Citizens' Issues
Public Interest Exclusive
Pratibha Patil gives up land; activists win

Following persistent agitation by three intrepid activists, and supported by several exclusive articles in Moneylife alone, written by Vinita Deshmukh, the President of India, Pratibha Patil agrees to give up the land on which she was building a palatial post retirement bungalow

President Pratibha Patil has announced that she will now give up the large tract of A1 army land that she had grabbed to build a palatial post-retirement bungalow. This follows persistent newsbreaks only in Moneylife for the last one month and continuous agitation by activists in Pune.

A statement from the Rashtrapati Bhavan said, “Considering the fact that the issue has got linked with the issue of war widows accommodation by some people, the President has chosen to forego the aforesaid allotment of accommodation proposed to be made to her as her post retirement home in Pune.” It also said that, “What has pained the President the most is the fact that she is now being portrayed by some people as one who, by agreeing to accept a defence accommodation for her post retirement home, is insensitive to the cause of war widows and ex-servicemen. But facts are to the contrary. She has always been proud of our brave jawans who are ever-ready to display their spirit of sacrifice while defending our borders. She has the highest regards for our war widows who have lost their dear ones for the sake of security and integrity of the nation.”

It was Moneylife which broke the story that Pratibha Patil, president of India and the supreme commander of the armed forces was building a palatial home for herself on a whopping 261,000 sq ft of land in Khadki Cantonment in Pune (out of which the bungalow occupies about 4,500 sq ft). The land belongs to the defence. It was planned to have a fortified home. It was more than the stipulated 2,000 sq ft norms as stipulated by the law. Here is our first article

President Pratibha Patil grabs 2,61,000 sq ft of land meant for soldiers and officers

The issue came to limelight after information was revealed under the Right to Information (RTI) following a query by Col Suresh Patil (retd) and founder of Justice for Jawans (JFJ), RTI activist Anup Awasthi and Indian Ex-servicemen Movement (IESM). They campaigned against Ms Patil’s ‘snatching’ away land meant for soldiers and officers.

The RTI application was sent to the President’s office. As per the reply, under the President’s Emoluments and Pension Act, 1951 and rules framed under the President’s Pension Rule, 1962, “where suitable government residence is not available for allotment to a retired president, the size of the residence to be taken on lease to be provided to a retired president shall have a living area not exceeding 2,000 sq ft”.

In an earlier response from the Rashtrapati Bhavan, to a campaign by a group of ex-servicemen, said that, “No illegality has been committed. The land has been allotted to the President for use during her lifetime and will continue to belong to the defence ministry," it said rebutting charges that the plot had been "given" to the President.”
Vinita Deshmukh, who consistently followed the story, told Moneylife that, “She is absolutely thrilled by the response from the President. It is truly a people’s victory.”

Moneylife has been consistently at the story. After the first article, Vinita wrote about the fact that Pratibha Patil’s house stands on defence land meant only for military use with military spending its resources for her benefit.
(Pratibha Patil’s house stands on A1 defence land meant only for military use; military spending its resources for her)

Soon after the above story was published, it went viral in the social media. However, the President's office came up with a denial which did not address the core issues, but was carried faithfully by the mainstream media (Pratibha Patil’s Pune Bungalow: Denying the undeniable ).

The protests gathered steam and spread both nationwide. (Protest against President’s land grab set to spread countrywide)

Further, it was found out that Pune Cantonment Board’s reply to RTI application says that the cantonment comes under the jurisdiction of the Maharashtra Tree Act. Apparently, trees too were being uprooted to give way for the palace.

Trees cut illegally for President Pratibha Patil’s Pune bungalow?

Even the home ministry questioned the President’s move. The president’s office instead stood ground and stated their reply, which was full of factual errors.

Ministry of defence had questioned ‘precedence’ of allocating defence land for President Pratibha Patil’s retirement home

With the social media and nationwide protest at the peak, the President office sent an emissary to pacify the RTI activists. However, the Governor of Tripura, DY Patil, had planed to fly down to Pune to pacify activists opposing President Pratibha Patil's post-retirement home; tweets depleted his confidence and he sent his confidante instead, who in turn asked the soldiers to "tone down the agitation". Thus showing the power of the citizens.

Twitter buzz scares away Pratibha Patil's emissary sent to pacify protestors of Pune land grab

Vinita Deshmukh finally wrote that many unanswered questions remain. By the time, the nation was fed up.
President Pratibha Patil’s palatial home in Pune: Many unanswered questions




3 years ago

it is shame on us.... venkat


5 years ago

Congratulations! Now it is important to march ahead,to reach the further goal of the jawans and war widows getting their rightful share of existence. The monelife team can further put their weight so that 1. the guilty should be severely punished as far as destructing the ecology is will take so many more years to restore the same 2. the land should go to the deserving lot no matter how small in designation he is.
It would have been a great gesture for the first lady who proudly takes the salute of honour to publicly apologise and ask for whatever punishment. She can set an example that deserves to be saluted.


5 years ago

Despite Parliament remaining strangely silent (not for, not against); despite all political parties and elected representatives ignoring the issue; despite the MSM giving higher prominence to the denials from Rashtrapati Bhavan; despite the veiled and not so veiled threats; despite the real power for retaliation that some people have - this initiative worked. And rapidly too. But proves one more point - compared to the size of other scams underway in India, this was a minnow - one off-the-record comment from a political friend here in Delhi said it all:- "This is what happens when big people aim small". So, onwards to catch the big guys, now that the power of the tools used, what is dismissively referred to as "social media" or worse "internet noise", has been proved. Well and truly. Congratulations, again, Moneylife, Sucheta, Debashish, Vinita. And for the gentlemen in Pune, Patil, Pathak, Anand and others, salutes and more. The platform is there, bring on the trains . . .



In Reply to malq 5 years ago

You can include yourself proudly in the team of Sucheta, Vinita and Debashish in exposing the corrupt politicians MR.VM ji.


5 years ago

A pertinent blog on TOI on this issue


5 years ago

Congrats to the men responsible in restoring not only the land to the rightful owners but also demonstrating that persistance pays. May the good samaritans be bestowed with more health and more vigour to fight similar injustices of the society.


5 years ago

Congratulations to all the "concerned great and brave persons" who made the President of India to quit illegally occupied land in Pune. I sincerely wish Almighty to bless these "great and brave citizens" of our country with peace, prosperity and all happiness. Once again three cheers to them.


5 years ago

Congrats to all those who fought. A small victory brings great delight, still bigger issues we face. Can this be called "a small step against corrupt,big step against injustice"?

S Prabhu

5 years ago

Hearty Congratulations to Ms. Vinita Deshmukh and the team of activist. Today it has been proved that if you have will, common people can shake any highest office or the person. If every Indian comes forward in this fashion then I am sure the corruption will come to an end within a year. So its time for every Indian to come open and fight against corruption. Hats of Madam Suchita Dalals and her team for doing a great work for the country. Satyamev Jayate. Jai Jawan Jai Kisan


5 years ago

good work!
govt are not the king and queens . they must show accountability to spend public money and resources.


5 years ago

Congratulations Moneylife. May you and other activists have more power to carry on the fight against various politically powerful vested interests.

PR Vaidya

5 years ago

Congratulations to Ms Vinita Deshmukh for fruitful work.
However the mention of War Widows is not clear. Do not remember Vinita's article mentioning this, but Rashtrapati Bhavan press- note mentions this. Did someone else project this aspect? Irrespective of that aspect, acquisition of land in excess of requirement was the issue and what has happened is good for that reason alone.

Request Moneylife to clarify this aspect please.


5 years ago

Thank you MoneyLife ! Please continue the good work and expose shameless behavior !

Capt Kiriti Guha

5 years ago

I am extremely happy that at last some sense has got into the head of President and she has finally given in to incessant public pressure and decided not to use the of the land allotted to her. It is a great victory for Moneylife and all the activists as well as the general public who fought for the cause.


5 years ago

The land grabber gives up because of persistent efforts of the activists. Now she will grab some other land to justify her SERVICE (SIC) to the country. When we will be rid of these GREEDY politicians.


5 years ago

It is indeed very satisfying to see that the unrelenting campaign by Col Suresh Patil and his friends, ably backed by Vinita Deshmukh and Money Life, has yielded the desired result.
It shows that a persistant campaign for what is right will yield results.
This also holds a lesson for the mainline electronic media that if they do not back citizens' movements for justice just because their fodder comes from the corrupt they will be doing great injustice to the cause of truth!

AMFI platform for fund transaction: A white elephant in the making?

The Association of Mutual Funds of India is will shell out enormous money to duplicate what is available, with no idea how any investor would be persuaded to use it

While the Association of Mutual Funds of India (AMFI) has at last started talking against the Securities and Exchange Board of India’s (SEBI) debilitating move to ban entry load in August 2009 without much discussion, the former is about to embark on a dubious adventure. AMFI has been planning to spend crores of rupees to build a MF Utility, a comprehensive mutual fund platform to buy and sell mutual funds. A lot of market observers are wondering who will benefit from it and how?

An industry source, who does not want to be identified, believes that costs can easily be upwards of Rs15 crore. The industry itself is divided as to who will pay for this white elephant and why. While the larger fund companies (about four) are in favour of the plan, the vast majority of fund houses are unwilling to shell out money for it.

Indeed, with such a high price to develop the product, how will AMFI recover the cost, especially at a time when retail investors are shying away from investing in equity funds? As of now, mutual funds can be bought physically through distributors but participation is abysmally low relative to savings being generated. There are already three ways one can buy funds online. One, all fund houses such as HDFC Mutual Fund and ICICI Prudential Mutual Fund have their own portal for transacting online. Two, there is the hair-brained idea of former SEBI chairman CB Bhave, which is to get mutual fund investors ‘trade’ online through broker terminals. This has been a flop. Finally, it is pertinent to note that, at the moment, there already exists a platform for mutual funds, namely Finnet jointly developed by two registrars and transfer agents—Computer Age Management Services (CAMS) and Karvy. This platform covers almost 95% of the industry’s schemes and products. A rationale for developing yet another one and that too led by an association which has refused to do any kind of self-regulation, is not clear when there are already three online models around. If AMFI’s idea of using technology is to improve ‘distribution’, it clearly missed the point.

AMFI had stated the intentions of building this platform last year, when Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) and National Stock Exchange (NSE) had built their own platforms. In order to compete with them and offer investors a stand-alone platform, AMFI had come up with this idea. According to AMFI, investors will now have a single login ID instead of multiple, providing unified access to all AMCs. Any investor now access any scheme online either directly or through a distributor (who would fill up the form on behalf of the investor and process it further through the registrar and transfer agent). This is exactly similar to Finnet.
One head of a fund house calls it a half-baked idea. Most importantly, today investors need to be persuaded to invest in equity mutual funds. The MF Utility will be a “Do-It-Yourself” model which has no chance of succeeding in India in the near future. With no one to advise investors what to invest in MF Utility, what is the point of technology? Yes, technology does make things easier, but there has to be an incentive for distributors to do business, but this incentive is insignificant when SEBI banned the entry load in August 2009. Apart from AMC distributors, what will other distributors do? A head of a one of the smaller AMCs says that “this looks like a platform to benefit a few.”




5 years ago

btw who is the white elephant here? the creator or the platform?

Deepak R Khemani

5 years ago

The idea if it is implemented properly and if it works then it is actually a good one where finally the investors and distributors will do away with the UNNECESSARY paperwork involved in every transaction, each form compulsorily has to have a SID/KIM (for INVESTOR PROTECTION AND INFORMATION), I wonder how many distributors let alone investors have ever bothered to read the KIM, it finally ends up in the dustbin.The chances of rejection due to improper Bank Particulars, KYC, Nomination etc will disappear, If Fundsindia's claim that their platform does work and a few have said that they are happy after using it then it would have made sense to use that platform since it was available and it was tried and tested!


5 years ago

There is another platform namely that provides such a platform since many years. I have been using it since many years. The best part is that they provide it charging not a single rupee and excellent customer service.

While I feel providing online capability is definitely useful, I think the cost at which it is being done sounds bad. They could simply tie up with an existing platform and provide the facility to interested investors (I am sure there would be many in today's electronic age).



In Reply to Shashibhushan 5 years ago


if entry load comes will fundsindia start charging??


In Reply to Layman 5 years ago


Srikanth from FundsIndia.

At the outset, we have no plans to start charging for our mutual fund services. We get paid for the services we provide in the form of trail and upfront fees paid to us by AMCs.

Even if entry loads come back, it is hard to predict the form in which they will and the options that will be available then. While we will react to that situation from a business perspective, our goal will always be to provide our MF services at zero cost to investors.




In Reply to Srikanth 5 years ago


thanks for the immediate reply.


In Reply to Srikanth 5 years ago

Hello Mr. Srikanth,

I guess your company and the likes of fundssupermart etc have an ARN number - which in a way means that you are an authorised mutual fund distributor.

Does that also mean that you have to take the exams / courses as prescribed by AMFI and NISM? If yes - then isn't it ironic that even through you are not recommending funds to your users still you have to pass an exam to stay in business?

Or is my understanding of ARN incorrect in the sense that you have to have ARN just to act as distributor but just take the certification / pass to exam to recommend funds?

Srikanth Meenakshi

5 years ago

Today, retail investors also have the choice of investing through platforms such as (covers all schemes of 38 AMCs). The service is free and offers the same convenience as the proposed MFUtility with many more features and value-added services for retail investors and advisors.

When the concept of MFUtility came up, we (at FundsIndia, I am a director here) proposed that we will build it for them (using our tried and tested in-house technology) for a fraction of the cost that your article talks about. For reasons unknown to us, we were not selected (although we submitted our bid in partnership with one of the BIG IT companies in the country). If our offer had been taken up, MF Utility would have seen the light of the day earlier and at a fraction of the cost. That would have translated to cost-benefits to investors and distributors everywhere.

Building a platform such as this is not easy and getting it right quickly is impossible. As it stands now, it is likely that the proposed platform will cost a lot, will re-invent the wheel, and yield few, if any, benefits.




In Reply to Srikanth Meenakshi 5 years ago


It is shocking you were not selected. I am sure MF Utility is going to be a big flop show and a big egg on their faces.

AMFI instead of address the core issues is concentrating on platform thinking passengers(investors) will comet to to board the trains ( Funds). The way redemption are happening and AMC's like Fidelity leaving India and 4 CEO's quitting something is fishy out there.



In Reply to Sanjay 5 years ago

If you ask me is even better than funds india. They have personalised services, more funds, more banks and research which helps an investor. Fundsindia does not have these services. Moreover fundsupermart is a large MNC organisation compared to fundsindia which is a start up and no one knows where its headed in the future.

Rohan Lopez

In Reply to Dhananjay 5 years ago

Hi Dhananjay,
I must say that your suggestion is very helpful. As an average person who wants to invest in mutual funds, i wanted more information before i could invest my hard earned money into mutual funds. as you said has a very good information on their website about mutual funds.
For a layman like myself, mutual funds investment is complicated, i liked some of the articles on their site on Tax Saving. Thanks for the suggestion. Exploring the website, hope it solves my investment queries and makes investing easier.

Public Interest Exclusive
Airports Authority conned by bounced cheques

Airlines and other airport service operators, which have issued cheques amounting to Rs7.23 crore to AAI’s Southern Region, have bounced. AAI is silent about it

Airlines such as Air India, JetLite, Paramount Airways, along with other parties operating at the airport, which have issued cheques amounting to Rs7.23 crore to airports under the Airports Authority of India’s (AAI) Southern Region, bounced. The information furnished under a Right to Information (RTI) application.

The RTI application was filed by Pune-based activist Sanjay Shirodkar with AAI’s Southern region, to seek the details of cheques it received from 2000, which later bounced. According to the reply, 25 cheques from 2006 till today, amounting to Rs5.8 crore, which were issued to Chennai and other airports controlled by it, got bounced. Mangalore airport received seven cheques of a total amount of Rs1.7 crore issued on 15th September 2009 by Air India which were dishonoured, while Hyderabad Airport was issued one cheque of Rs1.6 lakh, by Air Deccan, which bounced.

“I don’t know if the amount has been recovered, compounded or settled. But I pity the aviation sector. While the ministry of civil aviation is talking about modernisation of all airports, there seems to be no co-operation in paying the fees by the airlines and other parties for using the airport,” says Mr Shirodkar.

According to the list, Paramount Airways issued three cheques in 2007 and 2009 for a total amount of Rs4.1 crore, which bounced. Interestingly, Paramount, which was started in 2005, had to shut its operation two years ago after the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) had de-registered its three planes. The action came after the airline was embroiled in payment battle with GE Capital Aviation Service and Celestial Aviation Trading, its lessors. Paramount was the only airline to offer business class service at a cost which at price in par with the fares of economy class of other airlines.

The RTI reply also revealed that Air India issued eight such cheques of Rs1.7 crore, Air India Express issued seven cheques of Rs95 lakh, while JetLite issued five cheques amounting Rs28 lakh which bounced.

The national carrier Air India is also in deep financial turmoil. Recently the union government announced a financial restructuring plan for Air India where Rs30,000 crore will be infused in the carrier till 2020. The same goes for JetLite. According to a report, Jet Airways has phased out its low-cost service JetLite, which was launched in 2007 and rechristened it as JetKonnect—another low-cost brand. In the third quarter of FY11-12 Jet Airways lost Rs101 crore while JetLite had a loss of Rs21 crore. The financial crisis is the main reason for merging the low-cost brands.

An RTI application filed by Mr Shirodkar revealed that that Kingfisher Airlines had issued five cheques amounting Rs122 crore between August 25, 2011 and February 21, 2012 to the AAI which bounced due to insufficient funds. According to news reports, the AAI had not initiated any action against the airline.

Mr Shirodkar had also sought the list of instances of cheque issued to Pune and Ahemdabad airports, which were dishonoured.

According to the list, from 2000 to 2012, the Ahemdabad airport received cheques which later bounced from airlines such as Emirates Airlines, Qatar Airways, SpiceJet, Indigo Airlines, and others like Flemingo Duty Free Shop, Blue Dart Aviation, Akbar Travels, etc. Interestingly, the reply received from the AAI relating to cheques received by the Pune airport which were dishonoured did not include a single airline company name but only included other parties operating at the airport providing services such as PK Hospitality Services, Mercury Car Rentals Service.



Shadi Katyal

5 years ago

One should ask simple question that if the first cheque bounced due to lack of funds of any airline why is not mandatory to accept only Cashier cheques . Why even allow usage of airport while old cheques are bouncing and new one are being presented.
Does the left hand know what right hand is doing or bureaucracy just moves on with blindfold.
In our nation which is run by Babus trhe reply will be we jut follow the rules so what are the rules

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)