Moneylife » life » public-interest » moneylife-foundation-sends-representation-to-pm-fm-and-rbi-urging-ban-on-mlm-schemes
Moneylife Foundation sends representation to PM, FM and RBI urging ban on MLM schemes May 18, 2011 07:29 PM | Moneylife Digital Team Share this article:
All MLM are cases of cheating plain and simple and there is no reason why they cannot be prosecuted under S.420 suo moto by the police when both the numbers and values run into millions
When our 'honest PM' and 'intellectually arrogant' FM have their hands full tackling larger 'public issues' MLMs are a flea bite - 'you pay for your greed and stew in your own juices!' they'd say.
Bangalore based Unipay2U (Unigroup: Unipay2U, Visarev (Unigateway2U, Unigold2U) - Scam of Rs. 35,000 Crores approximately, might be even more than that, so surprise to see moneylife hasn't given any information regarding that company.
Owner: James @ Mugu (Actual Name: Mugunthan Gnanam / Gangam) a malaysian resident now absconded, Govt. not taking any action.
Also one company called Way2Life (WealthLine), Chennai based has looted Rs. 5,000 - 10,000 Crores, and vanished,
Owner: Chithara Kumar, tamilian now believe to be residing in Canada along with his family.
I'm having just a small list of companies around 276 MLM companies which are operating in India which all has MCA, ROC registration, even ISO also, all have cheated & ran away and still companies keep on coming & keep on closing. what hell this govt. is doing i can't understand? which country we are living in? I don't think in no other country this kind of scam would have happened except india..!
Compare to all other scams even Speakasia's, other companies scams are too big; i will ask moneylife to turn your attention towards other companies also, speakasia is having consumer power which i have not seen in any other company in my life, let us see how govt. handles this company panelists. This number is too big, govt. has to do something for them. Rest of the companies in the market collects money in the name of investment & also watching advertisements & doing surveys for which you are paid they tells.. huh, until what time they'll run the show! one day they are closing & running away na, why govt. is not taking any step remains a big question??
MLM Rackets cannot hold meetings in Hotels, Resorts, convention Centers
Newspaper Report June 13, 2011
Police warns Hotels, Resorts and Convention centers against allowing money chain companies to hold meetings in their premises. If anyone found flouting the order, they will be booked under Prize Chits and Money Circulation Schemes (Banning) Act, 1978.
CRIMINAL Complaint against MLM Company UNIPAY2U / visarev
20 investors who were duped by a Malaysian based MLM company UNIPAY2U filed criminal complaint before the City Police Commissioner, Thrissur.
According to the reports, 27 investors went to Malaysia to discuss the matter directly with the Company but they could never meet the Managing Director. However, the officials of the company assured them that they would get back their money before March 31, 2011. Since they did not receive back the money they went to their Bangalore office but could find the office "CLOSED".
First:First of all get the facts properly. SA never said they are selling surveys. The money being paid is for the opinion.
Second: The money collected is not for membership its for the subscription of E-Zine Magazine for a period of one year which is avl in every panel ID. This E-zine is the product here.
Third: Not necc every company is bad. As someone pointed out it is for the betterment of everyone these MLM companies can be brought under RBI or SEBI regulations.
Fifth: MLM is a great oppurtunity, only few can be sucessful as it requires sales and marketing skills. IN western countries MLM is most successful.
IM not here to argue....I only wanted to say that dont let oppurtunities go away....If any one wants to discuss with me plz call me @ 9982249004
Times of India - ‎May 27, 2011‎
LUCKNOW: The Lucknow Bench of the Allahabad High Court directed the additional solicitor general of India to obtain instructions from the Centre to frame guidelines and monitoring mechanism on the operation of Speak Asia Online Private Limited. ...
I am unable to understand one thing that till now, company is paying everything which it promised. No One complainted towards that they did not get money or something else. Then How we can say it as a scam.
First thing - PROMISES ARE MEANT FOR BREAK.
Second thing -Bakre ko ID ke pahle khila-pila kar mota-tagda kiya jate, usey kya pata ki wo ek din halal hoga. Woh koi SCAM-VScam ki complain nahi karta. Isi tarah Jab ye Scheme bhi iske satuaration point ka target achieve kar legi, us din .....baley baley ho jayega galey galey (hi mera paisa gaya, gaya). Ab aap hi sochiye ke Scam start kaise hota hei? Scam ho jane ke baad hi maloom padta hei ki woh SCAM tha.
Summarising all comments, the moot question here is- If SpeakAsia is genuine company, Why they are charging 11000/- to become member. If survey is their sole object then to do survey one should be literate, english known, major age and have access to online computer. those should be main criteria and not amount of 11,000/-. Hight of stupidity of those people who become member is is that they forget they are giving commission if one make more and more member, which means more and more 11,000/- and out of those 11,000/- speakAsia is paying commision (khud ki juti kud ke sir). I suggest people to be alert and cautiost of such scheme, whose only object is cheat people once scheme has collected huge amount and then vanish. just imagine as of now if we assume 15 lac member multiply by 11,000/- per person i.e. equal to 1650 crore already collected. and lastly from where they are getting survey, which companies are appointing speakAsia to do survey, why SpeakAsia is not registered in India, what an SpeakAsia member have legal remedy, if compnaies go air...???
Your remark added to comments shows your ability in reading & understanding the subject matter, though as you being claimed elsewhere that you spent whole life in court in reading judgement , but do my dear friend was able to grasp ratio decidendi made in those judgemnent, otherwise, it was not expected from person of legal fraternity like you to make comment like- OYE Bewakoof . For your kind information Advocate for SpeakAsia has already discontinued his services once he came to realize SA working modus- operandi and no more fighting for his client SpeakAsia. All bank accounts of SA are already freezed. Let Wisdom prevail.
do not show your views that any company can run dont work on probability theory indian media personals are full of illitrate they need talent every news that you show aur any media are just baseless do some heavy reporting not chep reporting
do you really do any research on anyones business model it is not mlm speakasia is a totally a revolution this model will change the way of business and not ambani and birla can earn everyone should earn infact government should try these schemes and all of the reporters in any news channel plz recruit some knowledgable person
SpeakAsia is definitely an MLM case and a classic copycat case. Maybe be Nilay Singh is a member of SpeakAsia and hence the defender. Asking government to ban MLM is of no use since all their families are involved in one MLM business or the other and there are so many in India. Let the Blind Leading the Blind continue. Ultimately, the poor must get poorer and the rich must get richer. Thats the MLM result.
I am happy that Moneylife has taken steps to send a petition to the FM and others in the context of MLM and particularly Spaek Asia. While I laud the efforts of the team at Moneylife, I would like to provide you a gentle note that while action is being done from our end, advertising by SpaekAsia continues in the TV media, so damage is continuing. Can we please stop the damage via advertising medium since we are already enlightened on this subject. Thank you
Is this news bigger than 2G Scam, Honorable Shri Sai Baba's Demise, India Winning World Cup after many decades, Japan Tsunami, etc ???? that its being covered wid such a dedication.....come on people!!! The media doesnt have time to report out the daily woes of people, but SpeakAsia news is covered multiple times a day, same news being repeated for a week now.
Yes this is bigger news then what else you have described , since here money of 19 lac people of india is involved, whereas in those instance no real time money is involved. further those instances are of one time and are over but this scheme if not stopped timely, then continue to involve more people.
Money Life deserves gratitude for exposing this Scam.During debate the other day on "Headlines Today" Sucheta Ji rightly took credit for exposing the same of Speak Asia.
These company should not be banned bcoz neither people who have invested their money are child nor they r fool.So i agree that they shud come under the rules of RBI nd SEBI.Bcoz if these companies will be banned then wat about the investors money.
you people should warn the investors before investing.
Another Survey and MLM Company is offered by Prathibha Group, Surat being having 8 industries in their group. They entere into MLM sector with website marketviewonline.com. Is it safe r we should avoid it
I totally agree with you that all MLM Co.s should either be banned or brought under some Strict Regulator so that investors' benefits could be taken care. You can also add Instant Forex in the Defaulters List.
people who are investing their money with speak asia, are aware of what they are doing . why some people are creating problem for them. may 10% are fool but 20 million are not fool. they knows what should be done.
On your question -why some people are creating problem for them? because those who have already became member of SA are fooling more people on behalf of SpeakAsia to become future member, with a malafide intention so as to get their own money back and more money. And whom do you fooling is your own brother sister, uncle, relatives, friends and neibours. This fooling in legal terminology amount to cheating, since those members are propogating, endorsing SA scheme to those new members. [Cheating is a offence punishable U/s 417 & 420 of IPC for your kind information, please]. Hence if any new member who feels cheated may file police complaint not only against SA but also against his or her senior member /penalist who made him/her member.
All ponzi scheme investors believe in the scheme otherwise it would fail. The company has no revenue other then subscription charges. They mentioned that they have done surveys for ICICI Bank which the bank spoke person denied publicly. Once the ponzi scheme is closed its investors blame government for not protecting them.
What about Goldsukh. This is another big scam in Jaipur. They were raided by IT department last year which collected 29 Cr and is another bubble ready to bust. Can you expose them too?
flc online
ramsurvey
aviso pacific
Algulf
Spidy survey
green prithvi
elison.asia
hollywood survey
gb media
ukadworld
admatrix
in survey companies ke against kuch hoga ya yeh chalti rahengi
Great job Moneylife... please try to get all articles printed in print media too (in your magazine) so that more awareness is spread against these MLM schemes
If the regulators do anything meaningful, I will frankly be surprised. They love to put off everything till tomorrow. If they were alert, we should not have had these scams in the first place.
In the 80's the leasing cos used to announce incentives for fixed deposits in loud hoardings right outside the RBI building and the gentleman to whom we had brought out the risks, wanted us to 'bring it to his attention', by writing a letter!! Today, things have not changed at RBI. Sarkari babus, waiting to collect pension and in the meanwhile duck responsibilty as much as possible.
Just make sure that you understand the difference between MLM chain schmes and MLM distribution networks (such as Amway, Oriflame, Tupperware, Modicare). The latter are genuine businesses, if you study the business models carefully.
The major part of money is actually going to all the head honchos and RAJA babus who started the distribution scheme, read deeply about MLM chainschemes and distribution networks too and compare the percentage of the money share received from top to bottom in your trees or networks.
Dear friend when u have become fool by the companies like what u told, y r u blaming SpeakAsia. Media is showing baseless articles, and making people fool. come on yaar bring enough evidence to prove the SAOL a fraud and then comment.
I' ve lost huge money in similar firm called NANO FOREX offering 20% interset in five months and for a period of 24 months on the money invested. whom to contact ?
1. We are trying to spread the actual facts so that people can know the entire story before falling prey to such 'Get Rich Schemes'
2. Even though it has been rewarding, it can reach saturation at any moment and run away one day (like in Bangladesh)
3. Its not a new kind of Business, its just MLM with a new fake idea of money generation via Web-Survey
4. The major part of money is actually going to all the goons and RAJAs who started the ploy
5. 15 lacs people is a huge number and enough to put a stop to this menace
6. Journalism is Print and Media... Media is nothing but a corporate whore, but Print media, specially MoneyLife is like the Anna Hazare, which guides the ignorant (I WANNA BE RICH) Indians...
Hope you make good money in SA.
But at the same time, the earlier the truth comes out, the better it is
Its very simple to understand:
1. The MLM companies like SpeakAsia want you to make more and more members.
2. They use the money from new joinees to pay others ans keep the major part with themselves.
3. They pretend to give you some stupid survey, product etc and tell that this is what generates money (which they pay to you)
Now here are the validations:
1. Would any company like ICICI, Bata, Nestle etc pay Rs.500 for a survey to be done by a complete novice?
2. None of these companies are accepting of ever hiring Speak Asia's services.
3. No financial background of such companies.
4. Its operation is busted in other places like Bangladesh where they have reached ssaturation.
5. No operation in countries with strict financial laws like US,UK etc.
Rem one thing, you may like to join the ride, and it can be rewarding, but for how long, is the main question. This will go bust one day and majority of new joinees will be at loss.
So even if you want to join SA, use your leisure money, something you can afford to lose in a high risk and 'expected' high return...
Baaki koi nahi, sabko apna faisla lene ka poora haq hai. Also, MoneyLife is a very big name when in comes to warning investors, so their opinion should be taken seriously. Like me, I guess most of you too would have come across ML articles on SA by regularly visiting ML website. And we visit ML website because we have trusted it for long...
So guys, its a NO from me too, but you can take your pick
If ur company known about speakasia, so why ur company taken an action with speakasia. when more than 20 lakhs people invested in speakasia. its a fault by u & urs all media channels. its responsible of u & media to refund the money of 20 lakhs people. i heared some people filed a case to speakasia. so listen speakasians are not weak, and we are 20 lakhs people shoot a leagal action all the media channel & ur company as soon. so plz ready for legal action about u & all media channels as soon.
Hey comeon....give the media a break. Have you or other 19 lakh SAOL agents ever asked any media house whether you can invest your money in SAOL? Them why blame them for your stupid decision.. And when SAOL does not have any legal position in India, how can you threaten to take legal action....from Singapore may be?...hahahaha
Dude Nitin
Go and learn some english man!
Or better of, please write in Hindi...
You just gave great injuries to my eyes and mind after I read your STUPIDEST comments EVER!!!
So if your speakasia is already paying you or has already paid you then why are you crying here? Please go to your panelist or distributor or whatever. However if you have to take legal action then suggest you speak with enforcement directorate too . . .
Kudos for Money Life to send representatives to PM, FM and RBI. Well begun is half done, Its really a very good step taken by your ML Team, I m quite hopeful now that all these schems will either be banned or regulated in near future
Manoj Bhalla
Whatever the reason for SAOL is in picture, the concept that it brought is amazing and since all the 'panelist' are paid for more than 10 months now without any failuare. It showed its commitments towards its panelist. Now why to make stir? Is media making nonsence out of sence??? Why cant they understand new ways of busniess? I agree there are loopholes like money coming from foreign country. etc but as a concept, as a rule it seeems SAOL has done good and fair job with its panelist. They circulated the money by making the memberw within. Even though base is like MLM but it has good ends to not stopping like typical MLMs and people have accepted the concept whole heartly. Now who's what interest to stop it and sink the money of 15Lac people? Why? I dont have any respect to media now. They've lost trust!!! Journalism is becoming enemy of India.
@Nilesh
1. We are trying to spread the actual facts so that people can know the entire story before falling prey to such 'Get Rich Schemes'
2. Even though it has been rewarding, it can reach saturation at any moment and run away one day (like in Bangladesh)
3. Its not a new of Business, its just MLM with a new fake idea of money generation via Web-Survey
4. Money coming from foreign countries??? This is the most imaginative comment ever. The money is actually going to all the goons and RAJAs who started the ploy
5. 15 lacs people is a huge number and enough to put a stop to this menace
6. Journalism is Print and Media... Media is nothing but a corporate whore, but Print media, specially MoneyLife is like the Anna Hazare, which guides the ignorant (I WANNA BE RICH) Indians...
Hope you make good money in SA.
But at the same time, the earlier the truth comes out, the better it is
@Buzz, Hey Dude whatever hindrances u or ur gang of medias are trying to put on SAOL, we have crossed the bench mark of 2million yesterday. The propaganda u all created gave the company a huge TRP.The joinings were 3 lakhs in past 7 days which is again a record.So dude chill mar!!! Yeh saare 20 lakh log koi anpad ganwar nahi they jo kisike behkawe me aa gaye ho.
On the report above how shrewdly it is reported that "But it also refused to name a single client".
On the press conference itself the company was ready to show its clients list if the reporters were ready to sign the NDA.But why sud they??? unka masala jo khatam ho jata na.
Last but not the least Is this news bigger than 2G Scam, Honorable Shri Sai Baba's Demise, India Winning World Cup after many decades, Japan Tsunami, etc ???? that its being covered wid such a dedication.....come on people!!! The media doesnt have time to report out the daily woes of people, but SpeakAsia news is covered multiple times a day, same news being repeated for a week now.
Congratulations on the excellent coverage and investigation by the Moneylife team.
Please investigate other up and coming fraud schemes such as AdMatrix as well.
By the way, it is appalling to read shameless plugs by speakasia agents on a page that is exposing their nefarious activities.
good work money life.Keep it up. let us run a campaign against such companies on the net so that they are exposed.You should start a page on facebook also.
JP Morgan Loss: Were any laws broken?
When banks are in trouble, they often mislead the world about their financials. Maybe JPMorgan disclosed everything properly about its $2 billion loss, but that's what we need to determine.
4 doctors of Max Hospital held guilty of negligence; anxious father
Following the death of his daughter due to medical negligence in Delhi’s posh Max Hospital, the aggrieved father invoked 50 RTI applications in various departments to seek justice. Last week’s order by CIC Shailesh Gandhi provides some hope
‘Lucrative’ assignments: A Messy Saga
Top bureaucrats and chairmen of banks and public sector entities (barring a few honourable exceptions) are guilty of corruption and looting of public assets. However, their political godfathers ensure that they escape strict action
Harshad Mehta Scam: A Distorted Picture of 1992
Even after a 20-year effort, the special court is discussing the possibility of pushing the hearings. The only major beneficiaries have been India's lawyers, whose incomes rose by a factor of 10 or more
What's Hot Recent Additions
RIL does not hold stake in any media company – True or It may be true that on paper, RIL does not hold any stake in any media company, as the minister stated in Rajya Sabha. However, the Reliance group now openly controls Eenadu TV
Did New India overcharge lakhs of policyholders? – II New India Assurance admitted that a software glitch resulted in overcharging mediclaim premium, but has dragged its feet on providing information. It now says that it gave a wrong
Daily cleansing for the mind Breathe away to happiness and glory! Bath for the mind consists in daily replacing our negative thoughts like hatred greedy, jealousy, anger and pride with positive thoughts like
Did New India Assurance overcharge lakhs of mediclaim Is New India Assurance sitting on crores of extra premium collected due to a software glitch? It does not even know how many policyholders paid excess premium and is stonewalling
President Pratibha Patil’s luxurious home continues to The 2,42,000 sq ft of land in Pune returned by President Patil is to be ‘suitably’ used for an alternative purpose. Communication from the ministry of defence is
DISCLAIMER: This article is written purely in the public interest. While every attempt has been made to ensure that the information provided on this page is accurate, Moneywise Media Pvt Ltd and its group companies (together called as ‘Moneylife’) will not be held responsible for any claim, loss, damage or inconvenience caused as a result of any information within these pages or any information accessed through its site(s).