Investor Issues
High-net worth individuals, guinea-pigs of structured products

Wealth managers continue to pitch high-risk structured products to HNIs. Each time a new set of investors get fooled

Amidst the stock market volatility, and market calls of so-called experts turning out to be frequently wrong, it is not surprising to find investors turning away from equities. Considering the losses they have incurred, market intermediaries don't want to pitch simple equities to investors, especially high-net worth investors (HNIs). One of the products that wealth managers keep coming out for HNIs has a fancy name-structured products. These invest part of the money in debt and partly in high-risk products like derivatives. All these years, the core of structured products was Nifty futures and options. But wrong calls there too have led to large losses in Nifty-based structured products sold to HNIs. So, now, structured products have another hot product at their core, one that never fails to attract Indians: gold.

These products aim to replicate the performance of gold while promising to keep your money safe. They are called gold-linked debentures. How is your capital safe? Almost 80% of the money is invested in a fixed income product in such a way that on maturity the invested part (say 80%) and the plus they get on the interest equals that of the principal. The rest 20% or so is put in gold. Not physical gold but gold futures whose value is dependent on gold.
Many investors are enticed by the investment proposition offered by these products-safety of capital and upside of gold. It is a sham.

Most investors believe that structured products are designed in a manner that equips them to deliver superior returns. Besides, they also consider them to be less risky. Structured products are not as simple as they are usually made out to be; they are quite complex. Since they use a blend of investment strategies, it is difficult for most investors to understand the strategy driving the risky part. Expectedly, investors aren't aware of the situations when the strategy might fail to deliver.

We had many instances where people have made huge losses investing in these products. A major example of this is Aditya Birla Money, the brokerage arm of Aditya Birla Group which suffered over Rs100 crore in losses on its 'Options Maxima' strategy for HNIs in 2010.

The HNI clients had put money in the so-called structured product called Options Maxima product, under the strangle strategy. The scheme promised returns of around 1%-1.5% every month based on the arbitrage opportunities through this activity, which ensured what was considered a very fair 12%-15% return annually.

A strangle involves purchase or sale of particular option derivatives that allow the holder to profit, based on how much the price of the underlying security moves, with relatively minimal exposure to the direction of price movement. It was considered "safe." Apparently, the bets were yielding good returns for both the dealer as well as the investors as long as the Nifty was moving in a range. The bets went wrong after the sharp up-move in the index in early September 2010.

The same thing may happen with these gold futures on MCX. Gold futures can be bought with a 12% margin and losses are marked to market. This means that any movement in the price of gold will increase or decrease the margin and profit/loss accordingly. Thus if the margin requirement is 12% and the prices of gold moves down by 12% your whole capital gets wiped out.

Terms like derivatives, paired trades and equity-linked debentures, among others, have enticed a lot of investors into investing in these products. A strong marketing pitch by fund houses combined with fancy terms/investment strategies leads them to believe that structured products are superior and investors are dumb if they don't get into such complex ideas yielding higher profits. However, there are certain elements that investors need to consider before investing in structured products. Some of the structured products claim to perform across market conditions. Too good to be true, isn't it? This is simply because these products have not even gone through enough back testing, to guarantee the investor any return of principal or performance.

Investments in instruments like structured products should be made only after there is a clear understanding of its investment proposition, risks involved and the returns projected. If the investor can unravel the structure and can take on the risk for that additional return, then he can consider investing in them. To deal with it, the first question an investor has to ask is: what is the maximum loss possible? If he is told, "loss is ruled out, your capital is protected", the salesperson is possibly lying.

These products have come in the market in waves and have failed to succeed at all times. They come and go and each time they enter with a core product that is hot at the moment. And this time it is the yellow metal. But even if they inflict losses each time there seems to be a market for them always. Each time there is a new set of gullible wealthy investors.


Vedanta chairman: SEBI has approved open offer for Cairn India

Anil Agarwal says Vedanta plans to launch open offer very soon; is confident that government will approve acquisition before 15th April deadline

Mumbai: UK-based Vedanta Group today said it has received the nod from the market regulator to acquire a 51% stake in Cairn India at a cost of $9.6 billion and that it would launch an open offer soon.

"We have already received SEBI's approval for an open offer. The issue will open very soon. Within the next one to two days, we will send out the mails regarding this to all concerned," Vedanta Group chairman Anil Agarwal told journalists.

The Vedanta chief also appeared confident that the deal to acquire a majority stake in Cairn India, promoted by Edinburgh-based Cairn Energy Plc, would soon receive the approval of the government, PTI reports.

"We have a deadline of 15th April and I believe the government will give its approval before that... The royalty issue has to be sorted out with the government and the ONGC. We can... take up that issue later," Mr Agarwal said.

The deal, which has been hanging fire since November 2010, is likely to be considered for final approval by the Union Cabinet at its meeting in the national capital tomorrow.

As per the Takeover Code of the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), the acquirer is required to come out with an open offer to give an exit option to existing shareholders.

In August 2010, British energy giant Cairn Energy agreed to sell its majority stake in Cairn India to the Vedanta Group. But the deal has been hanging fire, with Cairn India-after some initial reluctance-making conditional applications for government approval on 23rd November, three months after the deal was announced.

The conditional approval it sought, came with a rider that government consent was not mandatory and that the corporate deal involving a share transfer does not trigger the pre-emption rights of the partner, state-owned ONGC.

The oil ministry has put a condition for granting approval for the deal, saying Cairn must get a no-objection from ONGC, which holds stakes in eight of the 10 properties of Cairn India.

The deal is awaiting the approval of the Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs (CCEA) and according to the Petroleum Secretary S Sundareshan, Cairn Energy will have to take the consent of ONGC before selling its majority stake in its Indian unit.

"To my mind, they (Cairn) will require ONGC's consent," Mr Sundareshan said yesterday. He said that his ministry had received applications for approval only at November-end, and the government did not delay processing the application.

Once the government's nod is obtained, the two firms can approach their shareholders seeking an extension of the 15th April deadline, on the grounds that the conclusion remains a mere formality. However, due to the delay in getting regulatory clearances, the Vedanta Group would have to announce a fresh schedule for the open offer.

On 17 August 2010, two days after the announcement of the deal, the Vedanta group offered to acquire up to 20% stake from public shareholders for a price of Rs 355 a share. The Rs13,631 crore 'open' offer was scheduled to launch on 11th October and close on 30th October.

Any deal involving acquisition of 15% or more stake in a listed company requires the acquirer to make an open offer for 20% stake purchase from public shareholders and such an offer needs to be approved by SEBI.

Shares of Cairn India were in the red on the Bombay Stock Exchange Tuesday afternoon, at Rs365.20, or down 0.6% from its close on Monday, in a weak market.


L&T Metro Rail (Hyderabad) achieves financial closure for Hyderabad Metro Rail Project

L&T Metro Rail (Hyderabad) Ltd, the SPV incorporated to implement the Hyderabad Metro Project has achieved financial closure for the project

L&T Metro Rail (Hyderabad) Ltd, the SPV incorporated to implement the Hyderabad Metro Project, has achieved financial closure for the project. L&T Metro Rail is the subsidiary of Larsen & Toubro. The financial closure has been achieved in six months and is the largest fund tie up in India for a PPP (public private partnership) project till date.

A consortium of banks led by State Bank of India has sanctioned the entire debt requirement of Rs11,480 crore for the project. The equity component for the project, expected to be around Rs3,440 crore, would be infused primarily by L&T Group. The project will get a viability gap grant of Rs1,458 crore from the Central Government through Government of Andhra Pradesh.

Hyderabad Metro Project was announced by the Government of Andhra Pradesh (GoAP) on PPP mode under the Design, Built, Finance, Operate and
Transfer (DBFOT) basis. L&T emerged the lowest bidder and signed the Concession Agreement through its SPV, L&T Metro Rail (Hyderabad) Ltd, with the Government of Andhra Pradesh (GoAP) on 4 September 2010.

Shares of L&T were being quoted at Rs1,666 in late afternoon trade on the Bombay Stock Exchange today, down 1.42% from their previous close.


We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)