Right to Information
Maharashtra's 84 VIPs are guarded by 812 personnel, reveals RTI

Sushilkumar Shinde and his family is the topmost VIP family in the state with 66 security personnel deployed to protect them, reveals a reply received under the RTI

About 812 police officers and security personnel have been deployed for the security of 84 VIPs in Maharashtra, reveals a reply received under the Right to Information (RTI). Out of these, 52 personnel are used to provide protection to union home minister Sushilkumar Shinde and his daughter, Praniti, who is also a member of legislative assembly (MLA).


According to the information received by Pune-based RTI activist Vihar Dhurve, Shinde and his daughter Praniti have been accorded Z-Plus security, and have a total of 52 security personnel guarding them, while the union home minister's wife Ujwala Shinde has been granted a Y-category security and has a total of 14 personnel for her security.


The 12 VIPs that are entitled to Z-plus category security include Maharashtra governor K Sankaranarayanan, Maharashtra chief minister Prithviraj Chavan, deputy chief minister Ajit Pawar, home minister RR Patil and union agriculture minister Sharad Pawar.


While there are a total of 46 security personnel guarding Chavan, there are 31 for Ajit Pawar. Minister for public works department (PWD), Chhagan Bhujbal is guarded by 25 security personnel, the RTI reveals.


Maharashtra's former chief minister Ashok Chavan, Shiv Sena president Uddhav Thackeray, Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) chief Raj Thackeray and Mumbai police commissioner Rakesh Maria are among the 18 persons that have been granted Z-category security and have 15-22 personnel guarding them.


Dhurve, through his RTI sought to know the total number of police and security force deployed for the protection of political and non-political VIPs in Maharashtra.



Capt Edgar Sylva

3 years ago

I live on the same street as Shahrukh Khan and would like to know how many security & police force personnel are deployed for his & his family protection- including vehicles, etc.
I believe that he paysa pittance to the Govt for this protection but the Govt is totally immune to the inconvenience that these actors & actresses cause to the residents of the area with traffic jams and crowds standing on the middle of the road.
B.J.Road/ H.K.Bhabha Road as a good examle with not a single traffic policeman around (except the constable sitting in the towing van picking up vehicles indiscriminately from even parking areas on the road.
(when I asked him lately about traffic control, he told me it is not his job??)

Eicher Motors Q1 net profit jumps 65% on robust sales

Eicher Motors reported first quarter net profit to Rs160.62 crore on robust sales growth of its Royal Enfield Motorcycle business and exports

Eicher Motors Ltd, the producer of iconic ‘Royal Enfield’ or Bullet brand motorcycles in India, recorded a higher first quarter net profit on robust sales growth in its motorcycle business and exports.


For the quarter to end-March, the trucks, buses and two-wheelers manufacturer, said its stand alone net profit rose 65% to Rs160.62 crore from Rs97.20 crore while total revenues, including sales, increased 79% to Rs720.59 crore from Rs401.99 crore, same period last year.

Eicher Motors’ motorcycle business unit recorded growth of 85% during the first quarter on record sales of 64,268 units of Royal Enfield from 34,736 units, same period year ago.

While the industry continues to decline, Royal Enfield continues to perform exceptionally well posting record sales and production numbers this quarter and working its way to become a leader in the global mid-sized motorcycling industry. We had a very strong volume growth this quarter and we do continue maintain an extremely healthy order book,” said, Siddhartha Lal, managing director & chief executive officer, Eicher Motors.

However, Eicher Motors commercial vehicle business sales remain negative during the quarter due to slowdown in auto industry. Its heavy duty truck sales fell by 32.7% to 1,420 units, light and medium duty trucks by 29.1% to 5,413 units and buses by 15% to 1,859 units respectively. Its Volvo truck sales grew 18.4% to 167 units from 141 units a year ago period. Its exports grew 148.2% to 1,122 units from 452 a year ago period.

The commercial vehicle industry continues to battle the enormous downturn that has been affecting this sector for more than 30 months now. The first quarter of 2014 has been particularly tough that saw the domestic industry (5 tonne and above) decline by 18.3%. Despite tough conditions, VECV has continued to perform well,” said Mr Lal.

On 14th March, Eicher Motors has declared final dividend of Rs30 per share.

Eicher Motors shares hits an all time high of Rs6,756 on 9th May on BSE.

At 2.19pm Monday, Either Motors was trading 1.1% up at Rs6,544 on the BSE, while the S&P BSE Sensex was up 2.2% at 23,494.

For more stock results, check out this page


Conned Indian Financial Consumer

As these examples from Moneylife Foundation’s Helpline show, the consumer has little chance of being treated fairly by companies, regulators and intermediaries

Mr Mallick from Sambalpur in Orissa runs an NGO. He has 17 insurance policies, sold to him by eight banks through their Bankassurance partners, with large premiums. He claims to have borrowed funds from various banks for a project (which we gather involves lending to the rural poor like a banking correspondent) and was persuaded to buy insurance policies. Since Mr Mallick’s English is poor, it is not clear if there was coercion; he alleges ‘gross mis-selling’.

In most cases, he was not able to pay anything after the first premium. The banks involved in the mis-selling include Union Bank of India (sold him SUD Life Insurance), Punjab National Bank (sold him Metlife India Insurance), HDFC Bank (sold him three policies of HDFC Standard Life), Axis Bank (Bajaj Alliance Life Insurance), Oriental Bank of Commerce (Canara HSBC Life Insurance), Karnataka Bank (two policies of Aviva Life Insurance), IDBI Bank (two policies of IDBI Federal Life Insurance Co) and ICICI Bank (five policies of ICICI Pru Life Insurance). There is also a TATA AIG policy.

The premium figures he refers to are so huge, that I don’t want to mention them here them without looking at the policy documents. Did he buy policies to get loans? A State Bank of India official has sent me a list of bankers who coerce SME borrowers to buy insurance policies simply to process loans.

The story is repeated at all nationalised banks, because the perks for such sales include foreign junkets, commissions, conveyance and no transfers. And this is happening even at the level of chief general managers!

Mr Mallick is in a financial mess. Banks have collected their commissions and the insurers are foreclosing the policies because he can’t pay. Mr Mallick is either completely financially illiterate, or, as he says, a victim of ‘gross mis-selling’. Unfortunately, at present, RBI’s regulatory infrastructure has absolutely no sympathy for people like Mr Mallick. If he writes to RBI’s banking ombudsman (BO), his case will be dismissed without even the right to appeal, as the BO had done in Suchitra Krishnamoorthi’s case and those of countless others. All that the BO will ask is whether or not he had signed the insurance documents. If the answer is yes, the case is dismissed.

The real question is: Why would anyone, in his right senses, buy 17 insurance policies and commit to the payment of such high premiums? We believe he was made false promises by his bankers, taking advantage of his financial illiteracy. Like Suchitra Krishnamoothi, he too made the mistake of trusting his bankers and did not suspect that they would mislead him.

Mr Mallick is not alone. There is Mr Rakshit, a 74-year old marine engineer, who is HSBC’s customer since 1963. His funds with the Bank exceeded Rs72 lakh; a big chunk was invested in mutual funds, under the advice of a fund manager. After this ‘advice’ led to a Rs25-lakh loss in 2010, he asked that the money be invested in safer fixed deposits. But that led to the real loot.

Mr Rakshit was apparently persuaded to write cheques totalling Rs44 lakh in the name of Sarogi Sales Corporation, a firm belonging to his relationship manager’s father. Another Rs11.5 lakh went to the relationship manager’s mother. He was further conned into transferring a flat to the relationship manager’s family, complete with registration deed (the family claims it was under the guise of a tenancy deed).

Mr Rakshit’s family approached RBI for help, but HSBC neatly shifted the onus of explaining the weird transactions on to the senior citizen and termed it a private matter between the two. Why would a senior citizen transfer money and assets to his bank manager? Shouldn’t the Bank or the employee explain? But RBI does not seem to be pushing HSBC hard enough probably because there was no NGO to keep up the pressure. The Rakshits have filed a civil and criminal case in Kolkata and, given our slow judicial system, it is advantage HSBC at the moment.
Then there is professor Tiwari from Guwahati who has written to us about being ‘mis-sold’ 21 policies by HDFC Life, Reliance Life Insurance and Birla Sunlife. Thanks to the efforts of Moneylife Foundation’s Insurance Helpline, and our expert Raj Pradhan, Mr Tiwari got back Rs5.1 lakh from Reliance Life Insurance and HDFC Life Insurance.

We are now attempting to get a more recalcitrant Birla Sunlife, which has sold him insurance in identical circumstances, to refund his money. Again, why would a man need 21 insurance policies? He was clearly made to believe he was buying an investment product. Mr Tiwari of Guwahati heard about resource-crunched, Moneylife Foundation through Uday Dhoot and Rahul Agarwal, two insurance intermediaries.

They are members of the Council for Financial Planners (COFP), one of the many bodies floated by financial intermediaries to push their agenda. We assume, in good faith, that
Mr Dhoot and Mr Agarwal, referred Mr Tiwari to Moneylife Foundation only after failing to get him a refund themselves. Both are at pains to say that Mr Tiwari is not their client, but won’t say who sold him 21 insurance policies.

Now here is the irony. While Mr Dhoot and Mr Agarwal got Moneylife Foundation working hard for Mr Tiwari’s refund, they were themselves busy with a COFP ‘convention’ fully funded by top mutual fund companies of the very same groups that ‘mis sold’ the policies—Birla Sunlife, HDFC Mutual Fund and Reliance Mutual Fund—at a five-star venue in Bengaluru.

Since the market regulator mandates mutual funds to spend a chunk of money on enhancing ‘financial literacy’, much of this spending goes for lavish conventions by financial intermediaries rather than consumers of financial services who need the literacy effort.

In fact, there is hardly any financial support to those involved in real advocacy, grievance redress and education efforts, because activist organisations hurt the interest of these financial service providers. Regulators, as well as the financial services industry, are fully aware of this hypocrisy; but large sums of money continue to be funnelled into gratification efforts in the name of promoting financial literacy.

Moneylife Foundation took up the issue of mis-selling of third-party financial products with RBI governor, Dr Raghuram Rajan. We are most upbeat that Dr Rajan, once he applies his mind to the issue, will begin to see how people’s finances are decimated by bankers who prey on their ‘trust’.

We are especially heartened by the speed with which he has directed banks not to levy penalties for failure to maintain minimum balances on inoperative accounts. He has also implemented the long-pending demand to scrap foreclosure charges/ pre-payment penalties on all floating rate term loans sanctioned to individual borrowers, through a directive.

At the time of our meeting, banks and intermediaries seem to have made the case that an outright ban on sale of third-party products would cause ‘the pendulum to swing too far’ against banks.

He was also under the impression that RBI meticulously studies thousands of complaints that it receives and acts in the interest of consumers. The truth is that the pendulum is stuck at the other end and the global move towards treating customers fairly has not gone beyond lip-service in India.

Who better to endorse this than Dr KC Chakrabarty, the former deputy governor, who never failed to say that it took years to implement even obvious decisions in India? Personally, I see the 6th and 7th May directives as a signal that Dr Rajan is beginning to take a hard look at how customers are treated.

RBI is focused on financial inclusion, but without a clear consumer protection framework which spells out accountability and punishment. As a result, every effort to bring in new customers will only lead to more disenchantment.

Sucheta Dalal is the managing editor of Moneylife. She was awarded the Padma Shri in 2006 for her outstanding contribution to journalism. She can be reached at [email protected]



u k saluja

3 years ago

I would like to bring to your kind information that many companies from Mumbai/Indore like AVON Corporation Ltd., Micro Technologies India Ltd. and Plethico Pharmaceuticals have been asking for fixed deposits which were being promoted by Bajaj Capital Limited in Delhi/NCR. All these three companies are not paying back money to their matured fd holders on due dates and emails/telephone calls made to them are either not replied or absurd committments are made. Bajaj Capital has also washed their hands off the responsibility and advised us to file complaints to CLB who have already issued many orders in January and March 2014 to these companies to payback to their fdholders who had filed cases earlier. This is a scam being played in the financial capital of the country and old and infirm are being taken for a ride by promoters of these companies. Implementation of orders issued by CLB is also extremely slow and/or payments delayed on one or the other pretext. It would be appreciated if moneylife could bring managements of these companies on board to redress grievances of their stakeholders on priority and do a great service to the senior citizens/housewives and sick people. Thanks.

Dinesh Acharya

3 years ago

I have utmost respect for the untiring efforts you and your foundation put to help people. In the article you have mentioned one person as a marine engineer. Mariners are one of the most easy prey for agents. Totally out of touch with the real world and trustworthy and flush with funds.


3 years ago

Its is the mistake of RBI to permit banks to sell insurance policies.And you will be surprised to know that there is a quarterly target of insurance business for staff in the banks. If they don't perform they are sacked & if they perform they are promoted & clients are taken for a ride.RBI should make the banks responsible for non-payment of renewals and should force bank to pay renewals from the profits of the bank as its a clear case of MIS-SELLING to Mr Mallick of Sambalpur.

jaideep shirali

3 years ago

Mis-selling of financial products is rampant, partly due to the ignorance of the banks themselves. Shop keeper insurance policy being used to insure a factory is an example,used because the shopkeeper policy is cheaper. Part of the problem lies with customers, who haggle with a vegetable vendor for a Rs. 5 discount, but sign a form and a Rs.50,000 cheque with almost no questions. We seem to have this, " I do not have the time, just tell me where to sign", approach regarding investments. Schemes which promise, say 27% p.a. when bank FDs are at 9 % p.a. should raise red flags, but we have people merrily investing and then saying RBI/ SEBI should protect them. I do not understand how we are so casual with our own money. We must develop a habit of asking many questions, before we sign an investment form and cheque, it's finally our money.


NAGARAJ Tirumani Vemula

In Reply to jaideep shirali 3 years ago

You are right. Ignorance is a bliss for deceivers.

Yerram Raju Behara

3 years ago

This is no strange news. Banks have been mis-selling insurance products ever since their introduction. 17 policies in one name and on inter-connected platforms and are these beyond the audit trail? RBI and IRDA ARE MUTE SPECTATORS. It is time such things are fought to the last breath by MLF and ensure an exemplary punishment by way of penalties to the institutions apart from compensation to the aggrieved.

Joseph Korah

3 years ago

Such a sad state of affairs especially to see how the Old and Infirm are being looted by these Bank Managers by miss-selling Insurance Policies. clearly no one would need 17 and 21 Insurance Policies. Hats off to Money Life foundation and its team in highlighting such issues and bringing it to the public. Only hope for the people is immediate action from the RBI Governor Dr. Rajan to set right these matters.

Mohan Bhaya

3 years ago

I wish we had 1000 Sucheta's in our stupid country. We need to caution Old and infirm to beware of the trap, Stock Broking co:s have laid to rob Old and infirm, of their savings.The modus operandi is they make the Old, to sign for F&O, on totally false assurances.Once the Old man falls in the Trap, they waste no time to rob him off his savings. The Old and Infirm can not even fight back and Sebi, instead of being a Police acts like a Post Office.


3 years ago

Can we blame investors for not investing in financial products and for investing in land if such blatant mis-selling happens repeatedly?

These entire issues stem from the fact that incentive system is skewed towards upfront payment. As long as the intermediary keeps on getting his commission / remuneration without having to worry about performance of client’s money, there will be no solution for mis-selling.

Do we need so many regulations and rules if “only trail commission” is adopted across the financial products? Wouldn’t financial services be a more respectable industry then?

Mr.Rakshit’s case is an extreme one and there should be a mechanism to deal with such matters within the regulatory frame work if there is a prima facie evidence of mis-use of one’s position in a bank . The basic fact is Mr.Rakshit might not have trusted so blindly had it not been a bank employee.


3 years ago

Financial conning: Follows in the footsteps of Indian Governance, the operative leit motif of which is CONNING:

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)