Loans: Strictures against Mahindra Finance

N ational Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission passed strictures against Mahindra Finance for using its financial muscle to delay refund to a customer, Sneha Waikul, in a car loan case.

Sneha Waikul had applied for a loan from Mahindra & Mahindra Finance Services to purchase a car. The company asked her to sign on a blank paper while applying for the loan. Later, Rs2.84 lakh was sanctioned, to be repaid in 36 equated monthly instalments of Rs10,170 each, for which post-dated cheques were obtained by the company. Ms Waikul paid 17 instalments amounting to Rs1,72,809, after which there was a default in repayment. So the company forcibly seized the car through its ‘recovery agents’, without giving a notice. Ms Waikul then contacted Mahindra Finance and was asked to clear the entire outstanding loan at one go by paying Rs2,13,798. Ms Waikul then filed a complaint before the Central Mumbai District Forum. The company contested it.


The Mumbai District Consumer Forum directed Mahindra Finance to refund Rs1,72,809 paid by Ms Waikul, along with 9% interest from 3 December 2009, till repayment, and awarded costs of Rs5,000. The company appealed to the Maharashtra State Commission but the appeal was dismissed.


Mahindra Finance then filed a revision petition before the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission which directed the company to first pay Rs7,000 to enable Ms Waikul to make arrangements to contest the revision. The Commission also passed strictures against Mahindra Finance for using its ‘financial muscle’ to delay the matter, and dismissed the revision with further costs of Rs25,000 payable by the company to Ms Waikul.


Banking: RBI Nod to Self-attestation of Documents

The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) relaxed KYC (know your customer) norms allowing self-certification of documents needed for opening bank accounts. RBI has asked banks to “allow self-certification; accept a certified copy of the document by mail/post” for account opening. Banks have also been asked not to seek fresh documents if an existing KYC-compliant customer of a bank desires to open another account.


For periodic updating of KYC, RBI told the banks not “insist on physical presence of the customer” and to also not seek fresh proof of identity and address in case of no change in status for ‘low risk’ customers. If customers are unable to comply within a time period, ‘partial freezing’ may be introduced.


Drawbacks in LIC’s VBPY

I find the following drawbacks in the newly launched Varishtha Bima Pension Yojana (VBPY) being administered by Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC). For each drawback, I am giving a suggestion to improve the scheme.


(a) The scheme has maximum pension of Rs5,000 per month. It is insufficient, since it is family-based and not individual-based. A couple can have only one such account.


Suggestion: Monthly pension be increased to Rs20,000 per person, to meet inflation.


(b) It is available to a person who has completed the age of 60 years. A person may go for voluntary retirement at an early age, and s/he may get commutation of pension, gratuity and provident fund. S/he may be interested in investing in a safe avenue, to get a steady income.


Suggestion: Therefore, age limit of 60 years may be brought down to 40 years.

(c) It gives loan up to 75% of the invested amount which is available after three years.


Suggestion: Loan of 75% of the deposit may be made available immediately after its deposit, as the person may want the loan suddenly and may be in dire need of money.


(d) Liquidity of this scheme is poor.


Suggestion: The limit for withdrawal may be reduced to seven years from the date of deposit, for a depositor up to the age of 70 years, and to three years, for depositors above the age of 70 years. This will give good liquidity to a senior citizen who has no other source to meet his immediate requirements.


(e) There is no income-tax benefit on the interest.


Suggestion: Interest may be tax-free up to Rs10,000 per month up to the age of 60 years and fully tax-free after the age of 60 years.


In addition, the 3.09% service tax for depositing the amount in this scheme should be withdrawn. Just like bank deposits, there should be no type of tax for making a deposit in VBPY.


Finally, partial withdrawal in multiples of Rs66,665/- should be allowed.


These are some suggestions which would to make VBPY a popular scheme.


Moneylife Foundation may prevail upon the Government of India to incorporate these modifications in VBPY.

Shirish S Shanbhag, by email


Great Work!

I am a member of Moneylife Foundation and do attend the seminars once in a while—though not as frequently as I would like to.


We are quick to criticise people or institutions, whereas we never take the time to appreciate those who are doing a good job. This is to tell you that you and your colleagues are doing great work and I really appreciate it.


My office is based in Navi Mumbai. I would request you to hold your seminars in Navi Mumbai also. People living there are mostly young couples for whom these financial fundas would be a boon. Do let me know if I could help in any way.

Niranjan Bangera, by email


Brave attempts at stopping corruption

This is with regard to the article “Ranjit Sinha Is the Symptom” by Sucheta Dalal (Moneylife, 2 October 2014). The article clearly states: “The malaise of corruption and influence-buying is deeply ingrained in the system.” I am thankful to Moneylife.


Our system is depressingly corrupt. But there are brave attempts at trying to stop it by people like Shanti Bhushan, Arvind Kejriwal (AK), and organisations like Moneylife, and a few others.


I have now revived the hope of freeing our system from corruption, thanks to AAP’s (Aam Admi Party) tireless attempts. I would like your opinion on AK and AAP. Can they do some good?


Thanks and congratulations for the bold anti-corruption article.

(Name withheld on request), by email


Details of ECS entries are required

This is with regard to “ICICI Bank offers cardless cash withdrawals at ATMs”(Moneylife, 2 October 2014). There are many mistakes/problems created by some nationalised banks for its customers. And prime minister Narendra Modi wishes that all citizens must have bank accounts. Recently, from 2014, Punjab National Bank has stopped printing the full details of ECS (electronic clearing service) entries.


As we know, practically all dividends of companies are credited directly to shareholders’ bank account. But many companies do not send ECS advice of dividend payments. And banks do not inform customers about the details. Banks have been making entries in the passbook, but full details of such receipts are not entered. They enter incomplete information from which it becomes difficult to reconcile the receipts. It is more cumbersome and time-consuming to relate—get details of such entries, unless one has first-hand information of such receipts.


The Reserve Bank of India must issue a directive to banks to enter full details of all ECS/ direct credits for all entries made in the passbook / account statements-ledger account of parties to facilitate sources /details of each and every entry. It will help the income-tax department also to know the exact and correct details of each entry. The software for making entries in passbook / account statement of account-holders must be changed, if required.


Also, it should be mandatory to send the ECS advice for dividends credited directly to shareholders’ account by all companies by speed /registered post. The necessary changes, if any, required in rules and regulations must be initiated.

Mahesh Kumar, by email


CCTV systems in government offices

This is with regard to “Ranjit Sinha Is the Symptom” by Sucheta Dalal (Moneylife, 2 October 2014).There was a news report in July 2013 headlined “We beat Pak, again”. It said that according to the Global Corruption Barometer, corruption in India is at an all-time high—double the global rate. The cancer of corruption cannot be cut off unless we the citizens refrain from corrupt practices ourselves. Don’t we pay bribes to get work done? Why do we elect candidates who are corrupt? Will government employees stop asking for bribes and honestly do the work entrusted to them? One way to curb this evil would be to install CCTV systems as well as audio recording equipment in government offices. Are we prepared for this?

Mahesh Kapasi, by email


Big fan of Prof Hegde

This is with regard to “Every chest pain doesn’t mean a heart attack” by Prof BM Hegde. I have become a big fan of Prof Hegde, as he has busted many myths and malpractices. His ideas on vaccines and excessive medicine usage were eye-openers.



Duplicate accounts

This is with regard to “Jan Dhan: Desi Problem, Videshi Terms” by Sucheta Dalal. Duplicate accounts are surely opened in large numbers, especially in cities. The amount collected is also very large (about Rs1,500 crore). The Reserve Bank of India must find a way to eliminate duplicate accounts before benefits start flowing.

Anil Agashe


How to apply the concept in Indian markets?

This is with regard to “Timing Your Stock Buying” by R Balakrishnan. The article is clichéd, to say the least. I would not mind reading it on, but not here. Quoting Warren Buffett does not a good article make! We have read a lot of Buffett and his way of investing. What we fail to grasp is how to apply those ideas to Indian markets today. Everything makes sense in retrospect. Some examples would have helped.

Shreyas Bhatewara


RBI maintains silence?

This is with regard to “Will Narendra Modi Go after Chain-money Schemes?” by Sucheta Dalal. RBI (Reserve Bank of India) always maintains silence. Whether it was the City Limozine or Sahara, RBI always kept silent.

Usha Dhoot


Lazy investors?

This is with regard to “E-voting Is Here” by SD Israni. Though this is a very good step, most Indian investors are basically lazy and laid back. More than one year has passed, but hardly any investor has taken note of the power of e-voting. Recently, in the Gujarat Ambuja/ ACC matter, investors were advised to vote against the resolution, but no action was taken by investors. Hence, the resolution was passed. Investors wake up only when they are being hit and then they act like cry-babies.



We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)