MCX price trends

Premium Content
Monthly Digital Access

Subscribe

Already A Subscriber?
Login
Yearly Digital+Print Access

Subscribe

Moneylife Magazine Subscriber or MSSN member?
Login

Yearly Subscriber Login

Enter the mail id that you want to use & click on Go. We will send you a link to your email for verficiation
Commodity trends

Soybean
The export of soymeal during April 2013 was 0.1 million tonnes compared to 0.33...

Premium Content
Monthly Digital Access

Subscribe

Already A Subscriber?
Login
Yearly Digital+Print Access

Subscribe

Moneylife Magazine Subscriber or MSSN member?
Login

Yearly Subscriber Login

Enter the mail id that you want to use & click on Go. We will send you a link to your email for verficiation
Aruna Roy quits NAC; praises Sonia, blames PM

While profusely thanking Sonia Gandhi-led NAC, the social activist criticised Manmohan Singh for rejecting minimum wages under MNREGA and his government for failing to pass several money-guzzling schemes that would have put tremendous strain on the fiscal situation. Ms Roy has, of course, always been completely silent about large scale economic mismanagement and corruption that causes inflation and hurts the poorest of the poor


Social activist Aruna Roy, best known as a prominent leader of the Right to Information movement, which led to the enactment of the Right to Information (RTI) Act in 2005, has decided not to continue working as a member of the National Advisory Committee (NAC).

 

Ms Roy has written to UPA chairperson Sonia Gandhi requesting that she should not be considered for another term of NAC and Ms Gandhi has accepted the request. Ms Roy’s term as member of NAC comes to an end on 31st May.

 

In the letter the social activist, has recorded her ‘deep appreciation’ and ‘gratitude’ for Ms Gandhi and chosen to criticise Prime Minister (PM) Manmohan Singh for slow progress of some of the money-guzzling schemes of the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) government and also for opposing minimum wages to workers under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act.

 

Ms Roy had questioned the rejection of recommendation of the NAC by the PM. She said, "I do believe that it is extremely unfortunate the Prime Minister rejected the NAC recommendations on payment of minimum wages to workers under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) and chose instead to appeal the Karnataka High Court judgment ordering the payment of minimum wages to workers under the MGNREGA. More distressing is the Government's refusal to pay minimum wages even after the Supreme Court refused to stay the Karnataka High Court judgment. It is difficult to understand how a country like India can deny the payment of minimum wages and still makes claims of inclusive growth. However, I realise that this effort to persuade the Government to respect the minimum wages law must now continue outside the NAC."

 

Highlighting the role of NAC, she said the NAC working group on implementation of flagship programmes took up several issues related to implementation of the MGNREGA.

 

“The recommendations of the working group were sent to the Ministry, which has set up a programme advisory group to oversee implementation of these recommendations and the new guidelines that have been issued by the Rural Development Ministry. Despite its contribution to changing the lives of the rural poor, implementation of this crucial flagship programme remains a challenge,” she said.

 

She also criticised the UPA government for not getting passed the Food Security Bill, Lok Pal Bill, Grievance Redress Bill, Whistleblower protection Bill.

 

Here is the letter sent by Ms Roy to Ms Gandhi...

 

To,

Mrs. Sonia Gandhi

Chairperson NAC

Motilal Nehru Marg,

New Delhi                                                                                                          11th May 2013

 

Dear Mrs Gandhi,

This is in continuation of the conversation we had some time ago, when I had requested that I not be considered for another term in the NAC. I am grateful for your accepting my request, while assuring your continued support to campaigns for social sector causes being taken up outside the NAC.
 

While the NAC has dealt with many important issues over the last year, I would like to take this opportunity to record my appreciation for issues taken up by the working group I co-ordinated. These issues have been processed by the NAC and have been sent to Government for necessary action.
 

The Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA): The NAC working group on implementation of flagship programmes took up several issues related to implementation of the MGNREGA. The recommendations of the working group were sent to the Ministry, which has set up a programme advisory group to oversee implementation of these recommendations and the new guidelines that have been issued by the MoRD. Despite its contribution to changing the lives of the rural poor, implementation of this crucial flagship programme remains a challenge. There is a huge group of MGNREGA beneficiaries who are critical, but supportive of the law. They are losing public and political space to a small, vocal, and powerful minority determined to undermine the basic objectives of the MGNREGA. I feel it is time to concentrate on building peoples campaigns for effective mobilisation around the MGNREGA. Hopefully, the measures initiated by the Ministry will provide support to these efforts, and the MGNREGA will come closer to achieving its true potential.
 

I do believe that it is extremely unfortunate the Prime Minister rejected the NAC recommendations on payment of minimum wages to MGNREGA workers and chose instead to appeal the Karnataka High Court judgment ordering the payment of minimum wages to MGNREGA workers. Even more distressing is the Government’s refusal to pay minimum wages even after the Supreme Court refused to stay the Karnataka High Court judgment. It is difficult to understand how a country like India can deny the payment of minimum wages and still makes claims of inclusive growth. However, I realise that this effort to persuade the Government to respect the minimum wages law must now continue outside the NAC.   
 

Pre Legislative Process It is a matter of great significance that the NAC has approved a pre legislative consultative process and will send it to Government for necessary action. In my opinion, the NAC is itself a kind of pre legislative body that has benefited immensely from the public consultations it has held. The functioning of the Justice J S Verma Committee, and its celebrated report were also an outcome of a pre legislative consultative process. The NAC recommendations on this issue, are the beginnings of what will hopefully grow into a more robust and detailed process of public consultation. Nevertheless, there can be no doubt that mandatory public consultation and engagement is one of the most important facets of a participatory democracy. Indian Democracy will certainly be strengthened, if the NAC recommendations are acted upon by Government.
 

The recent record of Parliament on debating policy and legislation underscores the need for this process. Given the hunger and malnutrition scenario in the country, a food security Bill should have been debated and passed by Parliament by now. There has been extensive and healthy debate within the NAC as well as in the public domain on the provisions of the Bill, making it clear that if Parliament were to take it up, it would most likely result in robust and well supported legislation. While questions of poor delivery of social sector programmes continue to plague us, the debates over the past two years have given us a very sound set of measures which should be enacted without delay.
 

The Working Group on Transparency and Accountability also took up a number of accountability legislations, including the Lok Pal, Grievance Redress Bill, Whistleblower protection Bill etc albeit for a short period of time. Many of those legislations have been through Parliamentary committees and now urgently need to be enacted.  The campaign to have these legislations enacted, and peoples monitoring mechanisms such as social audits, must be strengthened. I feel the immediate enactment of these measures is critical to the future of democratic governance in India. The primary need is to act, and I realise once again that the place where I now need to concentrate my energies is outside the NAC.
 

I would like to place on record my gratitude and appreciation to you, and other members of the NAC for the opportunity I have been given to pursue causes of the poor and marginalised, as well as issues related to transparency, accountability, and democratic governance. I have had in the NAC a very competent and capable set of colleagues who extended the critical, analytical support needed to turn ideas that originate in peoples campaigns and movements, into workable draft policy initiatives.
 

I would also like to record my deep appreciation of the democratic freedom I enjoyed as a member of the NAC. I can say with absolute certainty, that I have expressed my views fully and openly. It has never been even mildly suggested by you as the Chair, that I curtail my expression either within, or outside the NAC. This has given me the space to finish my term with the NAC, with the confidence that I contributed my best to its functioning; without intellectual compromise, or negatively affecting my role outside.
 

I look forward to a continued association with you, and all the members of the NAC, and to petitioning the NAC from the outside!
 

With many thanks
 

and
 

With warm personal  regards,

Yours sincerely,

Aruna

User

COMMENTS

ABHA CHAWLA MOHANTY

4 years ago

MADAM ARUNA ROY....QUITTING NEEDS NO "EULOGY"....YOU HAVE ASSERTED,,,,GREAT!

jaykayess

4 years ago

Let's forget about Manmohan's Singh performance as a PM for just a minute, and focus on the economics of the issue.

Does Aruna Roy think she is a better economist than Manmohan Singh???

After all, it is essentially Manmohan Singh's single-handed efforts of liberalization in the early 1990's (as FM) that has created rapid growth - otherwise we would be still stuck at 2-3% annual growth rates.

What does Aruna Roy mean by "inclusive growth"? Is she alleging that India's economic growth after liberalization has NOT been inclusive? Is she blind to the fact that India's poverty rate has halved after liberalization-led growth? It has dropped from 1 in 2 people to 1 in 4 people below the poverty line.

Wake up, Madame Roy, and come out of your privileged position in the NAC ivory tower and get some "real" economics into your thinking.

A S Bhat

4 years ago

The poor PM is guided entirely by Soniaji. So why blame PM and not Soniaji?

REPLY

Dayananda Kamath k

In Reply to A S Bhat 4 years ago

bahu hai dowry harrasment ka case lag sakta hai

MOHAN

4 years ago

.


She will keep on praising Madam Soniaji. She knows very well that political career of MMS is about to be ended soon.

Very intelligent lady ! indeed !!

Dayananda Kamath k

4 years ago

one of the main reason for india's plight today is extending mnrega to all districts at the instance of rahul gandhi, without assessing the schemes performance in pilot districts selected. govt has thrown the money at ngo s without accountability.nor any economic assets created commensurate with the amount spent. they won the election from this scheme and money from the scheme. this year they are bringing direct payment of subsidies. when you can monitor subsidy to 100 accounts how you can monitor crores of account. it is a safe guarding system to cover up so that no body can catch them for miss management. at a later date. justification is rajiv gandhi statement that only 15% of govt subsidy reaches the beneficiaries. for the inefficiencies of your policy and implementation you are gain burdening the country. f

SuchindranathAiyerS

4 years ago

If you think this is funny, you should see the kind of JNU/IIC/Feminists types who, from the "China Study Group", advise SoniaG Gandhi Saheb on how to retreat before China!

REPLY

Krishnan

In Reply to SuchindranathAiyerS 4 years ago

I agree with the comments of Suchindranath Aiyer. This is precisely is the problem with our foreign policy, outsourced to day dreamers.

suresh hegde

4 years ago

I think raj ahluwalia has made fair comments. PM's action can not be termed as oppose to poor or downtrodden portion of society. The issue is before Hon'ble Courts. Let us wait for outcome.

suresh hegde

4 years ago

I think raj ahluwalia has made fair comments. PM's action can not be termed as oppose to poor or downtrodden portion of society. The issue is before Hon'ble Courts. Let us wait for outcome.

Narain Jagirdar

4 years ago

I welcome Ms Aruna Roy's decision and wish other members of the NAC too resign and the body is wound up so that the nation can stop the drain of people's money through hare brained ideas parading as 'inclusive' growth but in practice are channels for massive corruption by the party faithfuls.

Dipak Chatterjee

4 years ago

IT IS SAD NEWS THAT NAC MEMBER IS RESIGNED, OTHERS MEMBER OF NAC ALSO FOLLOW THE PATH OF ARUNA ROY, I KNOW SOME MEMBERS ONLY POLITICAL OPPORTUNIST PEOPLE THEY HAVE NOT DONE ANY REMARKABLE WORK ONLY NAME. MRS SONIA GANDHI MUST BE REMOVED THAT TYPE OF PERSON FROM PANEL(NAC)
DR. DIPAK CHATTERJEE
MUMBAI

Krishnan

4 years ago

What a sad state of the country where the so called social scientists and ex-bureaucrats, stoop so low in sycophancy and lack of comprehension of the damage harebrained scheme to the economy.No word on corruption and stashed black money in tax havens.

raj ahluwalia

4 years ago

Aruna Roy's resignation from the NAC...the Best thing to happen to the Nation...
NAREGA does not make GOI the 'employer' in the normal sense of the word...It is more like social security...and lots of people are drawing it without doing any work...
How can you ask GOI to spend the money it has not got...Nothing comes from Nothing and Nother ever goes...
Also robbing a small tax paying minority to pay those who dont contribute + a Massive Leakage of Funds..
KBD..Kiss ke Baap Ki Diwali

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.
  Loading...
Close

To continue


Please
Sign Up or Sign In
with

Email
Close

To continue


Please
Sign Up or Sign In
with

Email

BUY NOW

The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)