Queries at MONEYLIFE FOUNDATION’S Legal Resource Centre

Justice for Foreign Investors in FD of an Indian company

I am a 61-year-old Malaysian citizen married and living in India. My family and I had invested in fixed deposit of a listed company for one-year period. The maturity date has passed and the company has defaulted in paying back the maturity amount as well as interest.

 

Post-dated cheques issued by the company have bounced due to insufficient funds in the company’s bank account. The company is Gujarat-based and has hotels and other business. I sent several emails to company officials but got no replies. I even tried contacting them on their phone number but no one picks up the phone. I want to know if there is a law to protect foreign senior citizen like me. Where should I make a complaint?

 

LRC’s Reply: There are no separate laws for investors falling in foreigners or senior citizens category. The process of filing complaints is the same for every investor who has bought Indian investment products. Corporate FDs are an unsecured investment and, to that extent, unsafe. You should have known this at the time of your investment.

 

Like other investors facing similar problems, you have to follow a simple process of filing a complaint with the company. Since you have already done so and they have not responded to your queries, you can file a complaint against the company on the website of ministry of corporate affairs (MCA) as well as the Company Law Board (CLB). Once you file the complaint with MCA and CLB, the chances of getting your money increases as MCA and CLB can order Neesa Leisure Limited to pay you.

 

We have provided a detailed process; you just have to follow it with necessary links. Here is what you need to do:

  1. First, you should file a complaint with the investor grievance cell or with the company secretary of the company. Go to the company’s website and check contact details. Email them regarding your issues and complaints and save it as a proof that they did not bother to reply to your complaints.
     

  2. If you do not get a proper response from them by email or on their helpline numbers, escalate the issue. You can do so by filing an online complaint to MCA as mentioned below.
     

  3. On MCA website (http://www. mca.gov.in/MCA21/index.html), click on ‘Important Links’ on the right side of the menu; then click on ‘Lodge Investor Complaints’. It will provide you the investor complaint form (http://www.mca.gov.in/ DCAPortalWeb/dca/EFormDisplay. do?method=getForm&contentId=1 021&taskID=9501 ). Fill in all the necessary details and submit your complaint online.
     

  4. While filling online complaint form on MCA’s website, you need to enter the corporate identity number (CIN) of the company (http://www. mca.gov.in/DCAPortalWeb/dca/ MyMCALogin.do?method=setDefa ultProperty&mode=14 ).
     

  5. You can also file a case against the company with the CLB under Section 58A (9) of Companies Act, 1956, or under Section 45QA of the RBI Act, 1934. You need to fill form no. 4 of company law board regulations and submit it with a demand draft of Rs50 to nearest CLB bench.

Keep reading Moneylife (http://www.moneylife.in /). We published an article on, “How to get your money back from Yash Birla group companies” (http:// www.moneylife.in/article/how-toget-your-money-back-from-yashbirla-group-companies/34593. html ) to guide our readers about getting their corporate FD amounts back from the Yash Birla group of companies. Many got their money back using this process, as the CLB directed the company to pay to its deposit-holders. (http://www. moneylife.in/article/company-lawboard-directs-zenith-birla-ltd-topay-dues-of-its-depositors/36446. html).

User

COMMENTS

Vaibhav Dhoka

2 years ago

I have complained to SFIO and received information that matter is with EOW Gujarat police 8-9 months back there after no response from any of government bodies like ROC Ahmedabad,EOW Guj.police etc.

REPLY

Srikanth Shankar Matrubai

In Reply to Vaibhav Dhoka 1 year ago

Any progress Vaibhav Dhoka bhai???.
Please update

Srikanth Matrubai

3 years ago

The thing with Neesa Leisure is that the Company continues to maintain that it is tiding over a temporary liquidity issue and will bounce back and will pay all the investors their money.
But when???
This month??
This year??
This life????????
No time frame.
Feel that they are just dragging the issue as much as possible.
Felt really sorry.
5 of my clients have put their hard earned money in FDs and not just my clients but even I am feeling the pinch.

laxminarayanbansal

3 years ago

sir,
our complaint this company:neesa leisure" we file to complaint to MCA, but not action this company.reply for MCA again--- श्रीमान जी हमने नीसा लेसर कंपनी के खिलाफ आपसे शिकायत की थी. आपने उस बाबत हमे कंपनी द्वारा दिया गया जबाब भेजा. यह पत्र इस मेल के साथ अटैच है .इस पत्र मे कंपनी ने जबाब दिया है की हम लोग कंपनी लॉ बोर्ड हमे जो भी आदेश देगा हम और हमारे क्लाइंट'स उन आदेशो का पालन करने के लिए बाध्य होंगे.
महोदय दिनांक 29/03/2014 को नीसा लेसर के खिलाफ मुंबई कंपनी लॉ बोर्ड मे सुनवाई हुई थी उसमे कंपनी लॉ बोर्ड के बेंच मेंबर'स ने कंपनी "नीसा लेसर लिमिटेड को 30 दिनो के अंदर मेय इंटरेस्ट के सभी क्लाइंट'स को पैसा वापिस देने को कहा था और कंपनी को आगे टाइम देने से मना कर दिया था. अगर 30 दिनो के अंदर कंपनी पैसा वापिस नही करती है तो उनके सभी अधिकारी और डाइरेक्टर'स की गिरफ़्तारी के आदेश जारी कार उन्हे गिरफ्तार किया जा सकता है. और पेनल्टी अलग से लगेगी.
महोदय हमने हमारे सभी क्लाइंट'स की जानकारी और डिटेल आपको भेजी थि. और उसी के संदर्भ मे आपने हमे ये पत्र उपलब्ध करवाया था.
महोदय कंपनी "नीसा लेसर " ने 30 दिनो से ज्यादा का समय निकाल दिया लेकिन कंपनी ने अभी तक हमारे किसी भी क्लाइंट'स का पैसा वापिस नही किया. और ना ही अभी तक कोई सूचना दी. हमने हमारे सभी क्लाइंट'स की सभी डिटेल फॉर्म न-4 मे भरकर और 50/- का ड्राफ्ट लगाकर कंपनी लॉ बोर्ड मे भेज दी है.हमने ये शिकायत क्रमश दिनांक 04/04/2014,10/04/2014,19/04/2014 मे बाइ रज़ी. पोस्ट से भेजी है जो की कंपनी लॉ बोर्ड मे क्रमश 08/04/2014,16/04/2014,25/04/2014 को प्राप्त हो गयी है.कुल 16 क्लाइंट'स की सिकायत है. जिनकी कॉपी हम आपको भी इस मेल के साथ भेज रहे है. उनकी रसिदे भी हमे अब तक नही मिली है.
महोदय आप हमारी शिकायत पुनः दर्ज कर कंपनी के खिलाफ सख्त कारवाही करने की कृपा करे और कंपनी जो की सबको गुमराह कर रही है तथा उसे कानून का उल्लंघन करने का तथा उसका द्रुपयोग करने का अधिकतम दंड मिलना चाहिए तथा उसके सभी अधिकारियो और डाइरेक्टर'स को गिरफ्तार करना चाहिए. एवम् जैसा माननीय आप और कंपनी लॉ बोर्ड जो सजा दे.
laxminarayan bansal gangapur city.

REPLY

Srikanth Shankar Matrubai

In Reply to laxminarayanbansal 2 years ago

I think the Chairman of Neesa Leisure Mr.Sanjay Gupta is taking advantage of being close to our dear PM Mr.Narendra Modi.
I hope our PM knows what a crook this Sanjay Gupta is..............

Regulators’ Rap on the Knuckles

IRDA should act a little more in consumer interest

ARight to Information (RTI) application to the Insurance Regulatory Development Authority of India (IRDA), followed by an appeal, is what it took to ferret out the information that, until August 2013, Reliance Life Insurance, through its corporate agent, had defrauded 2,141 persons into buying insurance with the false assurance that they would get an interest-free loan equal to 10 times the premium. The agent was AB Capital which ran a call centre that expertly duped people by claiming that the loan would be processed once the policy was bought. Immediately after the policy purchase, they would stop taking the calls.

Until the RTI, Moneylife Foundation (MF), our not-for-profit entity, and Raj Pradhan our insurance expert, had been plodding, case after case, to help the 30-odd victims of this fraud to get back nearly Rs22 lakh from Reliance Life. We repeatedly wrote that the geographical spread of the victims made it clear that the complaints reaching us were a fraction of those duped. It is not that Reliance Life has not initiated action. It has terminated the agency contract AB Capital and filed a criminal complaint, leading to the arrest of five officials. But, contrary to what it claimed to the regulator, the fraud has not ended with 2,141 cases. Our insurance helpline continues to receive complaints even today. In fact, Reliance Life has now adopted stricter standards for making payments. Why would IRDA not follow a clear and simple process to find out how many people have been cheated? The process would be to ask Reliance Life to provide a list of all policies sold by AB Capital, eliminate those who have got their money back and publish a list of all others on IRDA’s website, or in a national daily, asking people to write to a central helpline if they have also been cheated. The job of the regulator is not merely to act as a post-office while harried persons run from pillar to post seeking redress.

We do admit that IRDA has levied stiff penalties against several insurers, including Reliance Life, for mis-selling and other violations after due process and investigation. That surely has its place, but a financial regulator needs to have a parallel process of forcing those guilty of mis-selling to collate, compile and redress grievances through refunds. The regulator must recognise that Indian regulatory and legal systems rarely compensate victims by way of costs, interest or for the mental agony and hardship suffered in fighting their battles; so, the least they can ensure is that the money is refunded quickly.

User

COMMENTS

Vaibhav Dhoka

3 years ago

Comensation to Victim is need of hour and should be detterent to errying entity.

Fair & Stable Financial Services

We have a long way to go before financial consumers feel safe

Consumers International (CI), a global network of 240 consumer organisations, has decided on four key areas of financial consumer protection (FCP) that will be the focus of its consumer advocacy in the coming year. CI will campaign to place FCP on the agenda of the G20 nations, and also work at influencing recommendations of Financial Stability Board (FSB) and OECD. These four areas are: action to prevent abusive financial products and practices; promotion of competition in financial services; measures to tackle consumer debt and consumer access to basic products.

Where does India figure in all this? And what is the attitude of our regulators to the concerns of global consumers of financial products? Probably, for the first time ever in the 25 years since SEBI came into existence, the Sensex is scaling new, all-time highs but the majority of Indians are completely uninterested.

The same is true of insurance where, too, the regulator does not seem to understand that keeping the faith of consumers must be a priority. As far as the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is concerned, there is now an inclination to work at a comprehensive consumer protection framework, but RBI still has no formal engagement with consumers. The top brass at the banking regulator believes that the many complaints it receives everyday gives it a fair idea of consumer grievances. We beg to differ.

Most consumers articulate their issues poorly and are unable to place them appropriately in the context of a regulatory or consumer protection framework. That is why an NGO like Disha Financial Counselling is required to guide people correctly. More important, the availability and willingness of banks to provide basic banking services, which the RBI governor mentioned recently, will be the key to financial inclusion in India, along with a focus on ensuring safer mobile payments, which is also a global concern. (Moneylife Foundation, of which this writer is a founder trustee, is a supporter-member of CI.)

User

COMMENTS

CHILUKURI K R L RAO

3 years ago

The more and complex the number of rules to safe guard the interest of investors the bigger is the mechanism required to implement those rules. In reality complexity helps unscrupulous elements thrive.


Keeping it Simple is the Key. What better way to keep it simple than to design the incentive system(for an advisor) in such a manner that better performance of clients’ portfolio automatically gives better incentive to the advisor as well?


If upfront commissions are banned Trail becomes the only mode of remuneration for distributors there by opens up an opportunity for quality to thrive and in bringing back the trust of investors.


Do we need so many regulations and rules if “only trail” is adopted by all the fund houses in Mutual Funds? If the same principle is applied across the financial products wouldn't financial services be a more respectable industry?

REPLY

Nilesh KAMERKAR

In Reply to CHILUKURI K R L RAO 3 years ago

MF industry has been losing about 15000 folios per day. Now it is difficult to reverse the situation by tinkering with a few basis points here and there.

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.
  Loading...
Close

To continue


Please
Sign Up or Sign In
with

Email
Close

To continue


Please
Sign Up or Sign In
with

Email

BUY NOW

The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)