RTI Judgement Series
RTI Judgement Series: The games babus play with ration cards

Food & Supplies Department at the GNCTD prepared a ration card in someone else's name and despite a direct order from the FAA it asked the applicant to file another application for a duplicate ration card. This is the 103rd in a series of important judgements given by former Central Information Commissioner Shailesh Gandhi that can be used or quoted in an RTI application

The Central Information Commission (CIC), while allowing an appeal, directed the Public Information Officer (PIO) of the Food & Supplies Department (FSD) at the Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi (GNCTD) to provide a ration card to the applicant, else file a police complaint for the loss and send a compliance report.


While giving this judgement on 24 June 2009, Shailesh Gandhi, the then Central Information Commissioner said, “This incident shows the extremely callous attitude of the department that is meant to offer public service. This reinforces the need for the department to comply with Section 4 of the Right to Information (RTI) Act and put up details of those who apply for ration cards/BPL cards, date on which cards are given to them and reasons for rejections, if any, on the website.”


New Delhi resident Neema Gupta, on 1 May 2008 sought information regarding issue of a ration card to her, from the PIO of Food & Supplies Department, at GNCTD. Here is the information she sought under the RTI Act and the reply given by the PIO...


1. Why the delay for issue of a new ration card in the name of Neema Gupta for more than three years?

PIO's reply: Ration card bearing number No. 09020072 was prepared in the name of Bimla Devi.


2. Who is responsible for this delay?     

PIO's reply: There has not been any delay in preparation of the ration card.


3. Who are the officers responsible for this delay and harassment?  

PIO's reply” In view of I&II, the above question does not arise.


4. What action was taken in this matter?       

PIO's reply: Since you did not turn up to collect the ration card, the same was sent to the headquarter.


Not satisfied with the reply, the applicant filed her first appeal. In his order, on 22 July 2008 the First Appellate Authority (FAA) said, “The ration card of the appellant was prepared by the PIO as the family details exist in the database of the department but the same was not delivered to the appellant and the appellant is running here and there to obtain her ration card. I, therefore, directed the PIO i.e. Asstt. Commissioner (Sought-West) to complete necessary formalities and prepare the ration card to the appellant and deliver it to her within a period of 10 days from today.”


However, after failing to receive her ration card, Neema Gupta, the applicant, then approached the CIC with her second appeal.


During the hearing before Mr Gandhi, the then CIC, the PIO accepted that he had not complied with the order of FAA in terms of giving the ration card to the appellant. He claimed that he sent a letter no127 dated 31 July 2008 by FSO-Circle (9) asking her (Gupta) to apply for a duplicate ration card.


The Commission pointed out to the respondent that the information provided to the appellant in reply to the original RTI Application on 21 May 2008 stated that ration card bearing no09020072 was prepared in the name of Bimla Devi. The FAA, DP Dwivedi, additional commissioner (SW) had asked for the card to be supplied in 10 days by his order of 22 July 2008.


The Commission asked the PIO why a duplicate card was sought to be made when the original card was not delivered.


The PIO said, “...in compliance of FAA's order the then FSO-Circle(9) Amodh Bhartwal—as informed by him on phone—tried to find out the card form the record of the circle office but the ration card was not traceable. Hence we personally sent a copy of application for a duplicate ration card. The then FSO and assistant commissioner tried their best and left no stone unturned to trace the ration card.”


Gupta told the Commission that she has been pursuing this ration card since 2006 but did not get any reply form the department. Her father-in-law had gone to the department four to five times and he was told that the ration card will be available if he paid a bribe, this was in 2006. The FAA had told her that the ration card was active and therefore she feels that the ration card is probably being misused.


Mr Gandhi then asked the PIO whether ration could not have been stolen or misused. The PIO stated that he would like to search for the ration card again.


The Commission then directed the PIO to deliver the ration card personally to Bimla Devi before 10 July 2009. “The PIO will either give the ration card to Ms Bimla Devi before 10 July 2009 or file a police complaint for loss of the ration card and ensure that another card issued to Bimla Devi and Neema Gupta. The PIO will send a compliance report with photocopies of the cards and police complaints applicable to the Commission before 20 July 2009,” the CIC said in its order while allowing the appeal.




Decision No. CIC/SG/C/2009/900066/3820


Appeal No. CIC/SG/C/2009/900066



Complainant                                   : Neema Gupta

                                                                New Delhi.


Respondent                                      : GS Dhodi

                                                            PIO & Asstt. Commissioner (South-West)

                                                            Govt. of N.C.T. of Delhi

                                                            Food & Supplies Department,

                                                            Office of the Asstt. Commissioner (SW)

                                                            C-22/23,Udyog Sadan,

                                                           Qutub Institutional Area in  Delhi.




3 years ago

Discussion > Others > Rti act: spreading hatred against applicant


S&P upgrades RIL to ‘BBB+’ on greater clarity on expansion

With this upgrade, RIL is now rated higher than some of its global emerging market peers demonstrating the strength and competitive position of Reliance in the refining and petrochemicals sector

Ratings agency Standard & Poor's (S&P) has raised the long-term corporate credit rating on Reliance Industries (RIL) to ‘BBB+’ from ‘BBB’, one of the highest ratings by the agency for an Indian corporate and the highest rating by S&P for an Indian oil & gas company. S&P, howeve, has kept the outlook negative on RIL reflecting the outlook on the soverign credit rating of India.


"We upgraded Reliance because we believe the company's strategy to grow organically will strengthen its competitive position and support its profitability," said Standard & Poor's credit analyst Andrew Wong. "Reliance's articulation of its growth strategy removes the uncertainty regarding the company's use of its high cash balance."


"The new rating which is two notches above the S&P rating for the Indian sovereign is testament to RIL’s strong financial and business profile. Furthermore, Reliance is the only Asian company in the oil & gas sector to be rated two notches above the sovereign by S&P. With this upgrade, RIL is now rated higher than some of its global emerging market peers demonstrating the strength and competitive position of Reliance in the refining and petrochemicals sector," the Mukesh Ambani-led company said in a release.


The ratings agency said, "We now have greater clarity on Reliance's expansion strategy. The company intends to spend more than $30 billion on growth over the next three years, of which at least 75% will be toward its core businesses of refining, petrochemical, and exploration and production (E&P). The company's capital spending in E&P will enable it to grow its shale gas business and reverse the fall in production in KG D6 gas field."


The rating also underpins RIL’s position as a leading large scale, integrated and efficient oil refining and petrochemicals company.


V Srikanth, joint CFO of Reliance Industries, commented, “The upgrade recognizes the value of our focused capital expenditure plan in strengthening our profitability and competitiveness. It reflects the confidence of the rating agency on our execution skills, discipline and financial prudence. I am also delighted that this rating brings us at par with many companies in our international peer group.”


Pulse Beat

Medical developments from around the world

Foods that Promote Good Sleep

Almonds and walnuts contain a lot of tryptophan, magnesium, and melatonin—a powerful trio that promotes sleep. Oatmeal is generally considered a breakfast fare, but studies have shown that there are actually several benefits from eating oatmeal before going to bed. Cherries are another great food before bedtime. They contain melatonin, the sleep inducer in nature. Bananas are another good source of so many sleep-inducing ingredients. Milk is also good; but, as such, milk is not good for health, although it promotes sleep because of its antigenic properties.

Danger from Lipsticks

Lipsticks are found to contain large amounts of aluminium, cadmium and lead! In addition, they also contain some pro-oestrogens that might provoke breast growth which might lead to breast cancer!

New Findings on Papaya

University of Karachi researchers, Mariam Naseem and her colleagues, have found many new health benefits of the papaya fruit and its seeds. They have shown that papaya fruit is very good for liver and kidneys. In addition, the seeds, taken regularly, are supposed to keep the liver in good health.

Anger and Heart Attacks

According to research published online in The American Journal of Cardiology, outbursts of anger may be linked to an increased risk of heart attack in the following few hours. Researchers looked at data on nearly 3,900 patients who had participated in an earlier study. The investigators found that the more intense the outburst, the higher the risk.

Mushrooms for Health

The maitake, also known in English-speaking countries as the ‘hen-of-the-woods’, is a large, earthy-brown mushroom that grows at the base of trees, especially oaks. It is native to north-eastern Japan (and is a major culinary ingredient) and certain parts of North America. It is useful for health and prevents cancer, heart disease and even obesity. However, further studies are needed before it can be recommended.

Fitness in Middle Age May Reduce Risk of Later Heart Failure

According to American Heart Association’s Quality of Care and Outcomes Research Scientific Sessions 2013, fitness in middle age lowers risks of heart failure, based on a study of 9,050 men and women. “People who weren’t fit at the start of the study were at higher risk for heart failure after age 65,” said Ambarish Pandey, lead author and an internal medicine resident at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center in Dallas. “However, those who improved their fitness reduced their heart failure risk, compared to those who continued to have a low fitness level eight years later.”

Angelina Jolie’s Senseless Preventive Mastectomy

The rich and the famous get media attention for every small event. Angelina Jolie’s preventive mastectomy is the best pointer to American medical business. In the first place, the role of genes in transmitting disease is almost negligible as the human genes in our meta-genome are not even 0.00001%. Whereas there are 25,000 human genes, there are three trillions of germ genes. In addition, cancers take decades to show up in adults. Everyday, we get rogue cells that might grow into cancer in a conducive environment. If Angelina Jolie had been living and sharing her mother’s environment the process might have already started and if the breasts are removed, it might have already penetrated another organ.

The surgeons must be laughing their way to their bank.


We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)