G-Secs Yields Dip

The 10-year benchmark G-Secs yield was down by just 3bps (basis points) last fortnight to end...

Premium Content
Monthly Digital Access

Subscribe

Already A Subscriber?
Login
Yearly Digital+Print Access

Subscribe

Moneylife Magazine Subscriber or MSSN member?
Login

Yearly Subscriber Login

Enter the mail id that you want to use & click on Go. We will send you a link to your email for verficiation
Public Interest Exclusive
Has Modi, the Emperor, Really Lost His Shine?
There is much that we certainly did not expect from the Modi sarkar
 
“We had an emperor on 27th of May 2014,” said industrialist Rahul Bajaj in an interview to NDTV, “but the shine seems to be wearing off.” The Emperor image was perfect for Narendra Modi on 15 August 2014 when he delivered his maiden speech as prime minister (PM), from the ramparts of the historic Red Fort, in a regal red-and-green safa (headgear). When you read this column, the PM would have delivered his second Independence Day (I-day) speech. Many of us, who had scrambled to switch on our television sets to hear the PM on I-day, for the first time ever, are no longer so enthused. 
 
On the positive side, the PM has done well to energise India’s relationship with many nations during his frenetic foreign visits and to connect with the vast Indian diaspora. Mr Modi also earned kudos for raising the issue of latrines and sanitation on I-day and for following it up with the Beti Bachao (save our daughters) campaign. His call to post a ‘selfie with daughter’ touched people across the country.
 
The Pradhan Mantri Jan-Dhan Yojana (PMJDY) was another big I-day announcement with the laudable objective of bringing 40% of unbanked Indians into the formal banking system with a no-frills account, debit card and an insurance cover of Rs1 lakh. According to the PMJDY website, nearly 470 million accounts had been opened at the end of July 2015 and a whopping Rs20,769 crore has been deposited in these accounts. Are these really unbanked Indians rushing to deposit their money in the safety of banks? Or is a PMJDY account a way to avoid scrutiny by the tax authorities due to its lax KYC (know your customer) rules? Only time will tell. The PM followed this up with two more insurance schemes (accident cover and health insurance) at very attractive premiums. 
 
Unfortunately, a series of successful events, product launches and international visits does not make up for a series of mis-steps and inexplicable actions. The government seems badly advised about issues that it needs to prioritise in parliament and outside. It has failed to revitalise the economy, despite the benefit of a sharp fall in oil and gold prices and a decent monsoon. Its failure to manage parliament put it in the ignominious position of allowing the 44-member Congress party to lead a rag-tag opposition to boycott parliament and stall its key bills. But, worse, nobody has a clue why this is happening.
 
Mr Modi lampooned his predecessor by referring to him as ‘Maun-mohan Singh’ but his silence on several key issues has begun to rankle just as much. Why are so many top public sector banks (PSBs) headless for 13 months when their gross bad loans are set to touch Rs4 lakh crore, and a whopping Rs70,000 crore has been committed for their recapitalisation over the next four years (in addition to Rs45,000 crore in the past four years)? Why is accountability of government-owned banks not a priority for Modi sarkar
 
Many of us cheered when the PM announced his plan to shut down the Planning Commission last August. But NITI Aayog, the renamed Planning Commission, is not even Modi sarkar’s primary think tank. According to The Economic Times, the government will dole out nearly Rs500 crore in fees to the Big Four audit and consulting firms—PricewaterhouseCoopers, Ernst & Young, Deloitte and KPMG—along with strategy firms such as McKinsey, The Boston Consulting Group (BCG) and Bain & Company by March. This ‘quantum leap’ in engagements covers Make in India, Digital India, smart cities, Swachch Bharat and skill development. One would not grudge the money spent on consultants, if the government had used them to also produce white papers on various issues like the Black Money (Undisclosed Foreign Income and Assets) and Imposition of Tax Bill, 2015, the rollout of the Goods & Services Tax (GST), and to draw up an action plan for implementation of new policies. Had this been done, the government may have avoided a serious loss of face on the amendment to the The Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Bill, 2013 (commonly known as the Land Bill) which may now be dropped. A consultant’s study may have exposed the myth that land acquisition is holding back economic development. There is plenty of land under the control of sick public sector undertakings that can be imaginatively redeployed for new industries with some smart planning and out-of-the-box thinking. But the government seems disinclined to look at such options. 
 
R Jagannathan, a senior editor, has correctly pointed out that the rollout of the GST will be fraught with teething problems in the first couple of years. Its impact on traders, BJP’s big support group, and their reaction is still unknown. Yet, Mr Modi seems to have staked so much on it. 
 
Then there is the Black Money Bill which gives rather draconian powers to tax authorities. Moneylife Foundation had flagged these issues in April. BJP leader, Dr Subramaniam Swamy, then said, “I agree that the Bill contains some harshness and powers may be misused by revenue officials. The Bill is more like an I-T Bill and de facto amnesty scheme. The amnesty would also be dropped and in the end it will be just empowerment of I-T officials.” He also said there is nothing to stop the generation of fresh black money. Leading advocate Anil Harish told us how several of his clients were exploring foreign citizenship to avoid the draconian provisions of the Bill. The same thought was echoed by Rahul Bajaj in his interview to NDTV. A report by Ambit Capital says that several Indian businessmen, heading medium and small industries, as well as MNC executives may prefer to leave the country to avoid taxtortion under the Black Money Bill. 
 
The biggest worry for many of us is the repeated autocratic disregard of Supreme Court’s (SC’s) order against mandating biometric-based Aadhaar identification through the backdoor. If that weren’t enough, the government was planning to push through the Human DNA Profiling Bill 2015 in the monsoon session of parliament. In fact, the advocate general even argued that right to privacy is not a fundamental right under the Indian Constitution. 
 
On 11th August, a three-member SC bench said that Aadhaar can only be used for PDS, kerosene and LPG distribution. Personal information collected under Aadhaar cannot be shared by any authority, except for criminal investigation that too with the permission of the court. A Constitutional Bench will separately decide the larger question of whether collecting biometric data for preparing Aadhaar cards infringed on individual privacy and if the right to privacy was a fundamental right.
 
The UIDAI (Unique Identification Authority of India) project was the brainchild of Nandan Nilekani on the false premise that it will provide an identity to India’s rural, illiterate poor. Activists say that, in response to an RTI query in April 2015, it is learnt that only 219,000, out of 835 million Aadhaar numbers issued, were for those who did not have any other identity proof, i.e., only 0.03%. 
 
When they were in the opposition, both, Mr Modi and Arun Jaitley, were against Aadhaar. If something convinced the PM to change his mind about the efficacy of Aadhaar after assuming power, doesn’t he owe people an explanation? 
 
Finally, what do we make of the brazen display of State aggression against Maggi noodles? The PM has maintained a studied silence over the treatment of an MNC, even as reports have come in from laboratories in India and overseas that there is nothing wrong with the noodles. Having forced a huge loss on the company and damaged its reputation, the consumer affairs ministry, which seldom stirs itself to act, has filed a class action suit before the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission seeking Rs640 crore in damages. 
 
If the Congress alarmed investors with the way Vodafone was hounded, then the handling of Nestlé makes a mockery of Mr Modi’s call to Make in India. But the PM hasn’t uttered a word. Well, this is certainly not what we expected from the Modi sarkar
 

User

COMMENTS

Manoj

1 year ago

Extremely poor article - the kind that comes out of pens of those who think they are only consumers, not citizens, nor part of economy.

let me take them step by step. Is there a perfect way to prevent fraudsters from entering any govt scheme? If you have any solutions, except Aadhar and racial profiling, I'll be happy to hear them, but I think you have none.

Same with Black money steps. Agree they increase the power of the government, but what would you rather have? Right to Black Money bill? If so many luminaries want to leave the country, isnt that expected, knowing how crony loot of India's banks & public funds continued unabated for 10 years. Somehow that is also Modi's fault, huh?

Finally, the motivation for Maggi. Is it your case that Maggi has a right to mislabel and feel toxic products to citizens, and noone should interfere in the matter?

It is crazy that the same indians who constantly bemoaned the lawlessness and lack of enforcement of public interest by regulators, start grudging when they are given teeth and asked to use them in public interest, with dark dire threats of 'possible abuse'. What would solve this problem you have with everything that's done - a 3rd round of colonizers taking over the country??

All it shows is a negativity towards anything & everything that is India or done by indians. Not surprising - Macaulay education has created a large bunch of such indians since over a century. Even Gandhi wrote about this phenomenon in 1928.

manoharlalsharma

1 year ago

Has Modi, the Emperor, Really Lost His Shine? NOTHING CHANGED BUT SURE IT AFFECTED BY RAHU , THE GRAH WITHOUT BODY.

tikku

1 year ago

Introduction of new cards, enacting new laws etc will make no difference. If strictly followed, old laws are sufficient on which country ran well when these were followed. Gradually the laxity and apathetic attitude by the law enforcing agencies as well as in the quality of Governance by the succeeding Governments and corrupt practices by the political leaders, common public also increasingly became indifferent to laws. More important is to ensure implementation of the existing laws. Coining phrases and singing lectures will never do. I feel there is no tangible change in Governance even in this Modi era

Sudarshan Joshi

1 year ago

I fail to understand writer's opposition to Aadhar card. Cards similar to this are being used by all advanced countries and are an effective way to tackle corruption and crime. Right to privacy is a great argument by activists to derail the scheme. In the country where I stay, I can not live, rent, shop unless I have my ID. All my actions can be tracked with this if required. And that is a big deterrent for those looking to exploit the system.

KAVIRAJ B PATIL

1 year ago

What is the use of harsh laws when they are not implemented fairly and firmly. Occassionally, we hear some hanky panky about a politician's tax returns. But after a while, nothing happens. When the finances of political parties are not transparent, it is unfair of the Modi government to ask blue collar tax payers to mention a number of items in their tax returns. The taxpayer may spend more on preparing the return rather than the actual tax.

Ralph Rau

1 year ago

People of India especially idealistic youth are desperate to believe the promise of Less Government & More Governance.

The choice it seems is bring back a party which takes from a smaller economic cake (5.5% growth) OR support a party which takes from a bigger economic cake (7.5% growth using revised modelling).

5000 crores of election support funds has to be paid back ?

The greater danger is economic growth may not be guaranteed but re-writing of Indian history and re-shaping of Indian culture is guaranteed.

After all BJP = RSS = “Cultural” Organisation ?

It will be good to see a balanced analysis of the RISKS and OPPS of Modi Sarkar for 15 years.

REPLY

Meenal Mamdani

In Reply to Ralph Rau 1 year ago

I agree with the points that you have made.

Suhas Palshikar has written on this issue recently in the Indian Express "Avoidance of Debate". Even if Congress and BJP are avoiding this debate, readers should not. A civil public debate on this issue is the need of the hour. What path does India follow towards prosperity?

At least people should discuss the issues Suhas raises within their own family and friend circles.

ramchandran vishwanathan

1 year ago

Mr.Narendra Modi needs to prioritize the initiatives with target dates or atleast target quarters. The issue with this Government is extremely poor execution. We must bank on our think tank rather than outsourcing it to BIG 4. Am sure we are not short of individuals who have the calibre & talent to work towards our country's growth
Focus is key. Its also time for us citizens for active participation. Am glad that Moneylife is aggregating like minded people to take up critical issues.

S.S.A.Zaidi

1 year ago

Very well articulated.I wish points raised are pondered over.Everything is lost when credibility is lost
Zaidi

S.S.A.Zaidi

1 year ago

Very well articulated.I wish points raised are pondered over.Everything is lost when credibility is lost
Zaidi

S.S.A.Zaidi

1 year ago

Very well articulated.I wish points raised are pondered over.Everything is lost when credibility is lost
Zaidi

Dahyabhai S Patel

1 year ago

In wasting time to make acronyms etc., it has become senseless to call NITI Aayog (Commission) which reads when expanded as :National Institute for Transforming India Commission!!! Is there any difference between Institute and Commission? If not why the repetition? By naming it NITI is it full of Honesty (niti)? Is it not childish?!!!!

Dahyabhai S Patel

1 year ago

Apart from spending Rs.5000 crores on ads, how much black money might have generated in publicity and canvassing for about six months before general elections and distributing monies (at least Rs.500/100 note/s) and liquor to voters as is a practice which every body knows including CEC and supported by late Gopinath Munde and some MP from Haryana or so, that they spent more than Rs.20 crores each for their election compaign. Is it possible to get big favour without the monetary (ashweta laxmi) contribution to matrusanstha and party?

NANDAKUMAR M S

1 year ago

Whether he has lost his shine, I do not know, but certainly you have lost the willingness to be objective beyond personal likings and criticise where it is deserved. UIADI did not come today. And your support for Maggie is not at all correct. Do you really think a company will keep quiet and destroy the product if it is totally correct?

Ankur Bhatnagar

1 year ago

The government actually knows what needs to be done to revive the economy and everything along with it: that is minimum government and maximum governance.

However, looking at its actions, it seems that the government doing the opposite.

manoharlalsharma

1 year ago

MODI did all as NEW businessman wanting to open all windows at a time including out side of the COUNTRY without KNOWLEDGE of flow of BREEZE with HOPE to get BIG BUSINESS but forgetting the STAFF size and ability to control.

Fortnightly Market View: Back to Reality
China throws a googly
 
Afortnight ago, the Nifty was trading at around 8,534. At the...
Premium Content
Monthly Digital Access

Subscribe

Already A Subscriber?
Login
Yearly Digital+Print Access

Subscribe

Moneylife Magazine Subscriber or MSSN member?
Login

Yearly Subscriber Login

Enter the mail id that you want to use & click on Go. We will send you a link to your email for verficiation

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.
  Loading...
Close

To continue


Please
Sign Up or Sign In
with

Email
Close

To continue


Please
Sign Up or Sign In
with

Email

BUY NOW

The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)