if you cannot go "upcountry", then at least walk through the lanes of what are called "urban villages" or "lal dora settlements", within Delhi.

There are a few such habitats, their main streets have become commercial hotspots where everything can be purchased at prices way below what is charged in the main markets nearby, and where the bylanes provide dormitory shanty town accommodation for the people who keep South and New Delhi alive and ticking.

Delhi does not have the benefit of a Dharavi-type urban "slum" of massive size in the middle of the city, so the toiling masses, mostly recently removed from their rural settings, largely live in these invisible enclaves, scattered within the "posh" areas nearby.
For example, Kotla Mubarakpur village, located between Defence Colony and South Ex-I (NDSE Part I); Sadiq Nagar village, located between Ansal Plaza, South Ex-2, Andrews Ganj and Lajpat Nagar-4; ZamrudPur village, located between Greater Kailash, Kailash and Lady Sri Ram College.

Each one of these "rural urban villages" is less than 500-1,000 metres away from the "happening" markets of South Ex, Defence Colony, GK, Ansal Plaza and Lajpat Nagar, and lie within a square of about 3 km by 3 km within some of the costliest real estate in India. There are a few more around, like Shahpur Jat, Hauz Khas Village and Bhogal/Nizamuddin, which have similar attributes, but they've also become important for other reasons. Almost all of them appear to go back in history a few centuries, if not more, with ample archeological evidence.

It is important to provide these geographical  and other details, because there is a generation of young people growing up in South Delhi who have never been there, inside their bylanes. Likewise, there is a generation of people living in those villages who do not come to the "posh" areas unless it is for reasons of working there. And not unsurprisingly, there is a generation of media people who are from the first group-that reflects in their reportage too.

So, when I went on a cycle tour of these three urban villages earlier today, what did I see?

Sure, it was raining, so there was the usual overflowing gutters, mud, slush and more on the roads, and chaos. But, I also saw what nobody else seems to have picked up so far: crowds of people standing outside television shops, watching the Anna Hazare movement unfold in front of their eyes, just like they would if there was a cricket match on. Only difference being, the cricket running commentary as well as scores in the case of cricket would also be carried on radio, while in this case, radio simply pretended that the whole movement did not exist.

It was even more interesting in the case of Doordarshan (DD). Barring a very short mention about Anna Hazare's release, nothing else, back to the usual. Same on All India Radio (AIR), almost violently different from the cable and satellite channels.
Now, for a moment, imagine that you and I are in the real poor rural areas of India, where disposable incomes are still very low, and satellite and cable TV have minimal penetration, if at all. The only option, then, are the LPT (low power transmitters) for Doordarshan in the tea shop nearby, and All India Radio. Why is this so important?
Look closely at the crowds thronging the Ramlila Maidan venue (which I have visited a few times already) and the other venues all over the country. As pointed out previously, the composition is largely middle class and urban or semi-urban-the rural poor who make up the numbers are simply not present. At the same time, despite the best efforts of DD and AIR, it is not as though they are not aware of what's going on. So where are they, our rural poor?

To get an answer I spoke with some of the people watching television on the streets of Sadiq Nagar and then subsequently at Kotla Mubarakpur. Anecdotal, sure, but valid all the same, and then re-confirmed this with a friend who is an authority on rural banking realities. Here is what emerged.

# In rural Bihar, especially North Bihar, for example, the success stories on growing maize as well as fish are much more than what the out-of-date numbers would reveal. But just a few parameters, like seed replacement, as well as repayment of loans taken, for example, tells you what is going on. Add NREGA to this, where is the time for Anna, and how is he relevant in a state where corruption has come rocketing down and which has not seen a single farmer suicide for debt reasons over the last few years? This is in a scenario where land reforms have led to fragmented small land holdings.
# In rural Kerala, which is mainly the mountain parts, the ground reality is the opposite-huge estates and plantations escaped the land reforms that swept other parts of India for particular crops like rubber, cashew and some others. Now, rural labour that has picked up best practices from other parts of the country, and has some money as well as staying power, is making moves towards these huge tracts, taking smaller parcels on sub-lease or profit-share, and going through some amazing agriculture models for high-value crops being grown quietly within the plantations.

# I was supposed to head into the mountains of Kumaon over the weekend, but had to cancel the trip due to heavy floods that caused massive dislocation of road and rail routes, as well as damage to life, limb and property. Elsewhere in the country, too, floods seem to be doing more this year than they normally do. This is being reported on DD and AIR, along with relief measures, but seems to be largely absent from the private "news" channels.

# FM radio channels, of course, do not reach the rural poor at all in most cases. But even where they do, it appears as though the prohibition on them talking about news now extends even to providing updates on traffic jams due to the processions being taken out in support of Anna Hazare. It is often forgotten how the urban poor, who may have  a mobile phone, but not much access to cable and satellite television, invariably have a small radio built into the said mobile phone.

To sum up, the update from an ear on the ground here is that the Anna Hazare/India Against Corruption movement, if it at all claims to owe any allegiance to Gandhiji, needs to take some rapid steps to go to the rural poor. And very soon. Which, in the excitement of being blinded by the bright arc and halogen lights of television, does not seem to be happening.
What is happening, however, is that a certain element of squabbling between some other organisations that are trying to get involved, seems to be creating not just static and churn, but also reducing the effectiveness. This, along with the visible presence of some people who can best be called "opportunistic carpet-baggers", is not going un-noticed.

This movement deserves a lot more support, from across all segments, than it is getting so far. Blindly. Because, otherwise, the country continues to get sold down the river.

And that is the real threat, the huge uncontrollable monster which emerges from not being able to control corruption, when those who do not have the interests of the nation, realise that they can continue to buy their way through. Matters are way beyond street level corruption now and the emerging rural agricultural strength of the country must be brought into the equation. Food prices globally are rising faster than energy prices, and while it is easy to talk about "development" of India being put to risk because of this movement, the truth is that the target for other countries to "control" India will be the wealth of agricultural production and potential thereof which rests in the hands of the upwardly mobile rural poor.
Who, as was said before, seem to be terribly unrepresented in Anna Hazare's movement.



A Banerjee

5 years ago

A very good study inter alia on a total disconnect between the "happening" or "the arrived India" and the rural India as well as the rural hamlets within the Indian Metros (like Delhi, as is the representative case in this article). For the large masses of the Indian citizens living in the inaccessible corners of India, like for instance in the Sunderbuns in Bengal, or the most undeveloped villages without roads, water connections, toilets, transport/communication facilities, health care even on a minimum scale, schools, etc., this current movement organised and compered inter alia by three Magsaysay awardees has just no relevance as they are destined to live and die in total apathy of the "arrived India" of the metros, the TRP-conscious media, the public school-IIM-IIT-educated high-value human products and of the bribe-'eating' officials of all levels. Even those living in Delhi but within the ghettos surrounded by the rich and powerful do not find much relevance of all this furore over Lokpal since everyday they must pay to the authorities (whether in uniform or not, whether in vehicles with blinking red-blue lights or in posh cars driven and owned by the petty MCD officials, to name a few) to be able to see the next morning's sun! One does not become the Cab Sec or the Union Home Sec or the CP of Delhi (or any metro) or even join the IAS if you must even bother about how these nameless masses of humans live and, in fact, they don't even care. Their eyes are riveted on post retirement slots (preferably abroad) or the successive pay commissions or the sojourns abroad at govt. coat in the name of foreign tours, etc. The mundane and petty issues of the dying hungry people cannot really be bothered about by the people at such high levels who do not even know-nor are required to so know-the prices of the essential commodities like food! All that is for the commoners. And, with corruption unabated, they do not even care for the anti-corruption machinery, whether CBI (which is under their thumbs) or CAG or Lok/Jan Lok Pal or whatever authority the Parliament creates finally. As long as the politicians ready to eat out of their hands are around, this class of corrupt class shall remain, indestructible as they are. One Dalit leader has called the Anna Hazare led agitation an upper caste manifestation of its rights. It would be better and truer to categorise this instead an upper "CLASS" movement to protect their property rights which the majority of the citizens are deprived/dispossessed of.
Congrats to the writer for contributing this excellently thought provoking piece.

The unnecessary controversy over Anna Hazare’s spotless army record

RTI activist Subhas Agrawal is surprised that details of his query about Anna’s service with the army was sought to be misused by a ruling party spokesperson

The latest attempt by an embarrassed UPA government, to contain the protests that continue to build up in the movement for a strong anti-corruption law, has backfired. A Congress party spokesperson had challenged Anna Hazare's right to lead the fight against graft, citing alleged corruption charges against him, and claimed that Anna had refused to come clean on his army record, as was asked for in a query under the Right to Information (RTI) Act.

However, the reply that the RTI applicant received shows that Anna's army record is honourable and there is nothing more than what the 74-year-old Gandhian has claimed publicly.

Subhas Agrawal, the RTI activist who filed the query, is surprised over the episode. First, he is unable to understand how his correspondence with the Central Principal Information Officer (CPIO) was leaked out to Congress spokesperson Manish Tiwari. Second, the RTI application for which he received the reply was not filed by him.

"I have not received a reply to a query I filed on 13th April, in which I had asked six questions about Anna Hazare's army record and the qualifications required for recruitment of army drivers and cooks," said Mr Agrawal. "Instead, I received a reply to a 20th June query, which was not filed by me.

However, that application had eleven questions, on the same topics, and the reply to some of those questions shows that Anna Hazare had an unblemished career at the army and had won some medals before he was honourably discharged."

Kisan Baburao Hazare (who is today popularly addressed as Anna Hazare), as the Deputy Commandant & Appellate Authority ASC Centre (South), said in his reply to the 20th June query, that he joined the army as a sepoy in 1963, and was honourably discharged in 1983 on completion of his service. He received five medals, and did not suffer any punishment during his service period.

"I don't know who filed this query, but the reply was directed to me. May be it was a mistake on the department's part," said Mr Agrawal. To his original query, the CPIO had replied on 27th May that since the information sought pertains to a third party (Hazare), the CPIO had written to Mr Hazare to seek his permission for revealing his service details.  

"But what surprised me more was that the CPIO's letter, that Mr Tiwari referred to in the 14th August press conference, was addressed to me in response to a petition, and I have no idea how he got hold of it." Since he hasn't received a reply for his 13th April query, Mr Agrawal has gone for an appeal.

In his appeal, Mr Agrawal has said, "I was shocked and surprised that the CPIO's said letter dated 21 May 2011 was referred to by a spokesperson of the ruling party in the Union Government in a press conference telecast by news channels, in a bid to defame Shri Kisan Baburao Hazare. I appeal that an enquiry may kindly be made as to how the said correspondence was leaked to a third party (ruling party spokesperson) without inviting objections from me, as is usually done by many public authorities including even the Central Information Commission."




5 years ago

anna Hazare sahab is doing right thing. he is fighting against corruption. corruption is spreading in the entire govt officers and buroctrats in general and in police Department in particular all over india. i fully support the agitation of shri anna hazare.

P M Ravindran

5 years ago

The dates are confusing...! SC Aggarwal's application of 13 Apr- no reply received or replied on 27 May that Anna's concurrence is required! Then there is the CPIO's letter of 21 May, referred to by Tiwari, which is not accounted for. Lastly there is the letter by the CPIO in response to somebody else's application of 20 Jun but routed to Aggarwal!

Apart from the confusion over the dates, there is another question that begs answer: Had the CPIO taken Anna concurrence before replying to the application of 20 Jun?

nagesh kini

5 years ago

This is a case of the right use of the RTI to ascertain facts. At least it has tailed the canard of Anna's army career.
Long live RTI activism.


5 years ago



5 years ago




5 years ago

Can kongresh or Manish tiwari so called the spokesman, dare to enquiry of other 150 criminal holding on the Parliment office, As per Manish tiwari if some one is any issue with their carrier they can't do or justify for the public life, so as per him all the sitting MP from all the party should not able to be a public figure they should not able to sit on Parliment because they are not currupt but they are more down then the currupt nature like currupt,dishonest,criminal record,name the crime they are.. so A open letter to manish tiwar,pl. file RTI for all the MPs.

P Giri Durga Siva Prasad

5 years ago

The spokespersons have access to all kind of information, they peep into all the records they want because the systems are loose. When the janlokpal bill is passed they cannot continue it, if continued then he will have to sit for some time in jail and rest of his life at home. Now our first effort is to bring the janlokpal bill drafted by Annaji and Team into effect

Rakesh Kumar

5 years ago

Anna sir, carry on your strike, I will with you


5 years ago

not a wise thinking by rulling party.

NS Choudhary

5 years ago


Will Maneesh Tiwary also look into the record of his colleauges with same zeal? We hate everyone who even tries to raise a finger on the past of Shri Anna Hajare.
Only .....thu....thu...//

pradip shah

5 years ago

must be send to every emidia for top most publicity.every one in India should have excess to this news.Manish Tiwari must be exposed.

Tough decisions needed to achieve 9% growth in 12th Plan: PM

The prime minister also underlined the need to focus on implementation and governance to improve effectiveness of the flagship programmes aimed at promoting inclusive growth

New Delhi: Amid global economic uncertainty, prime minister Manmohan Singh on Saturday said the government will have to take 'difficult decisions' to achieve 9% growth rate in the 12th Five Year Plan (2012-17), up from 8.2% estimated for the current plan, reports PTI.

"... 9% target (in 12th Plan) is feasible only if we can take some difficult decisions," Mr Singh said in his opening remarks at the meeting of the full Planning Commission here.

The meeting has been called to approve the approach paper for the 12th Five Year Plan.

The prime minister also underlined the need to focus on implementation and governance to improve effectiveness of the flagship programmes aimed at promoting inclusive growth.

"These (flagship) programmes will continue in the 12th Plan, but as the (approach) paper rightly emphasises, we need to focus on issues of implementation and governance to improve their effectiveness."

The prime minister also made a case for stepping up agriculture sector growth rate to 4% during the next plan saying it is necessary to avoid inflationary pressure and improve rural income.

India was growing by over 9% before the global financial crisis in 2008 pulled down the economic growth to 6.8% in 2008-09. The economy is likely to grow expand by 8% during 2010-11.

The agriculture sector is estimated to grow by 3.3% during the current plan period (2007-12).

"I am happy to inform members that although the approach paper talks of achieving 3% agricultural growth in the Eleventh Plan ... the latest estimates suggest that this will be 3.3%," Mr Singh said.

Agriculture contributes about 14%-15% to the country's gross domestic product (GDP).

The commission had examined the range of 9%-9.5% for economic growth during the 12th Plan and it proposed that the government should set the target at 9%.

Mr Singh further said that achieving 9% growth will require large investments in the infrastructure sector.

The global markets are in a tailspin amid concerns over euro zone debt troubles and their impact on banks, weak economic data in the US and other parts of the world.

On the domestic front, while high inflation is the biggest concern for the government, the industry has expressed worries over rising interest rates.

The approach paper notes that India was 'fairly successful' during the 11th Plan in using a combination of public investment and public private partnerships for infrastructure development.

"We need to bring greater momentum to both these components so that present infrastructure shortages can be addressed in the shortest time available," Mr Singh said.

Noting that land acquisition has become 'highly controversial', Mr Singh said the approach paper rightly argues that a new legislation is required to deal with the situation.

The paper points out that the new legislation should strike a balance between the need for fair compensation and the need to ensure that land acquisition does not become an 'impossible impediment' to meet the needs for infrastructure development, industrial expansion and urbanisation.

The prime minister said that health, education and skill development were key areas of the strategy of inclusive development in the current plan and they will continue to be focus areas in the next as well.

Mr Singh said the Planning Commission has rightly endorsed the importance of the process of fiscal correction announced by the government, even if this means that total resources available for the plan in the short run will be limited.

"Resource limitations imply the need to priorities carefully. Some priority areas like health, education and infrastructure will have to be funded more than others," he said.


We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)