Citizens' Issues
CIC asks home ministry to disclose file notings on mercy petitions

The CIC directed the home ministry to disclose file notings and correspondence related to mercy petitions of all death row convicts including Afzal Guru

 

The Central Information Commission (CIC) has asked the ministry of home affairs (MHA) to disclose copies of the file notings, not forming part of the ministerial advice to the President of India, related to mercy petitions of all convicts on death sentence including Afzal Guru and others.

Sushma Singh, Central Information Commissioner, in an order dated 26th June, said, “the Chief Public Information Officer (CPIO) of the MHA should provide the file notings after severing all the names and other references regarding the identities of the public servants those file notings and making those correspondence”.

The CIC also asked the ministry to disclose the copies of the correspondence made by MHA to the President’s Secretariat from time to time in connection with the mercy petitions.

Right to Information (RTI) activist Subhash Chandra Agrawal, along with Venkatesh Nayak, Suchismita Goswami and Nandita Sinha filed the second appeal before the CIC, after the concerned authorities failed to disclose the information sought by him. In the application, they sought following information:

1.    Copy of complete correspondence/file-notings/documents, etc, relating to mercy-petitions of Afzal Guru and other convicts of death sentence whose files have been forwarded to the President’s Secretariat by Union home ministry after rejection of mercy petitions of Devindersingh Khullar and Mahender Nath Dass by the Honourable President of India.

2.    Complete and detailed information together with correspondence/file-notings/documents, etc, including list of convicts of death sentence whose mercy petitions are decided by the Honourable President of India after rejection of mercy petitions of Devindersingh Khullar and Mahender Nath Dass by the Honourable President of India.

3.    Complete updated detailed list of pending mercy petitions at any stage like at Union home ministry and President’s Secretariat or with state governments, etc, by persons convicted of death sentence.

4.    Complete updated list of mercy petitions sent finally by Union home ministry with its recommendations/comments, etc, to the President’s Secretariat/Honourable President of India for final disposal mentioning also recommendations made by Union home ministry and dates of recommendations sent by Union Home Ministry.

5.    Any other related details.

6.    File-notings on movement of this RTI petition as well.

The CPIO, in his reply, refused to disclose information related with point no 1 saying that it cannot be disclosed under Section8(1), (a), (g) and (i) of the RTI Act. In reply to point no 2, the CPIO said, “Two mercy petition cases i.e. cases of Murugan, Santhan & Arivu of Tamil Nadu and Sattan & Guddu of Uttar Pradesh, have been decided after the decision of mercy petition case of Devender Pal Singh. Documents of the case of Murugan, Santhan & Arivu cannot be disclosed under section 8(1)(a),(b) & (g) of RTI Act. However, some pages of the mercy petition case of Sattan & Guddu can be furnished on the payment of Rs82 for 41 pages (Rs2 per page)”.

However, Mr Agrawal felt that it is unjustified that exemption may be sought only for some selected cases while file notings are allowed on rest other cases. “(The) CPIO has also not mentioned any court order prohibiting disclosure of file notings as claimed under section 8(1)(b) of RTI Act. Rather it is a matter of great public interest involving even life and liberty of certain individuals that too at a time when demand for abolishing death sentence is worldwide, including even in India,” he said.

While no decision has been taken on the mercy petitions of several convicts on death sentence, there is one case of Ram Chander Ravji, whose fate was decided in record six days by the President of India, says Mr Agrawal. “File-notings disclosed in case of one Ravji @ Ram Chandra decided in record six days by the then President of India with final hanging done in less than three years of committing the crime (murder) had shocked even many legal luminaries and those in judiciary, and even rules were changed thereafter to decide mercy petitions on basis of the date of the trial court judgment rather than earlier system of deciding according to dates of filing mercy petitions,” he said.

“Providing file notings on mercy petitions can effectively check any such repeat of wrong decision on mercy petitions like was admittedly done in supersonic hanging of Ravji @ Ram Chandra in record shortest period as referred above,” said the RTI activist.

User

COMMENTS

P M Ravindran

4 years ago

Treason again! The Act provides for giving file notings as they are and not censored versions!

Moneylife magazine

 

Moneylife, an Essential Tool for Learning-Earning-Spending-Investing Cycle. Moneylife magazine is a fortnightly that is focused on personal finance topics borrowings, mutual funds, real estate, stocks, insurance and taxes. It empowers the individual to invest and spend wisely by offering hard facts, insightful opinions, unbiased options and useful tips from the world of money. Moneylife has created a high mindshare with its innovative content and pro-reader stance. It delivers a stellar mix of unique content, sharp analysis and a lucid writing style in a classy design and layout that is a cut above its competitors. Moneylife offers a totally honest opinion about financial products; we are one of the rare publications to analyse life insurance products from with the interests of policyholders in mind and have carried a crusade against debilitating pyramid schemes. 
 
Among Moneylife’s innovations are unique long career interviews that have drawn out the fascinating stories of the biggest and the best achievers in their own words. Moneylife has been the only magazine to feature luminaries such as Mukesh Ambani, Ratan Tata, Professor CNR Rao, RK Laxman, Professor MM Sharma, Keki Dadiseth, KV Kamath, Dr RH Patil, Amitabh Bachchan, Geet Sethi, etc. These gripping interviews have become the talking points across the country and have been compiled as bestselling two-volume titles called Pathbreakers and Pathbreakers2. Buy the books here.
 

 

User

Founders

Founders: Moneylife has been founded by Debashis Basu and Sucheta Dalal who bring a combined experience of 50 years of understanding business, regulatory and consumer and investor issues.

 

Debashis Basu is a Chartered Accountant by qualification with 25 years of experience as a journalist and the author of several business books. He has worked with The Times of India, Business World, Business India, Business Today, Financial Express and has written columns for Business Standard and The Economic Times. He has co-authored the best-selling The Scam: From Harshad Mehta to Ketan Parekh with Sucheta Dalal and has also authored Face Value: Creation and Destruction of Shareholder Value in India; Growth Alchemy: Why Smaller Firms Fail to Find Finance and How Market-based Solutions Can Help; Pathbreakers 1&2 and Plain Truth Series on Stocks, Mutual Funds and Investments. He was a member of the Task Force of the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) on the creation of IndoNext market segment for smaller companies and served as the member of the mutual fund advisory committee of SEBI. He directs the research and reporting on financial products at Moneylife and also oversees the design and business aspects of Moneylife.

 
Sucheta Dalal is among the best known financial journalists in India. Her 25 years of outstanding investigative reporting spans the Harshad Mehta scam, CR Bhansali scam, exposé of Enron, bad loans in banks, numerous corporate shenanigans and regulatory lapses have appeared in Business Standard, The Economic Times and The Times of India. She received the Chameli Devi Award for outstanding journalism and Femina Woman of Substance Award, both in 1993. She served as a member of the NR Narayana Murthy committee on corporate governance in 2003, was a member of the primary market advisory committee of SEBI and a member of Investor Education and Protection Fund of the Government of India. She is also a trustee of the Ahmedabad-based Consumer Research and Education Centre. She has co-authored the best-selling book The Scam: From Harshad Mehta to Ketan Parekh; AD Shroff: A Titan of Fianance and Pathbreakers 1&2. Based on her outstanding investigative journalism spanning two decades, she was awarded the Padma Shri in 2006. She directs the current news and socially-oriented reporting at Moneylife, the Foundation’s activities and grievance redressal activities.

User

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.
  Loading...
Close

To continue


Please
Sign Up or Sign In
with

Email
Close

To continue


Please
Sign Up or Sign In
with

Email

BUY NOW

The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)