Personal finance Friday

Kotak MF declares dividend under Kotak Quarterly Interval Plan Series 3

Kotak Mutual Fund has announced the declaration of dividend under the dividend option of Kotak Quarterly Interval Plan Series 3. The record date is 17 August 2010. The quantum of declaration will be 100% of distributable surplus as available under the plan(s) on the record date. Kotak Quarterly Interval Plan Series 3 is an open end debt scheme. The net asset value (NAV) of the Kotak Quarterly Interval Plan Series 3 stood at 10.1006 on 12 August 2010.

ICICI Pru MF declares dividend under ICICI Pru Medium Term Premium Plus-DH

ICICI Prudential Mutual Fund has announced the declaration of dividend under the dividend option of ICICI Prudential Medium Term Premium Plus-DH (Dividend Half Yearly). The record date is 17 August 2010. The quantum of declaration will be 3.151%. ICICI Prudential Medium Term Premium Plus-DH is an open end debt scheme. The net asset value (NAV) of the ICICI Prudential Medium Term Premium Plus-DH stood at 10.3184 on 12 August 2010.

SHCIL starts new service to serve mutual fund investors

Stock Holding Corporation of India Ltd (SHCIL) has started a new service, which provides the benefits of the secondary market to mutual fund investors in buying and selling units. It provides an opportunity for subscription and redemption of mutual fund units through the BSE STAR Platform in demat mode. SHCIL has started this service through its subsidiary SHCIL Services Ltd. According to the regulatory norms, clients who want to use the new service will have to execute necessary KYC (know your customer) documents and have a demat account. SHCIL, a depository participant (DP), offers demat and custodial services and third party distribution of financial products. Investors opting for the new facility will receive a unified statement for their holdings and transactions in various mutual funds along with all other demat securities such as shares, debentures, bonds etc.

IDFC Mutual Fund files offer document with SEBI to launch IDFC Retirement Fund

IDFC Mutual Fund has filed an offer document with the Securities Exchange Board of India (SEBI) to launch IDFC Retirement Fund, an open ended fund of fund scheme. The new fund offer (NFO) will offer units of Rs10 each. The investment objective of the scheme is to generate returns by making investments in different mutual fund schemes. The scheme will be a fund of fund scheme that can invest in a mix of equity, debt and liquid funds. The scheme will offer five plans-Plan 2015, Plan 2020, Plan 2025, Plan 2030 and Plan 2035. The scheme will have two investment options-growth and dividend. The dividend option includes dividend pay-out and dividend re-investment. The entry load shall be nil. However, a 1.5% exit load of the net asset value (NAV) shall be applicable if investors redeem or switch out such investments in two years from the date of subscription. The minimum subscription amount for all plans is Rs5,000 and in multiples of Re1 thereafter.

Reliance MF files offer document with SEBI to launch Reliance Interval Fund II- Fortnightly

Reliance Mutual Fund has filed an offer document with the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) to launch Reliance Interval Fund II- Fortnightly. The fund is a debt oriented interval scheme. The new fund offer (NFO) will offer units of Rs 10 each. The investment objective of the scheme is to seek to generate regular returns and growth of capital by investing in central and state government securities and other fixed income/debt securities. The scheme is available in two options-growth and dividend. The dividend option includes two sub-options-dividend payout and dividend reinvestment. The entry and exit load for the scheme shall be nil. The minimum subscription amount for the scheme is Rs5,000 and in multiples of Re1 thereafter.


The facts of the matter

Even when analysts get all the facts right, their own prejudices and personal incentives get in the way of accurate forecasts. But enormous opportunity exists for those analysts who manage to read the tea leaves right, despite the constraints

Information is the raw material of the financial industry. Certainly there seems to be enough of it. But what does it all mean? All worshippers need high priests to interpret the entrails, read the runes, or decode the cards. For understanding the financial health of a company, this means reading the numbers.
But numbers by themselves are often meaningless. It is necessary to compare them to something else. Often these are expressed as ratios. We have ratios that are current. We have ratios that are quick. We have ratios of cash flow. But it does not end there.
Besides ratios, we have returns, returns on equity, assets and employed capital. We all like to forget returns on unemployed capital. Then things move in cycles, cash conversion cycles, operating cycles and the great business cycle.
The high priests of these numbers for investors are financial analysts. Financial analysts do the necessary research. They interpret the raw data churned out by company accountants and try to make sense of it. If they have good records they can be extremely well paid and a few have risen to be demigods of Wall Street. But are they right?
This has to be looked at from two different perspectives. The first question is whether their analysis is correct. The second is the value of their predictions. Finally we have to ask whether anyone cares.
As the legendary speculator Bernard Baruch said, "If you get all the facts, your judgment can be right; if you don't get all the facts, it can't be right." Analysts' job is to get the facts, but management has a very large economic incentive to convince them otherwise. To do so they use all sorts of schemes.
For example, the hallmark of good corporate governance and hopefully good management is supposed to be an independent board. By most corporate laws, the board is supposed to ensure that management works for the shareholders and not themselves. To be truly independent the board is not supposed to have economic incentives or relationships with the company on whose board they sit.
Independent directors get good marks from analysts. If a company makes an effort to recruit independent directors, analysts are happy. The likelihood that the company receives a subsequent stock upgrade rises by 36% and the chance of a downgrade falls by 45%. But what is independent? Even if there is no economic relationship, there is often a social relationship. It should not come as any surprise that 45% of the members of nominating committees on the boards of large American firms have "friendship" ties to the CEO. In emerging markets where family and State-owned firms predominate, the other board members are likely to be family members or ruling party members.
Then analysts can always be bribed, perhaps not with money, but there are other methods. The more a company's profits missed forecasts the higher the probability that management will bestow favours on analysts including recommending them for jobs and or helping them join exclusive clubs. Of course in countries with less diligent watchdogs, the bribes are simply money.
Even if analysts do get the facts, often their own prejudices and other incentives get in the way. According to a McKinsey study, over the past 25 years, analysts' forecasts on average have been 100% too high. They are also loath to predict a long-term profits decline. Analysts forecast that less than 0.2% of companies will suffer a long-term decline. In reality about a third do. A Harvard study found that sell-side forecasts were more accurate than buy-side estimates.
Finally like all market players analysts tend to rely too much on history. Research found that the correlation between analyst's earnings forecasts and actual growth for the coming year to be a mere 0.28. In contrast the correlation between the forecasts and the past year was 0.75.
With all their faults we still need someone to do the number crunching, don't we? Yes and no. Recently all stocks and all markets have this unsettling habit of correlating. So it doesn't matter if you invested in Europe, Japan or the US since 2007 - they have basically moved in lock step. Emerging markets are more volatile, but they also have consistently moved in the same direction as the developed world. There is also no difference between value stocks or growth stocks.
One reason for the correlation has to do with the popularity of exchange-traded funds (ETFs). Many investors just choose a sector or a market with an ETF, not an individual stock. So a good company within the ETF can get dragged down if there are problems within the sector or the market. In other words, the micro-numbers are irrelevant. You don't need to pick a stock; you need to pick a sector, an individual market or even the global market to make money.
Of course, the paradox is that the analyst can be more important than ever. The correlation misprices and good companies eventually will outperform their sector. So for those analysts good enough, enormous opportunity awaits.

(The writer is president of Emerging Market Strategies and can be contacted at [email protected] or [email protected]).


Cadbury Éclairs: The ad may bomb!

The madness in this commercial gets reduced to self-indulgence on the part of the advertiser

Some amount of madness is expected from candy advertising, for sure. After all, you can't be expected to rationalise and argue with the consumers in this product category. However, ad ideas are going totally bizarre and outlandish of late. With no story to tell about the product, the creatives are going berserk with gimmicky tactics. Cadbury Éclairs has been running a new series of commercials where the consumer's head is seen exploding into a chocolate bomb after gobbling down the thing. Chocolate blast, they call it. Not a very savoury sight, let me quickly add. In fact, it borders on the grotesque. But the advertiser will probably claim this is their way of demonstrating 'chocolate experience'. Yeah right!
And in their latest bomb blast version, the protagonist not only loses his head, he also slips into a psychedelic trance! The commercial features a young lad, bored and sleepy at an uncle and aunty party. The grannies torment him by pulling at his chubby cheeks, and worse, he gets glad-eyed by a totally square girl. Frustrated and pissed off, he downs a Cadbury Éclair, his head blasts like a chocolate volcano, and then the choc psychedelics take over. Of course, the special effects last only a few seconds (makers of Cadbury Éclairs would want the dosage increased, else how do they sell volumes?), and the dude returns to the humdrum world of geriatrics.
Shockingly dull advertising. A crime, if you ask me. To deliver such rubbish creative, given that the client would have given the ad agency a huge creative license to experiment. After all, there are no scientific features to a candy, so the product is always a great opportunity to push the creative envelope. The chocolate bomb idea is so silly, self-absorbed and uninteresting, I would actually much rather enjoy the aunty party… the oldies look like much more fun in comparison! And that's a telling statement on the commercial. Net-net: a complete waste of an opportunity to do some great work. Madness is all very well, but the key to it is viewer entertainment, else the madness gets reduced to self-indulgence on the part of the advertiser.
By the way, the psychedelic lights trick would be a super idea for pushing ecstasy or coke. Hopefully the ad agency creatives were munching Cadbury Éclairs when they came up with this bomb of an idea.



Sunil Date

7 years ago

Yes indeed. "Not a very savoury sight, In fact, it borders on the grotesque" Very rightly said. Would I feel like eating chocolate, if I imagine my head exploding or taking a bath in chocolate ?" 'Uuuugggggh"

Incidentally most of us watch TV while having our dinner in the 2000 to2100 (prime time slot ?) Shoud'nt toilet cleaner ads be banned in this slot ? especially when they show the interiors of the toilet ?


7 years ago


We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)