Striking Air India pilots have no rights to be trained says High Court

As long as the Air India pilots are on strike, the Court says it is not inclined to hear the matter and these pilots cannot go on strike as well as get training simultaneously 

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court on Wednesday said the striking pilots of Air India have no right to get training on advanced Boeing 777 to be used in international flights, reports PTI.

Refusing to hear an Air India appeal against the single judge's 11th May order which had stayed the training of more pilots till the implementation of Justice Dharmadhikari panel recommendations on the issue, a bench of Acting Chief Justice AK Sikri and Justice Rajiv Sahai Endlaw said "let them call off the strike, we will then hear the matter." 

The high court, however, refused to disturb the ongoing training of the Air India pilots.

"So long as they (Air India pilots) are on strike, the court is not inclined to hear the matter. They cannot go on strike as well as get training simultaneously," the bench said pulling up the Air India management for seeking court's intervention for training to the pilots who are on strike.

The bench, while posting the matter for hearing in July, made it clear that if the pilots call off their strike, they can file an application for hearing the matter.

"As they are on strike, they have no right to get any training. If the strike is called off they can move an application for hearing of the matter," the court said.

The order came after Air India's counsel Lalit Bhasin submitted to the court that the single judge was wrong in staying the training being imparted to the Air India Pilots for Boeing 777.

He also submitted that staying the training will cause huge financial loss and the advance flight will be grounded.

According to Air India, 200 Commanders (chief pilots and 200 First Officer (co-pilots) need to undergo training for Boeing 777 but at present only 64 Commanders and 62 co-pilots are undergoing training.

To Bhasin's submissions, the court wanted to know whether the Air India Pilots are on strike and getting training at the same time. 

The Court's 11th May verdict had come on a plea by the erstwhile Indian Airlines pilots under the banner of Indian Commercial Pilots Association (ICPA) for an order to stay the ongoing training and also direct Air India to impart training to them as well along with their counterparts in Air India for the rank of Commanders for Boeing 777.

"I hereby make it clear that those pilots of Air India, who are already on training on advanced aircrafts, shall not be disturbed," Justice Suresh Kait had said, adding, however, "... those who have already taken the training on advance aircraft shall be subject to the outcome of the instant petition." 

"I am of the considered opinion that till the report submitted by Justice Dharmadhikari Committee is implemented, the imparting of training on advanced aircraft, in this manner, shall remain stayed," the single judge had said.

Considering ICPA's contention that if the new training system is implemented, co-pilots of Air India will be directly promoted to the post of commanders of the advanced aircraft, the court observed it will prejudice the rights of erstwhile Indian Airlines pilots who will remain as commanders of basic aircraft only, thus affecting their seniority.

ICPA had moved the high court alleging it has not been dealt "at a par" with Indian Pilots Guild (IPG), an association Air India pilots.

During the course of hearing, Air India counsel Lalit Bhasin had argued that the management had taken the decision to train only Air India pilots for advance aircrafts because of their different nature of job and different experience profiles.


I-T dept not to reopen cases prior to April 2012 says Pranab Mukherjee

In cases where assessment proceedings have become final before first day of April 2012, the I-T department would not re-open the cases says the finance minister

New Delhi: Providing comfort to worried foreign investors, Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee on Wednesday said the Income Tax (I-T) Department will not re-open cases where assessment proceedings had been finalised before 1 April 2012, reports PTI.

"I gave a commitment in Parliament with regard to retrospective amendments that the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) will issue a policy circular to clarify that in cases where assessment proceedings have become final before first day of April 2012... such cases shall not be reopened. Now CBDT has issued a circular in this regard", he said while inaugurating Pratyaksh Kar Bhawan in the capital.

Mukherjee, in the Budget 2012-13, proposed to amend the Income Tax, 1961 with retrospective effect to tax Vodafone- type merger and acquisition deals done overseas that involve domestic assets.

These amendments, which came into effect with the President giving assent to the Finance Bill, 2012, had raised concerns among investors about re-opening of the old cases.

Referring to issues concerning transfer pricing, Mukherjee said he had constituted an advisory group to deal with international taxation, especially multi-level tax deduction at source (TDS) on software companies.

"I have constituted an advisory group to resolve various issues in the area of transfer pricing and international taxation. The group has held its first meeting on 25th May.

"On advise of group and Nasscom, I have approved issuance of a circular to avoid multi-level TDS on software under section 194 J (of the Income Tax Act). This will remove hardship in case of software distributors," Mukherjee added.

Section 194-J of the I-T Act deals with fees for professional and technical services and covers royalty and non-competence fees.

Multinational companies resort to transfer pricing to shift profits from high-tax countries to low-tax jurisdictions with a view to reducing overall tax liability.

Talking about the economic issues, Mukherjee said, India is also confronting the same problems as the world economy and underlined the need for fiscal consolidation.

At the bottom of the global crisis is tendency to spend more than the capacity to spend, he said.

"As individual is expected to live within its means, the state is also expected to live within its means... There comes the question of fiscal consolidation to maintain the fiscal discipline through proper revenue realisation to disburse it judiciously and of course spend it judiciously," he added.

In the Budget 2012-13, Mukherjee had proposed to bring down the fiscal deficit to 5.1% of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) from 5.9% during the previous fiscal.


RTI made easy: Government to set up call centres, website for filing applications

Soon, anyone would be able to file an RTI application over the phone, with help and guidance from a call centre as well as through a website

While the government is consistently blamed for diluting the RTI (Right to Information) Act in several ways besides making illogical amendments at the state level, it is gearing up to make filing of RTI applications by just making a phone call. Citizens will not have to take the pains of either writing a RTI application or taking the pains to post it or physically deliver it. Proposals for setting up such privately run call centres have been advertised by the “Department of Personnel & Training” (DoPT) with the last date of submission being 10 July 2012.

The project has been named “RTI Call Centre and Portal Project” under which 2,000 centres are proposed all over the country.

The DoPT, which has put up details of the project on its website, cites two facilities under it.  One is the computerised call centre which would facilitate the citizen to file his/her RTI over the phone; file first appeal applications over the phone and even track the status of their first appeal. This facility is termed as “Computer Telephony Integration enabled Call Centre Setup”. Second, is the development of a “web portal” which would provide information about the RTI Act as well as facilitate filing of RTI and first appeal applications.

The DoPT’s decision to start such a computerised facility is the result of a study sponsored by it on “key issues and constraints in the implementation of the RTI Act.” The findings revealed that citizens continue to face inconveniences in filing RTI requests; ineffective record management practices leading to delay in providing information by the public authorities and awareness level amongst citizens regarding their rights under the RTI Act is still low—though there has been a consistent 30%-35% annual increase in filing of RTI applications, showing citizens’ enthusiasm about the Act. It is DoPT’s assessment that due to the ease of filing, the call centre and portal will become the single largest mode of filing RTI applications in years to come.

The business model will be run as a PPP (public private partnership) format. The private agency is required to set up, operate and maintain the RTI Call Centre as well as the portal. The private agency can either set up a new centre or operate for an existing centre. It should have the facility of voice calls, SMS (outbound services) and IVR (Interactive Voice Response—a technology that automates interactions with telephone callers). The DoPT would pay the agency based on the number of calls and the talking time of the calls. For voice calls, the DoPT will make full payment that is Rs30 per call if the call duration is less than 15 minutes. For calls exceeding 15 minutes, 10% deduction will be made for each subsequent three-minute slabs. For example: If a call last 24 minutes, and “per connect minute charge” is Rs2, then the payment for the call will be commuted as per the calculations stated below:

Charges for the first 15 minutes: 2x15=Rs30

Charges for the next three minutes: 2x3x.9= Rs5.4

Charges for the next three minutes: 2x3x.8=Rs 4.8

Charges for the next 3 minutes: 2x3x.7=Rs 4.2

Total                                                =Rs44.4

The payment for any voice call would be restricted to a maximum of 24 minutes duration call worked out as per above. The SMSs (outbound) and IVR calls have different payment terms. (For more information on the business model go to:

For the citizen who wants to use this facility, all calls to the call centre would be chargeable at non-premium or premium rates depending on the purpose of the call. Calls seeking information, status check, and transcribing of RTI application/first appeal would be charged non-premium charges. These charges would be as per the caller’s existing call plan. To submit a statutory fee for RTI application, premium rate would be applicable and this would be deducted in his phone bill. This charge would be in addition to his existing normal call plan.

The method of filing RTI application is envisaged as follows:

Citizens can call the call centre from any number anywhere in the country

When a citizen calls in, the call centre agent will provide required information on RTI

If a RTI application is to be filed, details along with mandatory information including, his/her name and address would be obtained

Once the RTI application is transcribed, a Unique Reference Number (URN) will be generated and provided to the caller. There will also be a provision for informing applicants of their Unique Reference Numbers (URN) through SMS. Till this time, the RTI application will be stored in the call centre

Once the caller makes the payment of statutory RTI fee against its URN by calling/sending SMS to the “RTI fee line” within 24 hours and confirmation received, it will be sent to the relevant PIO. Public telephone booths cannot be used for this purpose.

Envisaged benefits for the citizen

Power of information is just a phone call away

Removes the hassles of physical presence at Central Public Authority for filing application

Money saved by way of travel time/wage loss as well as for making Drafts/Postal Order from Bank or Post Offices

Government bears the cost of transmitting the application to the Central Public Authority

Citizen’s handicap arising out of literacy level variations could be overcome by the call centre executives

Benefits to the government

Systematic management and real time monitoring of RTI applications and first appeals

Further improvement in transparency in government functioning

Empowerment of the common man through easy information dissemination

Man-hours spent by individual departments in collecting RTI applications can be saved by centralising the process on the portal

Support data analysis indicating area of improvement as well as sectors demanding intervention

1. For more information go to:

2. The Request for Proposal may be downloaded from or

3. Complete proposals may be submitted to the office of Director (IR), Department of Personnel and Training, Room No280, North Block, New Delhi-110001 by 5pm, Tuesday, 10 July 2012. Any queries in this regard may be addressed to [email protected].

(Vinita Deshmukh is the editor of Life 365 ( She is also the consulting editor of Moneylife, an RTI activist and convener of the Pune Metro Jagruti Abhiyaan. She is the recipient of prestigious awards like the Statesman Award for Rural Reporting which she won twice in 1998 and 2005 and the Chameli Devi Jain award for outstanding media person for her investigation series on Dow Chemicals. She co-authored the book “To The Last Bullet - The Inspiring Story of A Braveheart - Ashok Kamte” with Vinita Kamte. She can be reached at [email protected])




anantha ramdas

4 years ago

It is gratifying to note from Ms Vinita Deshmukh's article that we can now file an RTI over the phone. I am not aware if we can be allowed to file an RTI over the interrnet with the relevant details. Upon receipt, there should be an automatic system established that will prevent the full identify of the person being published, but codified, by a confirmation to the sender.

This way ID of the person is protected.

All the same, we all owe our thanks and gratitude to valiant fighters like Vinita who stands for the aam aadmi.

Thanks and god bless and give you all the strength you need in your crusades.

regards ramdas

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)