1) The MCD was amongst the earliest to really try, as an organisation, to work with people on RTI. Despite everything which is wrong with the MCD, much of which is also due to the strange "thing" that Delhi is, where bigger thieves and looters move around openly - there were eager as well as honest people in the midst who tried.
2) Early adopters of RTI, including Arvind Kejriwal (now LokPal Bill and more), Parveen Amanullah (now a Minister in Bihar) and others worked through the early days, amidst tough opposition from existing vested interests. Blade slashing when going to submit an RTI? MCD organised weekend camps and made it easier to send them by post, as well as gave people the option of both Acts, State and Centre.
3) Long story short, MCD (like Delhi Metro, DTC and some other local bodies) appears to be on its way to try to help. Ofcourse, if you go to the MCD office, then much has not changed - but steps like this, atleast for those with Credit Cards, solves some issues.
4) There are a few glitches - an instant email copy of the application, option to apply online and send the payment later by some other means, other languages . . .but no two ways, this is a great step forward by an organisation which was simply never admired for anything in the past.
It just shows that yes, we can do things the correct way, if we want to.
Thanks, Vinita, for this great article, and thank you Mr. Phatak.
Response to A Banerjee
Vinita is absolutely right. A properly worded and focused RTI query does elicit better response. No way with inquisition of why, how, when type cross question. Amchi BMC has been quite responsive to the extent of telling us not to go for RTI. Sec.4 is an useful tool or weapon!
Well, I for one would keep my fingers crossed despite this initiative. This is because, I have never been fortunate enough to have received a single response to my several emails to MCD Commissioner who, being an IAS, is naturally above law and id unapproachable. His secretary is equally unapproachable and, the author ought to have noticed, there is no e-mail access addresses of a single MCD functionaries available anywhere. The culture of bribes obtains even more forcefully and not one single paper can move without that "extra" payment (rates commensurate with inflation!) that is customary in MCD under any party, be it Congress or BJP! The ordinary middle class people building or reconstructing/remodelling/extending their residences are the worst hit as, for every single procedure, one must pay a huge sum for getting the required permission/sanction and approaching the higher officials is neither safe nor permissible, with the IAS Commissioner remaining beyond reach as ever. I had seen some serious complaints some time ago in the website of consumercomplaints.in about the encroachment of public land/space/footpath by the rich and powerful in certain south Delhi gated communities. Strangely, there has never been any action taken while, in the same localities, the moment a resident of modest means commences reconstruction/repairs of his dwelling unit, the visits by the MCD hoologans begin demanding bribe which is compulsory. Otherwise, under some rule, the construction is stopped and the ratepayer harassed. What then is this hype about the ONLINE RTI facility? Does the author think that, any resident of modest means, seeking any information under the RTI Act from the MCD will be safe and be immune frome harassment bordering on danger to life and property?
Let this be the start of a debate on this move by the MCD which is bound to be only a showpiece as the MCD officials are immune from any action by any authority.
I tend to believe you on the corruption front of the MCD. However, MCD's online RTI application should be commended as the common, faceless man can sit at home and invoke this Act with the click of the mouse. When more and more citizens file applications which i should think they would as it is made simple now. then the pressure on the municipal corporation to be transparent will be more. Subsequently it should lead to dip in corruption. It may be a long drawn battle but we have to make a beginning somewhere. So, I think we all should spread the good word to invoke RTI applications on so many issues that hurt the common man in Delhi and become a huge citizen pressure group. I know it is only logical to be cynical but we need to get off it whenever there seems an iota of hope of change for the better. Hope you agree/
A Banerjee11 months ago in reply to Vinita Deshmukh
Having been in the civil service and an activist of sorts, and having been a Delhi-ite and also a witness to how the MCD functions, I would like to keep my fingers crossed. This is because, if due to any RTI application any MCD official or employee were to be in trouble, the RTI applicant would need protection. But, yes, let us hope.
Not that the Mun.Corp.of Greater Mumbai is lagging behing. They do respond but at their own sweet will and pleasure.
My RTI application sent to a Ward Office was forwarded by the AE Maint. to the Tree Officer who reports to him with a cc to me. He replies and says a part of the info relates to the AE Environment with whom he shares his room, in fact both are seated next to each other! Another response follows.
This is a futile exercise to gain time and/or avoid replies.
To save on time and waste of stationery, instead of 10 Public Info. Officers at the Ward Office, the BMC HQ must be having many more, there ought to be just one department collating all the data and forwarding a consolidated response.
In another RTI applicatioin
the SRA replied to all queries but said those relating to Bank Guarantee and Security Deposit of the same Contractor are with the Accounts who took time to respond.
good of you to share this info which i consider landmark and needs to be sent to all Public Authorities one has a contacts and I shall do so. Thanks
N. Varma
This is a awesome effort by the minicipal corporation of delhi to allow filing of RTI online and payment , this is very useful to thwe commen man , good work by Mr Patnail also to the PMC to keep aside one day to allow inspections , an excellent article by Mrs Deshmukh again as this is a important issue , keep up your good work and writing on social issues , all the best NK
Dr RC Patnaik, chief of the information technology department of MCD, deserves to be congratulated for his initiative. The sad fact is that this important news is yet to be highlighted by leading newspapers and TV news channels.
JP Morgan Loss: Were any laws broken?
When banks are in trouble, they often mislead the world about their financials. Maybe JPMorgan disclosed everything properly about its $2 billion loss, but that's what we need to determine.
4 doctors of Max Hospital held guilty of negligence; anxious father
Following the death of his daughter due to medical negligence in Delhi’s posh Max Hospital, the aggrieved father invoked 50 RTI applications in various departments to seek justice. Last week’s order by CIC Shailesh Gandhi provides some hope
‘Lucrative’ assignments: A Messy Saga
Top bureaucrats and chairmen of banks and public sector entities (barring a few honourable exceptions) are guilty of corruption and looting of public assets. However, their political godfathers ensure that they escape strict action
Harshad Mehta Scam: A Distorted Picture of 1992
Even after a 20-year effort, the special court is discussing the possibility of pushing the hearings. The only major beneficiaries have been India's lawyers, whose incomes rose by a factor of 10 or more
What's Hot Recent Additions
RIL does not hold stake in any media company – True or It may be true that on paper, RIL does not hold any stake in any media company, as the minister stated in Rajya Sabha. However, the Reliance group now openly controls Eenadu TV
Did New India overcharge lakhs of policyholders? – II New India Assurance admitted that a software glitch resulted in overcharging mediclaim premium, but has dragged its feet on providing information. It now says that it gave a wrong
Daily cleansing for the mind Breathe away to happiness and glory! Bath for the mind consists in daily replacing our negative thoughts like hatred greedy, jealousy, anger and pride with positive thoughts like
Did New India Assurance overcharge lakhs of mediclaim Is New India Assurance sitting on crores of extra premium collected due to a software glitch? It does not even know how many policyholders paid excess premium and is stonewalling
President Pratibha Patil’s luxurious home continues to The 2,42,000 sq ft of land in Pune returned by President Patil is to be ‘suitably’ used for an alternative purpose. Communication from the ministry of defence is
DISCLAIMER: This article is written purely in the public interest. While every attempt has been made to ensure that the information provided on this page is accurate, Moneywise Media Pvt Ltd and its group companies (together called as ‘Moneylife’) will not be held responsible for any claim, loss, damage or inconvenience caused as a result of any information within these pages or any information accessed through its site(s).