SEBI cracks whip on two 'advisors' who gave intra-day tips via SMS

SEBI debarred two ‘unregistered experts’ after it found the duo offering intraday tips, stock advisory services to investors through SMS and promising daily earnings between Rs5,000 to Rs75,000

Market regulator Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) after noticing that certain entities were offering intraday tips and stock advisory services to through SMS, has debarred two persons from dealing in the markets.


SEBI said, it debarred Imtiyaz Hanif Khanda and Vali Mamad Habib Ghaniwala from providing unauthorised investment advisory and portfolio management services (PMS) via SMS. Both have also been banned from buying, selling or dealing in the securities market.


Investors were promised daily earnings of between Rs5,000 and Rs75,000 through their intraday tips by the duo. SEBI said both Khanda and Ghaniwala operated through proprietary concerns Right Trade, Sai Traders, Bull Trader and Laxmi Traders for providing investment advice without a SEBI registration.


SEBI said they were found making misrepresentations using unrealistic claims, false statements such as having office in various countries, foreign institutional investor (FII)-based calls and jackpot calls.


SEBI found that the website, had claimed that it provided PMS and investment advisory services in equity and commodity segments in several countries.


The PMS was designed to grow capital with the help of a fund manager using fundamental analysis and their experience.


Charges and returns were dependent on the investment amount.


The duo provided FII-based calls in equity futures and options, which included intra-day calls, positional calls and jackpot calls in Nifty and the Bank Nifty at $300 per month.


A pay per call scheme was also available on a 30% profit sharing basis, said SEBI.


SEBI found that the duo received money from investors using four bank accounts maintained with ICICI Bank, Rander Branch at Surat in Gujarat. Most of the transactions were cash deposits from various parts of the country and cash was withdrawn through ATMs.


SEBI observed from the bank account details that Right Trade and Sai Traders had a common address. Further, Bull Trader and Laxmi Traders also had a common address.


SEBI found both to have prima-facie solicited enticed and induced investors to deal in securities on the basis of their investment advice and stock tips, and banned both.


Stock exchanges and depositories have been directed to ensure strict enforcement of directions.




11 months ago

Could someone advise of the right procedure to provide intraday trading tips as per SEBI's guideline, both for Equities market & Commodities market.

Over one lakh signatories request PM for public consultations on RTI amendment

An amendment to the RTI Act to exempt political parties from the Act is likely to be considered today in the Parliament. Citizen groups continue to fight against it

Activists of the Delhi based National Campaign for People's Right to Information (NCPRI) have demanded that the Right to Information (RTI)Amendment Bill, instead of being put to vote, should be referred to the Standing Committee or the Select Committee of the Parliament in order to facilitate public consultation.


Reiterating the unprecedented popularity of the RTI Act and earlier attempts to dilute it, the NCPRI letter to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh states, "Any amendment that dilutes the people's right to information would weaken this important avenue of reform, and even undermine the process of realizing constitutional promises. There have been a series of attempts to amend the Act since 2006, which have been nullified by public pressure, and the political will of a part of the establishment and government. It is not often that there is a legislation that has become so popular and has been so resolutely defended by the ordinary citizen.


"You will recall that your government made an assurance in Parliament in 2009 that the RTI Act will not be amended without public consultation. It would be a travesty of this assurance if such an important issue, which has drawn a sharp public outcry, were to be passed without deliberation and consultation in the Parliamentary Standing Committee,'' the letter says.


The letter also mentions Singh's praise in last year's Independence Day speech for the Act. "…most importantly, as you so powerfully stated in your Independence Day address 'through the RTI Act, the common man (sic person) now gets more information than ever before about the work of the government'...The Act brings to light irregularities and corruption and opens the door for improvements."


Aruna Roy, Nikhil Dey and Anjali Bharadwaj of the NCPRI believe that political parties could be having some legitimate concerns that this order could impinge on political activity but it could be solved by informed dialogue and consultation.


Their letter states, "We feel that the order from the Central Information Commission (CIC) could have been used to open the door for improving the political and electoral system and to bring to light the corruption and irregularities that are plaguing it. Over one lakh people from across the country, have signed an online petition urging you to not amend the RTI law, and there are numerous other petitions with the same message addressed to different authorities that are gaining momentum and popularity.''


The Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI) along with Satark Nagrik Sangathan too has put up a petition.  The organizations urge citizens to sign the petition in large numbers as the voting for the Bill is likely to happen today. The link to sign the petition.


In the meanwhile, Maharashtra State Gazetted Officers' Federation has publicly declared that all political parties must come under RTI; if they seek such exemption then the political parties have no moral right to implement it for others.''


In defence of staying out of the RTI Act, political parties in a chorus had stated that information pertaining to their expenditure is available with the Election Commission and hence, they need not come under RTI.


However, Delhi based RTI activist Subhash Agrawal's experience has been otherwise. Agrawal had sought information from six state political parties regarding their land allotment, contributors made by party members to the party fund and legislators involved in corrupt practices. The parties were  Samajwadi Party (SP), All India Trinamool Congress (TMC), Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK), All India Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (AIADMK), Janata Dal United (JD-U) and Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD).


Agrawal says, "Political parties and Union government, while opposing political parties coming under purview of RTI Act, are telling people that information relating to them can be obtained by filing RTI petitions at Election Commission. But even Appellate Authority at Election Commission has expressed its inability to provide any such information under provisions of section 2(f) of RTI Act. Before amending RTI Act to keep political parties out of purview of RTI Act, Union government should ensure that people may get required information concerning political parties from Election Commission and other concerned public-authorities under provisions of section 2(f) of RTI Act.''


Will today be the dark day? Lets wait and watch.


(Vinita Deshmukh is the consulting editor of Moneylife, an RTI activist and convener of the Pune Metro Jagruti Abhiyaan. She is the recipient of prestigious awards like the Statesman Award for Rural Reporting which she won twice in 1998 and 2005 and the Chameli Devi Jain award for outstanding media person for her investigation series on Dow Chemicals. She co-authored the book “To The Last Bullet - The Inspiring Story of A Braveheart - Ashok Kamte” with Vinita Kamte and is the author of “The Mighty Fall”.)



Dayananda Kamath k

3 years ago

start a post card campaign to president of india demanding amendment that political party and public authority to be liable to come under right to information act. because public authority is achieved by political party. and not exempting political party from public authority.


3 years ago

Will the lame duck Na-awaz Na Sharif Prime Minsiter of India do anything about it?

Vinay Joshi

3 years ago

Hello Ms.Vinita,

Yes, i'm one of the signatories of that 100K+ petitioning the PM.

If you remember the twin judgements of the apex court tainted MP's/MLa's] & CIC on RTI.

RTI - CIC, no appeal preferred as the political parties fear the wrath of the SC! So via media - BEST to amend - WHERE birds of a feather flock together!? Together the legislature prevails.

IN THIS SCENARIO CAVEAT TO BE FILLED ASAP SO AS TO RESTRICT THE LEGISLATURE in taking any action as the matter will be subjudice. CIC not aggrieved, hence 3rd party seeking to uphold the verdict.

The purpose of society at large should not be only to defeat this RTI.

Other serious aspects should be put also in public domain for signature campaign.

Aug,22 the cabinet will take up a proposal re. convicted netas, SC judgement.


Today coz of 3rd & 4th estate we are somewhat better off & CRUSADERS like you or Sucheta in financial highlights.

[further - what a fallacy - I&B proposing to "LICENSE" Journalists!!??] Emergency thro' back door! IG had failed to take over IE! rather stop it?]

The Cabinet proposal "ONLY" envisages to "ONLY SUSPEND" his vote.
Will it not entail amendment to sec 8[4] Rep.of Peoples act as struck down by SC?

What misuse argued by political parties? WHEN YOU BLATANTLY MISUSE 356? As per your need!


Further tho' the proposal of Judicial Appointment Commission to change the collegium system IS AT nascent stage to be considered by the Cabinet, Aug,22, VEHEMENTLY SHOULD BE OPPOSED! The Govt. will have more say in appointing its appointees!

So lets get started with sign campaign on all counts.


Rescuing rupee: How NRIs can play a positive role

Here are some thoughts on what the Indian government can do to induce NRIs further to remit and invest more in their home country

So we have one more day when the Indian rupee was against the wall and had to succumb to the level of 64 against the US dollar. The bears apparently took a breather and did not pursue the kill. Maybe, they are planning for one on Friday for an outright onslaught.


The estimate of non-resident Indians (NRIs) - all categories - has widely varied from 30 to 40 million now. For the purpose of this article, let us take it at the lower rate of 30 million residing abroad in various categories.  The largest concentration is in the Middle East, estimated at 20 million plus.  The second lot, said to be in the Far East (mostly in Malaysia, Singapore, Indonesia) are about seven and 10 million; US has three million, UK at two million and rest of the world five million.  On second thoughts, it should really be more than 30 million because we left out the whole of Africa, Latin America, China, Europe, Eastern block and Australia, New Zealand, as these should account for a few million more.


Anyway, the point at stake is that except for the Middle East where permanent residency has too many conditions to comply, other areas offer wide scope and opportunities for permanent stay leading to citizenship also.


By categorizing all these people as NRIs, we clear the slate and take it for granted that all these people have reasons to remit part of their earnings back to India on a regular basis.


And how do they remit?  A large percentage of them, say about 70%, remit the funds back to India through normal banking channels, thanks to the setting up of branches of Indian banks in most of the countries where there is a growing Indian population.  The balance may be said to be using non-banking channels, such as the ‘hawala’ route. This is debateable as only guestimates can be made in the dark and no reliable information is available, unless we have some information from the government agencies.


The purpose of remittance covers, generally, the following activities:


a) To meet the cost of maintenance expense of the family left behind by the NRI who has left (say) on a job overseas.  Initial remittances cover his/ her travel costs, visa charges, agent fees and other money borrowed for the purpose of travel. In addition, this expense may cover several months of earnings by the individual concerned.


b) Subsequent remittances may be to truly meet family expenses, on a regular basis, to cover cost of education of children, purchase of essential household items and medical expenses. It must be remembered that getting the family members to join has too many hurdles in the Middle East and similar immigration formalities in other countries too.


c) Once settled (2/3 years from departure date) the NRI may return to meet the family and then plan repairs to the family home (if any) and or plan a purchase of land, flat so as to ‘acquire’ a personal property.


d) It is by this time, NRI gains the knowledge to ‘save’ and ‘invest’ in a little more systematic way as the previous year’s earnings were mostly directed to settle loans and other obligations created as a prelude to getting the job abroad.


e) The educated class of NRIs and some others become enlightened to open non-resident external (NRE) rupee accounts have foreign currency deposits (FCNRs) and also take the much needed insurance cover for the family.


f) Those NRIs who manage to get into western countries, such as USA, UK, Europe and eastern group like Singapore, Malaysia and Australia consider themselves as lucky because the immigration policies open up the prospects for permanent settlement, more often than not leading to citizenship.


g) With the government of India relaxing the rules and making dual citizenship procedure reasonably easy, it makes life a lot more easier for NRIs to target the countries of their choice locations.


The remittance from NRIs is substantial and is said to exceed $20 billion every year. Most of them, particularly those settled in the US and UK are very well to do, and have huge business interests abroad running into billions of dollars. These people of Indian origin, holding the nationality of the adopted countries have also returned to India to invest and the government offers them a wide range of benefits and special consideration to welcome their investments into the country.


Now, what can the government do to induce them further to remit more and invest more in the country?  Here are some thoughts for the government to seriously consider…


a) Offer Indian Sovereign NRI Bonds, valid for 5 years, at a flat rate of say 9%, payable in rupees, freely transferable at maturity; this may be extendable, by the beneficiary, for two more terms at an additional bonus of 1% for the entire duration


b) At the time of maturity, if the account holder (NRI) decides to accept the Rupee in non-convertible account, give an additional 1% to 3% interest, permitting the use of the total amount in specified areas of investment, such as setting up production, infrastructure facilities, educational institutions and other areas that the government may nominate at that time


c) The interest earned on these bonds can be reinvested in treasury bonds for a minimum of three year period, after which, the whole amount can be repatriated and not subject to any tax


d) The face value of these Bonds will be in multiples of $1,000 or £1,000 and freely transferable to members of the same family - resident or non-resident - but need to be pre-identified at the time of initial purchase


e) The government may also relax the rules pertaining to investment by NRIs holding dual citizenship in areas of agriculture i.e. purchasing, owning farmland and actually involved in farm production, against the current policy that prevents purchase


Instead of procrastinating the issue of Sovereign Bonds, the Indian government must go ahead and bring this out immediately, preferably well in time before Diwali so that NRIs can take the opportunity to subscribe.  In fact, this can be a regular annual feature to ensure that additional funds come into the country. 


(AK Ramdas has worked with the Engineering Export Promotion Council under the Ministry of Commerce. He was also associated with various committees of the Council. His international career took him to places like Beirut, Kuwait and Dubai at a time when these were small trading outposts; and later to the US.)



Shadi Katyal

3 years ago

The GOI has never liked NRI and comes out when in trouble? Shy should an NRI who is not even welcomed but treated shabbily on arrival to visit parents and family should;d help?
India could have learn long ago how China used her ex patriots who gave the seed money to start industry but we paid taxes in early days as the money sent to parents was treated as gift.
Why are there still restrictions on investments in any industry?
Why do NRI has to bribe babus?
India has a long way go go to learn how to welcome and show some respect to NRI and not play the game being played for past 6 decades.
There is no security that your investments will not be taxed retroactively like done in Vidofone case.

Vinay Joshi

3 years ago

Dear Mr.A.K Ramdas,

You have not answered me in your first post! Possibly no answers!

FYI, RBI has set a cap on FCNR[B] to LIBOR/SWAP+ 400bps. Update yourself.

NRI's are well versed than what is thought, i'm not talking of labourers.

It is evident you are not following the macroeconomic policies of the Govt.

Why are you talking on bourses aspects in this post of yours w/o answering my earlier. You can't answer! as simple.

In your own quest, i'm asking you what should S.Africa, Brazil, Indonesia, even S.Korea do to strengthen their respective currencies? Leaving Russia aside.

As per my last post to you, YOU have not, can't, answer volatility in world currencies.

Propping up the FX rate can't last for ever.

When investors pulling out from emerging markets, so much from other countries also due to their own concerns & Fed looming large, nothing can be stated.

There can be 'n' no. of theories which may surface, fact remains strong reserves & economy can only sustain the currency turmoil. WHY PRC not affected? In spite of slowdown!?

FYI, Jim O'Neil, the person who coined the word 'BRIC', has stated that India will teach the pessimists a lesson. [this i've said in this forum many times.]


nagesh kini

3 years ago

As one practicing FERA/FEMA for long advising NRIs, i tend to agree with Mr. Ramdas whose suggestions are more sensible for the MOF babus or Mint Road mandarins.
With another NRI Raghuram Rajan now set to occupy the hot seat of the RBI governor it is fondly hoped that conditions will improve and such suggestions will be considered.
I totally disagree with the comments made on the state of Indian economy and politicians.
Those in the USA have not long ago witnessed the failures of Banks big and small across the US continent following the sub-prime crisis and how the US govt. had to bail them out.
Fortunately today the Indian banking system is quite robust with an underlying sovereign guarantee.
The conditions in the Middle East and the Western world are no longer as lucrative - many Indians have come to realize that east or west, home is best.The term NRI bears a new nomenclature of NOW RETURNING Indians, from the once snooty NOT REQUIRED/RELIABLE Indian that they earlier flaunted!

sanjeev naik

3 years ago

No way, we dont want to play any role in this mess. until last 3 month i was regularly sending money to India but now seeing that the money in India is depreciated, i would rather keep it with me in dollor terms. or may sell equivalent dollars in futures to hedge the risk.. the Sins of these politicians will soon take rupee to 100 also which means further losses for me.. and in return what we get abroad is some arrogant IFS babus mistreatment in the Indian embassies and consulates and begging(and sometimes blackmailing)customs officers upon arrival.. why to believe the fake and a story which takes place only when there are accidents...



In Reply to sanjeev naik 3 years ago

Agreed - this whole ethnic appeal to fellow Indians is just crony capitalism taken to greater lengths. Hoping to milk or sucker Indians overseas into bailing out the corrupt kleptocracy is disgusting. And then these same crooks take out full-page ads in Indian newspapers: "Dear NRIs, stop meddling in our country" - it really makes me want to spit on the ruling class and their cronies.

Vinayak Bhimarao Mudholkar

3 years ago

Enjoy NRI at the cost of resident Indians !!!....Our entire export has been bailed out by depriciting rupee. Why can't we aim at quality oriented export instead of depending upon labour arbitrage?....Why can't we have Indian Google, Microsoft, Apple or likes of them in many fields?

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)