Red Cross: How we spent Sandy money is a ‘trade secret’

The charity is fighting ProPublica's public records request for information on how it raised and spent money after the super storm

Just how badly does the American Red Cross want to keep secret how it raised and spent over $300 million after Hurricane Sandy?

The charity has hired a fancy law firm to fight a public request we filed with New York state, arguing that information about its Sandy activities is a "trade secret."

The Red Cross' "trade secret" argument has persuaded the state to redact some material, though it's not clear yet how much since the documents haven't yet been released.

As we've reported, the Red Cross releases few details about how it spends money after big disasters. That makes it difficult to figure out whether donor dollars are well spent.

The Red Cross did give some information about Sandy spending to New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman, who had been investigating the charity. But the Red Cross declined our request to disclose the details.

So we filed a public records request for the information the Red Cross provided to the attorney general's office.

That's where the law firm Gibson Dunn comes in.

An attorney from the firm's New York office appealed to the attorney general to block disclosure of some of the Sandy information, citing the state Freedom of Information Law's trade secret exemption.

The documents include "internal and proprietary methodology and procedures for fundraising, confidential information about its internal operations, and confidential financial information," wrote Gabrielle Levin of Gibson Dunn in a letter to the attorney general's office.

If those details were disclosed, "the American Red Cross would suffer competitive harm because its competitors would be able to mimic the American Red Cross's business model for an increased competitive advantage," Levin wrote.

The letter doesn't specify who the Red Cross' "competitors" are.

The Red Cross is a public charity and occupies a unique place responding to disasters alongside the federal government.

Among the sections of the documents the Red Cross wanted redacted was "a two-line title" at the top of a page, one line of which was "American Red Cross."

The attorney general's office denied that redaction, writing that it "can not find disclosure of this two line title will cause the Red Cross any economic injury."

Asked about the effort to have Sandy materials kept secret, Red Cross spokeswoman Anne Marie Borrego told ProPublica: "We sought to keep confidential a small part of the letter [sent to the AG] that provided proprietary information important to maintaining our ability to raise funds and fulfill our mission."

Doug White, a nonprofit expert who directs the fundraising management program at Columbia University, said that it's possible for nonprofits to have trade interests — the logo of a university, for example — but it's not clear what a "trade secret" would be in the case of the Red Cross. He called the lawyer's letter an apparent "delaying tactic."

Ben Smilowitz of the Disaster Accountability Project, a watchdog group, said,

"Invoking a 'trade secret' exemption is not something you would expect from an organization that purports to be 'transparent and accountable.'"

In agreeing to withhold some details, the attorney general's office found that portions of the documents the charity wanted to redact "describe business strategies, internal operational procedures and decisions, and the internal deliberations and decision-making processes that affect fundraising and the allocation of donations."

The attorney general's office also found "that this information is proprietary and constitutes trade secrets, and that its disclosure would cause the Red Cross economic injury and put the Red Cross at an economic disadvantage."

Another section the Red Cross wanted redacted was a paragraph that noted the charity's "willingness to meet with the [Office of the Attorney General.]" The attorney general's office denied that part of the request

Borrego, the Red Cross spokeswoman, declined to say how much the charity is paying Gibson Dunn but said, "we do not use funds restricted to Superstorm Sandy to cover those expenses."

We'll let you know when we get the documents we asked for — at least the parts that aren't trade secrets.

If you have experience with or information about the American Red Cross, including its operations after Sandy, email [email protected]

Related articles: Read our other coverage about how the Red Cross' post-storm spending on Sandy is a black box.




Nagesh Kini

3 years ago

The NPO sector has necessarily to be brought under the Consumer Protection Laws.At present they are not expressly exempted.
But they some how try to wriggle out to deny providing information. In one case even saying that the date on the court fee stamp is time barred!

Unquoted: Premier Capital Services

Stories of Price Manipulation

Premier Capital Services (Rs276)

Premier Capital...

Premium Content
Monthly Digital Access


Already A Subscriber?
Yearly Digital+Print Access


Moneylife Magazine Subscriber or MSSN member?

Yearly Subscriber Login

Enter the mail id that you want to use & click on Go. We will send you a link to your email for verficiation
Sensex, Nifty to remain range-bound: Weekly Market Report

The index is likely to remain in the 7,445-7,650 range for some more time.

The S&P BSE 30-share Sensex closed the week that ended on 27th June at 25,100 (down 6 points or 0.02%), while the NSE’s 50-share Nifty closed at 7,509 (down 3 points or 0.04%) for the week. We had mentioned in our previous week’s report that the Nifty has to hold above 7,470 for it to make efforts to move up.

On Monday, the index hit a low below 7,470, but managed to rise above this crucial mark again. News of the upcoming budget affected market sentiment. Nifty closed at 7,493 (down 18 points or 0.24%). A hike in the rail passenger fare and freight rates increased the worries of a further rise in inflation. The government will raise its import duty on sugar to 40% from 15%, as the government tries to revive business at mills that owe farmers around Rs11,000 crore, food minister Ram Vilas Paswan said on Monday.

As anticipated, on Monday the indices moved higher, breaking four days of negative move on Tuesday. Nifty closed at 7,580 (up 87 points or 1.16%). There are reports that the government may soon finalise a hike in natural gas prices and that the price hike will be lower than what was suggested according to the formula adopted by the previous UPA government, which recommended doubling the price.

Pessimism on the bourses again set in on Wednesday. Nifty closed at 7,569 (down 11 points or 0.14%). Reserve Bank of India on Tuesday allowed banks to engage non-deposit-taking non-banking finance companies as banking correspondents for financial inclusion.
The sentiments on the bourses were further affected after Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs deferred a decision on the revision of natural gas prices by three months. Nifty closed at 7,493 (down 76 points or 1.00%).

Nifty continued moving lower on Friday as well. Nifty closed at 7,509 (up 16 points or 0.21%). Oil prices dropped as militant violence in Iraq has not yet affected oil production from the country.  Power & Coal Minister Piyush Goyal said there were anomalies in the proposed formula which needed to be fixed before revising rates.

For the week, among the other indices on the NSE, the top two performers were Pharma (4%) and Smallcap (3%), while the worst two performers were FMCG (3%) and Energy (1%).

Out of the 27 main sectors tracked by Moneylife, top five and the bottom five sectors for this week were:

ML Top sector


ML Worst sector








Telecom Services




Oil & Gas




Consumer Products




Software & IT Services




We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)