SEBI suspends Bubna Stock Broking's certificate for three months

Bubna Stock Broking, now known as Sunbright Stock Broking, traded in 27.46 lakh shares and had contributed in a significant way in raising share price of GR Industries during January 2004 to 28 February 2005, SEBI said

Market regulator Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has suspended certificate of registration of Bubna Stock Broking Services Ltd (now known as Sunbright Stock Broking Ltd) for three months.


SEBI said its investigation in the scrip of GR Industries and Finance Ltd during 1 January 2004 to 28 February 2005 revealed that four stock brokers, Shyamlal Sultania, Ashok Kumar Kayan, M Bhiwaniwala & Co and Bubna Stock Broking had traded substantially in the shares of the company. Their cumulative trades accounted for 83.30% of the total traded volumes in the scrip at Calcutta Stock Exchange (CSE) during the investigation period.


Bubna Stock Broking traded in 27.46 lakh shares of the company and had contributed in a significant way in raising share price of GR Industries, during the period under investigation, SEBI said.


Rajeev Kumar Agarwal, whole time member of SEBI, in his order said, "I have considered the submission made by the noticee (Bubna Stock Broking) with regard to past actions taken against it. The enforcement action against the noticee in the earlier cases also indicates that the noticee has committed repeated default. I note that the prohibited activities and types of contraventions as found by the designated authority in this matter definitely have potential to disturb the market integrity and disturb the fair, equitable and efficient functioning of securities market. ...considering the facts and circumstances of this case and taking into account the interests of the investors, suspension of certificate of registration of the noticee for three months will be commensurate with the contraventions found in this matter."


SBI Dual Advantage Fund will disappoint. Stay away

Hybrid schemes in the past have delivered an inconsistent performance and offer no advantage for investors. Being closed-ended makes it worse

SBI Mutual Fund plans to launch a series of close ended hybrid schemes with tenures ranging from one year to five years. The exact duration of each series under the scheme shall be decided at the time of launch of the respective series. The scheme—SBI Dual Advantage Fund Series–(XX)—would invest over 65% in debt and money market instruments and the remaining part of the portfolio would be invested in units of equity oriented mutual funds and gold exchange traded schemes. Despite the high risk associated with the metal, many fund houses include gold as an asset class in such hybrid schemes.

In this scheme, the allocation to gold can go up to a maximum of 35% of the portfolio. The performance of the scheme would be dependent on the market-timing skills of the fund manager to actively move in and out of equities, bonds and gold. Predicting the movement of gold and interest rates are challenging tasks, even for the best of professionals. This will mean that the fund will most likely do a poor job of moving in and out of gold and debt products. That apart, how will an investor decide how much to put into such schemes when he already has money invested in equities, bank fixed deposits and gold separately?

In an article published a few months back (Read: Hybrid Gold Schemes: No Golden Touch), we analysed the performance of hybrid schemes investing in gold. Performance of these schemes has not been great over the past one year. Inflation has gone up by over 9% over the past year, but gold, which has always been considered a hedge against inflation, has declined in value. The recent sharp correction in the price of gold has not only come as a shock to many investors, it has also questioned many beliefs surrounding the asset. Out of the 24-odd schemes, as many as six schemes had an allocation of more than 25% to gold. All the six schemes have delivered a negative return over the past six-month period and were the worst performers among all the schemes. Just seven schemes have a track record of more than three years. But although gold has risen sharply compared to equity indices in this period, the returns of these schemes have ranged between 6% and 7%.

Similar schemes from SBI Mutual Fund have put up a mixed performance over the past one-year, three-year and five-year periods. Such inconsistent performance is one of the reasons hybrid schemes serve no additional value to investors. Below is the performance of the schemes:

Rajeev Radhakrishnan is the designated fund manager for the debt part of the portfolio. He has a total experience of 10 years in funds management with around 8 years in Fixed Income funds management and dealing. Richard D’souza, will be managing the equity portion of the portfolio. He has over 19 years of work experience in equities as a portfolio manager.


Other details of the scheme

Benchmark: Crisil MIP Blended Fund Index

Minimum Amount for Application in the NFO: Rs. 5,000/- and in multiples of Re. 1/- thereafter

Maximum total expense ratio (TER) permissible under Regulation 52(6)(c)(i) and (6)(a): Upto 2.25%

Additional expenses under regulation 52(6A)(c): Upto 0.20%

Additional expenses for gross new inflows from specified cities: Upto 0.30%

Exit load: NA as close-ended scheme


Vijay Kelkar recommended Padma Shri for Arun Firodia, a wilful bank defaulter

Arun Firodia, founder and chairman of the Kinetic Group of companies is declared as wilful defaulter by several banks and yet Vijay Kelkar recommended his name for Padma Shri, the fourth highest civilian award in India

Following directions from the Central Information Commission (CIC), the ministry of home affairs (MHA) has revealed that Vijay Kelkar, a key-functionary attached with the union finance ministry and himself an awardee of Padma Vibhushan, had recommended name of Arun Firodia, founder and chairman of the Kinetic Group of companies for Padma Shri. Earlier in January 2012, Mr Firodia was awarded Padma Shri from the trade and industry category.


According to a reply received by Subhash Chandra Agrawal under the Right to Information (RTI) Act what is more shocking various intelligence authorities including those attached with ministry of economic affairs also cleared Mr Firodia's name without any proper check. Several news-reports and website of Credit Information Bureau (India) Ltd (CIBIL) have mentioned Mr Firodia and his daughter, Sulajja Firodia Motwani as being wilful bank-defaulters.


See the reply Mr Agarwal received under the RTI Act…

Padma Shri (also Padmashree) is the fourth highest civilian award in India and is awarded in recognition of their distinguished contribution in various spheres of activity including the arts, education, industry, literature, science, sports, medicine, social service and public affairs. The selection criteria for the Padma awards, however, has been heavily criticised as many highly deserving people have been left out in order to favour certain individuals.


As Moneylife reported, despite all checks and balances, neither the committee nor agencies and regulators like Intelligence Bureau (IB), Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT), Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI), Central Excise Intelligence (CEI), Research and Analysis Wing (RAW) and Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) could find out Mr Firodia’s bank defaults.


Several banks have declared Mr Firodia a “wilful defaulter” continuously between 31 March 2005 and 31 March 2012 and yet his name was cleared. In a report available on the website of CIBIL, as of 31 March 2012, Mr Firodia's name has been shown associated with Kinetic Finance, Athena Financial Services, along with his daughter Sulajja Firodia Motwani. According to CIBIL data, as of 31st Match, Athena Financial Services has an outstanding of Rs54.60 crore, while Kinetic Finance owes Rs2.76 crore to debtors, mostly banks.


Demanding an enquiry in the clearance given by intelligence agencies and authorities to Mr Firodia for the Padma Shri award, Mr Agarwal said, "Exemplary stringent-most action should be taken against the irresponsible officers in these agencies having cleared Arun Firodia’s name for Padma Shri to prevent such carelessness by Intelligence Authorities in clearing names of Padma awardees in future. To save dignity of Padma awards, it should be immediately taken back from Arun Firodia. Surprisingly, the father-daughter duo have been turn-by-turn members of the governing-body of Council of Scientific & Industrial Research (CSIR), a union government-enterprise. Wilful bank-defaulters must not be allowed to hold posts in government-bodies."


We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)