Cabinet to take up GST Constitution Amendment Bill on Tuesday

After missing the original GST roll-out deadline of April 2010 and the near impossible deadline of April 2011, the proposed roll-out date of 1 April 2012 is also likely to be missed, revenue secretary Sunil Mitra opined

After missing the two GST roll-out deadlines of April 2010 and April 2011, the new roll-out date of 1 April 2012 is also likely to be missed, revenue secretary Sunil Mitra opined

New Delhi: The Union Cabinet is likely to consider a Constitution Amendment Bill on Tuesday to pave the way for the implementation of Goods and Services Tax (GST), a new indirect tax regime that will subsume various levies like excise and service tax, reports PTI.

According to sources, Cabinet will consider the GST Constitution Amendment Bill tomorrow, after which it will be introduced in the current session of Parliament.

The finance ministry has worked on the final draft Amendment Bill-the fourth since the discussions on the new tax regime started. Earlier, the first three drafts prepared by the Centre were rejected by the states, citing autonomy issues.

The fourth draft, a hybrid of the second and third draft, has proposed that the GST council for taking decisions on all important matters will be formed through a presidential order.

In addition, the composition of the GST Dispute Resolution Authority, proposed to be a part of the Constitution Amendment, will be decided by Parliament.

Furthermore, petroleum, natural gas, diesel and ATF have been kept out of the GST ambit in the final draft.

Last year, a draft Constitution Bill proposed by the Centre to the states had suggested a council chaired by the Union finance minister, with states as members, to make changes in GST.

The states, especially NDA-ruled ones, had raised objections to the proposal, saying it would give veto power to the Union finance minister over state taxation issues.

The Centre subsequently provided another draft to the states, suggesting that changes in GST could be made only if there was a consensus on those issues in the council. However, some state finance ministers did not agree to even this suggestion.

Taking into consideration the states' concerns, the finance ministry had floated a third draft on the GST Constitution Amendment Bill.

The new draft proposed to create a GST Council through an Act of Parliament, instead of a presidential order, as proposed in the previous draft. The Centre had also dropped any reference to the Union finance minister heading the GST Council.

After missing the original April 2010 deadline for GST rollout, the government proposed to introduce it in April 2011. But it is all set to miss this deadline too. According to revenue secretary Sunil Mitra, it may be difficult to implement GST from 1 April 2012, too.

The GST will subsume indirect taxes like excise duty and service tax at the central level and VAT on the states front, besides local levies.


Piracy on the high seas: How do Israel and Russia combat this menace?

A number of foreign flagships have their own armed personnel on board, they call them “seamen”, and organise documents for them from the flag state. But India has made it extremely difficult for armed personnel to sail on board Indian merchant  flagships

In the world of shipping, flags and nationalities often have interchangeable meaning, and it is not unusual for ship-owners and ship-operators to not just burn the candle on both ends, but also cut the candle up into small pieces, burn it at every end, and then burn it lengthwise too.

The history of almost every major shipping company is littered with evidence and anecdotes of what could best be called "extreme free enterprise"-slave trade, narcotics, arms, sanctions, colonial ambitions-nothing is or was impossible.

A roll-call of some of the major shipping interests around today, especially the 'Old Money' sorts from Western and Middle Europe, will show how as recently as during World War II, fleets were literally divided up to serve on both sides. That's nothing new. Somebody has to win, it made sense to cover all bets-this is also called hedging.

Some day soon, we shall also discuss derivates in the same context.
And of course, yesterday's gunrunners making their futures in and around Africa and Asia are today's corporate darlings, with shipping histories conveniently ignoring the truths. The only loyalty is towards turning over a faster profit, at any cost, especially when new flags can be rented by the hour.

Mongolia's maritime ambitions are the latest example, where anything goes.

So, in a way, why blame the poor Somalians-after all, if they were wearing suits tailored from bespoke outlets and could just knot their ties better than they do their lungis, they would not really look very different-and the flag would not really matter. Every European nation worth its colonial history has a few dozen flags lying spare here and there in the rest of the world-so what if they had to let go a Hong Kong or Singapore?
Here a fact: reading up on the small nation-states that still owe allegiance to the victors of the World War II, ostensibly fought on the basis of "freedom for all", is indeed extremely revealing. Thing is, there are so many of these little-little countries, mostly islands here and there, that it is quite a long read.

But it helps to understand shipping, and to figure out why shipping companies love them, too. It may be a bit difficult to memorise and sing so many new National Anthems, but hey, they can always buy a CD. Here's another fact: newer the country, easier the Flag of Convenience, and often prettier the flag.
But there are always exceptions. For some people, for some flags, never forget. And the Israelis stand very, very tall in this. In fact, their flags are the tallest in the world. Today, their ships sail past the pirate areas of the Indian Ocean, without challenge. A friend who was a Master on one of their Zim Line ships relates an episode of how while other ships would creep past in full black-out conditions, they would barrel through the piracy areas with all lights on and with floodlights shining on the funnel as well as name and port of registry. Every time. Nobody knows if the pirates out there can read Hebrew, so the name is also painted on in English.

Into this world we bring our gentle and loyal readers a small touch, a faint whisper of a part of a chapter in a huge book actually, of the amazing real-life story of the Ofer Brothers. Apart from owning the Israeli shipping behemoth, Zim, the Ofers are also known to own and control Tanker Pacific (one of the largest oil-tanker operators in the world) as well as a few other shipping interests-including the companies that owned the St James Park and the Asian Glory, that were hijacked and released in 2009.
One version is here:
Another version is here:
And here too, the third version, where you will notice that our old friends-the banks and the insurance companies-make their now usual grand appearance, as private investors too.
But this report is about piracy and Israelis. For that, please and kindly look carefully at the timeline below:
This is a statement issued by the operators after the release of their ship, the St James Park, mid-May 2009. "The company does not wish to jeopardise the safety of crew members held on its second hijacked vessel the Asian Glory or other vessels and crews that are still being held by Somali pirates in the area," Zodiac said in a statement. (The vessel St James Park, with a British flag, was hijacked on 28 December 2008 and released on 14 May 2009, with Indian, Pakistani and Bulgarian crew).
This is the statement issued by the operators after the release of their ship, the MV Asian Glory in mid-June 2009-"Zodiac said in a statement on its website that all crewmembers were well, but declined to provide further details." (MV Asian Glory, with a British flag, was hijacked in early January 2009 and released in mid-June 2009-its crew consisted of Ukrainians, Bulgarians, Indians and Romanians.)
But there has been no statement issued by the owners or operators, as yet, pertaining to the hijack and release of their ship the MV Arctic Sea, from the North Sea, in highly-controlled Western Europe waters. On voyage from Finland to Algeria with "timber", but suspected to have been carrying weapons likely destined for certain Arab interests. (MV Arctic Sea, Malta flag, primarily Canadian owned-beneficial owners unclear-was hijacked in late July 2009 and "found" in mid-August 2009 in the Atlantic Ocean).
The buzz in the maritime world in India and elsewhere has been loud and clear after this-Ofer's ships will simply not be touched again. In fact, any Israeli interests will not be touched again in the Indian Ocean piracy areas. Buzz also has it that on the waterfront in Puntland and the rest of the Horn of Africa, word is out that you don't mess with the Star of David, or those whom they protect.

So you now have MSC, (Med Shipping of Geneva, Switzerland, another shipping company with a history of its own, operating from that great maritime nation, Switzerland) the largest operators of cruise ships, openly declaring that their "security staff" was and is Israeli.
Here's another episode: April 2009, the MSC Melody with a "large number of passengers onboard" repelled an attack by boats and boats of pirates about 500 miles off Somalia. Apparently it was a planned attack. Initial news reports spoke about the ship taking successful evasive action, but truth is that the security forces onboard used firearms "and more" to drive off the attackers, and then actually doing some more too-which cannot and will not be repeated here.

But put it this way, there are videos circulating on the Internet of how security men from another nation captured some pirates, released the hostage crew who were being forced to operate the mother ship, and then, what the heck, tied the pirates up and then blew up the ship.

Some people got very, very, wet-and unhappy. Russian ships don't get attacked in Somalia any more, either, for some time now.
So this is what the MSC Melody's ship-owner's statement said: "Security work onboard our cruise ships is very popular with young Israelis just out of the army, the job is seen as a chance to save money and travel at the same time. Hundreds of veterans and reservists of elite Israel Defence Force units, including Naval commandos, are employed in security work on cruise ships and oil rigs in areas subject to pirate attacks."
And in the bargain, another amazing factoid is emerging in Africa-the Israelis are fast becoming important players in all forms of commercial enterprises in and around the emerging African countries. One country, (actually three of them), is reported to now permit nuclear tests as well as Armed Forces "training" on their territories. (South Africa stopped in the post-apartheid era, that is what one understands, and Angola is not all that big).

The Chinese are now facing competition, because cheap labour costs the same for both of them, especially if it is from Third World countries. And most of all, Israeli interest ships continue to flow through safely-which is more than what many other countries can claim.
Where is India on something like this?
1) All sorts of important people in Delhi are debating on whether Indian ships should have armed guards on them or not. Popular sentiment fashioned on some old traditions going back to, where else, the British, has it that merchant ships should not be armed. This is usually after lunch and before dinner, after which they all go home to their well-protected homes, mostly with heavily armed guards outside.
2) The Directorate General of Shipping, Mumbai, in its own brilliance has made it extremely difficult for ex-Indian Navy personnel to sail onboard Indian merchant flag ships. The background of this is somewhere else totally, and involves Supreme Court judgements, so it will not be discussed here, other than a single simple comment: "own goal". Or better, still, "self
3) Foreign flagships which have their own armed personnel onboard declare the security people as "seamen", and organise documents for them from the flag state. The actual arms are either declared and kept in bonded locker stores, or simply, sometimes, not declared, that's also life. Releasing a ship from official pirates in India is easier than getting it released from unofficial pirates in Somalia.
4) The ITF, BIMCO, Intertanko, Interbulk and the International Chamber of Shipping are meeting in London again next week. Apparently they plan to issue another joint appeal, after lunch and before dinner, and then launch another Web campaign. However, they are also not in favour of placing armed guards on merchant ships-though this is also being debated. To the best of my knowledge, the Indian government is not represented here this time, though some other Indians in shipping are.
There is no too ways about this-piracy at sea is now a very important component of what is increasingly being referred to as "MCO". (Multinational Crime Organisation). History teaches us that the New World was conquered by buccaneers and they were supported brilliantly by their backers-state, church or commerce. Things really haven't changed that much lately, either.



Nagesh KiniFCA

6 years ago

We have enough re-employable sailors, coast guards and commandos who can find gainful employment post retirement. Our netas from MOD,MOS,MEA only use photo ops to make long winding statements and drive the harassed families round Delhi darshan.
Years back small Isreal sent a plane all the way to Uganda on Operation Thunderbolt to rescue Air France passengers. We sent our MEA along with a dreaded terrorist to Khandahar.
Mera Bharat haiMahaan,
magar hum sub pareshaan,
kyo ki 99% hai beimaan!
Jai Hind.
Pray for the safe return of the hijacked sailors.



In Reply to Nagesh KiniFCA 6 years ago

Thank you for writing in. Please use your best efforts to get the Government to agree to position armed personnel onboard Indian flag shps.

Hyderabadi tussle: When Telangana supporters used Taliban-style mayhem to vandalise statues

Telangana supporters unleashed mayhem on the streets of Hyderabad on 10th March, vandalising statues of eminent personalities, similar to the destruction of ancient Buddha statues at Bamiyan by the Taliban

Friday, 11th March, was when Japan was shaken by an act of God. But on 10th March, Hyderabad was witness to a 'Million March' called by agitators fighting to carve out a separate state of Telangana—but the damage that they caused was more shocking and even more saddening than the tsunami that now has Japan on its knees.

The pro-Telangana agitators unleashed mayhem on the streets of Hyderabad. Apart from attacking the press and politicians (those who were not sympathetic to the bifurcation-or possible trifurcation-of Andhra Pradesh), these 'agitators' (many of them appeared to have been hired goons) chose to vandalise statues of eminent personalities from southern India's largest state. According to reports, one of the statues was dumped into the Hussain Sagar lake.

At this stage, it is a little too late to go into the details of the actual 'proceedings' of the day. However, over the weekend, Moneylife was inundated with messages from not just denizens of Andhra Pradesh, but also a number of other concerned Indian citizens who have rightly called this incident a "crying shame" not just for Andhra, but for the whole nation.

When you compare the disgusting 'agitation' with the sagacity with which the Japanese have handled the quake (their head of state has called it 'The biggest tragedy since World War II'), one can only wonder-shouldn't all of us at least get together and spare a moment of silence for the icons whose images have been so brutally vandalised?

Incidentally, all these statues were erected by the late Telugu bidda (son), NT Rama Rao (NTR), who ruled the state for two consecutive terms. And the sheer irony is that the memorials to PV Narasimha Rao, another Telugu bidda (AP's first and arguably one of India's most astute prime ministers) and NTR have been built at the banks of the Hussain Sagar lake. And the mob thought it fit to dump the statues of these icons into the very same lake.

One of our readers has sent in the link to a blog which has captured these photographs: (Please click: Some of these photographs are very disturbing.

The link to a report in Eenadu (in Telugu) is

We have been receiving a number of responses from Moneylife readers, and we shall be carrying a few of them today.




6 years ago


dr rajendra

6 years ago

i will destroy them ... thousand times... when you do not respect telenanga icons we will not respect andhra icons...

nagesh kini

6 years ago

We though the Talibani's were crazy, our Telangani's right here are a shade worst.
It is time all of them are dumped in the Hussain Sagar lake to give company to the statues.


6 years ago



6 years ago

I would compare this act to vandalizing British statues in India by Indian freedom fighters. Nothing more nothing less. These statues does not have archeological value. They were installed by Andhra rulers in 1986 on Telangana soil while ignoring heros of Telangana to show their cultural hegemony. This is in tune with general perception of Andhra people that they are superior and their accent is superior etc. Telangana movement is like freedom movement.


6 years ago

The writer has no idea abt the situation thr... u think its easy to live in repression n be refused statehood? U hv any idea how d Telangana region wz forcibly joined with Andhra? u hv nevr been 2 d city either, tht much is clear. no1 gains anything frm destroying statues, bt u destroy thm coz they stand fr NTR n othrs who have not allowed Telanagana 2 b a state. Tank bund used 2 b a beautiful plce b4 NTR decided 2 hv these ugly statues. so nxt time u feel lyk writing smthn u dont understand... just lv it. Y compare with Taliban or Japan? r these statues historic like Bamian? N u nevr say a word when Telangana supporters are killed in police firing or thrown in jails!!! hypocrite n shallow journalism... nvr going 2 come back 2 this dumb site



In Reply to nimi 6 years ago

ha ha...


6 years ago

Guys, please be aware that hating our brothers and sisters will not lead to any point. You will not realise this in this madness.



In Reply to bharat 6 years ago

very true bharat,

but very few in the world look at the holistic picture. people are so selfish today that there is no compassion and virtue that exists today.

whatever the case be, i feel very strongly about this and should be dealt with very strongly. having an attitude is something else but patience is always a virtue. in fact i think all this happened due to a chosen few and once they can be isolated the job is 90% done...



6 years ago

The comments on this article until now are wonderously awful.

there is one that says, what difference does it make if the statues are taken off.. i guess they are only concrete. How about taking the roof and a cupla walls off your home, they are also awful..

What we need to understand here is the synonimity and how we relate to these personalities and what have they contributed to our culture...

if these commentators think that does not matter, then the comparison to taliban is quite in place since they did the same to a couple of statues in Afghanistan that were centuries old...

LOL, we need to think about if we need such people in our country or just pack them off to AFG... :)

Whatever, immature comments, dont take them to heart dear writer/editor...



6 years ago

Thanks for publishing this and giving the info to entire nation about the nonsense going in AP.


6 years ago

Please don't get into areas where you have no insight or knowledge. Publishing such biased article is uncalled for. Probably I would never come back to this site again.

sri sri

6 years ago

the article is very biased and the comparison to japanese earth quake makes no sense.... how can destroying a few statues be a more sad moment than the lives of thousands of people.. for that matter how can destroying a few statues be a more sad moment than one life...


6 years ago

I was there when the Statues were demolished, It was the Proudest Moment of my Life, the statues were hollow cheap statues we just Lifted them and threw them in to Hussainsagar, Call us talliban I dont Care , But these are NO Baiyman Bhuddas that talibans destroyed these are More like statues of Lenin or Stalin that were destroyed during fall of Communism.
Mr Author You are a Hypocrite u didnt care when 1 lakh telangana people were locked up during that day.

Risen Sun

6 years ago

Not intended,.. but united andhra supporting looters Lagadapati, rayapati, CM, Governer , DGP and commisioner are leaving us very less option. any legal plea to save telangana rights they are ignoring and forcing/ bullyed / stressed out people to act in this way, Completly CM is responsible.


6 years ago

very unfortunate incident. State formation is just an adminstrative issue. People should realise Hyderabad cant survive without harmony in telugu people.



In Reply to chandu 6 years ago

does money life know about the exploitation made by the seemandraites. First get to know about the histroy before publishing any stories. Seems you have some one from the Seemandra community working with you.Ms Dalal, i respect your sincere efforts. If you want to publish about Telangana , first get your facts right and the discrimation perpetuated by the Seemandraites.I can help you with that


In Reply to raghu 6 years ago

What is the difference between jihadi and telangan movement?
After few years, people will ask us separate nizamabad state?what you do?if you not liking your telugu people, how other country people like us?I Kanow that telangan is neglected and we have to uplift much damage money,time wasted during few years, with that money we could have provided better water facilities in nalgonda with tlatest tachnologies "".how come andhra people looted telangana?if so all our telangana nri alos looting america?I born and brought up in Mahabubnagar.I wanted telangana development,but not this way.Is it our culture insulting neighbour district people?waht was doing KCR for 10 years in TDP goverment?we have to think when any politician says something, whether it is for his advantage or for telangana people adavantage.

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)