Sewri bridge can really change Mumbai, says Deepak Parekh

“We took 10 years to build the Worli-Bandra sea link. The Sewri bridge would be 10 times more important”

For a long time, the only way a member of the middle class could dream of owning a home was to try his luck in the lottery to grab one of those badly-built apartments of the housing board.

Finally, they had one more option—make a beeline for one of the offices of the Housing Development Finance Corporation (HDFC). In a sleazy industry—most builders were out to cheat you and 40% or more of the payment had to be made in cash—HDFC shone as a professional housing finance institution. While it was HT Parekh who pioneered the idea, it was his nephew Deepak Parekh who executed it to perfection, not only growing HDFC but also setting up a bank, a mutual fund, two insurance companies, a securities company and India’s largest real-estate private equity firm along the way.

But Mr Parekh has been more than just a creator of an outstanding, professionally-run organisation. Over the years, he became an indispensable part of the Indian financial world. His wide networking skills made his office one of two or three stops for top global businessmen and officials visiting India. He has been called several times to handle crises, most recently the fraud at Satyam Computer.
He has had the ear of successive ministers and top bureaucrats. You were privileged if you were a member of the FoP (Friend of Parekh) club. After a remarkable innings that lasted 31 years in HDFC, Mr Parekh is now stepping down from an executive role in HDFC. He recently spoke to Moneylife on a variety of issues including his career. One of his thoughts concern what needs to be done for the infrastructure sector so that the pressure of housing in cities like Mumbai can be reduced and the obscene real-estate prices can be brought down.
Here is Mr Parekh in a conversation with Moneylife over housing shortage. These thoughts came out during Moneylife’s conversation with Mr Parekh as part of its Pathbreaker series of interviews. For the full interview, please look out for the next issue of Moneylife.

Moneylife (ML): Over the past few decades, the housing scene has changed, there are many new lenders, yet, many things you have advocated for at least a decade have not happened. For instance, you talked about a housing regulator, sale of flats based on carpet area, clarity on various issues… what are your thoughts on these?
Deepak Parekh (DP):
The frustration or disappointment is that real estate and land is a State subject. The bureaucracy and politicians in the State are not in sync with what the people want. Like in Mumbai, what the common man wants is more affordable housing. If any government ensures more affordable housing or more rental housing, or at least makes an attempt to do it, please believe me they will win votes. But somehow, it is not attracting them. And land is such a costly thing with such vested interests that we have not been able to even scratch the surface. A friend of mine approached me a few days ago saying that she has been offered Rs1 lakh a sq foot for her apartment at Breach Candy. Should she take it? It is a 35-year old building with a garden and a swimming pool. I said please do. What are we talking about? At Rs1 lakh a sq foot it is out of the reach of everyone. Even the rich people can't afford these rates.

ML: What are the priorities in urban infrastructure?
I would say that a road or a bridge that connects Mumbai to the mainland (the Sewri- Nhava Sheva link) is far more important than any other. But they make the tender document so difficult and one-sided that nobody bids for it. So you lose years. And this project has been on the drawing board for decades. What do we do? Mumbai does not have enough infrastructure and it is an island.

How can an island grow? An island can grow vertically or you have to reclaim land. But for both, a prerequisite is adequate urban transport, water, sewage and fire-fighting abilities. So unless we do mass urban transport and have new water reservoirs or the other two prerequisites, you can't go high and you can't reclaim. So prices just keep going up. And you don't have an emergency project to link Mumbai to the mainland. That Sewri bridge can really change the city. It will be a 15 to 17 minute bus or car drive and enough land is available there. We took 10 years to build the Worli-Bandra sea link. The Sewri bridge would be 10 times more important than that. We are not doing it.

ML: The scrapping of the Urban Land Ceiling Act has not made things better. Why?
Maharashtra was one of the last States to scrap it. The Act is now scrapped by the Centre and finally also the State. Why was it scrapped here? Because the Centre said that it will not give you any funds under JNNURM (Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission). Only a carrot-and-stick approach worked. Now, when you scrap an old Act, shouldn't you also say that all the pending cases under the Act are dropped? They have not done that. The cases are continuing even though the Act is scrapped. So no surplus land is available today and no surplus land has come into the market after scrapping ULC. Look at the Godrej land in Vikhroli. They want to build affordable housing there, but it is still under litigation. The government should have said, 'we scrap Urban Land Ceiling Act AND all existing cases under the Act will be dropped'. They haven't said that, so the cases are going on—or rather, the hearings keep getting postponed, nothing happens. Show me one plot of land that has come out of ULC.

The problem is, with us, there is no black and white, there is always grey in every law. Whether it is taxation, excise or the ULC Act. In fact, in this CEO Forum that went to the United States with the prime minister, one of the first issues raised was that we want clarity of laws on taxation and foreign investment. Please tell us ‘yes’ or ‘no’, don't say ‘maybe’ and then we run around trying to find out what is allowed and what is not allowed.

ML: There is no move to set up a housing regulator as yet. Is it because real estate is a State subject?
No. Where there is a will, there is a way. It happened with electricity. How did so many States agree to break the transmission, distribution and generation chain? Initially, only one or two States were willing to do the trifurcation, the rest were not. Again, it happened because the Centre said, if you separate the three functions we will give you the funds under APDRP—the Accelerated Power Development and Reforms Programme. When there is something like that, the States comply, because they want cheaper money or they want grants or something. The same model as in electricity—where you have the Central Electricity Authority and then the State regulators—can be adopted for real estate.

Another area is the lack of uniformity over square footage that is charged to the customer. It doesn't happen anywhere else. What you can do is to charge separately for common amenities like a car park, or swimming pool or a club house, but you can't charge it on per square foot as super built-up and ask customers to pay for an area that they don't get.



uday dhavre

5 years ago

its my personnel question and would like to know fm u that.
i hv booked a flat at arrowcity manhattan 2 bhk for rs 1000000/-
i wanted to know its a good idea or a bad

IC Rao

7 years ago

The road infrastructure around Sewri will be ruined if the new Container Terminal is allowed to be set up by Mumbai Port. Mr Deepak Parekh should add his weight to the efforts being put in to stop this project by the Mumbai Dockland Regeneration Forum, Bombay Environment Action Group and others.

Vipin Pujara

7 years ago

If there are citizens to support mass movement on such issues, Sulekhaji should pursuade Deepak Parekh to provide guidance & participation in at least in initial five years.

Stocks snap four-day rally

Sensex sheds 57 points to close at 17,344, while the Nifty falls 17 points to 5,169

Stock prices fell marginally on Wednesday, ending a four-day rise that had lifted them to their highest level in 19 months. The BSE Sensex lost  57 points to close at 17,344 while the NSE Nifty ended at 5,169 points, down 18 points.

The market was volatile as traders rolled over positions in the derivatives segment from the December 2009 series to the January 2010 series ahead of the expiry of the near-month December 2009 contracts tomorrow (31st December).

The government has expressed concern about India’s rising fiscal deficit, which currently stands at 6.8%, and stressed the need for balancing economic growth and the fiscal deficit.

C Rangarajan, chairman of the prime minister’s economic advisory council, on Tuesday forecast the GDP to grow at 7% to 7.5% this fiscal, signaling an improvement in the domestic economic climate.

Shyamala Gopinath, deputy governor of the RBI, said the focus has now shifted to managing recovery and controlling inflation from fostering growth after the meltdown last year.

During the day, Aban Offshore (up 1.44%) informed that Credit Analysis & Research (CARE) has revised the ratings for the preference shares issued by the company.

Fortis Healthcare (down 0.45%) has announced the addition of a 175-bed hospital in Shiwani, Haryana. The hospital will be will be managed by Fortis under an O&M management deal.

Harrisons Malayalam (up 1.24%) has informed that HML Plantation workers in Kerala are on strike since December 28, 2009 on the issue of bonus.

Negotiations with various unions are under way to resolve the issue.

Hindustan Construction Company (down 0 .3%) has been awarded a contract worth Rs 374.66 crore from Indian Strategic Petroleum Reserves Ltd (ISPRL) to construct a strategic crude oil storage cavern at Padur in Karnataka. The scope of the project includes engineering and design, underground excavation, access tunnels, water curtain galleries, main storage cavern, shafts and associated underground civil works including geological mapping.

Cement shares gained on speculation that prices will rise on the back of an increase in infrastructure activity. 

Reliance Infrastructure (up 1.64%) extended yesterday’s gains on reports that its subsidiary, Reliance Power Transmission, has bagged two transmission projects worth Rs4,100 crore. 

European markets were trading marginally higher, reversing their early fall, led by bank shares. Key benchmark indices in the UK, Germany and France were up by between 0.02% and 0.07% Asian markets ended higher after rebounding from early losses. Key benchmark indices in South Korea, Singapore, China, Hong Kong and Taiwan were up by between 0.06% and 1.58%. However, the Japanese Nikkei 225 index fell 0.86%.


Maharashtra extends deadline for verifying ration cards

Phase I of the verification drive will end on January 31. Ration cards of high-income consumers will be verified in the second phase.

The Maharashtra government has extended the deadline for ration card verification to 31 January 2010. However, ration cards issued to high-income consumers have been exempted from the ongoing survey, said Anil Deshmukh, minister for food, civil supplies and consumer protection.

“The white cards (issued to high-income consumers) have been left out from the first phase of verification and will be taken up in the second phase,” said Mr Deshmukh. Stating the reason for not including the white ration cards in the first phase, he said, “There is a lot of processing load and hence the yellow and orange ration cards are being covered in the first phase.”

The government issues three different cards to consumers. The yellow-coloured ration cards are issued to persons in the ‘below poverty line’ category, while the orange-coloured cards are issued to people in the ‘above poverty line’ category. The white-coloured ration cards are issued to people in the high-income group with an annual income of above Rs1 lakh and who also own a four-wheeler and more than four hectares of land.

Around four years back, a similar exercise was undertaken by the state government. The minister, however, categorically said that the earlier exercise was meant for the computerisation of ration cards and should not be confused with the ongoing verification drive.

On being questioned why the computerisation drive was abandoned half way, the minister said, it would be re-started “very shortly”.

“Very shortly means we will first float the tender, call the concerned party and then the concerned party will conduct the process,” he clarified.

The verification drive for ration cards was started on 1 December 2009. However, the process was marred by a number of glitches, including citizens not being given receipts after filing application forms for the verification. On this, the minister said, “Such people will be given their receipts.”

This verification drive is now being publicised through advertisements in the newspapers, which wasn’t the case when it was started on 1st December.

Speaking about the main reason for not advertising on a large scale, Mr Deshmukh said, “Earlier, the local ration shops were a little reluctant due to the expected load the process would create. Now that we have decided that the white cards will be verified in the second phase, the load has been reduced. In Mumbai and Thane alone, the load of 6.5 lakh (white) cards has been reduced.”



Sanjay Shinde

3 years ago

we have white card but after my fathers death our annual income also decrease below 1 lakh. and because of white card we cannot get any thing from ration shop.
How we can change the colored of card from white to kesari. so what should I do please advise


6 years ago

I am a govt employee and I applied ration card in 2007 and I got orange colored card by mistaken(they gave white card but inside they wrote Kesar colour) that i didnt see. and i never take any benefits from the card, but i want to change my card from orange to white. but now they said form are not available. so what should I do


6 years ago

In Mumbai Many person are obtaining and misusing yellow card for avoiding court fees.
Where to make the complains.


6 years ago

get details


7 years ago

where would i get this form for verifying ration card


7 years ago

This is applicable only for Maharashtra so people from other states should not worry. For forms, pls check
Keep in mind that these forms are only for people residing in Mumbai/Thane, as per the website. Other residents from Maharashtra should contact nearest Tehsil Office. check this for more details..

Rakesh tripathi

7 years ago

From where would I get this form for verifying Ration card. Is it available online service.Pl call 8080419966.


7 years ago

hey, how would i know if the verification for white card holders has started, or when is the first phase getting over???.any idea?


7 years ago

You will get the forms at your local rationing shop.


7 years ago

From where would i get this form for verifying ration card

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)