Citizens' Issues
Criticism over unnecessarily huge awards for World Cup winning cricketers

Some people are critical that taxpayers’ funds should not be used for awards, when it is needed for more important purposes

India won the cricket World Cup after a wait of nearly three decades. And the victory was celebrated with much frenzy-crowds danced on the streets waving the tri-colour, people distributed sweets, many offered prayers in thanksgiving. Some state governments immediately announced big awards to honour the cricketers for their hard-fought achievement.

Amid the celebrations, some citizens are already questioning the wisdom of the authorities to spend so much money from taxpayers' funds that would have been better used to provide a meal to millions of deprived people in our society.

"The taxpayers' money should not be given to cricketers who make tonnes of money from advertisement opportunities over and above the crore they will receive from BCCI and others," said one comment on a discussion portal.

The Indian team has been well rewarded, quite literally. On the night of the victory, the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) announced a cash prize of Rs1 crore for each player in the World Cup winning team. State governments also joined in felicitating the players. The Gujarat government decided to honour two of the players from the state with the "Eklavya Puraskar", its highest sports award. The Maharashtra government announced a cash prize of Rs1 crore each for Sachin Tendulkar and Zaheer Khan. The Delhi government said it will give Rs1 crore each to Virender Sehwag, Gautam Gambhir, Ashish Nehra and Virat Kohli and Rs2 crore for captain Mahendra Singh Dhoni.

Another person wrote: "BCCI is a commercial body and can afford any amount of cash or material in prizes. Governments in states and at the Centre must not throw away money like this to the cash-rich players, while there is scarcity of food grains with so many poor living at, or below the poverty line."

Krishnaraj Rao, Mumbai-based Right to Information (RTI) activist, told Moneylife that on the one hand the state information commissions were deprived of funds and on the other each cricketer was being given Rs1 crore. "The budgetary requirement of the chief information commission of Maharashtra for 2010-11 was around Rs6 crore. But only Rs4.59 crore was allocated, for eight offices spread across the state. In fact, the working staff has to manage the entire petty cash requirement on their own," Mr Rao explained. "Such is the situation of the information commissioner's office. And the same state government is rewarding Rs1 crore for a single player."

As per BCCI's retention policy, Indian cricket players are paid retainership fees in three grades. Accordingly, Grade A players like Sachin Tendulkar, Gautam Gambhir get Rs1 crore as fees, Grade B players like Yuvraj Singh, Virat Kohli are paid Rs50 lakh as fees, and Grade C players like S Sreeshant, Rohit Kumar get Rs25 lakh. In addition to the retainership fees, players in the eleven for a particular game are paid for the match also. Accordingly, the payment for a Test match is Rs7 lakh, for a one-day international match it is Rs4 lakh and for a T20 match it is Rs2 lakh.

Some activists' have also criticised the government for its bias against sports other than cricket, which they describe as a "pampered child".

"There should be a national consensus and there should be a predetermined norm for prize money for a world champion, an Olympic champion, a national champion and state champion. The principle of equity should determine the prize money. There is no scope for fatalism and emotion-surcharged prize distribution. Let it not generate an adverse impact and a negative fall-out on other sports. Public money belongs to all categories of sports," said another netizen.

A couple of activists have pointed out that as if these cash awards were not enough, there have also been announcements of some life-time benefits for the cricketers. "Not only are they doling out prizes out of our tax money, they are committing for the future as well, with life-time railway passes and so on," read another comment.




6 years ago

i'd suggest something more radical.the big tax prizes are going to the richest indian cricketers -who easily PAY crores in it is really NOT CHARITY or any favor if they are actually getting some of their OWN money back. if a rookie cricketer gets 1 crore from the sarkar,i would be even more upset -because that would be truly theft .what the BCCI pays them or private parties pays them is none of our business.
one could ofcourse argue that this amounts to favoritism -certain taxpayers getting a good break. be it.the lesser the amount stolen from fewer people,its better.
in anycase,income taxes account for only about 8% of the govt's receipts.the rest comes from corporate taxes,indirect taxes and ofcourse money printing (rbi debt monetization or currency intervention MSS bonds etc).


6 years ago

Some friends were saying our Crickers are really good, they may ultimately refuse Prizes and Awards offered by other than BCCI. As they do not to become part of any financial Irregularities or Scams, Frauds which later come to light, as a lot of controversies are already coming in after such big Jack-pot's annoucements!

IMF lowers India’s growth forecast to 8.2% for 2011

"The challenge for many emerging and some developing economies is to ensure that present boom-like conditions do not develop into overheating over the coming year," the IMF said in its 'World Economic Outlook' report

Washington: The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has lowered India's economic growth rate forecast to 8.2% for 2011 and warned that boom-like conditions could lead to over-heating of the economy, reports PTI.

"The challenge for many emerging and some developing economies (is) to ensure that present boom-like conditions do not develop into overheating over the coming year," the IMF said in its 'World Economic Outlook' report.

The multilateral lending agency had earlier projected the country's economy to grow by 8.4% in 2011.

IMF took note of the high inflation in India, recorded at 8.31% in February, even as the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) expects it to come down to 8% by March-end.

"Signs of overheating are starting to materialise in a number of economies. Most of the increase in headline inflation in recent months has been due to a spike in food prices, but core inflation has also been increasing in a number of economies, most notably India," IMF said.

Further, it projected the Indian economy to grow at a moderate 7.8% in 2012 and cautioned that rising commodity prices and disruptions to oil supply could pose new risks to economic recovery.

"Commodity prices have increased more than expected, reflecting a combination of strong demand growth and a number of supply shocks. These increases conjure the spectre of 1970s-style stagflation, but they appear unlikely to derail the recovery," the IMF said.

According to the international multilateral organisation, the inflationary pressure is likely to increase further as high food and energy prices would require an increase in wages.

On global growth trends, IMF said, Asia would outpace other regions on the back of strong export performance, buoyant private domestic demand and rapid credit growth.

It said the financial conditions continued to improve after the global crisis, although they remained unusually fragile.

"In many emerging market economies, demand is robust and overheating is a growing policy concern. Developing economies, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa, have also resumed fast and sustainable growth," IMF said.

It added, "Given the improvement in financial markets, buoyant activity in many emerging and developing economies, and growing confidence in advanced economies, economic prospects for 2011-12 are good."

However, it retained its projection for global economic growth at 4.5% in 2011 and 2012, which is lower than 5% growth it projected for 2010.


Crompton Greaves to set up R&D centre in Nashik

Crompton Greaves is setting up of an ultra high voltage (1,200kV) research centre in Nashik as a part of its global research and development

Crompton Greaves Ltd has announced setting up of an ultra high voltage (1,200kV) research centre in Nashik as a part of its global research and development.

"(After) having achieved leadership position in the manufacture of high voltage power products up to 800kV, now we are setting up this ultra high voltage (UHV) research centre in city's Ambad industrial estate plan," SM Trehan, managing director of CGL, said.

After laying the foundation stone of UHV research centre here, Mr Trehan said that research activities planned here would tremendously enhance the company's technological capabilities in the advanced technological arena.

The company is making an initial investment of Rs40 crore for the centre and will further augment the infrastructure in the next three years by spending additional Rs20 crore, he said.


We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)