Citizens' Issues
Dr Kalam’s ‘assurance’ on nuclear power plants draws flak

To people living in the vicinity of nuclear power plants, what matters is scientifically substantiated logic

Former bureaucrats and activists have expressed their bewilderment at former president Dr APJ Abdul Kalam’s controversial defence of nuclear power plants. Dr Kalam’s article in The Hindu has been followed by a string of letters and comments from sector experts, who have pointed out the loopholes in his reasoning.

Former finance and power secretary, EAS Sarma, in a letter to Dr Kalam asks, “When you brushed aside the safety concerns about nuclear technology as mere conjectures, did you make an effort to ask the nuclear establishment whether Nuclear Power Corporation of India (NCPIL) had ever carried out a reliable engineering study of each existing nuclear power plant to estimate the compound probability of an accident taking place as a result of a mechanical failure arising from the failure of individual components? If this has not done, can you jump to the conclusion that the probability of an accident is negligible, merely on the basis of your own appreciation of the number of accidents that have taken place during the last few decades?”

Mr Sarma, a resident of Vishakhapatnam, heads an environmentalists’ group called ‘Forum for Better Vishakha’. He has expressed his apprehensions about the upcoming Kovvada nuclear power plant near Srikakulam, which is his native place. He pointed out that though NCPIL has adopted a zoning system around nuclear power plants; and have earmarked a monitoring zone of 16km around the power plants, the residents of that area have not been told about this.

Terming Dr Kalam’s article as biased, Mr Sarma has alleged that the former president has underplayed the negative aspects of nuclear power, and has not mentioned the long-term impact of radioactivity on health. Mr Sarma also said that Dr Kalam has not considered the costs of decommissioning nuclear plants or managing toxic wastes. He further asks, “Are you aware that these costs are difficult to quantify? The cost of decommissioning Chernobyl will never be known, as it can never be decommissioned. With foreign financial help, Russians are building a sarcophagus around the contaminated Chernobyl reactors! Till date, the cost of Fukushima is not known.”

His thoughts have been echoed by a former general manager of railways at Indian Railway Service of Engineers, who says, “The public at large and the educated intelligentsia have all grave doubts about the safety of our country depending on nuclear power. After the recent disaster in Japan at Fukushima, Germany has already decided to phase out existing N-plants and stop the construction of new ones.” He has requested Dr Kalam to write another article and address the questions Mr Sarma has raised.

Former IAS officer MG Devasahayam said, “I wonder as to why the venerable Dr Kalam is on an emotional overdrive preaching for nuclear power. He compares nuclear disasters with air-crash and missile-launching snags, calls the protesters ignorant cowards and goes to Kudunkulam to proclaim that the nuclear plant is a boon to the locals.”

User

COMMENTS

MUKESH

6 years ago



HOWEVER SAFE ANY NUCLEAR PLANT MAY BE, IT IS NEVER SAFE AGAINST FORCES OF NATURE, WHICH IS GOING TO CAUSE MORE HAVOC IN YEARS TO COME DUE VARIOUS IMBALANCES GLOBALLY - CLIMATE CHANGE, EARTHQUAKES, TSUNAMIS OF MUCH GREATER PROPORTIONS & DAMAGE, NOT COUNTING HUMAN MICHIEFS LIKE TERROR ATTACKS & OTHER MAN-MADE DISASTERS!

JAPANESE ARE THE MOST SAFETY CONSCIOUS, YET AGAINST FORCES OF NATURE AT FUKUSHIMA, THEY WERE HELPLESS!

IN A COUNTRY LIKE INDIA, WHERE EVEN ORDINARY ACCIDENT & SMALL DISASTERS ARE NOT MANAGED, BUT MISMANAGED, ANY NUCLEAR DISASTER, WHEN IT HAPPENS, WOULD BE THE WORST KIND IN HUMAN HISTORY AS INDIANS MAKE A JACKASS OF THEMSELVES! NONE OF THE EXPERTS' ASSURANCES MEAN A DAMNED! THIS IS NOT A COUNTRY WHERE SAFETY OR HUMAN LIVES ARE EVER VALUED AT ALL AS A MATTER OF HABIT!
DESPITE ALL THE MERITS OF NUCLEAR POWER, IT IS MOST FOOLISH TO GO FOR IT IN A COUNTRY LIKE INDIA WHERE NOBODY IS RESPONSIBLE FOR ANYTHING.

BM Hegde

6 years ago

“The liberties of a people never were, nor ever will be, secure, when the transactions of their rulers may be concealed from them.” Patrick Henry.

Clean nuclear power, coming from a conventional nuclear fission reactor, is only a myth! Of course, in the limited sense of carbon footprints, it could be clean. If one were alive to the story of nuclear disasters-man made like Hiroshima and accidental ones like Chernobyl and Fukushima recently-one would shudder to think of nuclear energy as safe and clean. Hiroshima was millions of times more sinister than the 9/11 inhuman destruction in New York City. Chernobyl is still killing people even as far away as Scotland. An estimated 4000 to 40,000 have already met their maker as per the official statistics, exiting here through the cancer door. Many more must be incubating still. Fukushima was so big a disaster which no one can size up so soon. A total of 6,00,000 pounds of plutonium and other wastes from nuclear sources are waiting to be disposed off all over the world. The owners do not even know where to dispose them off. As the half life of that stuff is around 750 years; many, many more future generations will have to suffer for our sins!

ajit

6 years ago

Please piblish Mr. E A S Sarma's letter and holistic article by Mr. Sankar Sharma as a rejoinder to Mr. Kalam. Available on http://www.dianuke.org.

Greek PM to step down in deal to save country, euro

After a closed-doors meeting between prime minister George Papandreou, opposition chief Antonis Samaras and head of state president Carolos Papoulias that lasted almost two hours, the statement was passed around to a waiting crowd of reporters from around the world that the prime minister would step down

Athens: Political leaders in Greece clinched a historic deal to form a national unity government to haul the debt-wracked country, and the Eurozone, back from the brink of disaster, reports PTI.

Prime minister George Papandreou crucially agreed to step down on Sunday, removing a key stumbling block which had held up an accord just hours before nervous financial markets reopen today with the euro in the line of fire.

“An agreement was reached to form a new government to immediately lead the country to elections after ratifying the decisions taken by the European Council,” the Greek president’s office said in a statement.

After a closed-doors meeting between Mr Papandreou, opposition chief Antonis Samaras and head of state president Carolos Papoulias that lasted almost two hours, the statement was passed around to a waiting scrum of reporters from around the world, causing a near-stampede.

“Prime minister George Papandreou has already stated that he will not lead the new government,” it added.

“Tomorrow there will be a new communication between the prime minister and the head of the opposition on the new prime minister and the new government.”

With patience in Europe and in Greece wearing thin, pressure had mounted throughout the day for an agreement that Mr Papandreou had said was needed to keep Greece in the Eurozone.

European leaders had become increasingly frustrated at the political impasse in Athens at a time when they want to press ahead with hard-won agreements reached in late October on tackling the Eurozone debt crisis.

The accord comes just ahead of a key Euro group finance ministers meeting today to discuss whether to release an eight billion euro ($11 billion) slice of bailout cash that Greek finance minister Evangelos Venizelos says is needed by 15th December to keep the country afloat.

There will likely be no let-up too in the pressure on Athens to implement stinging austerity measures in return for the cash payment, available under the first May 2010 Greek bailout package.

The new government will be tasked with implementing the terms of an October European Union (EU) bailout deal that calls for further harsh austerity measures on Greece, already at breaking point due to a shrinking economy and rapidly rising unemployment.

Greek media earlier tipped finance minister Mr Venizelos to take over from Mr Papandreou as the talks got bogged down for almost two days in a dangerous game of brinkmanship, with Samaras insisting on immediate elections, which Mr Papandreou resisted as too risky.
The damaging political stalemate threatened to see the country run out of cash within weeks after European leaders secured their hard-won overall Eurozone debt crisis accord at a summit late last month.

Greek business and church leaders piled the pressure on politicians to agree a national unity government as quickly as possible, saying the country’s future was at stake.

“The future of all of us for the next decade is being decided right now,” the Greek federation of enterprises said in a statement yesterday.

“The more the uncertainty lasts, the more the country is literally hanging by a thread,” the group said, calling for a “bold compromise of political maturity and national responsibility.”

Meanwhile, Constantinos Michalos, head of the Athens Chamber of Commerce, said the stalemate needed to be broken by yesterday, warning otherwise of dire consequences when the financial markets open again today.

“A solution is required immediately otherwise the country risks finding itself out of the Eurozone tomorrow,” said Mr Michalos.

Mr Papandreou set the ball rolling on Monday with a shock announcement that Greece would hold a referendum on the terms of its October bailout deal which calls for further fierce austerity measures.

The move stunned fellow European leaders, sent global markets into a tailspin and earned the Greek prime minister a humiliating dressing-down by the France and Germany on Wednesday ahead of a G20 meeting.

User

Digitisation of TV to involve investment of up to Rs40,000 crore

Entailing an expected investment of up to Rs40,000 crore, digitisation across the country will be completed by 2014 year-end after which the government would earn Rs30,000 crore each year on various accounts, including subscription

New Delhi: Digitisation of TV signals, which will give consumers much broader choice of channels at low price, will start in four metros from June next year, reports PTI.

Entailing an expected investment of up to Rs40,000 crore, digitisation across the country will be completed by 2014 year-end after which the government would earn Rs30,000 crore each year on various accounts, including subscription.

“It is generally a very big reform of the broadcasting industry,” information and broadcasting minister Ambika Soni told PTI in an interview.

She said the entire process of digitisation, that is to be implemented in phases, will be completed by 31 December 2014.

In the first step, the digitisation will be conducted in four metro cities by 1st June next year, two months after the target date set for it in a proposal approved by the Cabinet.

Explaining this delay, she said there was a provision for giving a six-month notice (after Cabinet decision). “So we are having to change it from 31st March, which was the time the metros had to (do), to 1st June. But it doesn’t disturb the rest of the schedule,” the minister said.

The current analog cable system offers consumers no choice of channels they can select. Generally, a single rate is charged from customers and the package is mostly of 80-90 channels.

Digital platforms will carry more channels and offer better quality. Digital cables have the capacity to carry up to 1,000 channels.

The move is expected to benefit broadcasters also as it will remove the need for paying carriage fee to cable operators, bringing down the cost of operations.

At present, carriage and placement fee contribute nearly 20% of the total cost of running a channel.

After digitisation, all satellite channels will be beamed to houses through set-top boxes.

“Earlier it was that the cable operators, those who had analog system, were not always onboard,” Ms Soni said, adding that it was “not an addressable system” as the government was losing out on revenue.

The I&B minister said digitisation would lead to an “addressable system” and that digital signals can be routed through cable operators who would have to go for the maximum investment of Rs3 lakh each for it. “They have welcomed it,” she added.

“It is also a step in favour of government. In the analog system, it was very difficult to tabulate government loses out on revenue,” she said.

By undertaking digitisation, the government expects to mop up revenues to the tune of Rs30,000 crore approximately per year, she said, adding that it would be on account of fees, subscription, etc.

The government has got Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) on board and both are working together, she said.

On the financial implications, she said the process could involve investments between Rs20,000 crore to Rs40,000 crore and the issue has been referred to the Committee of Secretaries for sorting out.

“I think this would mean an investment obviously and people who have to do the investment were waiting for us to announce this policy,” Ms Soni said.

The I&B minister explained that some financial implications, which could be called incentives, could not be a part of a Cabinet note. “So, the Cabinet took a decision that all those issues would be looked at by a Committee of Secretaries headed by the cabinet secretary,” she said.

The committee, which also includes revenue secretary, IT secretary and I&B secretary, will give its considered view within a month.

When pointed out that the finance ministry had been hesitant in funding the project, Ms Soni said, “They are right.

The incentive type of suggestion should not really form part of the Cabinet note. So those have been put before a CoS under the cabinet secretary. They will discuss that and give the answers.”

The help that had been sought from the finance ministry was in the form of exemption of tariffs.

Ms Soni did not elaborate but sources said the ministry, in its proposal, had said all entities involved in digitisation be considered infrastructure service providers, and tax concessions be accorded to them till complete digitisation is done.

The I&B ministry had suggested measures like waiving the 5% duty on set-top boxes that would have to be imported and installed by the consumers.

User

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.
  Loading...
Close

To continue


Please
Sign Up or Sign In
with

Email
Close

To continue


Please
Sign Up or Sign In
with

Email

BUY NOW

The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)