HC directs Costal Authority to clear projects in Bhuleshwar, Bandra Reclamation Bays

Declaring Bhuleshwar and Bandra Reclamation in Mumbai as ‘Bays’, the HC directed Costal Zone Authority to give clearances to two projects that were outside the CRZ norms for bays


The Bombay High Court, while accepting the certificate issued by Institute of Remote Sensing (IRS) for deciding upon the Costal Regulation Zone (CRZ) norms, asked the authority to provide clearances for two projects, one in Bhuleshwar and the other in Bandra Reclamation.


A division bench of Chief Justice Mohit Shah and Justice BP Colabawalla, while declaring sections of Bandra Reclamation and Bhuleshwar as ‘Bays’, directed the Maharashtra Coastal Zone Management Authority (MCZMA) to give necessary clearances within six weeks, for constructing projects in those areas. The petition was filed by two developers - Marine Drive Hospitality & Realty (representing the Bhuleshwar project) and Om Metals Consortium (for the Bandra Reclamation project).


The MCZMA had refused to grant clearances to these two projects on the basis that they breached CRZ norms, which restricts construction activity 500 metres from the high tide line. However, there are different Regulations that govern Bays, according to which restrictions are only applicable to a zone 100m from the high tide line. (This regulation applies to all “tidal influence water bodies” including “bays, estuaries, rivers, creeks, backwaters, lagoons, ponds connected to the sea or creeks and the like”.)


The HC accepted a certificate issued by Chennai-based IRS, according to which the concerned areas were not under the CRZ.


The MCZMA defended its stance by stating that the clearance for an earlier project near Mahim Bay was based on the fact that the certification from IRS received by those developers clearly specified that the area concerned was under a specific subsection of the CRZ norms – CRZ IVA, unlike the current cases.


The Bench, judgement said, “There is no substance in the contention being raised by MCZMA.... the Institute of Remote Sensing, has clearly certified that the project site falls outside 100 metres. Once this position is not disputed, it is of no consequence whether in petitioners' case the Institute of Remote Sensing has classified the water body as CRZ IVA.”


“The IRS was basically concerned with determining whether the water body at Mahim/Back Bay was indeed a 'bay' and if so, demarcation of the high-tide-line and area of 100 meters there from, which could be identified as CRZ area.” the decision reads.


The Science of Pranayama

Decoding the science of breath for modern times


We breathe without giving it a second thought and take this particular bodily function for granted. Yet, scientists are now telling us that giving each breath a thought might actually lead us to deep and lasting happiness and health. According to neuroscience, the act of breathing consciously paves the way to enhanced immunity, inhibits fight-or-flight response to stress, induces a state of relaxation, creates emotional stability, improves cardiovascular and respiratory health, is the perfect antidote to depression even when drugs have not worked out entirely and helps in the drug-free management of pain. This list of effects is by no means comprehensive; it is just the tip of the iceberg.


Pranayama is a technique in yoga that puts control over breathing back into your hands. Literally, the word means ‘extension of life force’, and the practice engages you with the nuances of breathing. This special and ancient yogic technique switches the light back in the dark spaces—the places in your body and mind that may have otherwise remained inaccessible. Pranayama vastly improves the mechanics of the nervous system because it affects what we always thought was beyond our influence.


Conscious breathing stimulates the parasympathetic nervous system through the vagus nerve which runs from the base of the brain all the way to the abdomen. This nerve is responsible for managing the nervous system responses and reducing the heart rate, to name only two of its most important functions. The neurotransmitter acetylcholine is released by the vagus nerve and plays a pivotal role in increasing calmness and focus.


Therefore, the more you stimulate the vagus nerve, the more acetylcholine it releases, directly lowering anxiety levels.


Adults who experience higher levels of vagal tone (activity in the vagal nerve), also experience enhanced feelings of connectedness and positive emotions which further amplifies the vagal tone. Consistent practice of conscious breathing can reduce blood pressure and calm the heart. This, in turn, scientists say, increases the life span of the blood vessels. Regular and long-term practice of pranayama can, therefore, prevent diseases of the nervous system such as stroke, migraines and Parkinson’s.


Another benefit of pranayama is that it stops grey cells from diminishing with age; your ability to perform at your best remains relatively intact as you grow older. Your memory and focus also improve in the process. An interesting scientific finding on the benefits of pranayama is that the expression of genes involved in stress response can be changed in a way that can potentially slow down the body-mind’s reactivity to stress.


This improves immune functions, metabolic activity and insulin secretion.


Pranayama is a great example of how matter can be influenced through the subtle act of awareness or objective observation. Your entire biology can be influenced by simply becoming aware of your breath and then manipulating it to move the controls from the primitive brain to the pre-frontal cortex—a direct effect of infusing the breath with your conscious attention. For example, emotions come under the authority of the pre-frontal cortex, as do many other mental and emotional aspects of being. Therefore, when you focus your consciousness around your breath, your consciousness is able to alter your body-mind for optimum wellness.


Meditation has been shown to sustain the health of our telomeres, the caps on the ends of chromosomes which determine longevity, to a certain extent. “Telomeres sit on the end of chromosomes (like the plastic tips on the end of shoelaces), stopping them from fraying and scrambling the genetic codes they contain. In healthy people, telomeres shorten progressively throughout life, more than halving in length from infancy to adulthood, and halving again in the very elderly,” writes the BMJ editorial. Latest research in the field of ‘epigenetics’ seems to suggest that genes have the capacity for both, normal and abnormal, responses to an environment. If one wants to derive maximum benefit from these practices, one has to be consistent and practise these with dedication and sincerity.


As in all such practices, what matters most are lifestyle changes in keeping with the eight core principles of Patanjali’s yoga.


(Professor Dr BM Hegde, a Padma Bhushan awardee in 2010, is an MD, PhD, FRCP (London, Edinburgh, Glasgow & Dublin), FACC and FAMS.)



Pushkala Ramani

2 years ago

Blessed are those who have the will.

Narendra Doshi

2 years ago


2014: A year of attempts to strangle the RTI

Strapline: Political parties defying summons by CIC, a headless information commission and much more meant a low year for this otherwise strong transparency law in 2014.


If 2014 was the triumph of the BJP which brought it to power with a thumping majority, it was also the year when this new government used its power to strangulate the Right To Information Act (RTI), as much as it could. Here are some of the milestones for RTI in 2014.

No Central Chief Information Commissioner

BJP government's clear allergy to transparency came in the form of procrastination in appointing the Chief Central Information Commissioner, the vacancy which continues since 23 August 2014. First, the government tried to give an excuse that it cannot take a decision in the absence of an opposition leader, despite the fact that the RTI Act clearly states that the leader of the biggest political group should be considered to be a part of this appointment committee. When media and RTI activists raised a hue and cry, it decided to call for entries from the public. Now that 200 citizens including all the seven central information commissioners applied, we still await the verdict of the government, which will hopefully come quickly and in early 2015. In the meanwhile, over 35,000 second appeals are pending due to the vacancy of Chief Central Information Commissioner, but the government clearly does not care.

All major political parties unite to be out of RTI purview

In June 2013, the CIC ordered that all political parties come under the RTI Act and declared them as public authorities. This was a result of tenacious pursuance by RTI activist Subhaschandra Agrawal and the NGO, Association of Democratic Reform through the RTI route. Ever since, the CIC has been sending summons to all the six major political parties to attend the hearing in order to hear their side, before making them public authorities. Earlier, it had directed them to appoint public information officers, but it fell on deaf ears. For the fourth time in November, CIC summoned them but all the major political parties – Indian National Congress (Congress), Communist Party of India (Marxist)-CPI(M), Communist Party of India (CPI), Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) and Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP), including the ruling BJP boycotted the hearing, reflecting their united stand to keep their funds, 75% of which comes from unknown donors.

Maharashtra government tries to keep ACB out of RTI

In a move suspected to have been triggered off by the scandalous irrigation scams involving prominent political leaders like Ajit Pawar, and financial irregularities and amassing of illegal properties by Pune’s divisional commissioner, all brought out by RTI activists, the Congress-NCP alliance government surreptitiously removed the Anti Corruption Bureau from the RTI Act. The notification issued by the then state government was in total violation of the RTI Act. It was RTI activist Vijay Kumbhar who sent an official complaint to the Governor, Vidyasagar Rao. By then, the BJP government had been established at the centre. The press release by the Governor’s office states, “The Governor took the decision to withdraw the notification issued by the State Government on 6thSeptember 2014 after considering representations from various RTI activists and taking cognizance of newspaper reports which reflected the view that the notification was in violation of the RTI Act. The Governor also got the issue legally examined before taking the decision to withdraw the notification.”  

BJP comes to power; closes Satish Shetty murder case

After the BJP government came to power at the Centre, in August the unthinkable happened, allegedly due to pressure from a senior BJP leader of Maharashtra. In a suspicious and strange turn of events, after four years of investigations the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), suddenly filed a closure report in the Satish Shetty murder case on 11th August. CBI investigations led to a 10,000 page report; several trips abroad by the investigative agencies and almost zeroing on 13 culprits, which gave a hope that the murder case of the Right to Information (RTI) activist would be solved. Suddenly the CBI informed the media about the closure of this sensational murder case, as it named the high profile owner of Ideal Road Builders (IRB), Virendra Mhaiskar, who is close to several top notch politicians of Maharashtra. A sub-registrar and others were also among the accused. The prominent one among the accused is allegedly known to be close to this political leader and hence the shocking turnaround. RTI activists suffered a deep blow in the loss of Satish Shetty and the eventual closure of his murder case.

Pratibha Patil continued to influence sensitive RTI decisions

Former President of India, Pratibha Patil who was compelled to return the expansive 2,60,000 sq ft of premier Defence Land in Pune, which she was turning into a post-retirement luxurious mansion, allegedly played her role in interfering with Information commission appointments. Her former secretary, Rajendra Jadhav, received the plum post of Amravati’s Information Commissioner, which incidentally is Pratibha Patil’s home town. If that was not enough, Jadhav got additional charge as Pune’s Information Commissioner, despite the fact that it takes nine hours of travel from Amravati to Pune, making it unpractical to give him the additional charge. This was after Pune’s Information Commissioner M B Shah fell ill. In fact, information commissioners of Mumbai and Konkan, who can travel to and fro within three hours were ignored. Like icing on the cake for Jadhav, he was promptly provided an official residence within a short time, despite the fact that several senior officers were in queue for accommodation. The biggest violation though, was courtesy SCIC Ratnakar Gaikwad, who over-stepped norms of appointment as only the Governor can appoint information commissioners, but there has been no action by the government on Gaikwad’s move.


(Vinita Deshmukh is consulting editor of Moneylife, an RTI activist and convener of the Pune Metro Jagruti Abhiyaan. She is the recipient of prestigious awards like the Statesman Award for Rural Reporting which she won twice in 1998 and 2005 and the Chameli Devi Jain award for outstanding media person for her investigation series on Dow Chemicals. She co-authored the book “To The Last Bullet - The Inspiring Story of A Braveheart - Ashok Kamte” with Vinita Kamte and is the author of “The Mighty Fall”.)




2 years ago

Transparency, like all other virtues, cannot be absolute. I'm sure you have complained about cases dragging on for years, yet you now complain about a closure of Satish Shetty case which has been investigated ad-nauseum.

As someone said, there are limits to what you can give to others, but no limits to what you can demand from others. It seems very true of this article.

So let me ask you a simple question - what would you rather have - a corrupt anti-national government against whom you can file a zillion RTI enquiries and make a noise on media, or a clean hard working one, which refuses to be sidetracked by real/imagined issues of activists. I dont expect you will answer, because you cant do so without negating your own stance.

Bapoo Malcolm

2 years ago

For those of you thought of achhay din, it was meant only for the politicians. Unfortunately the poor public thought that their lot would improve!

Some time back, when Moneylife had carried an article on goondas in AGMs, had commented that worse would follow. I was immediately criticised.

We are going Pakistan's way. With a Taliban flavour. Shooting small vessels out of the water makes good copy; like stories about attacks on the high and mighty. More is to come.

Rahul Gandhi, a non-icon at best, had kept on repeating that his team gave the nation the RTI Act. You ridiculed him, hopefully for monotony. Quite possibly it was the only thing that he could be proud of! But then, what a gift. Now why cry when the Act is being destroyed?

Chickens always come home to roost.



In Reply to Bapoo Malcolm 2 years ago

There is no need for you to bring your political axe to grind in this article. And nor are we impressed by your doomsday predictions. So please make comments that have some relevance to the article.


2 years ago

I fully agree with the report of Vinita Deshmukh. There appears to be an organised coterie who try to favour establishment against the transparency and accruing benefits of the act to the public. Till 2011 CICs used to be applicant/appellant friendly.If eh appellant is not personally present to put his points for getting relief, the CIC used to rely on what pleas are made in appeal and documentary evidence. No more so.Shri Ratnakar Gaikwad in a recent case just disposed of an appeal simply on default and what the respondent said as the appellant was not present because he was unaware of the hearing date being out of station.Can U imagine that within 17 days of second appeal, the hearing notice was sent? Can we believe such magical transformation in disposal of cases ?A simple information of a line was required for which the PIO and FAA both insisted on payment of Rs. 10 to get the ten page records to cull out information whether the applicant is able to understand or not. A time will come when getting a pointed information from an authority will be A FUTILE EXERCISE. And where is the monitoring of dissemination of justice as per the spirit of the act?


2 years ago

2014: A year of attempts to strangle the R.T.I. and me ? for Non-receipt of ‘CERTIFIED-COPY’ under application dated ; 09/01/2014 - Sr,No-306 , (O-130/2014 , E1-305) I would like to bring your notice that the final order to Change Bye-laws to accommodate as member to 315 families from The Government of Maharashtra vide No- RVA 2702/CR-208/15-C, Date-25/08/2003 is based on our Mumbai HCWP-No 4481/2001 and it is high time to think how can it get stayed by the same HC by filling of a newer WP-8508/2003 by the MC of the ‘Shree Ganesh Co-Operative Housing Society’Nerul,Navi-Mumbai-400706. It is aimed to continue uninterrupted mala-fide practices and to avoid intervention of competent state Government authorities & to block the fundamental ‘RIGHTS OF SHELTER’ for 315 families out of total 454 ? ‘being highly deprived of life, liberty and property without due process of law" therefore required ‘CERTIFIED’ copy as to confirm whether a ‘GENUINE STAY’ has been granted by this Honorable HC/MUMBAI or is a ‘BLUFF’ from society committee ? So be please to issue an ‘CERTIFIED’ copy of the ‘STAY’ or any kind of ‘ORDER’ as to define stay without any further delay. / Thanks With very warm Regard.

sohan modak

2 years ago

Thanks Vinita, You have exposed the hypocrisy of the successive governments, office bearers and political parties, all of whom have been strangulating the democratic institutions by abusing the power of rupee.

R Balakrishnan

2 years ago

The Modi Government does not like transparency. So do not expect anything so long as they are in power. They cannot carry power with responsibility and/or dignity. Unfortunate.

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)