Citizens' Issues
Campa Cola Case: Supreme Court stays demolition till 31st May

The Supreme Court that had ordered the demolition of illegal floors of seven buildings in Campa Cola Compound stayed its order till 31st May

After taking suo moto notice, the Supreme Court on Wednesday stayed the demolition of illegal floors of buildings in Campa Cola Compound till 31 May 2014.


Earlier today, the BrihanMumbai Municipal Corporation's (BMC) that was stopped from initiating action, demolished the main gate of the society which was blocked by residents, with the help of bulldozers. Police entered into the compound and evicted the protestors forcibly.


A bench headed by Justice GS Singhvi took suo moto cognizance of media reports and stayed the demolition process.

"It is not merely a legal issue, but a human problem," the bench observed. "We were badly disturbed by the events reported by the media last evening. From 11.30 to 3.30am we were disturbed."

According to the broad outlines submitted by attorney general GE Vahanvati before a bench out of nine structures originally proposed in the complex, only seven have been built, leaving enough floor space index (FSI) for accommodating the present members of the housing society.

Thus space is available for raising a new building. Those who are going to lose their accommodation may be put up in the new structure. The rules regarding FSI have also changed, which would allow the housing of all affected residents, Vahanvati said.

The bench noted the proposal of the attorney general and granted him time till next Tuesday to put his proposal in writing. They also asked counsel for the residents, FS Nariman and Mukul Rohtagi, to find out whether the proposal would be acceptable to them. The court observed that the suggestion seemed to be reasonable.

Yesterday, Campa Cola Society in Worli area of Mumbai witnessed tense moments as over 100 families barricaded themselves and refused to move out of the compound. However, BMC, the civic body, initiated action to disconnect power, water and gas connections before going in for demolition of illegal floors as per the orders from the Supreme Court.


Milind Deora, minister of state for communications & IT and shipping, told reporters that the BMC has confirmed that they have received stay from SC on demolition till 31 May 2014.


The apex court had set the 11th November deadline to vacate 102 flats declared as illegal. Families living in the compound had pinned their hopes on chief minister (CM) Prithviraj Chavan stepping in and saving their homes by passing an ordinance to regularise their flats. However, the CM reportedly does not want to go against the legal opinion of the advocate general.


The apartments in the Campa Cola Compound were constructed on land leased in 1955 to Pure Drinks Ltd. Pure Drinks was later allowed by the BMC in 1980 to build residential apartments. Seven high-rise buildings were constructed at the compound between 1981 and 1989 by developers Yusuf Patel, PSB Constructions and BK Gupta.


Illegal floors of Midtown Apartments, Esha Ekta Apartments, Shubh Apartments, Patel Apartments (two buildings, six floors each), BY Apartments and Orchid Apartments comprise 140 flats. While the builders were granted permission for ground-plus-five floors, Midtown has 20 floors, Orchid has 17, Esha Ekta has eight, Shubh has seven, while BY and Patel have six floors each.



Vaibhav Dhoka

4 years ago

Knowing well the illegal status of flats by flat owners and now demanding immunity from demolition shows which way we are going and how well the judicial orders can overruled or overturned,this is reason why people have loosing hopes in justice system.

shadi katyal

4 years ago

One should question SC that how such action was changed and thus created a precedent for other such illegal buildings.
Is it not common in our nation to violate all orders and do what we can do and when questions are raised we can buy the Law. Is it not what happened here. After all these flats did not just grew over night. Did people wsho bought these do any investigation? Yes one feels sorry for the families but some one has to suffer if we wish to change our society. Human factor is always involved in all facets of life.
The corruption is so rampant that one can get away.
Does anyone know hat happened to ADARSH BHAVAN???

chandan sinha

4 years ago

Thanks to those behind stopping this demolition by BMC. Now BMC should find those builders who constructed higher floors without approvals and make an example for small and big builders not just across MMR but also in whole of India...


Vaidya Dattatraya Vasudeo

In Reply to chandan sinha 4 years ago

A day-dream. This will never happen because it has never happened. BMC has yet to demolish other half-a-dozen or more buildings for which orders have been issued.

The buyers, since 1991 if not since 1984, were fully aware of illegality of the construction and had obtained a massive discount of more than 20%. It is admitted by an occupant on the TV. It is a fraud to start with.

It is like getting illegal admission to a college and in the month of March, when Universities refuse the forms, the parents go to court, seek mercy in the name of humanity and enjoy. All this predicted while taking admission illegally. It stopped ( probably ) only when one judge refused to accept this mercy.

Government must demolish these extra construction, and give all the administrative help to occupants to file case against builders, whether live or dead.

I wonder with all this hangama why the Court has never ordered immediate action against the concerned officers. The moment these officers are caught, they will give lot of interesting stories about who are all involved in this.

If it is not demolished, not a single illegal construction can be demolished in future. In the process law breakers enjoy and get more benefits and law abiding citizens have to suffer keeping with the law. When will it change. Who will change it.

chandan sinha

In Reply to Vaidya Dattatraya Vasudeo 4 years ago

It took 30-35 years for BMC to come to a conclusion of demolishing the floors above. That's more than a generation.Builders are equally involved if not more. What was BMC doing waiting for construction to complete and flats to be sold scrupulously and then tk action?

Btw, it's nt a day dream, am 30 sth and this is not 80s. Things r moving v fast now. Changes r fast. I believe Govt processes will c a mojor revamp soon in future and will live to see it. I am already part of it.

Polymer notes can curb fake currency racket

While we should welcome the move made by the RBI to combat the fake currency racket, we must debate their methodology adopted in test marketing of polymer rupee currency notes

In the past few months, Moneylife has carried reports on the urgent need to implement policies relating to replacement of paper currency notes by polymer-based currency, akin to what many leading countries like Australia, Singapore etc. have introduced. As our readers know, Australia was the pioneer that introduced polymer-based currency notes more than 25 years ago; these have long shelf life, compared to less than four years for paper base, and cannot be easily faked.


After a lot of deliberation, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) took the first major step in test marketing of Indian polymer currency notes. In fact, a field trial was carried out in Jaipur, Shimla, Bhubaneshwar, Mysore and Cochin. These locations were selected based on geographical and climatic conditions.


According to the Minister of State for Finance, Namo Narain Meena, Rs10 denominated polymer plastic notes were introduced to the above market on trial basis. We now have the figure that a billion Rs10 notes were printed and put into circulation in the five centres mentioned above. So far, the results of the field trials carried in these towns have not been made public by RBI, and in fact, not much publicity was given to this attempt, and so the aam aadmi uses the currency in the normal fashion!


While we should welcome the move made by the RBI, we must raise and debate the methodology adopted in test marketing. First and foremost is that the actual counterfeit notes in circulation in the country are in high denomination, such as Rs500 and Rs1,000 notes. From time to time, bulk quantities have been seized from couriers and smugglers from across the border from Bangladesh and Nepal.


Press reports indicate that in 2010 about Rs1,500-1,700 crore worth of fake Indian currency notes (FICN) were smuggled into the country; this increased to Rs2,500 crore in 2012, and so far, up to July 2013, as much as Rs1,200 crore have been caught. How much of these escaped the watchful eyes of the security agencies is difficult to even imagine.


First step from RBI, one would expect, is to announce that they intend to switch over to polymer plastic currency within a particular time frame. If this is considered as letting the cat out of the bag, then, without much publicity, we ought to introduce these polymer based currency notes in high value of Rs500 and Rs1,000. Within a scheduled time frame, we need to mop up the paper currency of these denominations and replace them totally. Only then the FICN can be prevented from entering the country.


This is particularly very important, considering the fact that elections are a few months away from now. Large scale smuggling of fake currency notes is more likely to increase than before. In this connection, it is worthwhile noting, with alarm, the reports on this subject by the National Investigation Agency (NIA).


NIA has now conclusive proof that these fake currency notes are the handywork of the ISI of Pakistan, whose main purpose in pushing these notes to destabilise the Indian economy and to finance its terror operations in India. These fake currency notes are routed through Bangladesh, Nepal; and now, the new and additional locations are UAE, Oman, Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Hong Kong and Shenzen (China).


The NIA has carried forensic analysis of the captured fake currency notes. It is observed, beyond reasonable doubt, that the paper used matches with the legal tender of Pakistan. Besides, they match almost all the security features and print Rs500 and Rs1,000 notes, and that these fake notes can be only duplicated by highly sophisticated machines that the Government of Pakistan owns.


The perfection of window and water mark formulations indicate that the FICN paper on regular currency making machines can only be owned by a sovereign country or state. “Most of the pivotal parameters of the paper like density (GSM) wax pick quotient, poly vinyl alcohol and PH values were found matching with the legal tender of Pakistan” according to NIA.


All these details have been made available to the Parliament Standing Committee and concurred by Research & Analysis Wing (RAW), the Intelligence Bureau and the Department of Revenue Intelligence (DRI). The matter is therefore, very serious and urgent steps should be taken not only by RBI in expediting their planned action to introduce polymer Rupee notes in higher denominations but also the Security agencies all over the country, particularly, on the land borders to totally stop smuggling of the fake currencies notes.


Moneylife would concede that RBI may be tight-lipped on the issue of their plans but after having received the test market reaction, time has now come for large scale plans to pump in trillions of dollars worth Rs500 and Rs1,000 polymer notes and demonetise the paper currency of the same denomination to nullify the effect of fake currency notes. Admittedly, a large quantity of fake currency notes has been "found" by bankers, who have been advised to withhold them to prevent further circulation.

As a word of caution for overseas travellers to the above destinations, it would be in their own interest neither to take high value Indian rupee currency notes nor to be stupid enough to "buy" the Indian currency abroad. These are more likely to be fake than anything else. In any case, beyond the authorised limit, no one should take in or take out the currency in the first place!


Any assurance from the Reserve Bank Governor in this matter would be welcomed by the concerned public, as fake currencies may play a role in the ensuing elections.


Earlier articles on fake currency racket:


Read an earlier story about counterfeit notes over here


Falling rupee and its counterfeit cousin!


When China sends fake rupee notes to a Delhi restaurant


(AK Ramdas has worked with the Engineering Export Promotion Council of the ministry of commerce. He was also associated with various committees of the Council. His international career took him to places like Beirut, Kuwait and Dubai at a time when these were small trading outposts; and later to the US.)


ASCI seeks to restrict ads of educational institutions

A new set of guidelines issued by ASCI’s code for regulation in advertising for the educational institutions would help curb false promises and misleading advertisements

Advertising Standards Council of India (ASCI) has come out with new set of guidelines in order the curb the false claims and propaganda made by advertisers, especially educational institutions like schools, colleges, universities and coaching classes.


These new guidelines issued by the ASCI have targeted several institutes who do not have accreditation from concerned bodies, flouting every rule and brazenly publishing advertisements on the print, broadcast and digital media.


False promises by several educational institutes are classic examples where the respective institutes proclaim glossy promises of placements and tie-ups with well known foreign universities.


In a country like India where a lot of premium is put on education, the industry has grown full fledged and equally, there has been growth in the cases where unsuspecting students and their parents have been duped. Unlike other tangible commercial products, the value of the education and training cannot be ascertained by inspection and demonstration being put to a standard measurement system. Instead, they are judged by degree, diplomas, recognition, accreditation, testimonials, track-record for placements, ASCI said in a release.


The guidelines as stipulated by the ASCI’s Code for Self - Regulation in Advertising, the Advertisements of Educational Institutions and Programs are as follows:


 1. The advertisement shall not state or lead the public to believe that an institution or course or program is official, recognised, authorised, accredited, approved, registered, affiliated, endorsed or has a legal defined situation, unless the advertiser is able to substantiate with evidence

2a) Advertisement offering a degree or diploma or certificate which by law requires is recognising or approving by an authority shall have the name of that authority specified for that particular field

2b) In case the advertised institution or program is not recognised or approved by any mandatory authority, but is affiliated to another Institution which is approved or recognised by a mandatory authority, then the full name and location of the said affiliating institution shall also be stated in the advertisement


Separately, the advertisement regulatory body has also come out with guidelines for using ‘supers’ while communicating disclaimers and qualifications in an ad. “Supers should be clearly legible and on TV ads should be held long enough for the full message to be read by average viewer on a standard domestic TV set,” ASCI said in a release.


Here is the minimum size of lettering of ‘Supers’ and its holding time on screen for TV ads is required…


1) For Print Ads the font size of the “Supers” shall be minimum 6 and 7 points for 100 cc or less and more than 100 column centimetre or equivalent size ads, respectively

2) For TV Ads the size of the “supers” shall be of minimum 12 pixel height and stay not less than 4 seconds duration on the screen for up to two lines of “supers”. For every additional line of super, hold time needs to go up by 2 seconds per line. The “super” should be in the same language as the audio of the ad.


We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)