RTI Judgement Series
RTI Judgement Series: PIO penalised for not providing information about ration card

The PIO was fined for not providing proper information to the applicant within stipulated time about the status of her ration card. This is the ninth in a series of important judgements given by Shailesh Gandhi, former CIC that can be used or quoted in an RTI application

The Public Information Officer (PIO), in the Food supplies and Consumer Affairs department in the Government of NCT of Delhi, was fined for not providing proper information to the applicant within the stipulated time. While giving this important judgement, Shailesh Gandhi, former Central Information Commissioner said the public authority suo moto must provide details of ration card applications on its website and submit a compliance report to the Commission.      


“The PIO will give the information to the appellant before 10 July 2009 about the status of her application giving names and designations of the officers who have dealt with the BPL card application and where the application is presently. The Commission awards a total compensation of Rs2,500 to the appellant for loss of entitlement and to compensate for the effort and the trauma suffered in pursuing this matter,” the Central Information Commission (CIC) said in its order dated 2 July 2009.


Delhi-based Nagina Devi, on 6 March 2009 sought information about her ration card from the PIO. She had applied for a ration card in 2006 and in spite of repeatedly being shunted to various places did not get any ration card.


According to the PIO, the Delhi Government accepted applications for BPL cards during February-March 2009. The PIO said that the application was received and sent to a Vigilance Committee headed by Member of Legislative Assembly (MLA) of the area. He also admitted that these cards are supposed to be given in 45 days but the time at the Vigilance Committee headed by MLAs takes indefinite time.


The Commission said, “The appellant has not been given any appropriate reply indicating what is happening to her ration card application. The approximate loss to her per month of free foodgrain and kerosene is about Rs500 per month. The loss of free foodgrain due to her is already three months which she has suffered is therefore Rs1,500 for three months. The Commission also feels that the loss of time and trauma which she has suffered on account of not getting her due entitlement and pursuing this application and appeal should be compensated with another Rs1,000.”


In his order issued on 2 July 2009, Mr Gandhi asked the PIO to give the information before 10 July 2009 about the status of Nagina Devi's application, giving names and designations of the officer who have dealt with the BPL card application and where the application is presently.


“The list of people for above poverty list (APL) and BPL cards with the dates of application dated on which the cards are given to them and reasons for rejection if any with dates must be provided suo moto by the public authority on its website. The PIO will inform the appropriate officer about this requirement of Section 4 and ensure that this is done before 15 August 2009. A compliance report will be sent to the Commission before 15 August 2009,” the order said.


Mr Gandhi also asked the PIO to ensure that the compensation of Rs2,500 is given to the appellant before 20 July 2009.




Decision No. CIC/SG/A/2009/001213+1214/3969



Appeal No. CIC/SG/A/2009/001213+1214


Appellant                                        : Nagina Devi



Respondent                                      : AK Singh,

                                                            Asstt Commissioner (NW),

                                                            Office of the Assistant Commissioner, N/W Distt,

                                                            Food Supplies & Consumer Affair,

                                                            GNCT of Delhi, CSC, CC Block,

                                                            Shalimar Bagh, Delhi-110 088


BSE Sensex, Nifty struggling to maintain uptrend: Wednesday Closing Report

Traders should sell the rally. A close below 19,300 on the Sensex and 5,870 on the Nifty would signal a downtrend

The Indian market closed lower despite the Index of Industrial Production rising to 8.2% in October. Presently the benchmarks are struggling to maintain the uptrend, however, a close below 19,300 on the Sensex and 5,870 on the Nifty would signal a downtrend. The National Stock Exchange saw a volume of 71.6 crore shares and an advance-decline volume of 626:824.


The market opened with small gains tracking supportive global cues. Investors awaited industrial output data for October, due later in the day, for further direction. Meanwhile, markets in Asia were mostly in the green in morning trade on speculations that the US Federal Reserve would unveil a new round of bond purchases at the end of its two-day meeting later today. Overnight the US markets closed higher even as some policymakers flayed president Obama for delaying the budget talks.


The Nifty opened 19 points higher at 5,918 and the Sensex started the day at 19,433, up 46 points over its previous close. Gains in auto and IT stocks pushed the benchmarks to their day’s highs in initial trade. At the highs the Nifty rose to 5,925 and the Sensex climbed to 19,479.


Profit booking saw the indices pare their initial gains and were range-bound on both sides of their previous closing levels in subsequent trade. A pick up in India’s industrial output for October did not help matters as the market continued its status quo.


Industrial production growth rate bounced back to a 16-month high of 8.2% in October on good performance of the manufacturing, power sector and higher output of capital as well as consumer goods. Factory output, as measured by the Index of Industrial Production (IIP), contracted by 5% in October last year.


A flat opening of the key European indices pushed the benchmarks to their lows in noon trade. The Nifty fell to 5,874 and the Sensex went back to 19,317.


The benchmarks continued to remain in the negative and closed lower for the second day in a row. The Nifty closed 11 points (0.18%) down at 5,888 and the Sensex finished trade at 19,355, a loss of 32 points (0.16%) over its previous close.


The broader indices continued to surpass the Sensex as the BSE Mid-cap index rose 0.06% and the BSE Small-cap index gained 0.24%.


The top sectoral gainers were BSE Consumer Durables (up 0.95%); BSE Auto (up 0.94%); BSE IT (up 0.38%); BSE TECk (up 0.34%) and BSE Oil & Gas (up 0.31%). The main laggards were BSE Capital Goods (down 0.99%); BSE PSU (down 0.81%); BSE Metal (down 0.71%); BSE Power (down 0.65%) and BSE Bankex (down 0.32%).


Nine of the 30 stocks on the Sensex closed in the positive. The chief gainers were Bajaj Auto (up 2.57%); Mahindra & Mahindra (up 2.20%); Hero MotoCorp (up 1.92%); Reliance Industries (up 1.53%) and Sun Pharmaceutical Industries (up 1.35%). The main losers were Hindustan Unilever (down 2.65%); BHEL (down 1.98%); GAIL India (down 1.67%); Jindal Steel (down 1.55%) and ONGC (down 1.44%).         


The top two A Group gainers on the BSE were—Satyam Computer Services (up 6.41%) and Bharat Forge (up 5.08%).

The top two A Group losers on the BSE were—Piramal Enterprises (down 5.68%) and Gitanjali Gems (down4.61%).


The top two B Group gainers on the BSE were—Next Mediaworks (up 20%) and Gokul Refoils (up 20%).

The top two B Group losers on the BSE were—Bio Green Papers (down 11.60%) and RFL International (down 10.22%).


Out of the 50 stocks listed on the Nifty, 17 stocks settled in the positive. The major gainers were M&M (up 2.18%); Bajaj Auto (up 1.96%); Hero MotoCorp (up 1.93%); RIL (up 1.58%) and IDFC (up 1.55%). The key losers were HUL (down 2.96%); BHEL (down 2.34%); Grasim Industries (down 2.22%) and HDFC (down 1.89%).


Markets in Asia settled higher on hopes of a fresh round of monetary stimulus by the US Federal Reserve at the end of its two-day meeting later today. Sentiments were also supported by a rise in Japanese machinery orders for the first time in three months.


The Shanghai Composite rose 0.39%; the Hang Seng climbed 0.80%; the Jakarta Composite gained 0.455; the KLSE Composite advanced 0.50%; the Nikkei 225 gained 0.59%; the Straits Times surged 0.75%; the Seoul Composite climbed 0.55% and the Taiwan Weighted surged 1%.


At the time of writing, two of the three key European indices were trading marginally up and the US stock futures were seen with minor gains.


Back home, foreign institutional investors were net buyers of shares totalling Rs1,309.88 crore on Tuesday whereas domestic institutional investors were net sellers of stocks amounting to Rs1,028.35 crore.


Private sector ship-builder ABG Shipyard today said it has bagged a Rs485 crore order to build a cadet training vessel for the Indian Navy. The vessel will be used to provide basic training to Naval cadets and trainees in activities such as disaster relief, search and rescue operations, the company said in a statement. The stock closed 1.20% higher at Rs375 on the NSE.


State-owned ONGC is set to undertake exploratory drilling work in three offshore oil and gas Blocks in Krishna-Godavari basin soon. Once all formalities are completed, the ONGC consortium will spend about Rs1,700 crore on developing these three blocks. The stock declined 1.44% to close at Rs259.90 on the NSE.


Two and three wheeler major TVS Motor on Wednesday said its market share in motorcycles segment is expected to expand by 2.5% with the launch of new bike in 125 cc segment. The company currently has 7% market share in motorcycles segment. TVS Motors settled 2.33% higher at Rs39.50 on the NSE.


Nomura expects steel industry to pick up

After a lacklustre performance throughout the year, Nomura expects near-term pick up as rupee depreciation makes steel imports dearer which will revive local demand

The steel industry has been in the doldrums for the entire 2012 but Nomura’s Equity Research expects a pick-up in the near-term. Several companies, according to media and broker reports, are sending signals that an uptrend could be imminent as they raise steel prices, indicating demand pick-up. Nomura said, “With rising global prices, and the rupee depreciation, we expect net imports to moderate from current levels. At the same time India would be entering a seasonally strong demand period and hence we expect demand to pick up from current levels.” The company is bullish on Tata Steel and Steel Authority of India (SAIL).

Nevertheless, Nomura expects near-term scenario to be beneficial for companies with expansion plans and value added products. “We believe Tata Steel’s 2.9mpta capacity, which is ramping up production, to be a key beneficiary of India being a net importer—with increased production from Tata Steel in Q4FY13.”

The steel industry is commoditised and value-addition is hard to come by and requires lot of capital expenditure.

Similarly, SAIL, which has been performing below-average, could do well as the company pushes for volumes and price cuts to get rid of its glut. It is surprising to note that India is a net importer of steel despite companies like SAIL having excess inventory. However, Nomura has cited the weak rupee and high global prices as reason for domestic demand to pick-up.

Historically, high fragmentation, economic woes in developed countries meant steel demand had been overall weak with benign sales. But slightly higher demand from China meant steel price didn’t dip and was steady if not sideways. India is a net importer of steel, which means the rupee depreciation would lead to dearer steel imports. This could force companies to buy locally instead, thus inciting demand pick up. Nomura thinks that there is a “mismatch between demand and produced material”

There’s also another factor—iron ore production has plummeted due legal and political problems in Goa. This is the raw material for steel. Limited supply and strong demand would mean an upwards bias in steel prices which would provide fillip to companies like Tata Steel and SAIL. It also added that “high value added products i.e. Tata Steel and JSW Steel have maintained their volumes in the above mentioned scenario (i.e. excess imports and slack in local demand).”

According to the government, India is expected to become the world's second largest producer of crude steel in the next two years on account of capital expansion and investments in new projects.

To read more stock research analysis by Moneylife on basis of Nomura research, click here.


We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)