Investor Issues
Investors Protection: Legally dishonest

Investors are not only being taken for a ride by companies and intermediaries; they are...

Premium Content
Monthly Digital Access


Already A Subscriber?
Yearly Digital+Print Access


Moneylife Magazine Subscriber or MSSN member?

Yearly Subscriber Login

Enter the mail id that you want to use & click on Go. We will send you a link to your email for verficiation
SEBI asks companies to provide audit issues in separate filings

SEBI also asked stock exchanges to conduct immediate scrutiny of the audit issues highlighted in these documents and seek necessary clarifications from the company

Mumbai: Tightening noose around companies trying to hide issues raised by auditors in their voluminous annual reports, market watchdog Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has asked all listed firms to submit separate documents for adverse observations made against them, reports PTI.
The regulator has also asked the stock exchanges to conduct immediate scrutiny of the issues highlighted in these documents and seek necessary clarifications from the concerned companies about the observations made by auditors.
If the auditors' observations are found to be serious, the SEBI can also ask the companies to restate financial accounts and to inform shareholders about it, the regulator said in a circular.
As per the current regulations, all listed companies are required to submit the copies of annual reports containing audited financial statements to the stock exchanges.
However, many serious issues about the companies' accounts, including possible cases of fraud, can go unnoticed even if they have been flagged off by auditors, as such observations are generally buried deep inside the bulky documents like annual reports.
To enhance the quality of financial reporting by listed companies, SEBI said it has "now decided to put in place a system to monitor the audit qualifications contained in the audit report accompanying the audited annual financial statements submitted by listed companies".
Accordingly, listed companies will now be required to submit two separate forms along with copies of annual reports submitted to stock exchanges.
Form A will detail the 'Unqualified/Matter of Emphasis Report', and the Form B will comprise of 'Qualified/ Subject To/Except for Audit Report'.
'Qualifications' made by auditors are the issues or observations flagged off by them about various aspects of the company's financials.
At times, the auditors may not make any 'qualifications', but flag off certain issues as 'matter of emphasis', while there could also be issues 'subject to' various factors and issues that might not be worth any concerns 'except for' certain developments.
These various kinds of observations are made in auditor reports for further action by the management of the concerned company.
The two forms, A and B, would be required to be signed by the CEO/Managing Director, Chief Financial Officer, Auditor and Chairman of the Audit Committee.
These forms would have to contain information about relevant notes in the annual financial statements, the response of management to the qualifications and comments of the Board/Chair of the Audit Committee.
Among other details, these forms would have details like frequency of auditor observations, whether it has been made for the first time or is repetitive in nature and for how long such comments were being made.
Besides, the companies would be required to give gist of qualifications/headings (along with reference to relevant page numbers of the annual reports) and the management's response.
Further, the forms would be required to contain additional comments from the board and audit committee about nature of the qualification, including materiality, agreement /disagreement on the qualification, steps taken to resolve the qualification.
The new guidelines would be applicable to all annual audited financial results submitted by the companies for the period ending on or after 31 December 2012.
In its latest circular, SEBI has also fixed deadlines for compliance at the level of the companies and stock exchanges for further action on issues raised in these new forms.
According to the market regulator, stock exchanges should carry out preliminary scrutiny of reports that would also include the bourses seeking necessary explanation from the listed company.
"Stock exchanges shall also consult one other for distributing the work in case shares of the listed company concerned are listed on more than one stock exchange," the circular said.
If necessary, the bourses can refer the cases to SEBI for further examination.
SEBI has also set up the 'Qualified Audit Review Committee', having representatives from Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) and stock exchanges, among others.
The panel would review the cases received from stock exchanges and guide SEBI in processing the qualified annual audit reports referred by them.
In case the committee finds that an audit qualification is significant and the explanation given by the concerned company is unsatisfactory, it may be referred to the Financial Reporting Review Board of ICAI (ICAI-FRRB).
It will check whether the qualification is justified or requires restatement of the books of accounts of the listed company.
"If ICAI-FRRB opines that an audit qualification is justified, SEBI may ask the listed company concerned to restate its books of accounts in compliance with the statutory requirements and inform its shareholders about the same by making an announcement to the stock exchanges," the circular noted.
In case, a listed company is asked to restate its financial results, it will have to be done within two months from the date of letter of communication to the concerned entity.


RBI asks banks to compensate customers for cheque clearance delay

Banks will have to pay the compensation at savings bank interest rate in absence of a specified rate, for delayed clearance of local cheques, says RBI

Mumbai: In a big relief to the bank customers, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has asked all banks to compensate them for delay in clearance of local cheques, reports PTI.
Banks, as per the RBI directive, will have to pay the compensation at savings bank interest rate in absence of a specified rate, for delayed clearance of local cheques.
"In case, no rate is specified in the cheque collection policies (CCP) for delay in realisation of local cheques, compensation at savings bank interest rate shall be paid for the corresponding period of delay," RBI said.
It also advised banks to reframe their CCPs specifying details regarding timeline for clearance of local cheques and compensation for delay and display them on their websites.
"...banks are advised to re-frame their CCPs to include compensation payable for the delayed period in the case of collection of local cheques as well," RBI said.
The central bank has issued the notification in view of difficulties being faced by customers with regard to cheque clearances.
"Instances of delayed credit to customers' accounts without any compensation for the delayed period beyond the timeline indicated in the CCPs, in respect of local cheques, have been brought to our notice", the RBI said.
Under the existing norms, the banks can provide facility of withdrawal of some amount against local cheques, subject to safeguards.
RBI, however, clarified there would not be any change in the guidelines regarding realisation and compensation for delay in clearance of outstation cheques.
Banks are required to collect outstation cheques in 14 days and in case of any delay, have to pay interest at the specified rate or equivalent to fixed deposit rate for corresponding maturity.




4 years ago

I had taken up the matter with RBI vide my letter dated 22.11 2011 about “no compensation for delay in clearance of local cheques ” after I learnt that there were several complaints from customers about delays in local cheque clearance and without any compensation for the delayed period.
I was vigorously following up with RBI since then.

RBI has not issued this circular on it's own.

It may be noted that the banks reframed their Cheque Collection policies (CCP) after RBI in it’s Master Circular on Customer Service in banks No. RBI / 2009-10 / 57 DBOD.No.Leg. BC.9 /09.07.006/2009-10 dated July 1, 2009 advised banks to comply with the final order on 'timeframe for collection of outstation cheques' passed by the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission in case no. 82 of 2006. The decision came on 28th July 2008.

However till date none of the banks had provided for compensation for delay in local clearing cheques. They were denying the compensation on the spacious plea that RBI itself has not stipulated it.

RBI also did not notice it on it's own and did not do anything as mentioned above.

RBI, has since issued a circular yesterday directing banks to compensate customers for any delay in clearing local cheques. This would mean that banks will have to compensate customers monetarily if a cheque to be credited in an account on Monday, for instance, gets delayed till Wednesday.

RBI has said that in case, no rate is specified in the CCP for delay in realisation of local cheques, compensation at savings bank interest rate shall be paid for the corresponding period of delay.

I will be failing in my duty if I do not thank all the officials of RBI who handled this matter in a positive and constructive manner without any hostility and adversarial attitude and therefore I thank them profusely.

Thanks & With Warm Reagrds.

Parvati Nivas,
Savarkar Road,
Dombivli (East) 421 201
(R) 0251-2424845/2451288

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)