Leisure, Lifestyle & Wellness
Life Exclusive
Doctors need to focus on health care, not wealth creation

We must do all in our powers to bring back the glory of medical practice of yesteryears where the patient and the doctor were two trusting human beings

“I therefore, the prisoner in the Lord, beg you to lead a life worthy of the calling to which you have been called, with all humility and gentleness, with patience, bearing with one another in love, making every effort to maintain the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace"—Anon

Has modern medicine lost its heart? With the advent of hospitals in the 18th century modern medicine has been going at a tangent vis-à-vis its avowed goal of “curing rarely, comforting mostly, but consoling always.” With the advent of corporate care in a hi-tech set-up in the last couple of decades, modern medicine is no more a calling; but a trillion dollar industry—the sickness industry. The word hospital derives its sustenance from hospitality. Today’s corporate hospitals are anything but hospitable, they are down right inhospitable and live to sell disease care at a premium! What was once a “bunch of corrupt, incompetent, and nepotistic” lot of doctors in London, in the words of Dr James Wakeley, in 1823, the medical fraternity today has become a “Corporate Monstrosity,” according to medical historian-journalist, Hillary Butler in 2011. William Wordsworth, the romantic English poet, traces the root of present rot in money minded society thus:

                   “The world is too much with us; late and soon,
                    Getting and spending, we lay waste our powers;
                    Little we see in Nature that is ours;
                   We have given our hearts away, a sordidboon!...”

Medical claptrap and its pseudo science
Ever since modern medicine was taken to the market place, market forces, especially advertisements and jargon, tried to sell the idea to the gullible public that modern medicine is the only saviour of mankind in the disease setting. People also seem to be fully convinced that modern medicine is “scientific.” The industry is fully cashing in on this colossal societal ignorance. Truth is that modern medicine in particular and biology in general are in search of their Holy Grail, the true non-linear holistic science base.

Most of what we do in medicine today is simply palliation—putting a lid on the smouldering fire. We are also obsessed with the search for a label, called the diagnosis, which in itself has become a prohibitively expensive disease. With the mad push to get at the final accurate diagnosis, the industry has devised thousands of tests, scans and scopes that together make a mockery of clinical bedside medicine. Reductionist ideas to replenish every drop of every thing that changes inside according to our tests denies the role of mother nature in setting things right with the help of the healing powers of the human body including its capacity for transmutation of elements!

The rise and fall of the corporate culture
The concept of hospitality in hospitals has been killed by the rise of the money-centred corporate culture in hospitals. Anything that goes up has to, per force, come down; since gravity is a very powerful force. Sooner the corporate culture comes down in the sick room the better for patients, doctors and nurses in every hospital. Illness itself is bad, to be seriously ill is worse enough but, to get into a corporate hospital today in that scenario is almost fatal, to say the least. All sided anxiety rules the roost in a serious disease setting in the hospital, but today’s corporate hospitals have a new breed of men and women who have had no training  in patient care or compassion at all, who are the corporate money masters. Young and well paid as they are, their sole training and directive is to make profit irrespective of consequences in any setting-agony, death and dying not excluded. Their motto is that “hospitals are built by money, of money and for making money.” They have not heard of that old man Hippocrates who averred that “one should not try to make money in the sick room.” Corporate money spinners have only heard of hypocrites all around them. It is a sight for the Gods in any corporate hospital when a seriously ill patient is being wheeled into the pinnacle of curing glory of these hospitals—the intensive care unit—the weeping relatives, patients struggling between life and death, compassionate doctors and nurses (majority of these two castes are still compassionate) trying to help and revive the patient, and these corporate vultures waiting for their pound of flesh in the whole bargain. Another novel money spinner is the present avatar of health (sickness) insurance, which looks like a boon but, works like a curse when the chips are down!

Technology plays an important role to add to the patients’ and relatives’ woes. A couple of decades old study done in Bristol and Sheffield Health areas in England by Mather and his colleagues showed that following a heart attack at home, a good risk patient (who does not have cardio-genic shock, heart failure and/or serious arrhythmias) is better off left at home than being rushed in a hi-tech ambulance to the hospital. A recent study in the US showed that the leading cause of a stroke today is getting admitted, following a heart attack, to a hospital where they have the technology to sell coronary bypass surgery. Immediate post heart attack coronary bypass surgery would increase stroke risk four fold! I can go on like this ad infinitum but, suffice it to say that most of these hi-tech new stuff do precious little to add to patient comfort in the long run. A study of chronic myeloid leukaemia at Christy’s in Manchester showed that the per capita death rate of patients registered there between 1900-1940 and 1950-1990 was almost identical with a marginal benefit in the first group. All that they did for those patients between 1900 and 1940 was tender loving care sans hi-technology.

Plea for Parsimony
Medicine being a worthy calling and the best God-given opportunity to do good to others in distress, we must do all in our powers to bring back the dead glory of medical practice of yesteryears where the patient and the doctor were two trusting human beings. That trust is being seriously eroded with patients being treated as buyers and doctors as sellers of disease care, the latter having become a saleable commodity in today’s corporate world. Happily the majority of doctors are still not fully sold to this corporate idea. It is only the venerated wealth generators who distort this good image of doctoring by their business designs of the sickness industry. I do not understand the words “wealth generation”. The only way one could generate large wealth is by printing currency notes. There is no way you could become stinking rich otherwise. To make big money you have to loot some one. In the name of wealth creation through sickness care would be looting the dying patients and their broke relatives. Let us be parsimonious in our effort to help others. It is in giving that we get. Have a heart.
 “Go to you bosom: Knock there, and ask your heart what it doth know”William Shakespeare

(Professor Dr BM Hegde, a Padma Bhushan awardee in 2010, is an MD, PhD, FRCP (London, Edinburgh, Glasgow & Dublin), FACC and FAMS. He is also Editor-in-Chief of the Journal of the Science of Healing Outcomes, Chairman of the State Health Society's Expert Committee, Govt of Bihar, Patna. He is former Vice Chancellor of Manipal University at Mangalore and former professor for Cardiology of the Middlesex Hospital Medical School, University of London. Prof Dr Hegde can be contacted at [email protected])



K J Choudhury

5 years ago

It is a fashion today to show doctor in bad light; movie is a typical example. It is unfortunate that the author has focussed on few city corporate hospitals, even there he should find out the doctor's share in the bill. The author should be aware that banks, electricity , water authority etc do not provide any concession and many hosptals can't sustain, hence close down. Most medical care in small town / villages are performed reasonally well by doctors under very limited resorces. Patients have a choice to govt hospitals. Today you can't practice with the help of a stethescope alone as refered to stories of the past. There are many unscrupulous doctors but they are far far few (and should be taken to task) compared to other professions today.


5 years ago

THere is more to it than we know. Recently I was waiting at a 5 Star Hotel for a meeting. I was able to overhear a loud conversation on next table. I realise that they are a group who run hospitals for bottom of pyramid people. They were from diff parts of India & were sharing notes on commission passed to Drs for referal. I was shocked to hear that ref comm is as high as 50% in NCR & Mumbai is abt 30%. It is paid by all Top hospitals & they have an annual meet with Drs to decide targets, commission, etc. One ground rule - OT (Op Theatre) should always be in use. An idle OT means serious trouble. Also they shield each other. If a case goes wrong, all Specialists are called to fix the issue. In such case, all extra expenses are borne by hospital to avoid bad publicity. May be Vinita takes up this as her next story.


nagesh kini

In Reply to Sanjay 5 years ago

All the commission going by name of cut as well as doctor wise 'quota' or target that includes investigations -blood, urine, xray, mri, ecg, in addition to consultancy and also surgery is an open secret, though the hospitals deny it for public consumption!

Nagesh Kini FCA

5 years ago

Dr. Vaibhavbhai, you are a doctor, I'm a CA. Ask any lawyer or engineer - there is no profession left out it is all cut throat business pure and simple.
People of Dr. Hegde's genre today are few and far between.
In the good old days the 'family doctor', a GP was the friend, philosopher and guide to generations of patients. Today's GP awaits his 'cut' from his referral the moment the patient leaves his portals.


dr sharmila rao pn

In Reply to Nagesh Kini FCA 5 years ago

You are right Mr.Kini, there is also a new threat, OTC medication, self medication after online study and self diagnosis, when the system fails, hammer the doctor. Dr.Hegde it is time you stopped doling the same story.


In Reply to dr sharmila rao pn 5 years ago

Sorry, Dr. Rao. As an income-tax man with 35 years' experience and the experience of handling the cases of thousands of doctors, hundreds of hospitals and drug manufactures, I think Der. Hegde is doing a great job.

Dr Vaibhav G Dhoka

5 years ago

I myself is medical practitionorAnd my experience is every section of society is cheating other member of society.May be Lawyer or Chartered accountant or TV mechanic or a plumber.A plumber charges Rs 400 to 500 per visit.Then how can we separate medicos from this GRAB All in present scenario.



In Reply to Dr Vaibhav G Dhoka 5 years ago

Plumbers are charging more cos there is a high earning doctor / lawyer / engineer ready to pay.

Also consider this - we get double digit hikes every year which negates the inflation. Does this happen for the plumber or mechanic or maid? Our employment allows us to enjoy whole range of facilities ranging from insurance to vacation to reimbursements etc. Do they get any such thing?


5 years ago

Very great article indeed. But, I may respectfully submit that, in a scenario where a very large number of medical graduates and MDs/MSs are being turned out by private medical colleges, which are all Demmed Universities too, after paying huge capitation fees ranging from Rs. 40-50 lakhs in the MBBS course and about a crore of rupees for MD/MS (excluding the regular and disclosed admission fees, monthly fees (payable in advance), and many other dwemands on their providers' pockets (many, of course, are from families of civil servants!), is it not too much to expect them to be saints as far as worldly riches and material prosperity are concerned?

Public Interest Exclusive
Pratibha Patil's abandoned retirement home: Who will foot the bill?

Anoop Awasthi, a formal naval officer and well known RTI activist has asked a series of questions related to the defence land and expenditures incurred on the “special repairs” of bungalow no 26A and 38, where the Presidential palace was coming up

Following the persistent agitation by the three intrepid activists, and supported by several exclusive articles by Vinita Deshmukh in Moneylife, the President of India Pratibha Patil agreed to give up the land on which she was building a palatial post retirement bungalow. However, there are many questions unanswered like who would bear the cost of demolishing the existing bungalow and constructing a new one. Right to Information (RTI) activists have already started filing applications seeking more details in the land grab case.

Anoop Awasthi, a formal naval officer and well known RTI activist (who was the one who procured vital documents under RTI) has asked a series of questions that could further nail the President. Mr Awasthi served as a naval officer (JCO rank) for 15 years. A tenacious RTI activist, Mr Awasthi had also fought a silent battle in the Lavasa campaign.

In his latest RTI applications, Mr Awasthi has asked the Command Works Engineer (CWE-Kirkee) Khadki and the Defence Estate Officer a series of question related with the defence land and expenditures incurred on the “special repairs” of bungalow no 26A and 38, where the Presidential palace was coming up.

He has asked the following questions:
1. Details of defence lands that have been converted into free hold in the last 20 years along with authority for the same.
2. Details of A1 lands on which encroachments have occurred and action taken against such encroachments.
3. Details of defence lands (A1 to C) under your holding where commercial activity is going on.
4. Details of action initiated against owners of such lands.
5. Details of resumption notices issued to grant property owners for various violations of provisions of the grant including like illegal construction, etc.
6. Details of sites licensed for advertisement hoardings on defence lands and details of revenue earned from such licenses for the last five years and the account under which these funds have been accounted for.
7. Details of reclassification of land done in the last 15 years and reasons for doing the same.
8. Details of transfer/disposal of surplus camping ground/abandoned air fields. Full details of defence land declared surplus in the last 20 years.
9. Details of grant of fresh leases in the last 30 years with details and authority for the same.

In a related RTI, Mr Awasthi has asked the following queries to the Public Information Officer, Command Works Engineer (CWE-Kirkee) Khadki, Pune
1. Details of expenditure incurred till 27 April 2012 on the special repairs to the bungalow no 26A and 38.
2. Copy of photographs showing existence of the building for which special repairs were sanctioned
3. Copy of the sanction order for special repairs to bungalow no 26A and 38 and name of the contractors
4. Date on which the special repairs to the residential premises for the president was completed or stopped.
5. Details of the proposed adjustment of the expenditure incurred and its final settlement.



Shanti Patel

5 years ago

We must congratulate Mr. Annop Awasthi for fighting against the highest offfice. All the departments at the disposal of the government starts working against you the movement you go like Mr. Awasthi.
I have experience and felt and know how hard it is to fight against the mighty single handily.
All the expenses which are incurred
MUST BE RECOVERED FROM THE SALARY OF OUR PRESIDENT. The highest office must set the RIGHT example. People must ensure this and protest the they have protested against
constructing and giving away land to her.
This type of thing happens when we appoint people without proper background, educational qualifications and real ability.


5 years ago

When the present president took over from Dr.Kalam the writing in the wall was very clear to everyone that the president too would follow the same footsteps of her mother-organisation adopting corrupt practices as well as dubious methods for personal agrandisement. Her role in Maharashtra was clearly published by many in media at the time of her candidature itself. But Sonia &Co would not heed it as they wanted a complying president for all the corrupt appointments by the UPA government.
India should now insist on Dr.Kalam coming back



In Reply to RNandakumar 5 years ago

Yes Nandakumar ...
I agree ... the head is corrupt (bahu & co.) .. so they want similar ppl to head every department to plunder India... we are mere spectators ... years back it was the Britons , Portuguese etc... now its our babuz...
Duno when people who love their Country will rule India ... we need a real Indian.. not one who pretends to be one...


In Reply to RNandakumar 5 years ago

yes we should ask the repesentatives to chose Klam one more time


5 years ago

Naturally the tax payers must pay!

Best Mutual Fund: How to choose winning equity funds

Look for 1-year, 3-year and 5-year performance, as Jason Monteiro explains

We are often...

Premium Content
Monthly Digital Access


Already A Subscriber?
Yearly Digital+Print Access


Moneylife Magazine Subscriber or MSSN member?

Yearly Subscriber Login

Enter the mail id that you want to use & click on Go. We will send you a link to your email for verficiation

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)