Citizens' Issues
Public Interest Exclusive
The story of two soldiers who took on the Supreme Commander

Commander Ravindra Pathak (retd) and Col Suresh Patil (retd) who have been campaigning against excess defence land being taken by President Pratibha Patil  are well known activists in Pune.  Let’s see how far their tenacity takes them in this campaign which is connected with the highest chair in this country

Col Suresh Patil (retd) saw death at close quarters when six of his colleague officers and 67 men were killed in the J&K sector in the 1971 Indo-Pak War. Commander Ravindra Pathak (retd) too was challenging death, as he was given the task of clearing under-sea mines to make Chittagong Harbour operational, immediately after the same war.

Today, both say they were gifted with a second life and hence, decided since then to give it back to the society, once they hang their boots, somewhere in the early 1990s.

It’s a story of two soldiers and one mission – to fight against encroachment of defence land by the present Supreme Commander of the Armed Forces, who is none less than the President of India, and it’s Pratibha Patil, this time round.

Col Patil fired the first salvo in August 2011 when he got a whiff of President Patil  “grabbing’’ a prime defence land in Khadki cantonment of Pune, admeasuring a whopping 2,42,000 sq ft as against her eligibility of getting only 4,498 sq ft of an existing government bungalow in any part of the country, as her retirement home.  

Col Patil, who formed the `Justice for Jawans’ organisation for ‘serving’ and ‘retired’ soldiers and officers who suffer many difficulties in terms of accommodation and other issues, took up the President’s retirement home issue, rather intensely.

His initial war cry to halt this unjustified “capture’’ of land when the President’s soldiers and officers in the same city were being denied their rightful official accommodation due to lack of space, did not have much impact. It fell on deaf ears of the authorities as well as the media. In the meanwhile, Defence Estate officers of Pune were making hectic trips to and fro Pune-Delhi to make way for Pratibha Patil to legally get this vast tract of land, studded with two `living’ bungalows.

Col Patil appealed to other defence NGOs to join in the campaign. That’s how Comm Pathak came into the picture. Since 2008, he was also working towards the cause of pension related issues of retired soldiers on behalf of the Delhi headquartered Indian Ex-Servicemen Movement (IESM).

After the sixth pay commission, the IESM had taken up a campaign nationally to demand ‘one rank one pension’ as consecutive pay commissions recommended different criteria for soldiers and officers who may have completed the same years of service; belonged to the same group; and held the same rank; but drew different pensions depending on the year they retired.

Protests manifested in the form of 25,000 soldiers and officers returning their medals to the Pratibha Patil, since 2010. As per the protocol, the President of India in his/her role as Supreme Commander of the Armed Forces is required to personally accept the ‘returned’ medals as a traditional form of protest. Ms Patil to date has not given an appointment and hence, the medals are lying in the Delhi office of IESM. Hence, the ire against Pratibha Patil was already there in the eyes of IESM members.

Comm Ravindra Pathak
In early 2011, Comm Pathak decided to join Col Patil and ever since the campaign has picked up momentum. They collected incriminating evidence against her proposed retirement home through RTI. However, they got a luke warm response from the media until this week’s story in Moneylife made national waves and went viral on the social network. Suddenly the controversy is raging through all corners of the country.

Col Suresh Patil (retd) is otherwise known as an environmentalist and has been involved in greening some parts of the cantonment. The two kilometre Bogra Walking Plaza that has been turned into a beautiful landscaped garden was once a stinking nallah. Similarly, he has greened another two kilometre stretch of a nallah bank in the Pune Municipal Corporation area, under his Green Thumb NGO. More details can be found at  Commander Pathak is active on this blog:

(Vinita Deshmukh is a consulting editor of Moneylife. She is also an RTI activist and convener of the Pune Metro Jagruti Abhiyaan. She is the recipient of prestigious awards like the Statesman Award for Rural Reporting which she won twice in 1998 and 2005 and the Chameli Devi Jain award for outstanding media person for her investigation on Dow Chemicals. She co-authored the book “To The Last Bullet - The Inspiring Story of A Braveheart - Ashok Kamte” with Vinita Kamte. She can be reached at [email protected])



Ashok Malkani

5 years ago

Hurrah for Cmdr Ravindra Pathak and Col. Suresh Patil. These two servicemen are the pathbreakers, who have taken courage to speak out their mind, even against the President.

For too long have servicemen been cowed down by authority and reduced to " Yes Sir, Yes Sir, Haanjee Sir" wallas.
Let the President not be allowed to grab defence lands. We have another shameful Adarsh scam in the making.


5 years ago

Any person after death req 2ft*6ft land. Whether President or Prime Minister or Poor Countryman at native place.
Why cant she go to her native n stay n set example to all Ministers


5 years ago

We have a wrong system of President elected by the corrupt politicians. It will help get a better President if he/she is elected by direct vote from the people. At least we will not get dumb Presidents like Pratibha Patil.

Anna should add this to his agitation.


5 years ago

Hats off to these soldiers. Hope they are not threatened or further put to risk or harm in their endeavours to help improve matters in India.

Typically, in such situations, local pressures and other sorts of methods will be employed by the back-door. Nothing is sacred.\\


5 years ago

On one end of the presidential spectrum we have Dr Rajendra Prasad who on retirement donated all his worldly possession and spent rest of his life in an Ashram. Now we are witnessing shameless act . Prestige of Presidential chair has been demeaned
by the present incumbent. Sad day for the nation.


5 years ago

Charity begins at home and no one is above law. For whatever service the President, whomever it be should gracefully accept what is legitimately given and set an example for the nation to follow.

Just as the duty of other is fraught with ,so is acquiring anything which is not ones due is deadly sin.
"Yatha Raja thatha Prajaa"

P M Ravindran

5 years ago

Kudos to Cdr Pathak and Col Patil! May their tribe increase!

Sandeep Patil

5 years ago

Dear Pratibha,

Please read the following quoting :

"Rivers do not drink their own water, nor do tree eat their own fruit, nor do rain clouds eat the grains reared by them. The wealth of the noble is used solely for the benefit of others!

"When the wealth in the house increases, when water fills a boat, throw them out with both hands!"

'How much should we provide for our heirs?'
Ask yourself 'are we taking away from them the gift of work? - A source of happiness?
The answer is given by Warren Buffett:
"Leave your kids enough to do anything, but not enough to do nothing!"

S Suchindranath Aiyer

5 years ago

The "Highest" Chair has been brought low like most others. In 21st Century India, there is no such ting as a "high chair". As for SoniaJi's PresidentJi, she is a true Head of the Indian State. Govt. extravagance, profligacy and corruption are reflected in galloping inflation, curtailment of freedom of expression, suicides, and the more subtle abrogation of the Constitution than Schedule 9.



In Reply to S Suchindranath Aiyer 5 years ago

well said..


5 years ago

Hats off to these 2 martyers like Anna Hazare. Because of these selfless Indian citizens, we are still functioning as a democracy. Govt. is still not got over Adarsh and trying its best to safegurad corrupt politicians who shamelessly still holding public offices. All the best to these brave solders of the land and thanks to Money LIfe to bring these courrpt high office bearers to books. All the best.

Mr Rohinton Khambata

5 years ago

President Pratibha Patil is misusing her position & grabbing land for her own bunglow is indeed very shameful.The Govt. or the Supreme Court must take action against her & must not allow this unjustfication of her demands.


5 years ago

It would be helpful if an update on the latest situation, preferably with photographs, could please be provided.

Interim, here is one more article on the subject from Delhi:-

Dr Ratna Magotra

5 years ago

A retirement home for the President is a perfect idea when merit and ability were the sole criteria for selection to the highest post. The idea needs another look now when the sole criteria is loyalty to the ruling party, merit no longer a consideration. One only needs to visit Congress Nagar in Amrawati and decide whether the current President needs a retirement home. She must be stopped from grabbing the defence land.

Vaibhav Dhoka

5 years ago

One can lable this as STUBBOURNESS.When the highest officer is contravertial what can we expect from others to those in power.


5 years ago


Economy & Nation Exclusive
China’s slowing GDP

The main reason why the Chinese slowdown does not scare pundits more is that they expect China to repeat its past actions by loosening its monetary policy and stimulating its economy as it did in 2009

China is slowing. Its (gross domestic product) GDP growth rate has fallen to 8.1%.  Not to worry. Forecasters everywhere are more than confident that the Chinese can stimulate the economy if things start to get bad. This might be true if China was a normal economy, but its strengths can quickly turn into weaknesses. The reality is that they have the wolf by the ears and there might be no way out.

In its latest forecast the World Bank has cut its forecast for China from 8.4% to 8.2%. While this growth rate seems enviable, it is a 13-year low. The Bank also forecasts that the Chinese economy, after a soft landing, will bounce back by the third quarter of 2012. The recovery’s shape would be somewhere between a vigorous ‘V’ and a flat ‘L’. The World Bank also forecast in June 2008 that the US would grow at 1.1%, Europe would grow at 1.9% and China would continue its growth of 9.4%. It also predicted in 2008 that a slowdown in the US would have little effect on China. It was wrong, very, very wrong.

The World Bank’s forecast has lots of support. A recent poll of 15 economists produced a median forecast of 8.3% while the Asian Development Bank (ADB) came in a little higher at 8.5%. Like the World Bank, the ADB’s forecast has been lowered from their report in December.

But it is not just the economic boffins who are forecasting slower Chinese growth. There is evidence from the real world as well. The most telling has to do with commodities. Over the past two years commodities seemed tied to equities. This has changed recently. World stock indices rose more than 11% in the first quarter while the Reuters-Jefferies CRB commodity index stalled, up only 0.2 %. This was reflected in Morgan Stanley’s index of commodity producers whose shares lagged behind other sectors and gained only 4%. The sluggish growth was no doubt due to falling demand from China.

Real estate construction accounts for 13% of China’s economic growth, but the sector is also slowing. Sales transactions in Beijing, Shanghai and Shenzhen are about 30% below levels last December. Investment in property construction growth was up 12% of the previous year in December, but that was half the growth in November. Developers have up to two years’ worth of supply on their books and there are an estimated 10 million to 65 million unoccupied apartments in China.

Car sales are also slowing. In 2010 car sales exploded, growing at 32%. They are still rising, but only at 4.5%. Dealers are now discounting to attract buyers. There is a concern that the annual forecast for a 10% rise in sales will not materialize.

The slowdown in China is cause for concern far from its shores. One estimate puts Chinese contribution to global economic growth at two-fifths, twice the contribution of the former locomotive, the US. China has also replaced the US as the dominant trading partner of an ever increasing number of countries. It makes up over 20% of exports of Taiwan, Australia, Korea and Japan. The impact of China’s slowdown is not evenly spread. It contributes over 1% to the GDP of Russia, Korea, Indonesia and Brazil. Germany, as well, would be quick to feel a chill, since China contributes .8% to its GDP growth. In contrast the US economy would hardly be affected. China takes only 7.6% of its exports and it contributes only 0.1% to its growth.

The main reason why the Chinese slowdown does not scare pundits more is that they expect China to repeat its past actions by loosening its monetary policy and stimulating its economy as it did in 2009. Certainly it is trying. Bank lending in March rose to 1.01 trillion renminbi. This is high by even the more recent standards of the last two years and is two and a half times the amount of lending of last September and October. It is equal to a third of the entire amount of money lent in 2008 alone.

Not surprisingly inflation, which was considered tamed, has risen again from February and food prices are rising again despite record foreign purchases. It is not only inflation that is an issue. Most of the money lent by the state banking system goes to local governments. The most recent estimate is that about 10% will go bad by 2013.

So the Chinese have a problem. Their economy is slowing. Western economists feel that they have plenty of room for further stimulation, but that stimulation only results in higher inflation and bad loans. As influential economist Tsinghua University Professor Yuan Gangming puts it “Monetary policy is already quite loose and the central bank won’t loosen more unless it wants to die”. Apparently they do.

(William Gamble is president of Emerging Market Strategies. An international lawyer and economist, he developed his theories beginning with his first hand experience and business dealings in the Russia starting in 1993. Mr Gamble holds two graduate law degrees. He was educated at Institute D'Etudes Politique, Trinity College, University of Miami School of Law, and University of Virginia Darden Graduate School of Business Administration. He was a member of the bar in three states, over four different federal courts and has spoken four languages. Mr Gamble can be contacted at [email protected] or [email protected]).



Cautious outlook: Weekly Market Report

Nifty may reach 5,450 if it manages to be stay above 5,185

Weak global cues, lower-than-expected industrial output growth for February and disappointing guidance by IT bellwether Infosys were seen as the main reasons for the domestic market falling 2% in the week. All eyes will now be on the inflation numbers for March, the RBI’s annual monetary policy, to be announced on 17th April and the ongoing earnings reports.

The Sensex closed 392 points lower at 17,095 and the Nifty finished the week at 5,207, down 115 points. The market is likely to remain cautious in next week. The Nifty may touch 5,450 if it manages to be stay above 5,185.

Disappointing US jobless data, which was released in the previous week, pulled the Asian markets down on Monday and India was no exception. A late recovery enabled the market, which was flat for most part of the day, settle higher on Tuesday. While gains in Europe perked up the indices in the second half of trade, the news of a massive earthquake off the Indonesian coast resulted in a flat close on Wednesday.

Lingering concerns about the debt crisis in Europe resulted in the indices paring their gains, but closing in the positive on Thursday. Dismal fourth quarter results from Infosys and a negative opening of the European indices saw the market plunge on Friday.

In the sectoral space, BSE Fast Moving Consumer Goods (up 4%) and BSE Healthcare (up 2%) were the top gainers while BSE IT (down 11%) and BSE TECk (down 10%) settled lower.

The top Sensex gainers were Hindustan Unilever (up 6%), ITC, Sun Pharma, Tata Motors (up 4% each) and Cipla (up 3%). The main laggards were Infosys (down 16%), TCS (down 9%), Hindalco Industries, BHEL (down 6% each) and Jindal Steel & Power (down 5%).

The Nifty toppers were HUL (up 7%), Kotak Mahindra Bank (up 6%), Ranbaxy Laboratories (up 5%), ITC and Tata Motors (up 4% each). Infosys (down 16%), Jaiprakash Associates (down 10%), TCS, Reliance Infrastructure (down 9% each) and ACC (down 6%) were the major losers on the index.

Pulled down by poor performance of manufacturing and consumer goods, India’s industrial growth slipped to 4.1% in February. Finance minister Pranab Mukherjee attributed the decline to rising interest rates and poor domestic demand which was aggravated by global uncertainties.

Meanwhile, the 6.8% industrial expansion in January has been drastically revised to 1.14% with chief statistician TCA Anant admitting ‘slippages’ in data collection. He said the problem mainly arose because of incorrect data on sugar production, though the segment has a small weight on the IIP.

Braving slowdown in the US and Europe, India’s exports crossed $300 billion in 2011-12, but the rising import bill pushed by high crude oil prices and the country’s obsession with bullion sent the trade deficit soaring to $185 billion.

IT giant Infosys on Friday posted a 27% rise in net profit for January-March quarter, but the company’s forecast of weaker revenue growth this fiscal due to an uncertain global economy sent its share spiralling down by 13%— the biggest fall in nearly three years. The company’s chief executive officer SD Shibulal said the year ahead “looks challenging” for IT services.

In international news, analysts have pointed out that the European Central Bank’s three-year refinancing operations (Long Term Refinancing Operations) are not a solution to the continent’s problems.


We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)