Leisure, Lifestyle & Wellness
Medical Astrology

A software that will tell you what kind of ailment you will have, based on your DNA! Is it scientific?

“Every man’s life lies within the present; for the past is spent and done with, and the future is uncertain.” — Marcus Aurelius

A few days ago, The Hindu reported on a medical horoscope available in a new software that is expected to be installed soon in all major hospitals. One has only to answer some questions and the software will predict your medical future accurately. This is not new. “Doctors have been predicting the unpredictable future of their patients all the time” felt WJ Firth, professor of physics at Strathclyde University in Glasgow, in the British Medical Journal in 1991.

Following similar advice, Angelina Jolie had her beautiful breasts removed, a couple of months ago, to avoid any future chance of her getting breast cancer based on her genetic data. Ultimately, science claims to have triumphed over nature in unravelling the secrets of the future against the natural law.

Why does nature intend to keep your future a secret? That is the only way a human being can be happy on this planet. Ignorance is bliss here. Imagine, for a minute, that the software declares that you will get cancer in the near future. Your life, from that time onwards, will be totally different and, for all you know, you might die of sheer fear of cancer.

When it comes to our poor village astrologer predicting people’s future, based on their horoscope, the rationalist ‘scientific’ community demonises him, in no uncertain terms. But we prefer a predictive software because it represents technological sophistication. The software is supposed to predict the future based on your genetic make-up, like the one Angelina Jolie experienced.

Curiously, not all the DNA in your chromosomes come from your evolutionary ancestors. Your DNA includes the genes from at least eight retroviruses and many other germ genes. At some point in human history, these genes were incorporated into human DNA. These perform important functions; yet, they are entirely alien to our genetic ancestry. There are more than 10 times the germ genes in your metagenome so that there is more bacterial life inside you than ‘human life’!

The software astrology is based on our genetic make-up as we are taught to believe that genes determine what each of us is like, physically; but genes are only a tiny part of our DNA! A large portion (97%) of our genes was thought to be junk, until now. We now realise that the process that goes on outside the genes—epigenetics—has a major role to play in our evolution and development. Otherwise, how can just 23,000 genes represent all that happens to us? The so-called junk (epigenetics) is as important as, if not more than, the known human genes.

The picture of the world we ‘see’ is also artificial. Our brains don’t produce an image the way a video camera works. Instead, the brain constructs a model of the world from the information provided by modules that measure light and shade, edges, curvature and so on. This also compensates for the rapid jerky movement of our eyes, the saccades. We have more than just five senses.

With all these new data accumulating from the new wisdom of quantum mechanics, the old idea of predicting the future from our genetic make-up, as they did in the case of Angelina Jolie, looks childish, to say the least. What worries me is that the new software astrology might do far more damage than poor village astrologers that rationalists cry hoarse about. I might now repeat my usual warning to the apparently healthy in society. Do not go to the hospital when you are healthy. You might get a wrong prediction of your future, thanks to the new software toy. Do see your doctor for any deviation in your health without fail and be an intelligent partner in your treatment process.

“In times of change, learners inherit the Earth, while the learned find themselves beautifully equipped to deal with a world that no longer exists.”— Eric Hoffer

Professor Dr BM Hegde, a Padma Bhushan awardee in 2010, is an MD, PhD, FRCP (London, Edinburgh, Glasgow & Dublin), FACC and FAMS.



Mahesh S Bhatt

3 years ago

There are Cosmic & Karmicvibrations we experience due to 9 Planets.

Sun,Moon & Earth's relative positioning brings about tidal energies in oceans which cover 71% of earth's area.

Humans also 70% fluid content in body hence scientifically prone to waves in emotions/creations etc.

Astrology is Science of Karmic influences on human soul which is energy which cannot be created nor destroyed but transformed.

Medical Astrology is small portion of the same.

Mahesh [email protected]


Suresh Ramasubramanian

In Reply to Mahesh S Bhatt 3 years ago

That is not "scientific" in that you won't find an iota of proof for that combination of assertions.


In Reply to Suresh Ramasubramanian 3 years ago

There are those who wish to pose as "rational" and "intelligent" with the clumsy use of the word "scientific". The rationale and intelligence within science is derived out of its ability to justify an argument, to merely oppose by stating something as unscientific is both petty and ignorant.

There are some amongst us here who hide an argument of nothing with the use of the word "scientific".


In Reply to Suresh Ramasubramanian 3 years ago

Mars is known as "Bhoomi Putra'(Son of earth). Latest pictures taken from the planet Mars suggest similarities between Earth and Mars.

How could our Rishis/Munis of days of yore find out that Mars has similarities with that of earth? Is it not amazing ?

Suresh Ramasubramanian

In Reply to MOHAN 3 years ago

Which latest pictures, and what specific "similarities", and quote just what which rishi or muni said about it.

I suppose such purveyors of superstition will have enthusiastic followers but I hardly expected to find articles of this poor quality in moneylife.


3 years ago

This article is very realistic and practical advice to people. Moneylife has indeed done a service by including this one.

As far as holding medical science in esteem or demonising astrology is concerned , both are wrong. For Medical science has gone no more than giving marginal relief and certainly offers no cure from most diseases or disorders , least of them being simple infections. Whereas astrology handles predictive part better in the interest of caution alone. Dr Hegde makes an interesting comparison that Preventive Health is only as effective a caution as astrology is. Don't follow either and live happily till such time it becomes unavoidable to see a Doctor.

What Dr Hegde has not mentioned is that people in the west find traditional medicine to be doing a lot more than allopathic medicine which emphasises on surgery as a solution to many ills. Yoga and ayurveda is a high end service today. Both certainly helps you enjoy life. That alone is the message.


Suresh Ramasubramanian

In Reply to krishna 3 years ago

There are superstitious people in the west too who believe in not vaccinating their kids (another thing dr Hegde advocated in a previous article), among other things.

Consult an astrologer to match horoscopes and fix dates for weddings, etc but if you trust them wih your life by asking them for medical decisions,well it is your life.

This article is completely unscientific,

Suresh Ramasubramanian

3 years ago

This is in bad taste, equating a case like Jolie's, where her mother died of breast cancer at an early age and where she too was, like her mother, genetically predisposed to it, with unscientific mumbo jumbo like astrology.

Moneylife is not doing its readers any kind of service by printing such articles. If such articles take their place alongside others that purport to offer financial literacy, I can only infer that the stock tips and market trends in other articles are also produced by consulting a jyotishi, checking for good omens at the time an IPO comes out etc.



In Reply to Suresh Ramasubramanian 3 years ago

Many years ago one day-trader went to an astrologer and asked whether it was good for him to do share trading. The old astrologer replied “Very good". Then he asked him whether he should go for "short or long". The old man who didn’t even heard of stock exchanges or share trading told him "you do whatever you want". Next day he went short and a few days later we learnt that the day-trader disappeared without a trace!!

Suresh Ramasubramanian

In Reply to MOHAN 3 years ago

Ho ho, I thought I was just cracking a joke but it looks like some people actually believe in it.

Rediff Money has this page for example .. http://money.rediff.com/tools/astrology/...


In Reply to Suresh Ramasubramanian 3 years ago

Whether Julie's grand mother also died of cancer ?. These are stupid assumptions made and now we see the results.

Even after doctors are sanctioned or arrested, Medicare keeps paying

A ProPublica analysis of recently released data shows that dozens of physicians who received payments from Medicare in 2012 had been kicked out of Medicaid, charged with fraud, or settled claims of overbilling Medicare itself.

This story was co-published with NPR

In August 2011, federal agents swept across the Detroit area, arresting doctors, pharmacists and other health professionals accused of running a massive scheme to defraud Medicare.

The following month, several of those arrested —including psychiatrist Mark Greenbain and podiatrist Anmy Tran — were suspended from billing the state's Medicaid program for the poor.

"Health care fraud steals funds from programs designed to benefit patients, and we all pay for it," U.S. Attorney Barbara McQuade said in a press release at the time of the arrests. "We hope that the strength of our efforts will have a deterrent effect."

But the indictment and Medicaid suspensions didn't deter Medicare from continuing to allow the doctors to treat elderly and disabled patients — and billing taxpayers for their services.

In 2012, Medicare paid Greenbain more than $862,000, according to newly released data on Medicare payments to physicians. Tran received $155,000.

Greenbain and Tran were among dozens of doctors identified by ProPublica who Medicare kept paying after they were suspended or terminated from state Medicaid programs, indicted or charged with fraud, or had settled civil allegations of submitting false claims to Medicare.

Outlays to these doctors amounted to more than $6 million in 2012, ProPublica's analysis shows. That's a small fraction of the $77 billion Medicare has publicly reported paying that year for doctors' visits and outpatient services in its Part B program, but it signifies a hole in regulators' ability to protect the program — and patients — against fraud and abuse, said current and former government officials and fraud experts.

The total dollars paid to sanctioned doctors is likely much higher. Only a handful of states post online the names of doctors terminated from Medicaid programs in a way that can be accurately matched to Medicare Part B payments.

"If you've been suspended or terminated in one of the federal programs...I would think that you'd be suspended in the other programs, just as a basis of good practice," said Louis Saccoccio, chief executive of the National Health Care Anti-Fraud Association.

Part B payments to doctors were released last week for the first time. A court injunction that had kept the information secret for 35 years was lifted last year as a result of a lawsuit by Dow Jones & Co., parent company of the Wall Street Journal.

But Medicare has long had access to the information. "They're the ones doing the paying," Saccoccio said.

Aaron Albright, a spokesman for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, said he could not discuss the status of individuals, such as Greenbain and Tran, both of whom were finally barred from billing Medicare this month.

By that time, Greenbain had pleaded guilty and been sentenced to four years in prison. Tran had been found guilty and trial and was sentenced to five years. She is appealing her conviction.

Albright said the Medicare payment data may not reflect money already recovered by his agency or held back from providers suspended from billing the program.

Preventing improper payments is a top priority for CMS, Albright said. The agency has employed new enrollment screening techniques to prevent high-risk providers from getting into the system and is using advanced data analytics to spot fraudulent billing before payments are made, he said. "Already, we have cracked down on tens of thousands health care providers suspected of Medicare fraud," he said in an email.

Medicare's fraud-fighting efforts have been criticized repeatedly in recent years. In an audit released last month, the inspector general of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services found that about one-third of states hadn't told CMS when they terminated providers from Medicaid and others had provided incomplete information, hobbling regulators' ability to flag sanctioned professionals.

In December, the inspector general faulted Medicare for not systematically reviewing the billings of the program's top-paid doctors and said it should be doing more to spot aberrant claims.

Last year, ProPublica reported that doctors who had been terminated from Medicaid or had been disciplined by state medical boards were able to continue prescribing medications to beneficiaries in Medicare's drug program, prompting Sen. Charles Grassley (R-Iowa) to push for better coordination.

Medicare has more direct responsibility for overseeing activities in Part B than in the drug program, which is administered by private insurers. The drug program doesn't even require that prescribers be enrolled in Medicare and payments go to pharmacies, not doctors. By contrast, in Part B, it's up to Medicare to monitor services and payments, which go to clinicians or their employers.

"There's been a disconnect between Medicaid and Medicare on problem providers," wrote Grassley, ranking Republican on the Senate Judiciary Committee, in an email to ProPublica. "The release of Medicare billing data should help force better communication between Medicaid and Medicare on these providers. The new transparency makes it harder to ignore when doctors who harm patients or defraud taxpayers in one program face no consequences in the other program."

Sen. Tom Carper, (D-Del.), chair of the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee, credited Medicare with ramping up efforts to verify the credentials of those treating its beneficiaries. "But there is still much work to be done," he said in a statement.

Among the physicians ProPublica found who continued to collect Medicare payments after being flagged by law enforcement or other oversight agencies:

Dr. Lawrence Eppelbaum, a Roswell, Ga., pain doctor convicted last year of inducing patients to be treated at his Atlanta pain clinic by paying their travel fees through a purported charity he controlled. He was indicted on the charges in March 2011, but Medicare paid him $500,000 to treat 80 patients the following year. This February, Eppelbaum was sentenced to 50 months in prison and fined $3.5 million. He is appealing.

In a sentencing memorandum, Eppelbaum's lawyer maintained that Medicare did not lose any money because of the doctor's conduct. "Virtually every patient would have received treatment somewhere, by some doctor," he wrote. "Thus, Medicare would have paid the exact same amount of money, albeit possibly to another provider."

Michigan ophthalmologist Matthew Burman was suspended by the state's Medicaid program in 2009 after he was convicted of a misdemeanor count of criminal sexual conduct arising from a patient's accusation against him. He subsequently surrendered his medical licenses in Texas and California and agreed not to activate his registration in New York. He was paid $379,000 by Medicare in 2012. (Medicare has not released payment data for prior years.)

Burman, who continues to practice in Michigan, said he could have re-enrolled in Medicaid but chose not to. "One has nothing to do with the other," he said. "I didn't violate any Medicare rules. Medicare has nothing to do with why I'm not a Medicaid provider."

Las Vegas pain doctor Steven Kozmary agreed in December 2011 to pay the federal government $1 million to settle health care fraud allegations involving Medicare and other programs. The government could have moved to terminate him from Medicare, according to the settlement. Instead, in 2012, Medicare paid him $563,000. He was disciplined by Nevada's medical board in 2013 related to the 2011 settlement. He did not return a phone call.

Louisville Dr. Steven Stern and his practice paid $350,000 to settle allegations of overbilling Medicare in September 2011. He and his practice were accused of overbilling Medicare for infusing Infliximab, a drug used to treat rheumatoid arthritis. Specifically, they were accused of splitting vials of the drug across multiple patients but billing as if a whole vial was used for each. In 2012, Stern received more than $3 million in payments from Medicare, including $2 million for infusing Infliximab. He did not return a phone call seeking comment.

Eight of 14 New Jersey health providers arrested in December 2011 on charges of receiving kickbacks for referring Medicare and Medicaid patients to a specific MRI center continued to be paid by Medicare in 2012. At the time of the arrests, Tom O'Donnell, special agent in charge for the HHS inspector general said, "The audacity of these physicians should offend honest taxpayers, especially at a time when our taxpayer resources are stretched thin."

Even a guilty plea sometimes wasn't enough for Medicare to cut off payments. Dr. Anthony Jase of New Orleans pleaded guilty to two counts of health care fraud in October 2011. He still collected $97,460 for Medicare billings in 2012. Last fall, he was sentenced to 15 months in prison and ordered to pay $360,293 in restitution.

"It certainly looks like there is a need for more attention," said Mark McClellan, former administrator at CMS who is now at the Brookings Institution. "One important consequence of the release of this information at the physician level is that it will lead to some further analysis and actions against these truly outlier physicians who are clearly billing improperly."

ProPublica's analysis also found payments to doctors who were subsequently barred from billing the program by the HHS inspector general, mostly because of fraud convictions. Medicare paid 135 of them more than $18 million in 2012, before they were kicked out.

Some doctors have been indicted post-2012, including Michigan oncologist Farid Fata, a Michigan oncologist who was paid $10 million in 2012, ranking him among Medicare's top-paid providers that year. Last year, Fata was accused of misdiagnosing patients with cancer so he could give them unnecessary, expensive treatments. Fata has pleaded not guilty; his lawyer did not respond to a request for comment.

In a conference call last week with reporters, CMS' principal deputy administrator Jonathan Blum said the agency knows it can do more to find fraud. "We know that there's waste in the system. We know that there's fraud in the system. We want the public's help" to review the physician payment data and report suspected wrongdoing.

Courtesy: ProPublica.org


Exporters diverting sugar in domestic markets?

Sugar exporters are reluctant to continue to export due to delay in getting the export subsidy of Rs3,333 per tonne. In fact, there are unconfirmed reports that some exporters, who have taken delivery, have diverted the goods to domestic market

The sugar industry is at cross-roads today. The whole sale price of sugar has gone down to be between Rs31.50 and Rs32.50 per kilogram and in many super market chains, if one buys on a "combo" basis, the consumer may get sugar at Rs31/kg.


On the whole the sugar industry - mills, farmers, cooperatives have been facing trouble since the last season. The sugar industry had huge arrears to pay to farmers, their cooperatives, transporters and the agricultural minister Sharad Pawar sought the government to give interest free loans to sugar mills to tide over the difficult situation.


While speaking at the 79th AGM of Indian Sugar Mills Association (ISMA), its chairman Srinivasan pleaded to the government to increase import duty on sugar to 40% from 15% and at the same time advised the government to create a strategic reserve of 2 million tonnes, use it in public distribution systems (PDS) and stabilise the market price beside setting a target of 4 million tonnes of raw sugar for export.


Apart from soft loans, an export subsidy of Rs3,333 per tonne was finally announced. Despite hiccups, so far, 1.45 million tonnes of sugar have been exported but the delay in getting the subsidy is making exporters reluctant to continue. In fact, there are unconfirmed reports that some exporters who have taken delivery have diverted the goods to the domestic market.


Meantime, global prices have also come down and reports on El Nino has been appearing in the press all over the world, because the rainfall pattern in South America has also been abnormal and weather bureaus are watching the situation in the Pacific carefully. The Indian Meteorological Department (IMD) is also of the opinion that this El Nino disturbance (intensity is not yet known) may affect our agricultural plans.


On the meagre subsidy, during recent WTO meet, Australia, Brazil and US raised objections and sought the Indian government to roll over its plan, as they felt, this subsidy (of Rs3,333 per tonne) would distort the global trade! Thankfully, it was clarified that this meagre subsidy was given to overcome some domestic problems faced by the industry and, as our own export was too small compared to the giants in the trade, it really would not make a dent in the international trade.


The sugar industry has not paid serious attention to the question of producing ethanol despite the mandatory 5% blending that the government has instituted. This has to progressively increase to 20% by 2017 when this move would bring in substantial saving in fuel imports. So far, only UP, Karnataka and a few depots in Maharashtra have taken this ethanol use seriously and have reached a 10% blending.


Realising the importance of import savings in this manner, the Inter-Ministerial Group (IMG) has now decided to revise the formula, which was used to arrive at the bench mark price of ethanol, which is currently Rs44 per litre. The revised formula is likely to be average refinery transfer price (RTP) for the previous financial year (or the cost of petrol to the oil marketing companies). This formula is likely to fetch an additional Re1 or Rs2 for the mills while the sugar industry expects this to be actually increased to Rs5 per litre! This again, is a decision that the new government has to take.


If the government is serious to introduce ethanol and reach the target of blending up to 20%, then it is imperative that directives are given to oil marketing companies (OMCs) to call for the tenders well in time and give priority to suppliers. As per the last report 65 crore litres of ethanol have been offered and only 31.55 crore litres have been lifted by them. This means OMCs are also not taking this matter seriously and a government directive to ensure increased acceptance of ethanol would make the project successful.


(AK Ramdas has worked with the Engineering Export Promotion Council of the ministry of commerce. He was also associated with various committees of the Council. His international career took him to places like Beirut, Kuwait and Dubai at a time when these were small trading outposts; and later to the US.)


We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)