“There is a need to raise financial awareness among senior citizens”

In an interaction with NGOs working for senior citizens, Susan B Somers, General Secretary of the International Network for the Prevention of Elder Abuse (INPEA) highlighted financial issues prevalent in the US and how they have been dealt with Moneylife Digital team

Susan B Somers, General Secretary of the International Network for the Prevention of Elder Abuse, Inc (INPEA) highlighted some financial issues that the elderly face in an interaction with other NGOs working for senior citizens. The interaction was organised by Silver Innings and Moneylife Foundation.

 “There is a need to raise financial awareness among senior citizens, especially women. They do not understand wills, tax issues and transfers. This leaves them completely vulnerable to financial issues,” said Somers who is also United Nations NGO Coordinator for INPEA. She is associated with the Somers Law Firm, New York.

Highlighting instances of financial exploitation in the United States, she said, “There have been various cases of financial exploitation of the elderly like fraudulent selling of expensive security systems under the pretext of safety or charging exorbitant fees for simple day-to-day jobs like repairing a car.”

Among other financial exploitation cases were repeated mis-selling of insurance policies to the elderly. “There were insurance agents or brokers, who convinced the elderly to flip their current insurance policy with another one, stating that the existing was no more useful to them. In reality, every time the elderly person changed his insurance policy the broker earned a commission. It was in the benefit of the broker and the not the elderly person,” stated Ms Somers.

While the elderly are highly susceptible and gullible to financial exploitation at the hands of their own family members and relatives, certain groups also reportedly took advantage of the same. “There was a rampant selling of living trusts which promised wealth protection for the elderly from the Government, from paying taxes, from family and relatives. This was in the form of a document. They charged a huge amount of fees for this document. Most times, one did not even need such a protection,” Ms Somers said.

On being asked on what steps have been taken or should be taken to address such issues which are equally applicable to Indian senior citizens, she said, “The government should issue information. To take reverse mortgage as an example, the government should provide information stating these are the good points about the product and these are the bad points of the product, this helps the senior citizen take an informed decision.”

“Another significant step taken in the US was a law stating a cooling-in period of three days. If the seller or agent approaches the elderly, he cannot be forced to sign or agree to buy the product or service right away, a cooling-in period of three days has to be practised. This avoids the elderly from taking any hasty decision while under pressure,” she added.




3 years ago

An interesting article that raises a lot of important issues about senior citizens. We need to raise more awareness so that our elderly can live a dignified life and these become the golden years of their life.

The Golden Estate
Privileged Living for Senior Citizens

Ntoni Timbyetaho

6 years ago

A friend of my went for shopping and the service experience was terrible BUT went a head and paid for it. This is no longer acceptable in the business today. This kind of situation reminds me of a waiter who demanded for a tip from the client even when the service was u nacceptable. For anybody to demand a tip or a pay, the quality of service provided MUST be exceptional arousing anf apetising.With the bad service customers should not reward it any more instead customers should vote with a RED card. Thanks and send me your thoughts

Ntoni Timbyetaho

6 years ago

My dear readers. Let me share with you myths about money. Some peple till to day believe that money is a source of all evil. One said that my husband would rather stay and live poor that having money.Adding that if he gets money their family will break down. Some people dont want to share any stories about money.For example certain couples dont talk and discuss at ll about money. This is a disease and must fight about it and advocate for open financial education even in families.

thanks and send me a comment...

Ntoni Timbyetaho

6 years ago

Fellow contributors i greet you. We still have a long way to go. The Parent found his son with about $0.005 and the parent beat the child to death reason being that he was not supposed to touch the money and is going to be a thief. This is terrible. Many people out there mainly in vilages things are bad. Some parents still believe so. I thought the parent will say my son you are going to be rich. Having money when u are very yound is like a crime. We need to educate our kids that money is a very good thing in life and we need it for many reasons. Thanks till next time

Ntoni Timbyetaho

6 years ago

Lack of confidence is also a big problem to finacial education today. some person fear to ask because they dont believe in themselves. Even the service providers dont take the trouble to educate them instead they take the advantage of customer/consumer ignorance. They gorget that an infomed and educated customer is much better than the one not informed.

ntoni timbyetaho

6 years ago

Susan, elderly are exploited every time and again because of lack of policy and fiancial information. one case an elderly was travelling in a tax and was given less money because he did not know the transport cost. also in some markets they are cheated because they know for them to nuy they sold like land or cows therefore they have the money. even those who help them they expect gains after. Another case here in Uganda was when a lady lost her rich husband but did not know how to claim the estates of the deceased. she feared and gave up till when i meet her and advised her. later she got her benefits. elders need easy and free access to information and policy to handle most of the transactions.

thanks for all the concern. i share the same because i strongly believe in financial education here in uganda and africa

ntoni timbyetaho

6 years ago

financial literacy is a big factor hindering financial services. financial consumers have a lot of i dont know of what is taking place in the market. This fear created money lenders who are not only exploitative but also very costly.

Poor financial education also has stopped some persons from banking. some persons keep the money at home. A family one night was attacked they lost life and money. A market was also burnt at night and the vendors lost stock and already made cash

Did you know that some people fear to touch money because they still believe that money is bad

Together we need to do a lot to help our communities

Thank you.

ntoni timbyetaho

6 years ago

nice to have your articles. i feel i need to speak for such persons in society in uganda africa. women ,children, those who cant read and write are always exploied and cheated

Special Court re-orders sale of Harshad Mehta’s flats in ‘Madhuli’

Justice DK Deshmukh of the Special Court—for the third time—has ordered sale of eight flats belonging to Harshad Mehta and his family in ‘Madhuli’ at Mumbai

For the third time since the saga began in 1992, the Special Court set up to try matters relating to the securities scam has asked the Custodian to initiate the process of selling eight out of nine flats belonging to Harshad Mehta at 'Madhuli'. This was once among the most sought-after addresses in Mumbai.

Spread over two floors and 10,400 sq ft, these interconnected flats at Madhuli Co-operative Society occupied by the extended Mehta family then spelt the ultimate in aspiration and achievement for investors and speculators in India’s recently liberalised economy. The property included a billiards room, a putting green and a mini theatre… things that were unheard of in 1992. The Mehtas owned five flats on the third floor and three flats on the fourth floor which were occupied by four brothers and their families and their mother.

The sale of the flats was first ordered in October 2003 after which the case has seen incredible twists and turns with multiple appeals and stay orders before being reverted to Justice DK Deshmukh's court. In an extremely detailed, 140-page order issued on 30th April, which is repeatedly underlined to highlight various aspects, the learned judge has spelt out the basis of his decision. It remains to be seen if this finally settles the issue or will Ashwin Mehta, the late Harshad Mehta's brother, continue his fight to retain the family home. It may be recalled that Harshad Mehta, once described as the Big Bull, died of a heart attack in December 2001 while still facing charges of having diverted several hundred crores of rupees from banks to the capital market. His brothers, Ashwin and Sudhir Mehta, are co-accused in many cases. Over the past 18 years, they have been embroiled in never-ending and messy litigation which includes some absurd tax claims by the government.

Justice DK Deshmukh says:”Because these properties are attached properties and as per the judgement of the Supreme Court in Jyoti Mehta's case, the Custodian is entitled to receive income from the attached properties and because the notified persons are occupying those properties, the Custodian is not getting any income from these properties, the Custodian shall initiate the process of sale immediately and complete it as soon as possible and submit a report to the Court."

The Special Court order also says that all the notified parties and entities operated in tandem with Harshad Mehta in conducting the securities transactions as members of one family constituting a group. Since the various notified parties in the petition are members of the Harshad Mehta group, the properties of each notified party and entity can be sold for discharge of the liabilities of Harshad Mehta, the court order said.

Last year in July, the Supreme Court had ordered that the sale of these eight flats owned by Harshad Mehta’s family shall be confirmed by the Special Court.

Members of the Mehta family had been trying to stall the auction of ‘Madhuli’ by filing various litigations. However, all of them, after reaching the apex court, have come back to the Special Court. Earlier in January, the Special Court had even said that the Mehta family was adopting delaying tactics to stall the sale of these eight flats.

Each notified member of the Mehta family had said that since their property or share in the said property is not funded by Harshad Mehta or brought before the securities scam, it should not be attached or termed as ‘benamidar’ of Harshad Mehta by the Custodian. 

Rejecting these arguments at the outset, the Special Court said:"In our opinion, the attachment of all the properties in terms of sub-section (3) of Section 3 of the Special Act is automatic. The said sub-section does not provide for any qualification that the properties which are liable to be attached should relate to the illegal securities transactions in respect of which the Act was enacted."

The Court said that it came to the conclusion that Harshad S Mehta had funded all the residential properties and they could therefore be disposed of accordingly. In this regard, the Court said, it relied on the report of the auditors Vyas and Vyas, who had considered the flow of funds from Harshad Mehta to various notified parties. “This was the fact that the funds had specifically been transferred for purchase of the properties just before the purchase. There was also a huge amount outstanding in the accounts of the notified parties to Harshad Mehta on 1-4-1990 and 1-4-1991,” the Court said.

An interesting aspect of the judgement is the detailed recording of various charges made by Harshad Mehta's widow Jyoti Mehta, while challenging Justice DK Deshmukh's earlier order in the Supreme Court. Some of Jyoti Mehta's arguments were that the judge had "misread" and "misconstrued" the Supreme Court directions in the Ashwin Mehta case, that the judge had "committed a serious illegality in so far as he relied upon the Janakiraman Reports and other reports which are wholly inadmissible as evidence" and that the judge had "reproduced large amounts of the Custodians' report" raising the question "as to whether he took into account the arguments of the appellants in the case". The rejection of each of these contentions forms a big chunk of the report.

The Mehta property, at its current market price (about Rs40,000 per sq ft), could fetch around Rs42 crore. According to the Supreme Court ruling, a part of the proceeds from the sale would be used to pay off income tax, banks and other debts of Harshad Mehta.



harshd mahanda

5 years ago

this jurgment miracle.iam also agree with.justice dk deshmukh was saying the statement wonderful.

Sherry G

6 years ago

Appeals and stays should not be granted when there are no grounds for the same. It is appalling that creditors have to wait for so long while those who benfited from the scam continue to live in luxury. As for the accusations made by Mehta's widow against the special judge, it's a wonder she wasn't had up for contempt of court.

shanker pai

6 years ago

excellent attempt to show the state of affairs .
they say ' law is an ass '
law takes its own time .
better late than never.

Shadi Katyal

6 years ago

Can some one please tell me why the SC has to order thrice and why first 2 orders were ignored.
It is possible that buyers want vacant flats.
Has our nation become so lawless that we dont have to even accept order from SC or is it that Special courts have no value

dillip swain

6 years ago

thank u apex court,
our court/justice.so early.

Auto experts see higher sales for rest of FY11

In the first month of FY11, the trend continued to be supported by the availability of retail finance and industry experts see the uptick continuing for the rest of the financial year

There has been an increase in sale of two-wheelers and four-wheelers over the past few months. In the first month of FY11, the trend continued to be supported by mainly the availability of retail finance and industry experts see the uptick continuing during the rest of the financial year.

“This trend is likely to continue in the future. If you look at annualised growth, there is an increase over pre-2007 levels. The growth will not be as strong as it is now, but it will continue,” said a research analyst from a leading brokerage who does want to be named.

The Bharat Stage-IV norms have not affected sales as most two-wheelers and
four-wheelers are already compliant with the new emission standards.

The analyst further said that due to increased availability of finance and lower interest rates, a lot of people, who had earlier postponed their plans to buy a two- or four-wheeler, have now decided go in for purchase. “Due to the economy picking up, the main growth in car sales has been in the urban sector. On the other hand, higher crop prices and the Sixth Pay Commission’s recommendations have increased income in rural areas, which has led to increase in auto sales,” he added.

During April, Tata Motors Ltd, India’s largest vehicle maker, reported a 52% increase in sales, including exports. The company sold 57,202 vehicles compared with 37,518 vehicles sold in the same month a year ago. Maruti Suzuki, the country’s largest carmaker, sold 93,058 units, including exports, up 29.7% from 71,748 units sold in April last year. Hyundai Motor’s total sales for April rose 17.24% at 52,020 units against 44,370 units in the year-ago period. Car manufacturing companies such as General Motors India and Ford India have also indicated an increase in sales.

Factors that will impact the sales growth in the future are the massive
under-penetration in Indian markets, aside from metros, and the non-availability of public transport. As the income and standard of living of people go up, so will the demand for cars increase.

Sandeep Singh, deputy managing director for marketing, Toyota Kirloskar Motors said, “I believe, if the interest rate in the case of retail finance continues at this level, and market sentiments remain positive, the pace of growth will continue, but may decline a little bit.”

Two-wheeler makers also reported higher sales during April. Hero Honda sold 3.71 lakh units of two-wheelers compared to 3.7 lakh in April 2009. Bajaj Auto Ltd, the country’s second largest two-wheeler maker, sold 2,79,095 units in April compared with 1,49,733 units in the same month last year. Also, the two-wheeler sales of TVS Motor Co in April rose 28% to 1,44,689 units from 113,119 units in the same period a year ago. Its domestic sales rose about 22% in April to 125,471 units from 102,985 units in the same period a year ago. Companies such as India Yamaha Motor and Suzuki Motorcycle India also showed an increase in sales of two-wheelers.

According to Sudhir Kukreja, an auto analyst, India is a place where the auto industry is expected to boom in the long term. But in the short term, there are some issues such interest rate and excise duty hikes—however, these will not impact the demand for automobiles. The demand is strong, but the impact of these factors is yet to be seen.

“The market moves on absolute figures, the high percentage growth rates are partly due to the fact that 2007 was a bad year,” he added. Mr Kukreja said that the sales of two-wheelers will be boosted by strong rural and semi-urban demand. The passenger car segment relies mainly on urban demand. A large number of global majors are entering this segment. The sales of commercial vehicles are impacted by manufacturing, mining and other such industrial activities. If the Index of Industrial Production (IIP) numbers continue to grow by 12% to 15% annually, then it will indirectly lead to higher sales.

“There are specific periods, where you will see peaks. Segment-wise, sales of commercial vehicles are influenced by depreciation cycles, which usually result in higher sales in the second quarter. Two-wheelers and passenger cars see increased sales in the festive season. Rural demand is also influenced by crop cycles,” Mr Kukreja said.


We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)