Connect with Us
Moneylife - Facebook Moneylife - Twitter Moneylife - Linkedin Moneylife - Youtube Moneylife Rss feed

Moneylife » Life » Public Interest » Central Railway never invited fresh tenders for stalls on platforms in Mumbai, reveals RTI

Central Railway never invited fresh tenders for stalls on platforms in Mumbai, reveals RTI

Moneylife Digital Team | 03/05/2013 05:37 PM | 

CR, railways, railway stalls, stalls on platform, Gupta at Thane, Dadar

According to the RTI reply, since independence, over 30 firms or individuals have been running multiple stalls in their names and Central Railway has never invited fresh tender for various stalls on platforms across Mumbai

Year after year, over 30 firms or individuals are continuously running their 24x7 stalls on platforms across stations in Mumbai since the Central Railway (CR) has never invited fresh tenders for the profitable business, reveals a reply received under the Right to Information (RTI).


The RTI was filed by West Bengal-based Ritesh Singh. While the CR has provided details about contractors who are running stall for food & catering (canteen), medicines, books, fruits and other miscellaneous items, a similar RTI is still pending with the Western Railway.


There are about 200 stalls on platforms in CR's Mumbai division. However, according to the reply, between January 1961 and December 2011, over 30 firms or individuals were operating all these stalls. Here are the names of these contractors, excluding Mahanand Dairy, the state-government backed milk co-operative and Catering Vendor Co-operative Society, which are neither firms not individuals.


Name                                              no of stalls                         stations

1. Balan Natural Pvt Ltd                      5                   Masjid, Mulund, Panvel, Badlapur, Karjat

2. Surya Foods & Agro Ltd                   4                    Byculla, Byculla, Dombivali, Kasara

3. Balram Sharma                                2                     Ghatkopar, Vikhroli

4. SA Pai                                                   2                     both at Kalyan Junction

5. M/s Ghanshyamdas & Sons           3                      Masjid Road, Sandhurst Road, KCE

6. M/s Chantulal & Sons                     4                      Matunga, Kurla Junction (three)

7. M/s CK Gupta & Co                          4                       all at Byculla

8. M/s MP Sahani & Co                       4                        all at Mulund

9. M/s KN Solunki & Brithers           6                        all 6 stalls at Thane

10. M/s Gupta Broth                           3                         all 3 stalls at Thane

11. M/s NB Enterprises                  1+2 kiosks           all at Thane

12. M/s Pessumal & Co                        2                         both at Dockyard Road

13. M/s NK Kalyankar & Sons          2                          both at Reay Road

14. M/s Surprakash & Brothers       2                           both at Sewri

15. M/s RS Goyal & Sons                     2                          both at Wadala Road

16. M/s SB Gupta & sons                    2                           Govandi, Mankhurd

17. M/s RB enterprises                       1+2 kiosks          all at Dombivali

18. M/s SH Jondhale                           2                            both at Dombivali

19. M/s AK Irani & Co.                        2                           both at Kalyan Junction

20. M/s Shri US Diwadkar                4                           all at Kalyan Junction

21. M/s MK Kashyap Ent.                   2                         both at Kalyan Junction

22. M/s Badlmal Giyanumal & Sons3                       Ulhasnagar, Ambivali, Vangani

23. M/s Shri Udhavdas Ratanlal        2                        both at Ambarnath

24. M/s YS Diwadkar                             2                           Neral Junction, Karjat

25. NG Mukadam                                    1                             Titwala

26. DS Bedi                                                1                                 Shahad

27. M/s Sirumal Sevaram & Sons      1                                 Kalyan Junction

28. Pradip Kanagali                               1                            Kalyan Junction


There are four firms or persons who are awarded more than one book stall.

1. CB Pingle                                       2        Sion and GTB Nagar

2. SK Thatle & sons                         2        Vidyavihar and Kanjurmarg

3. Jaycee News agency                 2        Vitthalvadi and Ulhasnagar

4. Tribhuvan Tiwari                      2        both at Dockyard Road


Although the stalls are allotted to these chosen contractors, they may not be running it in person. Several such stalls are given on sub-let basis that often runs in to several lakh of rupees and the operator is shown as manager on paper.


When Singh asked if there was any stay order from any court that prevents the CR from inviting fresh tenders, the RTI reply says there was no case.


Another interesting aspect is the list does not have names like AH Wheeler & Co and Higginbothams, which till 2004 were had a monopoly in book stalls on railway platforms across the country, except Southern Railway and part of South Central Railway zones. In 2004, it had bookstores in 258 railway stations and used to contribute to about 80% of the revenues earned by the Indian Railways from book sales.


Following the new book policy adopted by the Railways in 2004, AH Wheeler lost its monopoly.

Post Comment

More in Moneylife

Consumer Protection Act, Consumer Courts, winning cases, NCDRC, Rajyalakshmi Rao, consumers, Moneylife Foundation

What is the secret of winning cases in consumer courts? +1491 views


Post your Comment

Alert me when new comment is posted on this article
 Please read our Moderation Policy and Terms of Use before posting


Moneylife Foundation: Maharashtra CM Fadnavis says financial literacy empowers citizens


If this is the condition of people living in Srinagar one shudders to imagine the plight of people living in far .. Deepak R Khemani


Cleaning 60 lakh kgs of adulterated pepper under court diktat! Moneylife Digital Team

A bank run by beggars, for beggars in Bihar town IANS


1 Comment
Veeresh Malik

Veeresh Malik 2 years ago

This "Balan natural" can be found all over India at railway platforms and is anything but natural, selling mostly packaged products. Gossip connects them with a leading Congress party family where the son-in-law is an ever-rising and more rising star. How they managed to project themselves into this lucrative trade, and also managed to block off all real fresh food on so many railway platforms is supposed to be another story, backed by a leading MNC much in the news lately for re-purchasing their shares. . .

Reply »Link » Report abuse
Daily Newsletter

1,00,000 Readers

Follow Moneylife
DNL facebook icon DNL linked in icon DNL twitter icon DNL youtube icon DNL rss icon

Grab a Discount Coupon here

Moneylife Magazine

What's your say?

Will AMFI's decision to cap distributor's upfront commissions at 1% affect sales of close-end schemes?
Can't Say
Enter Code : secure code
    change code

What you said

Who will win the Cricket World Cup 2015?

Thanks for casting your votes! View Previous Polls

Join Over 100,000 Awesome Readers

  1. News that Mainstream media does not always cover
  2. Views that are bold and unbiased
  3. Reports that focus on your interests as consumer, investor & citizen