Investor Issues
ONGC’s mockery of investor services; it has not compensated investors yet for delay in 2004 share issue

The largest government company had promised redressal of complaints from investors, during the sale of 10% equity seven years ago. It also said it would pay interest if investors did not receive refund orders within 15 days of the issue closing. But the company has not done so, and it is now on the verge of a follow-on issue

The largest public sector company by market capitalisation in our country is Oil & Natural Gas Corporation (ONGC). It is also the highest profit-making corporate in our country with international operations. It is one of the four publish sector units that have been awarded the "Maharatna" status by the government of India.

In March 2004, the company came out with an offer for sale of 10% of its equity to the Indian public, amounting to over Rs10,500 crore, which was a huge success. It received unprecedented response from retail investors and the issue was oversubscribed several times-a record at the time. This resulted in the company and its registrars not being able to make the allotment of shares and issue of refund orders within the time stipulated in the offer document. This gave rise to a large number of complaints from investors.

The offer document contained this undertaking by the selling shareholder and the company: "…that the complaints received in respect of this offer shall be attended to by the selling shareholder expeditiously and satisfactorily. The selling shareholder has authorised the Company Secretary and Compliance Officer and the Registrar to the offer, to redress all complaints, if any, of the investors participating in this offer."

The offer document further stated that the selling shareholder shall pay interest at the rate of 15% per annum on the excess bid amount received, if refund orders were not despatched within 15 working days from the bid/offer closing date. But when investors demanded interest for the period of delay, the company was in a strange predicament, because, the funds realised from the offer for sale had been credited to the Consolidated Fund of India, as it was due to the Central government. The company did not receive any amount from this issue. Due to this unexpected situation, the company appears to have not been able to sort out this matter for the last seven years.

According to Stock Exchange requirements, all listed companies are required (under clause 41 of the listing agreement) to disclose every quarter-when publishing the quarterly results-the number of investor complaints pending at the beginning of the quarter, the complaints received and disposed off during the period,  and the complaints that remain unresolved  at the end of the quarter. In compliance with this requirement, the company has been meticulously mentioning these details only in respect of normal investor complaints with regard to transfer of shares, dividend payments, etc. However, during the last 28 quarters, the company has been honest enough to make the following statement after these mandatory details about the complaints outstanding at the end of quarter.

The notes read: " These exclude investors' complaints regarding the offer for sale up to 10% of equity shares of the Company made by the Government of India in March 2004, which are being attended to by the Registrars to the issue appointed by the Government of India."  The moot question is, if the company has not been able to resolve the complaints for the last seven years, how can an investor expect to get his/her complaint resolved at any time in the future?

ONGC has now announced that it will be coming out with a follow-on public offer (FPO) of shares  shortly. Will the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) allow the company to come out with the FPO without fully resolving the outstanding investor complaints pending for such a long time? SEBI should ensure that all the pending complaints are resolved, before allowing the company to divest stake.

SEBI should also ensure that the company and the registrars suo moto identify all those cases where refund orders have been sent after a delay and all those investors should be properly compensated with interest not only for the delayed period, but be paid compound interest. (Interest on interest should be paid to serve as a deterrent against repetition of such instances in future.) Those responsible for this state of affairs should be pulled up, and the aggrieved investors should be compensated on the lines of the disgorgement by SEBI in the IPO scam, recently.

Can we expect SEBI to act swiftly to protect not only the interest of the investors, but also the dignity and honour of the highest office in the country, in whose name the public issue of shares was made?

(The author is former managing director and CEO of a mutual fund. He writes for Moneylife under the pen name 'Gurpur'.)



nagesh kini

6 years ago

A classic case of corporate mis-governance, which is routinely practiced by the private sector.
A Navratna PSU, with a reputation, to guard simply cannot get away by passing on the buck to the Registrars nor does any disclosure serve the purpose. The SEBI must necessarily pull up ONGC and ensure that they pay the interest.

Aditya Birla Group acquires Domsjö Fabriker, Swedish speciality pulp manufacturer

Aditya Birla Group has acquired Domsjö Fabriker, a leading Swedish speciality pulp and bio-refinery company, through its global companies Thai Rayon Public Company (Thailand) and Indo Bharat Rayon (Indonesia), for $340 million from a Swedish consortium

Aditya Birla Group has announced the acquisition of Domsjö Fabriker, a leading Swedish speciality pulp and bio-refinery company, through its global companies Thai Rayon Public Company Ltd (Thailand) and Indo Bharat Rayon (Indonesia), for a sum of $340 million from a Swedish consortium.

KK Maheshwari, business head, pulp & fibre, Aditya Birla Group, said, "This acquisition is in line with our strategy of having a substantive part of our speciality pulp for our consumption through our captive source. With Domsjö Fabriker, we are closer to this goal."  

"As a large quality manufacturer of speciality pulp, Domsjö's has a synergistic fit with us. There is a great opportunity to further grow the company. Domsjö has an extensive investment programme for capacity expansion from its current 210,000 tons to 255,000 tons per annum by 2012. We are fully committed to Domsjö's growth.  Going forward, our intent is to expand the innovation and research and development efforts at Domsjö as part of our global R&D efforts, added Mr Maheshwari.

Speciality pulp produced by Domsjö, finds primary use in the textile segment (viscose staple fibre and viscose filament yarn). Around 25% of the production is used in premium applications, such as binding agents for medical products, particularly pharmaceutical tablets and in casings (wraps) for the food industry.


Magma Fincorp’s Q4 PAT rises 69% to Rs44.93 crore

Magma Fincorp consolidated profit after tax grew 69.86% to Rs44.93 crore for the fourth quarter ended 31 December 2011, over the corresponding period last year

Non-banking financial company Magma Fincorp Ltd said its consolidated profit after tax grew 69.86% to Rs44.93 crore for the fourth quarter ended 31 December 2011, over the corresponding period last year.

It had a consolidated profit after tax of Rs26.45 crore in the same quarter a year ago, Magma Fincorp said in a filing to the Bombay Stock Exchange.
Consolidated total income rose to Rs269.38 crore in the quarter under review from Rs216.48 crore in the same period previous fiscal, it said.

For the year ended 31 March 2011, consolidated PAT increased to Rs122.14 crore as against Rs71.32 crore in the last year. Consolidated total income jumped up to Rs872.34 crore in the year under review from Rs719.36 crore, it added.

The board of directors of the company has recommended a dividend of Re0.60 per share of Rs2 each for the year ended 31 March 2011.

On Tuesday, Magma Fincorp ended 0.14% down at Rs70.05 on the Bombay Stock Exchange, while the benchmark Sensex gained 0.16% to 19,121.83.


We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)